Lecture 4-2: The Synoptic Problem
Contents 94
- Lecture 1-1: What "New Testament" Means
- Lecture 1-2: Canon Formation as a Real Historical Process
- Lecture 1-3: Textual Transmission and the Modern Critical Text
- Lecture 2-1: The Parties of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 2-2: Synagogue, Temple, and Messianic Hope
- Lecture 2-3: Rome, Hellenism, and the Fullness of Time
- Lecture 3-1: Source Criticism and the Shared Material of the Synoptic Gospels
- Lecture 3-2: Form Criticism and Redaction Criticism
- Lecture 3-3: Evangelical and Canonical Responses to Critical Method
- Lecture 4-1: What Kind of Book Is a Gospel?
- Lecture 4-2: The Synoptic Problem
- Lecture 4-3: John's Distinct Relationship to the Synoptics
- Lecture 5-1: Matthew's Structure, Audience, and Fulfillment Citations
- Lecture 5-2: The Sermon on the Mount and Matthew's Kingdom Theology
- Lecture 5-3: The Great Commission and Matthew's Theology of Mission
- Lecture 6-1: Mark's Author, His Secret, and His Hurry
- Lecture 6-2: The Hinge at Caesarea Philippi
- Lecture 6-3: The Ending of Mark
- Lecture 7-1: Luke's Preface — A Historian's Method
- Lecture 7-2: Luke's Distinctive Emphases — the Poor, Women, the Spirit, and the Nations
- Lecture 7-3: Luke-Acts as One Continuous Work
- Lecture 8-1: John's Distinct Style and Theology
- Lecture 8-2: The Authorship Debate
- Lecture 8-3: John's Stated Purpose and Its Sign-Structured Design
- Lecture 9-1: The Quests — Old, No Quest, and Third
- Lecture 9-2: Criteria of Authenticity — What They Claim, and Their Limits
- Lecture 9-3: Contemporary Approaches — The Jesus Seminar and the Third Quest
- Lecture 10-1: Who Wrote Acts, and Why the Pronouns Change
- Lecture 10-2: Acts 1:8 — The Book Outlines Itself
- Lecture 10-3: How Reliable a Historian Is Luke?
- Lecture 11-1: Paul's Life and the Chronology Behind His Letters
- Lecture 11-2: The Pauline Authorship Debate
- Lecture 11-3: Letter Form and Paul's Central Convictions
- Lecture 12-1: Occasion and Structure of Romans
- Lecture 12-2: Sin, Justification, and Israel's Place
- Lecture 12-3: Romans and the New Perspective on Paul
- Lecture 13-1: Corinth and the Letter's Occasion
- Lecture 13-2: Key Issues Paul Addresses
- Lecture 13-3: 1 Corinthians 13 in Argumentative Context
- Lecture 14-1: Occasion — The Painful Visit, the Severe Letter, and Reconciliation
- Lecture 14-2: Paul's Defense of His Apostolic Ministry Against the "Super-Apostles"
- Lecture 14-3: Is 2 Corinthians One Letter or Several? The Partition-Theory Debate
- Lecture 15-1: The Occasion — The Judaizing Controversy
- Lecture 15-2: Audience and Date — The North Galatia/South Galatia Debate
- Lecture 15-3: The Argument — Justification by Faith and Christian Freedom
- Lecture 16-1: The Structure of Ephesians
- Lecture 16-2: The Authorship of Ephesians
- Lecture 16-3: One New Humanity — Ephesians' Theology of Reconciliation
- Lecture 17-1: Paul in Chains, Philippi in Partnership
- Lecture 17-2: The Christ Hymn — Self-Emptying and Exaltation
- Lecture 17-3: Joy Amid Suffering
- Lecture 18-1: Colossians — Occasion, the Colossian Heresy, and the Authorship Question
- Lecture 18-2: Colossians' Christology — The Supremacy of Christ
