FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH403E Figures and Movements in Christian Thought

Lecture 19-3: Fundamentalism, Machen, and a Historians' Argument That Will Not Close

Contents 97
CH403E Figures and Movements in Christian Thought
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Study People and Their Ideas
  1. Introduction: Why Study People and Their Ideas
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Method of Studying Figures and Movements
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "History of Christian Thought" Studies
  2. Lecture 1-2: Handling Sources — Primary, Secondary, and the Discipline of Context
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Researcher's Traps and Ethics
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Origen and the Alexandrian School
  1. Lecture 2-1: Origen's Life — Alexandria, Martyrdom, and Exile
  2. Lecture 2-2: On First Principles and the Alexandrian Reading of Scripture
  3. Lecture 2-3: Condemned Three Centuries Later — the Origenist Controversies
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Athanasius
  1. Lecture 3-1: Life and Exile
  2. Lecture 3-2: On the Incarnation and Homoousios
  3. Lecture 3-3: Athanasius Against the World, Fact and Legend
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Augustinianism and the Pelagian Controversy
  1. Lecture 4-1: Two Conversions, Two Convictions
  2. Lecture 4-2: Grace, Original Sin, and Two Councils
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Argument's Long Afterlife
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Anselm
  1. Lecture 5-1: Anselm's Life — Bec, Canterbury, and Two Kings
  2. Lecture 5-2: Faith Seeking Understanding — the Proslogion and Cur Deus Homo
  3. Lecture 5-3: Satisfaction Theory's Legacy — Dominance, Dissent, and an Honest Question
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Bernard and Medieval Mysticism
  1. Lecture 6-1: Clairvaux, Popes, and a Crusade
  2. Lecture 6-2: On Loving God and the Sermons on the Song of Songs
  3. Lecture 6-3: Abelard's Condemnation and Mysticism's Contested Place
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Thomas Aquinas and Thomism
  1. Lecture 7-1: Life and the Aristotle Crisis
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Summa Theologiae — Method and Central Moves
  3. Lecture 7-3: Thomism's Long Afterlife
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Scotus, Ockham, and Nominalism
  1. Lecture 8-1: Two Friars, Two Crises
  2. Lecture 8-2: Univocity, Voluntarism, and Two Kinds of Power
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Covenant That Could Not Give Certainty
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Martin Luther
  1. Lecture 9-1: Erfurt, Rome, and the Tower
  2. Lecture 9-2: Faith Alone, the Bound Will, and the Cross
  3. Lecture 9-3: Legacy — A Movement, a Failure, and a Dialogue
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: John Calvin
  1. Lecture 10-1: Noyon to Geneva — Calvin's Life
  2. Lecture 10-2: Union with Christ — the Institutes and Calvin's Method
  3. Lecture 10-3: Confessions, Kings, Capitalism, and Contested Ownership — Calvin's Legacy
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: The Anabaptists and the Radical Reformation
  1. Lecture 11-1: Origins — Zurich, Zwingli, and Schleitheim
  2. Lecture 11-2: Core Convictions and a Divided Movement
  3. Lecture 11-3: Legacy — Mennonites, Hutterites, Amish, and Religious Liberty
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: Beza and Reformed Orthodoxy
  1. Lecture 12-1: Theodore Beza's Life and His Succession of Calvin
  2. Lecture 12-2: Reformed Scholasticism and the Muller Debate
  3. Lecture 12-3: The Canons of Dort and Their Long Influence
Chapter 13 · Chapter 13: John Owen and Puritan Theology
  1. Lecture 13-1: John Owen's Life, from Oxford to Nonconformist Exile
  2. Lecture 13-2: Owen's Major Works — Mortification, Definite Atonement, and the Spirit
  3. Lecture 13-3: Puritan Theology's Shape and Its Twentieth-Century Recovery
Chapter 14 · Chapter 14: Spener, Francke, and Pietism
  1. Lecture 14-1: Spener's Reform Program and Francke's Halle
  2. Lecture 14-2: The New Birth, the Collegia Pietatis, and Practical Christianity
  3. Lecture 14-3: Zinzendorf, Wesley, and the Warmth/Precision Tension
Chapter 15 · Chapter 15: Jonathan Edwards
  1. Lecture 15-1: Jonathan Edwards — Life and Context
  2. Lecture 15-2: Jonathan Edwards — Religious Affections, Freedom of the Will, and the Beauty of God
  3. Lecture 15-3: Jonathan Edwards — Legacy, Slavery, and New Calvinism
