Lecture 6-2: Criticism, Rumour and Online Conflict
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Speaking as Witness, Not Marketing
- Lecture 1-2: Our Message and Our Voice
- Lecture 1-3: Choosing Channels: Face to Face, Print, Messages, Web
- Lecture 1-4: Who Is Listening: Members, Neighbours, Newcomers
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Communication Walk-Through
- Lecture 2-1: The Website as a First Welcome
- Lecture 2-2: Social Media and the Community's Voice
- Lecture 2-3: Accessibility and Plain Language
- Lecture 2-4: Many Languages, Many Readers
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Notice
- Lecture 3-1: Online Worship and Streaming: What It Is and Is Not
- Lecture 3-2: Making Things Simply and Well
- Lecture 3-3: People on Camera
- Lecture 3-4: Archives, Storage and the Long Life of Content
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Filming Notice and Consent Page
- Lecture 4-1: Respecting Those Who Made It: Copyright Principles
- Lecture 4-2: Music, Images and Licences in Practice
- Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Sources and Honesty
- Lecture 4-4: Tools and AI: General Principles
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Source and Permission Check
- Lecture 5-1: Numbers, Staging and Success Stories
- Lecture 5-2: Testimony, Stories and Emotional Appeal
- Lecture 5-3: Fundraising and Mission Reports
- Lecture 5-4: Paid Promotion and the Pull of Algorithms
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Report and an Appeal
A community that speaks in public will be spoken about. Some of what is said will be fair, and some will be wrong. Some will be said by a hurt person who has nowhere else to go, and some by a stranger who has never met anyone in the church. Some will be a rumour that began as a misheard sentence. Online, all of this arrives quickly, stays visible, and can be copied. The leader who reads it at night feels it in the body.
This lecture asks how a community should live with criticism, rumour and open conflict in public. The central claim holds: communication is witness, and witness includes how we receive being spoken against. We tell the truth, we respect the neighbour, and we do not let the loudest voice decide what is true. We also do not use the language of faith to silence a fair complaint.
A word about boundaries. Leading a congregation through conflict, and the long work of mending relationships, belongs to the change-and-conflict course. The immediate protection of a person in danger belongs to the safe church course. This lecture is about the public side: what we say, what we leave unsaid, and what we do with comments and messages.
This lecture is not legal advice. Rules about defamation, harassment, threats, privacy and the duties of the people who run an account differ by country, region and year. Check locally, and consult a qualified person if you face a threat or a false statement that is doing real harm.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Tell fair criticism from attack, and rumour from fact, using simple questions.
- Explain how Matthew 18:15-17 describes an order for dealing with a wrong, and why public posts are rarely the place for the first step.
- Describe when a community is free not to answer, and when silence would be a failure.
- Plan how to handle abusive comments without harming the vulnerable or the leaders.
If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother." — Matthew 18:15
World English Bible
But if he doesn’t listen, take one or two more with you, that at the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established." — Matthew 18:16
WEB
If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the assembly. If he refuses to hear the assembly also, let him be to you as a Gentile or a tax collector." — Matthew 18:17
WEB
A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1
WEB
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
WEB
For lack of wood a fire goes out. Without gossip, a quarrel dies down." — Proverbs 26:20
WEB
If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18
WEB
Don’t answer a fool according to his folly, lest you also be like him." — Proverbs 26:4
WEB
Answer a fool according to his folly, lest he be wise in his own eyes." — Proverbs 26:5
WEB
But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear:" — 1 Peter 3:15
WEB
having a good conscience; that, while you are spoken against as evildoers, they may be disappointed who curse your good way of life in Christ." — 1 Peter 3:16
WEB
Matthew 18 gives an order for a wrong between members of a community. Christians read it differently in detail, and it was not written for a world of public comment boxes; it is used here for its direction, which is to begin close and small. The proverbs speak of gentle answers, of hearing before answering, of the fire that gossip feeds, and of the odd pair at 26:4-5, which seems to say two opposite things about answering. Romans 12:18 sets a limit on what peace can be asked of us ("as much as it is up to you"). First Peter 3:15-16 speaks of giving an account with gentleness while being spoken against.
1. Fair criticism and attack are different things
Not all negative words are the same, and a community that treats them all as attacks will stop learning. Here are four questions to ask of any critical message. None of them gives a verdict by itself.
1. Is it about something that happened? Fair criticism usually points to an event, a notice, a decision, a sentence. Attack points to a person's character ("you people are all frauds").
