Lecture 6-1: A Good Question Makes a Good Conversation
Contents 41
- Lecture 1-1: What the Bible Says About Evangelism, Command or Invitation
- Lecture 1-2: Naming the Fear, Rejection, Looking Strange, Losing the Friendship
- Lecture 1-3: Five Misunderstandings About Evangelism
- Lecture 1-4: Why Is This Hard for Me, a Self-Diagnosis
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Drawing the Map of Your Own Fear
- Lecture 2-1: What the Gospel Is — The Minimum Core
- Lecture 2-2: The Kingdom of God and the Gospel
- Lecture 2-3: Between a Cheap Gospel and a Heavy One
- Lecture 2-4: The Gospel and My Own Life — What It Changed
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab — Explaining the Gospel in Three Minutes
- Lecture 3-1: How Jesus Evangelised — The Table and the Relationship
- Lecture 3-2: Listening Comes First
- Lecture 3-3: Between Friendship and Purpose
- Lecture 3-4: Approaching a Different Life and a Different World
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab — Mapping the People Already in Your Life
- Lecture 4-1: What a Testimony Is
- Lecture 4-2: Three Acts: Before, Encounter, After
- Lecture 4-3: Honest, Not Impressive
- Lecture 4-4: Thirty Seconds, Five Minutes, Fifteen
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drafting Your Testimony
- Lecture 5-1: Working as a Christian Works
- Lecture 5-2: The Hardest People: Family and Neighbours
- Lecture 5-3: Witness on a Screen
- Lecture 5-4: When the Life and the Words Agree
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Plan for This Week
- Lecture 6-1: A Good Question Makes a Good Conversation
- Lecture 6-2: Answering the Questions People Actually Ask
- Lecture 6-3: Talking with People of Other Faiths, and with Atheists
- Lecture 6-4: Losing the Argument and Keeping the Person
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab — Role-Play on the Hard Questions
- Lecture 7-1: When to Speak — Reading the Moment
- Lecture 7-2: Saying the Gospel in Your Own Words
- Lecture 7-3: The Invitation — Asking Without Pressing
- Lecture 7-4: When the Answer Is No
- Lecture 7-5: Practice Lab — Presenting the Gospel and Receiving Feedback
Most of us prepare for evangelism by deciding what to say. We rehearse an explanation, we memorise an outline, and then we wait for an opening to deliver it.
Jesus worked the other way round. Read the Gospels with a pencil and mark every question he asks. There are hundreds of them. Again and again, the Teacher who had the answer began by asking.
This lecture is about that habit. A question is not a delay before the real conversation. It is the real conversation. A good question does something an explanation cannot do: it lets the other person hear their own thinking out loud, in their own words, without being told they are wrong.
What these 14 minutes give you
- Describe how Jesus uses a question in John 5:6 and Mark 8:29, and say what each question achieves.
- Tell the difference between a question that puts someone on trial and a question that invites them to think.
- Explain why listening comes before questioning, and what happens when it does not.
- Use four practical habits for asking questions in an ordinary conversation.
When Jesus saw him lying there, and knew that he had been sick for a long time, he asked him, 'Do you want to be made well?'" — John 5:6
World English Bible
He said to them, 'But who do you say that I am?' Peter answered, 'You are the Christ.'" — Mark 8:29
WEB
Two questions, thirty seconds of speech between them. One is asked of a stranger who has been ill for thirty-eight years. The other is asked of the men who had walked with Jesus for years. Neither man is given the answer. Both are asked for it.
1. "Do you want to be made well?" — a strange question
At the pool of Bethesda, Jesus meets a man who has been ill for thirty-eight years. He asks him whether he wants to get better.
On the face of it the question is absurd. Who lies beside a healing pool for thirty-eight years and does not want to be healed?
But thirty-eight years is long enough to change a person. Long enough for hope to become a habit you no longer practise. Long enough that the man's daily work is no longer getting well; it is getting through the day. Jesus is not asking for information. He is asking the man to look at something he has stopped looking at.
Notice what the man says back. He does not say yes. He explains why it has never worked: there is nobody to put him into the water, and someone else always gets there first. That is not an answer. That is a description of a closed door.
And Jesus does not argue with it. He does not correct the man's excuse or point out the flaw in his reasoning. He simply tells him to get up. The question was not a trap to be sprung. It was a door held open.
2. "But who do you say that I am?"
Mark 8 shows the same habit used differently. Jesus asks first about public opinion — who do people say that I am? The disciples report the rumours: John the Baptist, Elijah, one of the prophets.
Then he turns the question round. But who do you say that I am?
He does not supply the answer. He could have. He had every right to open with a plain declaration of who he was, and the disciples would have written it down. Instead he waits, and Peter says it himself: You are the Christ.
That difference matters more than it looks. A conviction a person has spoken with their own mouth belongs to them in a way that a conviction they have been handed does not. Peter's confession is not a repetition. It is a decision, and later, when Peter fails badly, it is his own words he has to come back to.