Chapter 16 · Chapter 16: John Wesley and Methodism
  1. Lecture 16-1: Aldersgate and Fifty Years on Horseback
  2. Lecture 16-2: Prevenient Grace, Christian Perfection, and the Split with Whitefield
  3. Lecture 16-3: A Global Church, a Holiness Movement, and an Unfinished Reckoning
Chapter 17 · Chapter 17: Friedrich Schleiermacher
  1. Lecture 17-1: Schleiermacher's Life and the Speeches to the Cultured Despisers
  2. Lecture 17-2: The Christian Faith and the Feeling of Absolute Dependence
  3. Lecture 17-3: Liberal Protestantism's Century and the Argument That Followed
Chapter 18 · Chapter 18: Søren Kierkegaard
  1. Lecture 18-1: Copenhagen, Regine, and the Attack on Christendom
  2. Lecture 18-2: Abraham, Despair, and the Stages on Life's Way
  3. Lecture 18-3: Existentialism, Neo-Orthodoxy, and an Unresolved Inheritance
Chapter 19 · Chapter 19: Charles Hodge and Old Princeton
  1. Lecture 19-1: Charles Hodge's Life and Princeton's Long Memory
  2. Lecture 19-2: Systematic Theology, Baconian Method, and the Doctrine of Inerrancy
  3. Lecture 19-3: Fundamentalism, Machen, and a Historians' Argument That Will Not Close
Chapter 20 · Chapter 20: Abraham Kuyper
  1. Lecture 20-1: Kuyper's Life — From Parish to Parliament
  2. Lecture 20-2: Common Grace, Sphere Sovereignty, and Neo-Calvinism
  3. Lecture 20-3: Legacy — Bavinck, Worldview Evangelicalism, and an Honest Reckoning
Chapter 21 · Chapter 21: Karl Barth
  1. Lecture 21-1: Barth's Life — From Liberal Pastor to the Barmen Declaration
  2. Lecture 21-2: The Church Dogmatics and the "Nein!" to Natural Theology
  3. Lecture 21-3: Legacy — Claimed by Everyone, Debated on Election, Honest About Von Kirschbaum
Chapter 22 · Chapter 22: Bavinck, Vos, and Dutch Reformed Theology
  1. Lecture 22-1: Two Sons of the Secession — Bavinck's and Vos's Formation
  2. Lecture 22-2: Grace Restores Nature — Bavinck's System and Vos's Method
  3. Lecture 22-3: A Late Arrival — Bavinck in English and Vos at Westminster
Chapter 23 · Chapter 23: Dietrich Bonhoeffer
  1. Lecture 23-1: From Lecture Hall to Underground Seminary to Conspiracy
  2. Lecture 23-2: Costly Grace and an Unfinished Ethics
  3. Lecture 23-3: A Legacy Claimed by Everyone, Resolved by No One
Chapter 24 · Chapter 24: C. S. Lewis
  1. Lecture 24-1: From Atheism to Christianity — Life and Friendships
  2. Lecture 24-2: Mere Christianity, Narnia, and Screwtape
  3. Lecture 24-3: Legacy, Popular Influence, and Honest Criticism
Chapter 25 · Chapter 25: Martyn Lloyd-Jones and Expository Preaching
  1. Lecture 25-1: From Harley Street to a Mission Church
  2. Lecture 25-2: Logic on Fire
  3. Lecture 25-3: The Chair, the Call, and the Reply
Chapter 26 · Chapter 26: Francis Schaeffer and Cultural Apologetics
  1. Lecture 26-1: Francis Schaeffer's Life and the Founding of L'Abri
  2. Lecture 26-2: The God Who Is There and How Should We Then Live?
  3. Lecture 26-3: Schaeffer's Legacy — Political Mobilization and Later Critique
Chapter 27 · Chapter 27: Carl Henry, J. I. Packer, and Neo-Evangelicalism
  1. Lecture 27-1: Carl Henry's Uneasy Conscience
  2. Lecture 27-2: Packer, Fuller, the NAE, and the Chicago Statement
  3. Lecture 27-3: Fractures and the Contested Label
Chapter 28 · Chapter 28: Gustavo Gutiérrez and Liberation Theology
  1. Lecture 28-1: A Priest in Lima and a Bishops' Conference in Medellín
  2. Lecture 28-2: A Theology of Liberation and Its Central Claims
  3. Lecture 28-3: Rome's Caution, and a Family of Liberation Theologies
Chapter 29 · Chapter 29: Moltmann and Pannenberg
  1. Lecture 29-1: Two Formations — A Prisoner's Hope and a Historian's Discipline
  2. Lecture 29-2: Hope from the Cross, Revelation from the Future
  3. Lecture 29-3: Legacy — Political Theology, Faith and Reason, and Two Honest Objections
Chapter 30 · Chapter 30: John Stott and the Lausanne Movement
  1. Lecture 30-1: One Parish, One World
  2. Lecture 30-2: Basic Christianity, the Cross, and a Covenant
  3. Lecture 30-3: A Movement That Outlived the Room, and a Question Stott Left Open
Chapter 31 · Chapter 31: The New Perspective on Paul
  1. Lecture 31-1: Origins — E. P. Sanders and Covenantal Nomism
  2. Lecture 31-2: Development — Dunn, Wright, and the New Perspective Named
  3. Lecture 31-3: The Live Dispute — New Perspective and Traditional Response
Chapter 32 · Chapter 32: Korean Figures and Movements
  1. Lecture 32-1: The 1907 Pyongyang Revival and the Shrine-Worship Resistance
  2. Lecture 32-2: Minjung Theology and Its Relation to Latin American Liberation Theology
  3. Lecture 32-3: Growth, Global Mission, and Honest Reckoning