- Lecture 18-3: Philemon — Onesimus, and What the Letter Does and Does Not Say About Slavery
- Lecture 19-1: 1 Thessalonians — Occasion and the Eschatology of Comfort
- Lecture 19-2: 2 Thessalonians — Occasion and the Eschatology of Correction
- Lecture 19-3: The Authorship Debate over 2 Thessalonians
- Lecture 20-1: The Pastoral Epistles as a Category
- Lecture 20-2: The Authorship Debate
- Lecture 20-3: The Pastorals' Shared Purpose
- Lecture 21-1: Ephesus and the False Teachers Timothy Must Oppose
- Lecture 21-2: Church Order — Overseers, Deacons, and 2:11-12
- Lecture 21-3: Sound Doctrine and Godliness as One Concern
- Lecture 22-1: 2 Timothy — A Final Charge from a Man Who Expects to Die
- Lecture 22-2: Titus — Order for a Rougher Mission Field
- Lecture 22-3: A Composite Portrait of Pastoral Ministry
- Lecture 23-1: Hebrews — Genre and the Question of Authorship
- Lecture 23-2: Hebrews — Christ Superior to Angels, Moses, and the Priesthood
- Lecture 23-3: Hebrews — The Warning Passages and the Apostasy Debate
- Lecture 24-1: James — Author and Genre
- Lecture 24-2: James and Paul on Faith and Works
- Lecture 24-3: James' Practical Ethics — the Tongue, Wealth and Poverty, and Prayer
- Lecture 25-1: 1 Peter — Author, Audience, and Occasion
- Lecture 25-2: 1 Peter — Suffering, Hope, and Submission Within Hostile Structures
- Lecture 25-3: 1 Peter — The Household Codes and the Spirits in Prison
- Lecture 26-1: Who Wrote 2 Peter?
- Lecture 26-2: Jude — Contending for the Faith
- Lecture 26-3: 2 Peter and Jude Together
- Lecture 27-1: Occasion — A Denial "in the Flesh," and Kinship with John's Gospel
- Lecture 27-2: The Tests of True Faith — Love, Obedience, Right Belief
- Lecture 27-3: The Theology of Assurance — "That You May Know"
- Lecture 28-1: 2 John — The Elect Lady and the Danger at the Door
- Lecture 28-2: 3 John — Gaius, Diotrephes, and the Politics of Hospitality
- Lecture 28-3: The Johannine Letters and the Authorship Question — Returning to Chapter 8
- Lecture 29-1: The Genre of Revelation: Apocalypse, Prophecy, and Letter
- Lecture 29-2: Who Wrote Revelation? The Ancient Case for a Second John
- Lecture 29-3: Four Ways to Read Revelation's Visions
- Lecture 30-1: The Architecture of Revelation
- Lecture 30-2: The Beast, the Number, and Babylon — Reading One Symbol Four Ways
- Lecture 30-3: The Thousand Years and the World Made New
Read Matthew, Mark, and Luke side by side — the arrangement scholars call a "synopsis," from the Greek for "seeing together," which gives this whole puzzle its name — and something becomes obvious within a few pages: these are not three independent accounts written from scratch by three authors who happened to describe the same events. Whole sentences recur nearly word for word across two or all three Gospels. The order of episodes tracks closely across all three for long stretches. Even parenthetical remarks by the narrator, like Mark's aside that the reader should "let the reader understand" at 13:14, reappear almost verbatim in Matthew's version of the same scene. This is not the pattern of eyewitnesses independently recalling the same events. It is the pattern of a real literary relationship — one text depending on another, or several texts depending on a common source, in some combination.
