FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT701E · Chapter 12

Lecture 12-4: Borrowed Words — The Ethics of Sermon Preparation

When borrowing becomes misrepresenting

Advanced Expository Preaching

11 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Distinguish plagiarism — representing another's original work as one's own without attribution or meaningful transformation — from the universal, legitimate practice of relying on commentaries and other secondary sources.
  • State at least two different traditions' norms about using another preacher's outline, illustration, or manuscript, without asserting that one is simply the correct rule for everyone.
  • Explain how 2 Corinthians 8:21's double concern — honorable "in the sight of the Lord" and "in the sight of men" — applies to how sermon material is sourced.
  • Identify at least one concrete practice a preacher can adopt, in any tradition, to stay honest about borrowed material.
The question

Where does reliance cross a line?

Every sermon is built on borrowed material: a commentary's insight, a theology's framing, an illustration heard years ago. That is universal. The lecture asks when relying on someone else's labor becomes misrepresenting whose labor a congregation is hearing, and whether all traditions draw that line in the same place.

Key idea They do not, and the lecture says so.
Definition

What plagiarism names

Plagiarism here means representing another's original work, such as a specific recognizable sermon's words, outline and illustrations, as one's own without attribution, where hearers assume it is the preacher's labor. It does not name the ordinary use of a commentary's insight preached in one's own words. Scott Gibson draws this line.

Key idea No congregation expects pulpit footnotes.
Scripture

Why 2 Corinthians 8:21?

The lecture says Paul writes this about careful arrangements for handling a collection, so no one could accuse him. It uses the verse's double concern, integrity before God and before others, as a test for sourcing practices.

Having regard for honorable things, not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men.
A counter-example

The English Book of Homilies

The Homilies, issued in 1547 and expanded in 1571, were written by leading theologians to be read aloud verbatim by clergy who lacked training or a license to preach their own sermons. Everyone knew the arrangement. The lecture says this shows the expectation that a sermon is the preacher's own composition is not a universal feature of Christian preaching.

Key idea Gibson's norm reflects a specific tradition's expectation.
A living case

Lectionary traditions

A homily at the Mass or Divine Liturgy is preached on an assigned text. Using published aids or patristic homilies on the same readings is old, normal and open. The difference is not whether borrowing happens, since both traditions borrow, but whether it is disclosed in a context where preacher and congregation share an understanding.

Key idea Both traditions borrow constantly.
A shared test

Where the two norms agree

Own-composition tradition

Presenting another living preacher's substantially intact work as one's own breaks the expectation the congregation actually holds.

Shared-resources tradition

Using shared aids openly breaks nothing, because no one listening believes otherwise.

The double concern

Before God and before others

The lecture reads "in the sight of the Lord" as integrity that holds even if no one ever discovers it. It reads "in the sight of men" as integrity that could survive an open conversation with the people drawn upon. This does not say which tradition's expectation is correct, but it gives a test any preacher can apply.

Key idea Would this use of another's material survive being disclosed?
Recap

What to remember

All preaching borrows. Plagiarism is presenting another's specific original work as your own, where the congregation expects otherwise, and ordinary use of commentaries is not plagiarism. Traditions differ on what a sermon is expected to be. Test your practice by whether it would survive disclosure, and keep a running note of where each illustration, phrase and structure came from.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11