Jump to the key points ↓

15 min

Charles Hodge died in 1878 believing he had spent his career defending, unchanged, the Reformed doctrine of Scripture the church had always confessed. Within roughly fifty years of his death, the seminary he had taught at for fifty-eight years was reorganized by its own governing church in a way its most committed defenders of that doctrine considered a betrayal of everything Hodge, A. A. Hodge, and Warfield had stood for — and some of the ablest of those defenders walked out to found a rival institution rather than stay. This lecture follows Old Princeton's doctrine of Scripture out of the seminary's own classrooms and into the wider, harder arena of American Presbyterian church politics: the fundamentalist-modernist controversy of the 1920s, the 1929 reorganization of Princeton Seminary, and J. Gresham Machen's departure to found Westminster Theological Seminary as, in the founders' own telling, "Old Princeton" continued elsewhere.

The lecture then turns to a second, quieter but equally consequential legacy: the argument, still unresolved among historians of American religion, over how much this chapter's earlier two lectures should actually worry you. Some scholars have argued that Old Princeton's confident, Scottish-philosophy-shaped method did not simply restate the Reformation's doctrine of Scripture in modern dress, but subtly altered what "inerrancy" meant compared to what the Reformers themselves, or the church before them, had actually claimed. Other scholars have argued, with real force, that this criticism gets the history backward. This lecture presents both sides as carefully as it can, because the question genuinely remains open, and because chapter 1's warning against the "tidy villain and tidy hero" applies here as directly as anywhere else in this course.

What these 15 minutes give you

  • Describe Old Princeton's role in the fundamentalist-modernist controversy of the 1920s, including the Auburn Affirmation and the pressures that led to the seminary's 1929 reorganization.
  • Explain why J. Gresham Machen and several colleagues left Princeton to found Westminster Theological Seminary in 1929, and what they believed they were preserving by doing so.
  • State the Rogers-McKim thesis about the historical novelty of Princeton's inerrancy doctrine, and state John Woodbridge's principal counter-argument against it.
  • Explain why this specific historiographical debate remains unsettled, and identify at least one point where a more measured, middle assessment (associated with historians like Mark Noll) has tried to hold both sides' strongest evidence together.

Sanctify them in your truth. Your word is truth." — John 17:17

World English Bible

The doctrine this chapter has traced from Hodge through Warfield claimed nothing more, in its own self-understanding, than this verse's flat identification of God's word with truth itself. What this lecture studies is what happened once that claim became, in effect, a boundary marker for who counted as a faithful minister within American , and once historians began asking, decades later, whether the doctrine defending Christ's own prayer had been shaped, in ways its defenders did not fully notice, by a specific and contestable nineteenth-century philosophy.