Explaining exactly how that relationship works is called the Synoptic Problem, and it has occupied serious scholars for more than two centuries without producing a consensus every scholar accepts. This lecture, following the source-critical method introduced in lecture 3-1, presents the three positions that have shaped the modern discussion — the Two-Source Hypothesis, the Griesbach or Two-Gospel Hypothesis, and the Farrer Hypothesis — as honestly and fully as a single lecture allows. None is presented here as obviously correct. A student who finishes this lecture confident that the debate is settled has misread it.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Describe, with examples, the kind of textual agreement that makes the Synoptic Problem a real puzzle rather than an assumption imposed on the text.
- State the Two-Source Hypothesis accurately, including what "Q" is and is not.
- State the Griesbach/Two-Gospel Hypothesis and the case William Farmer made for it.
- State the Farrer Hypothesis and why Mark Goodacre argues it removes an unnecessary hypothetical source.
- Explain at least one genuine strength and one genuine difficulty for each of the three positions.
Since many have undertaken to set in order a narrative concerning those matters which have been fulfilled among us, even as those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and servants of the word delivered them to us, it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus.
Luke 1:1-3, World English Bible
Luke's preface again supplies this lecture's anchor text, because Luke is explicit that he is not writing in isolation from other written accounts:
Luke says plainly that "many" had already written accounts before his, and that his own work involved tracing "the course of all things" — a process of research and arrangement, not composition from nothing. Whatever those prior accounts were, Luke's own preface concedes that a Gospel writer working with existing written material is exactly the kind of process this lecture investigates. Later citations use (WEB).
1. The data the theories are trying to explain
Before any theory, it helps to see the actual pattern of evidence three kinds of observation together produce.
Triple tradition. Material appearing in all three Synoptics — for example, the healing of the paralytic let down through a roof (Mark 2:1-12; Matthew 9:1-8; Luke 5:17-26) — often follows the same sequence of narrated actions and shares enough exact wording that independent oral report becomes a strained explanation. Scholars estimate roughly ninety percent of Mark's content has a parallel somewhere in Matthew, and a large majority also in Luke.
Double tradition. A substantial body of material — mostly sayings of Jesus, including large sections of the Sermon on the Mount and its parallel in Luke's Sermon on the Plain — appears in Matthew and Luke but has no parallel in Mark at all. This material is often extremely close in wording between Matthew and Luke, sometimes nearly identical.
Order. When Matthew and Luke both include a pericope also found in Mark, one or the other regularly follows Mark's sequence, but Matthew and Luke rarely agree with each other in order against Mark. This pattern — sometimes called the phenomenon of "alternating agreement" in order — is one of the single strongest pieces of evidence source critics point to for Mark's centrality to the relationship, whatever exactly that centrality means.
Minor agreements. In passages all three share, Matthew and Luke occasionally agree with each other, against Mark, in small wording choices too minor to be coincidental and too inconsistent to form a clear pattern — famously, both Matthew 26:68 and Luke 22:64 add "Who is it that struck you?" to the mocking of Jesus, a detail absent from Mark's version of the same scene. These agreements are small in number but have played an outsized role in the debate, because different theories explain them very differently.
Any adequate theory has to account for all four patterns at once, not just the most obviously striking one.
2. The Two-Source Hypothesis
The dominant position in modern scholarship holds two claims together. First, Markan priority: Mark was written first, and Matthew and Luke each used Mark independently as a source, which explains the triple-tradition agreements and the order pattern — Matthew and Luke each generally follow Mark's sequence because each is working from Mark, and they rarely agree with each other against Mark because neither is following the other. Second, a hypothetical sayings source usually labeled "Q" (from the German Quelle, "source"), which Matthew and Luke each also used independently, accounting for the double-tradition material neither found in Mark. Q is not a surviving document — no manuscript of anything called Q has ever been found — but a scholarly reconstruction inferred from the material Matthew and Luke share but Mark does not.
The case for Markan priority rests on several converging observations: Mark's Greek is rougher and less polished than Matthew's or Luke's parallel versions of the same material, which is more easily explained as later authors improving an earlier author's style than the reverse; Mark's theology is, on several counts, less developed or more startling than Matthew's or Luke's treatment of the same episodes, which fits an editor smoothing a source's rough edges better than an author introducing new difficulties; and Mark is shorter, omitting material found in both other Synoptics that would be strange for an author to leave out if working from fuller sources, but unremarkable for two later authors to add to a shorter one.
