Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab — Role-Play on the Hard Questions
Contents 41
- Lecture 1-1: What the Bible Says About Evangelism, Command or Invitation
- Lecture 1-2: Naming the Fear, Rejection, Looking Strange, Losing the Friendship
- Lecture 1-3: Five Misunderstandings About Evangelism
- Lecture 1-4: Why Is This Hard for Me, a Self-Diagnosis
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Drawing the Map of Your Own Fear
- Lecture 2-1: What the Gospel Is — The Minimum Core
- Lecture 2-2: The Kingdom of God and the Gospel
- Lecture 2-3: Between a Cheap Gospel and a Heavy One
- Lecture 2-4: The Gospel and My Own Life — What It Changed
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab — Explaining the Gospel in Three Minutes
- Lecture 3-1: How Jesus Evangelised — The Table and the Relationship
- Lecture 3-2: Listening Comes First
- Lecture 3-3: Between Friendship and Purpose
- Lecture 3-4: Approaching a Different Life and a Different World
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab — Mapping the People Already in Your Life
- Lecture 4-1: What a Testimony Is
- Lecture 4-2: Three Acts: Before, Encounter, After
- Lecture 4-3: Honest, Not Impressive
- Lecture 4-4: Thirty Seconds, Five Minutes, Fifteen
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drafting Your Testimony
- Lecture 5-1: Working as a Christian Works
- Lecture 5-2: The Hardest People: Family and Neighbours
- Lecture 5-3: Witness on a Screen
- Lecture 5-4: When the Life and the Words Agree
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Plan for This Week
- Lecture 6-1: A Good Question Makes a Good Conversation
- Lecture 6-2: Answering the Questions People Actually Ask
- Lecture 6-3: Talking with People of Other Faiths, and with Atheists
- Lecture 6-4: Losing the Argument and Keeping the Person
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab — Role-Play on the Hard Questions
- Lecture 7-1: When to Speak — Reading the Moment
- Lecture 7-2: Saying the Gospel in Your Own Words
- Lecture 7-3: The Invitation — Asking Without Pressing
- Lecture 7-4: When the Answer Is No
- Lecture 7-5: Practice Lab — Presenting the Gospel and Receiving Feedback
This is the sixth Practice Lab.
This week you have looked at the power of a good question (6-1), the questions people actually ask (6-2), conversations with people of other faiths and with atheists (6-3), and the difference between winning an argument and winning a conversation (6-4).
Today none of that is discussed. Today it is said out loud, to another human being, in a room where nothing is at stake. You will work in pairs. One person asks a hard question; the other answers it in three minutes. Then you swap.
If that prospect makes you uncomfortable, you have understood the exercise correctly.
What these 13 minutes give you
- Give a spoken answer to one of the questions from lectures 6-2 and 6-3.
- Apply the questioning habit of 6-1 and the gentleness of 6-4 in a live conversation.
- Say from experience why attempting an imperfect answer is worth more than preparing a perfect one.
- Explain the confidentiality rule of this lab and keep it.
Always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear." — 1 Peter 3:15
World English Bible
Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." — Colossians 4:6
WEB
Paul writes "each one", not "everyone". There is no single answer that fits every person. You learn how to answer this person, and you learn it by doing it.
3.1 Why role-play
This course has said it from the first week: evangelism changes when you speak, not when you agree.
You now know, in outline, how to approach the five hard questions. But there is a wide gap between knowing something and being able to say it while a person is looking at you. The words come out in the wrong order. You reach for the illustration and it is not there. Your voice does something strange. This happens to everyone, including experienced preachers, and it happens the first time regardless of how well you have studied.
Role-play moves that first time into a safe room. The choice is not between an awkward attempt and a smooth one. It is between being awkward here, among people who are on your side, and being awkward for the first time in front of a colleague who has just asked you a serious question about her dying mother.
3.2 How to run it
One. Form pairs. One person is the questioner, one is the responder.
Two. Draw a question. Use one from lecture 6-2 or 6-3. Appendix 4, the role-play scenarios, has a wider set of situations and sample lines — use it if you have it.
Three. The responder answers within three minutes. It does not need to be a good answer. Try asking a question back (6-1). Try saying "I don't know" (6-2). Try staying gentle (6-4).
Four. Swap roles and go again. The person who asked now answers.
Five. Share one thing that went well — one each, and nothing else. No corrections. No "what you should have said". One thing that went well.
3.3 Four things to try
Try asking something back. Before you answer, try: "Can I ask what made you start thinking about that?" See what it does to the shape of the conversation.
Try admitting you do not know. Say it out loud, deliberately, at least once: "Honestly, I'm not sure. But here's what I do know..." Most people have never said this sentence and are surprised by how solid it feels.