1. The fundamentalist-modernist controversy and Princeton's institutional identity

By the 1920s, American Presbyterianism, like several other major American denominations, was engaged in an increasingly public conflict between theological conservatives, who came to be called "fundamentalists" after a series of pamphlets, The Fundamentals (1910-1915), defending doctrines including biblical , and theological liberals or "modernists," who wanted a Christianity reconciled with modern biblical criticism, evolutionary science, and a less doctrinally rigid confessional standard. Princeton Seminary's faculty, heirs to Hodge, A. A. Hodge, and Warfield (who died in 1921), stood firmly identified with the conservative side, and Princeton's doctrine of biblical inerrancy functioned throughout the controversy as one of the clearest, most precisely stated conservative positions available — cited by fundamentalists and criticized by modernists alike as the sharpest form the doctrine took.

The controversy came to a head over the 1922 sermon "Shall the Fundamentalists Win?" by the liberal Baptist preacher Harry Emerson Fosdick, delivered from a Presbyterian pulpit in New York and widely circulated, which argued for tolerance of modernist views within the denomination; conservatives responded forcefully, and the ensuing church-wide conflict included the 1924 "Auburn Affirmation," a document signed by over a thousand Presbyterian ministers arguing that certain doctrines fundamentalists treated as essential, including biblical inerrancy stated in Princeton's precise terms, should be regarded as theories about, rather than essential facts of, the faith. The denomination's governing bodies, seeking to manage this conflict institutionally, voted in 1929 to reorganize Princeton Seminary's own governance, restructuring its board and faculty appointments in a way that broadened the range of theological views represented on its faculty and diluted the conservative faction's previously decisive institutional control.

2. Machen's departure and the founding of Westminster

J. Gresham Machen, a New Testament scholar on Princeton's faculty and the most visible conservative voice in the controversy, had already published Christianity and Liberalism in 1923, arguing that was not a variant form of Christianity at all but, in its actual content, a different religion sharing Christian vocabulary. Machen judged the 1929 reorganization a decisive defeat for the theological identity Old Princeton had stood for since Hodge's own tenure, and rather than remain on a faculty he believed had been institutionally repositioned against that identity, he resigned, along with several like-minded colleagues including the Old Testament scholar Robert Dick Wilson and the apologist Cornelius Van Til, to found Westminster Theological Seminary in Philadelphia later that same year. Machen and the seminary's founders described Westminster explicitly, in their own public statements, as a continuation of "Old Princeton" theology rather than a new departure — the same confessional Reformed doctrine, the same commitment to biblical inerrancy, transplanted to a new institution once the old one's governance had changed. Machen himself was later suspended from Presbyterian ministry after founding an independent foreign missions board in defiance of denominational authority, and in 1936 he helped found a new denomination, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, dying suddenly at the very start of 1937. Westminster Seminary has continued to the present day as one of the most direct institutional heirs of Old Princeton's theological project.

3. An unsettled historians' argument: did Scottish philosophy reshape the doctrine it defended?

The most consequential scholarly challenge to Old Princeton's own self-understanding came decades after these events, from the historians Jack Rogers and Donald McKim, whose 1979 book The Authority and Interpretation of the Bible argued what has become known as the Rogers-McKim thesis: that the historic, mainstream Christian doctrine of Scripture's authority, from the early church through the Reformers, concerned Scripture's saving, salvific sufficiency, and did not require or even generally address the kind of precise, technical inerrancy in matters of history and natural science that the Princeton theologians made central. On this reading, Hodge, A. A. Hodge, and Warfield did not simply restate an old doctrine with new philosophical clarity; they built a genuinely new doctrinal emphasis, shaped decisively by Scottish Common Sense philosophy's confidence that texts, like natural facts, could be read with scientific precision, and then projected that new emphasis backward onto the tradition as though it had always been there.

This thesis did not go unanswered. The historian John Woodbridge published a detailed, chapter-by-chapter rebuttal, Biblical Authority: A Critique of the Rogers/McKim Proposal (1982), arguing that Rogers and McKim had significantly misread their own patristic, medieval, and Reformation sources, and that a concern for Scripture's inerrancy in matters of historical and factual detail, not merely saving doctrine, can be documented well before the nineteenth century, including in Augustine's own explicit statements about Scripture's freedom from error and in the Reformers' own treatment of Scripture's historical claims. Woodbridge's critique persuaded a considerable number of scholars that the Rogers-McKim thesis, at minimum, overstated its case.