The case for Q follows from the double-tradition material's character: it is heavily sayings-focused, agrees closely in wording between Matthew and Luke, and yet appears in different narrative settings and sometimes different order in each Gospel — patterns that fit two authors independently working from a shared written source of sayings better than one Gospel simply copying the other's arrangement.
3. The Griesbach / Two-Gospel Hypothesis
A minority but historically serious alternative reverses the order entirely. First proposed by Johann Jakob Griesbach in the eighteenth century and revived with vigor in the twentieth century by William Farmer, the Griesbach or Two-Gospel Hypothesis holds that Matthew was written first, Luke used Matthew, and Mark was written last as a kind of abbreviated conflation of both — drawing on material common to Matthew and Luke and largely reproducing it in condensed form. On this account there is no need for Q at all: the material Matthew and Luke share that Mark lacks is simply material Luke took directly from Matthew, with Mark's author choosing not to include it.
Farmer's case, developed at length in The : A Critical Analysis (1964), argued that the case for Markan priority had become an unexamined consensus rather than a genuinely tested conclusion, and that patristic testimony — several early church writers list Matthew first and describe it as the earliest Gospel — deserved more weight than modern source criticism had given it. Farmer also argued that Mark's supposed "roughness" could be read the other direction: an author abbreviating and conflating two longer, more polished sources might well produce exactly the choppier, more compressed prose Mark shows, without that roughness implying priority at all.
The difficulty most often raised against this position is Mark's own editorial behavior on the Griesbach account: an author working from both Matthew and Luke, deliberately choosing to omit material both his sources agreed on — including material as significant as the birth narratives and most of the Sermon on the Mount — while retaining some of the New Testament's more difficult or theologically undeveloped material, is a harder editorial pattern to explain than an author simply being the earliest and roughest source in the chain. Defenders of the Griesbach hypothesis respond that Mark's evident interest in a compact, action-driven narrative (a concern this course returns to in lecture 6-1) supplies a coherent, if distinctive, editorial purpose for exactly that kind of selection.
4. The Farrer Hypothesis
A third position agrees with the Two-Source Hypothesis about Markan priority but removes Q. The Farrer Hypothesis, first proposed by Austin Farrer and developed with particular force in recent decades by Mark Goodacre, holds that Mark was written first, Matthew used Mark, and Luke used both Mark and Matthew. On this account, the double-tradition material Matthew and Luke share — the material the Two-Source Hypothesis attributes to Q — is simply material Luke took directly from Matthew, exactly as the Griesbach hypothesis holds Luke took shared material from Matthew, but here with Mark's priority preserved rather than reversed.
Goodacre's case, made across several works including The Case Against Q (2002), is essentially one of methodological economy: Q is a hypothetical document invented specifically to explain an agreement pattern that a simpler explanation — direct literary dependence of Luke on Matthew — already accounts for without positing a source no one has ever found any trace of, in citation, manuscript, or patristic mention. Goodacre argues that the "minor agreements" of Matthew and Luke against Mark, which the Two-Source Hypothesis has to treat as a scattered secondary problem, become straightforwardly explicable once Luke's direct use of Matthew is granted: they simply are Luke following Matthew's wording at points where the Two-Source Hypothesis has no mechanism to explain the overlap at all.
The difficulty most often raised against Farrer's account concerns Luke's handling of Matthew's distinctive material, especially the double-tradition sayings: if Luke had Matthew's Gospel in hand, critics ask, why does Luke scatter sayings Matthew presents together in the Sermon on the Mount across many different, often less obviously connected settings throughout his own Gospel, rather than preserving Matthew's carefully constructed discourse? Defenders of the Farrer position answer that Luke's own compositional preferences elsewhere show a consistent tendency to disperse blocks of teaching material into smaller units set within a travel narrative — a stylistic habit, not evidence Luke lacked Matthew as a source.