Try holding both sides of 6-3. If the question touches other faiths, practise staying clear about Christ and warm towards the person at the same time. That combination is difficult and it is exactly what needs rehearsing.
Try not getting heated. Even in role-play, a sharp question can land like a real one. Notice it. Breathe. Practise the pause from 6-4 while it is only practice.
3.4 Awkwardness is normal
You will lose your thread. Someone will laugh. A sentence will come out backwards. All of this is normal and none of it is failure.
The introduction to this course promised you would not become an expert in eight weeks, and that promise still holds. The first attempt is awkward, the second is awkward, and somewhere around the fifth it starts to feel like talking. What you are doing today is the first of those five.
Awkwardness is not evidence that you are unsuited to this. It is evidence that you are practising, which most Christians never do.
3.5 The form
The card in section 4-1 is what you actually use. Print it, copy it by hand, or read it off a phone. Fill in the setting and the question before you begin, and let the observer — or the questioner, if you are only two — write in the last box while listening.
Keep the completed cards. In week eight you will look back at them, and the thing you could not say today is usually the thing you will want to see written down.
3.6 Aim at the person
One instruction governs the whole exercise, and it is the chapter's principle.
In role-play there is a strong temptation to perform: to produce the neat answer, to sound competent, to be the person in the pair who clearly knew what to say. Resist it. Winning the argument and losing the person is the ordinary outcome, and today is the day to practise the alternative while nobody's friendship is at risk.
Judge your three minutes by one test only. Would this person want to talk to me again?
3.7 Leader's note — running this in a small group
Setting up the room
Assign the pairs yourself. If people choose, the same people are left over every time, and they are usually the ones who most need a good partner.
Prepare question cards in advance. Write the questions from 6-2, 6-3 and Appendix 4 on slips of paper and have people draw one. Drawing is much easier than choosing.
Keep time strictly. Use a timer and stop at three minutes. Without a timer the first pair takes twenty minutes and nobody else goes.
Join a pair only if the numbers are odd. Otherwise circulate and listen. You will learn more about your group in twenty minutes here than in a month of Bible study.
Allow only encouragement in the feedback.
Not this: "You should have answered that differently." This: "You stayed calm when she pushed, and I noticed it."
Correction is not the purpose of this hour. If someone said something seriously wrong, take it up with them privately afterwards, not in front of the group.
Do not adjudicate 6-3 questions. If a pair lands on other faiths and the group looks at you for the right answer, do not supply one. Restate the landing point — clear about what you believe, gentle about how you treat people — and move on. This lecture is an open question and the leader's opinion is not the verdict.
Watch for real pain. A question about suffering or about hell may touch a real bereavement in the room. If someone goes quiet or tearful, stop the exercise for that pair. The lab is never more important than the person in it.
Restate the confidentiality rule before you start. People mention real names, real families, real fears. Say aloud: nothing from this room leaves this room. In some of the places this course is used, that is not a courtesy — a careless word outside the group can put a family at risk.
4-1. The Role-Play Card
4-2. Leader's checklist
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Pairs assigned in advance | |
| Question slips prepared (6-2, 6-3, Appendix 4) | |
| Timer used, three minutes kept | |
| Roles swapped and run a second time | |
| Only encouragement shared, no corrections | |
| No verdict given on 6-3 questions | |
| Watched for real grief behind a question | |
| Confidentiality rule stated before starting |
In short
- Today's exercise: in pairs, answer a hard question aloud within three minutes, then swap.
- There is a wide gap between knowing an answer and being able to say it. Role-play closes that gap in a safe room.
- Things to try: ask a question back (6-1), admit you do not know (6-2), hold clarity and warmth together (6-3), stay unheated (6-4).
- Awkwardness is not failure. It is evidence of practice, which most Christians never get.
- Feedback is limited to what went well. Correction, if needed, happens privately.
- The leader does not adjudicate the 6-3 questions and does not let the lab override a person's real grief.
- Confidentiality is not a courtesy here. In some places a careless word outside the group endangers a family.
- Keep your completed cards. You will use them again in week eight.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Purpose of the lab | Not memorising answers, but saying them out loud once. |
| The card | Setting, the question, three minutes, notes on what went well. |
| Encouragement only | One good thing each. Corrections happen privately, later. |
| Confidentiality | Nothing said in this room leaves this room. |
Remember this one sentence Evangelism changes not when you memorise the answer but when you say it out loud for the first time.
Do this during the week Write down the question that defeated you today, and prepare it using the cards in Appendix 3.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- As the responder, which moment was hardest?
- You tried asking a question back. What did it change?
- What did it actually feel like to say "I don't know" out loud?
- Playing the questioner, what did you learn about the person answering?
- Which question defeated you today, and how will you prepare it this week?