A more measured position, associated particularly with the historian Mark Noll (whose edited anthology The Princeton Theology, 1812-1921 remains a standard sourcebook for this material) and with George Marsden's histories of American fundamentalism, has tried to hold both sides' genuine insights together rather than declare one side simply right. On this reading, the church did hold, well before Hodge, a substantial historical commitment to Scripture's truthfulness that Rogers and McKim understated; but Scottish Common Sense philosophy also did give Old Princeton a specific rhetorical confidence, a specific scientific vocabulary, and a specific inductive method that earlier defenders of Scripture's truthfulness did not use in quite the same way, and that shaped how precisely and how defensively the doctrine came to be stated in response to nineteenth-century biblical criticism. Whether that shift in vocabulary and method changed the doctrine's actual content, or only its manner of defense, is precisely where the debate remains open, and this lecture leaves it open rather than resolving it for you: readers with genuine expertise, working from the same primary sources, continue to weigh this evidence differently.


Diagram 1. From seminary to seminary: 1812 to 1929

Old Princeton's Institutional Line 1812-1878 Alexander, then Hodge, at Princeton Theological Seminary 1881-1921 A. A. Hodge and Warfield sharpen the doctrine of inerrancy 1929 Reorganization; Machen departs to found Westminster Machen: "Christianity and Liberalism" is not a variant of the faith but a different religion. Westminster (1929) claimed direct continuity with Hodge, A. A. Hodge, and Warfield.

Diagram 2. A historians' argument, both sides stated

Did Scottish Philosophy Reshape the Doctrine? Rogers and McKim (1979) Historic doctrine concerned Scripture's saving sufficiency. Princeton's technical inerrancy was a genuinely new emphasis, projected back onto the past. Woodbridge (1982) Concern for Scripture's factual and historical inerrancy, not only saving truth, predates Princeton by centuries, back at least to Augustine. Noll and Marsden: earlier commitment to Scripture's truthfulness is real, but Princeton's vocabulary and method were genuinely new. Content or manner only? Historians still disagree.

5. Going to the Sources

Read J. Gresham Machen, Christianity and Liberalism (1923), chapter 1, "Introduction," freely available at ccel.org, for Machen's own statement of why he considered theological liberalism a different religion rather than a variant of Christianity — the argument that directly motivated his 1929 departure from Princeton and the founding of Westminster.


In short

  • In the 1920s, fundamentalists and modernists fought over doctrines including inerrancy. Princeton's faculty stood on the conservative side. The 1924 Auburn Affirmation called such doctrines theories, not essential facts.
  • In 1929 the church reorganized Princeton's governance, broadening the views on its faculty. J. Gresham Machen, who had argued in Christianity and Liberalism that liberalism is a different religion, left with colleagues to found Westminster Seminary.
  • Westminster described itself as continuing "Old Princeton." Machen later helped found the Orthodox Presbyterian Church in 1936 and died at the start of 1937.
  • Rogers and McKim (1979) argued Princeton's technical inerrancy was a new emphasis shaped by Scottish philosophy. John Woodbridge (1982) replied that concern for factual inerrancy goes back at least to Augustine.
  • Mark Noll and George Marsden hold a middle view: the earlier commitment to Scripture's truthfulness was real, but Princeton's vocabulary and method were new. Whether the content changed is open.

Topic: Old Princeton's doctrine of Scripture in the fundamentalist-modernist conflict, the 1929 split, and the unresolved historians' argument over whether the doctrine was new.

Remember: Historians still disagree on whether Princeton changed what inerrancy meant or only how it was defended. The lecture leaves the question open.

Caution: Neither "tidy villain" nor "tidy hero" fits. Rogers and McKim and Woodbridge each judge the evidence differently, and the middle position holds parts of both.

One line to carry into ministry: When a church divides over doctrine, count the cost on every side before treating the other group as a different religion.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Machen argued that liberal Christianity was not a variant of the faith but a different religion sharing Christian vocabulary. What do you find persuasive, and what do you find too sweeping, about drawing that line so sharply?
  • The 1929 reorganization of Princeton Seminary and Machen's departure to found Westminster split an institution that had stood for a single theological identity for over a century. What does this history suggest about the cost, on every side, of a genuinely unresolvable institutional disagreement?
  • This lecture presents the Rogers-McKim thesis and Woodbridge's rebuttal as a live, unresolved historians' argument rather than settling it. Having read both summaries, which side's evidence do you currently find more persuasive, and what would change your mind?
  • Noll and Marsden's middle position distinguishes between the content of a doctrine and the manner or vocabulary used to defend it. Can you think of another doctrine, in another era, where a defender's method or vocabulary might have shifted even while the underlying claim stayed substantially the same?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.