3. The question that puts someone on trial
In evangelism, a question can go in one of two directions, and the direction is set before you open your mouth.
Some questions have their answer already decided. The asker is not curious; the asker is prosecuting. You can hear it in the phrasing:
- "Are you really happy living like that?"
- "If you died tonight, where would you go?" — asked as a challenge, not a wondering.
- "Why haven't you believed yet?"
These are not questions. They are accusations with a question mark attached, and the person you are speaking to knows it within two seconds. Their shoulders go up. They stop telling you what they think and start defending themselves, and once someone is defending themselves the conversation is over even if the talking continues.
There is a second reason to avoid them, and in many places it is the more urgent one. In much of the world a person who admits interest in Christ is risking something real — a marriage, a job, a place in the family. If your question forces them to declare a position in front of others before they are ready, you have not been bold. You have been careless with someone else's cost.
4. The question that invites someone to think
The other kind of question has no answer waiting behind it. The asker genuinely wants to know.
- "What was the hardest part of that for you?"
- "How have you thought about faith over the years?"
- "Have you ever wondered what happens after we die?"
These carry no verdict. They do not require the other person to defend anything, because nothing has been attacked. They can simply think, and say what they think.
Something else happens too. When a person explains their own position out loud to someone who is genuinely listening, they often hear the weak places in it themselves. Nobody has to point them out. You do not have to win an argument that the other person is quietly having with themselves.
5. Listening comes first
Good questions do not come out of nowhere. They come out of listening.
In week three we said that listening is where evangelism begins. Questions are the next step, and they depend entirely on the first one. A question invented in advance and dropped into a conversation sounds like a form being filled in. A question drawn from something the person has just told you sounds like what it is: attention.
Suppose a neighbour says, "I am so tired these days." You have two options. You can change the subject to church, which tells her that her tiredness was an opening for your agenda. Or you can ask what has been making her so tired, which tells her that you heard her.
Only one of those two conversations is still going next week.
6. Four habits
One: ask before you answer. When someone raises a subject you know something about, resist the explanation for thirty seconds. "What do you think about that?" costs nothing and usually doubles the length of the conversation.
Two: strip the verdict out of the question. "Doesn't that way of living wear you down?" carries a judgement. "What matters most to you these days?" does not, and it will get you further.
Three: when the answer seems wrong, ask again instead of correcting. "That's interesting — what made you see it that way?" keeps the door open. A rebuttal closes it. You will still get your turn.
Four: after you ask, actually listen. If questions become a technique, people can feel it, and being handled feels worse than being preached at. The question must be real or it is not worth asking.
7. Aim at the person
Everything in this lecture points the same way, and it is the direction the whole chapter takes.
A question aimed at winning is a weapon: it corners, it exposes, it forces an admission. A question aimed at the person is an invitation: it opens, it waits, it leaves them their dignity.
You can win with the first kind. You will usually lose the person. Winning the argument and losing the person is the ordinary outcome, and it starts as early as your first question. Aim at the person, and you will still be talking to them in a year.
Diagram 1. Two Directions a Question Can Take
Diagram 2. What they said, and what you could ask
| What they said | The reply that closes it | The question that opens it |
|---|---|---|
| "I am so tired these days." | "That's why you should come to church." | "What has been making it so heavy?" |
| "I don't believe in God." | "Why not?" (as a challenge) | "Was there something that shaped that?" |
| "When you're dead, you're dead." | "No, that's wrong." | "How does that sit with you?" |
In short
- John 5:6 — Jesus asks a man who has given up whether he still wants to be well. The question opens a door rather than springing a trap.
- Mark 8:29 — Jesus refuses to supply the answer, and Peter's confession becomes Peter's own.
- A question that puts someone on trial has its answer decided in advance; the hearer feels it and starts defending.
- A question that invites thinking carries no verdict, and people often find the weak places in their own position without being told.
- Listening comes first. A question drawn from what someone has just said sounds like attention; one prepared in advance sounds like a form.
- Four habits: ask before answering, remove the verdict, ask again instead of correcting, and genuinely listen.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| John 5:6 | "Do you want to be made well?" — a door held open, not a trap. |
| Mark 8:29 | "Who do you say that I am?" — the confession has to be theirs. |
| On trial or invited | One kind of question demands a defence; the other invites a thought. |
| Listening first | Draw the question out of what they just told you. |
Remember this one sentence A good question does not corner someone. It gives them room to think.
Do this during the week In one conversation, ask a question before you give your answer.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why do you think Jesus asked a thirty-eight-year sufferer whether he wanted to be made well?
- Peter had to say the confession himself. What is lost when we supply people with the answer?
- Think of a recent conversation. Did you ask anything that put the other person on trial?
- Do you agree that listening has to come before questioning? What happens when it does not?
- Name one question you could ask someone this week, and write it in the words you would actually use.