5. Where this leaves a student
Three views remain
This is a point where readers will not agree. Each of these three positions is held today by scholars who have devoted careers to the underlying Greek text, and each explains part of the evidence more naturally than its rivals explain that same part. The Two-Source Hypothesis remains the default assumption in most seminary curricula and critical commentaries, largely on the strength of the order argument and Mark's stylistic roughness; the Griesbach hypothesis keeps a smaller but genuine following, strengthened by its appeal to patristic testimony and its refusal to posit an undiscovered document; the Farrer Hypothesis has gained real ground in recent decades precisely because it shares Markan priority's strongest argument while dispensing with Q's weakest feature — that it has never been found. No experiment can adjudicate a historical-literary question like this one, and it is worth naming plainly that a Christian's confidence in the Gospels' truthfulness does not depend on settling it. Whichever explanation is correct, all three positions agree the canonical result is four books the church received as authoritative Scripture — the question is only how the writing process behind three of them worked.
In short
- The evidence any theory must explain has four parts: triple tradition (all three Gospels), double tradition (Matthew and Luke, not Mark), the order pattern (Matthew and Luke rarely agree against Mark's sequence), and minor agreements (small shared wording against Mark, like "Who is it that struck you?" in Matthew 26:68 and Luke 22:64).
- The Two-Source Hypothesis holds Mark was written first and used independently by Matthew and Luke, who also independently used a hypothetical sayings source, "Q" (from German Quelle) — no manuscript of Q has ever been found.
- The Griesbach/Two-Gospel Hypothesis, revived by William Farmer, holds Matthew was written first, Luke used Matthew, and Mark conflated both last — eliminating the need for Q and appealing to patristic testimony that names Matthew as earliest.
- The Farrer Hypothesis, developed by Mark Goodacre, keeps Markan priority but has Luke use both Mark and Matthew directly, eliminating Q by economy and explaining the minor agreements as simply Luke following Matthew's wording.
- All three positions agree on the canonical result — four books the church received as authoritative Scripture — and disagree only about the compositional process behind three of them; the debate is not resolved and a Christian's confidence in the Gospels' truthfulness does not depend on resolving it.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: The Synoptic Problem asks how Matthew, Mark, and Luke's shared wording, sequence, and even shared editorial asides are best explained, and three real positions remain live today: the mainstream Two-Source Hypothesis (Mark first, plus a hypothetical sayings source "Q" that has never been found), the Griesbach/Two-Gospel Hypothesis revived by William Farmer (Matthew first, Mark last, no Q needed), and the Farrer Hypothesis developed by Mark Goodacre (Mark first, Luke uses both Mark and Matthew directly, no Q needed). Each theory explains some part of the evidence — triple tradition, double tradition, the order pattern, or the minor agreements — more naturally than its rivals, and "this is a point where readers will not agree." What all three share is agreement on which four books the church received; only the writing process behind them remains contested.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Explain in your own words the difference between "triple tradition," "double tradition," and "minor agreements." Why does an adequate theory need to explain all three, not just the most obvious one?
- What is the strongest single argument for Markan priority? Is that argument, by itself, also an argument for Q — or are they logically separable, as the Farrer Hypothesis shows?
- Farmer argued that early patristic testimony favoring Matthew's priority deserved more weight than it had received. What kind of evidence would you want to see before deciding how much weight patristic testimony should carry against internal literary evidence?
- Goodacre's case against Q is partly an appeal to economy — not multiplying hypothetical sources beyond necessity. Can you think of a case, in this lecture or elsewhere, where a simpler explanation is not automatically the correct one?
- Does the Synoptic Problem's lack of resolution affect your confidence in the Gospels' content? Why should it, or why should it not?