2. Could it be checked? Some criticism is accurate in part. "Your notice gave the wrong time" can be checked in a minute. "Everyone knows you hide things" cannot.
3. Does it want something? A person who wants a correction, an answer or an apology is often telling us something we need to hear, even if rudely. A person who wants only that we suffer is different.
4. Who is it from? A member, a neighbour, a harmed person, a competitor, a stranger. This does not change whether it is true. It changes how we answer, and what we must protect.
(an invented example) A parish office receives two messages the same week. One says: "The website says the food bank is open on Tuesdays. I took two buses on Tuesday and the door was shut. I have a child with me. Why does no one answer?" The other says: "This church is a joke and everyone in it is a hypocrite." The second may hurt more, but the first is the one that asks something of the church. It deserves a reply that day, an apology and a correction. The second may deserve no reply at all.
2. Rumour and fact
A rumour is a claim passed from one person to another without anyone being able to say how they know. It is not the same as a lie, though it can do a lie's work. It often begins from something true that has been shortened or has lost its context.
A community can ask of a rumour:
- Who first said it, and what did they actually see?
- Is a harmed person involved? If so, their wishes come first, and the community must not use the rumour as a reason to expose them.
- Would answering it publicly make it larger?
- Is there a true, short thing we can say that does not hurt anyone?
Proverbs 26:20 says that without wood a fire goes out. A rumour fed by a public denial, a long defence or a counter-attack gets more wood. But a rumour that is spreading and is hurting someone cannot be left alone. The test is whether the person it is about, or the community's members, are being harmed by it. If they are, a short, calm and true statement is better than silence. If they are not, quiet work (a word with the person who began it, a note to those who asked) may be enough.
Never answer a rumour with an untruth. A denial that turns out to be partly false will be remembered long after the rumour is forgotten.
3. Matthew 18:15-17 as an order, not a weapon
Jesus describes three steps for a wrong done between members: go to the person alone; take one or two others if that fails; tell the assembly. The passage has been read in different ways. Some read it as a pattern for discipline inside a church, some as a general principle for any dispute among believers, and some stress that it begins with winning back a brother, not with winning an argument. This course needs only the direction it shows: begin close and small, and widen only if needed.
What follows for public communication is simple and often hard to hear.
- A complaint about a member or leader that is first aired in a public post has skipped the first step. The person who posted may have good reason: they may have tried and been ignored, or may fear the person. The community should ask, kindly, whether they have a way to be heard in person, and should provide one.
- A community that receives a public complaint should not answer publicly in a way that humiliates the poster. It can answer briefly in public ("Thank you for telling us. We are going to contact you directly.") and then do so.
- The passage does not tell a church to settle every wrong in private. Where someone has been harmed by a serious wrong, especially a child or a vulnerable person, the harmed person's safety and the proper authorities come first, and no one is asked to confront the person who harmed them. The safe church course treats this. Matthew 18 should never be used to tell someone to keep quiet.
The passage also does not forbid open words in every case. It is about a brother who sins against you. It does not govern what a church says to the public about a matter of public concern, or how it answers a stranger. Use it as an order for dealing with members, not as a ban on all open speech.
4. The freedom not to answer
A leader who reads every comment and answers each one will not last long. There is a freedom here, and it rests on two verses that seem to pull against each other. Proverbs 26:4 says not to answer a fool according to his folly. Proverbs 26:5 says to answer a fool according to his folly. Readers have long noticed that the book puts them side by side. One plain way to read them is that wisdom discerns which fits the case: sometimes an answer only feeds a quarrel, and sometimes silence leaves a falsehood standing.
A community may decide, in advance and in writing, what it will not answer:
- messages that only insult, with no question or fact in them;
- demands to argue about doctrine in a comment box;
- repeated messages from a person who has been answered;
- messages that are clearly meant to provoke.
A community may not decide that it will not answer:
- a person who says they were harmed;
- a question of fact about a time, a place or a service;
- a request to remove a photograph or personal detail;
- a threat to someone's safety, which goes to the proper authorities.
The line is between not answering and not listening. Even where there is no reply, someone may need to read the message to check whether it hides a real need.
5. Abusive comments and protecting people
Some messages are abusive: they use cruel words, threaten, or harass. There are two groups to protect.
The vulnerable first. A comment that names a child, a harmed person or a member who is sick should be hidden or removed promptly, and the person should be told, kindly, if they would wish it. A community's public space should not become the place where a harmed person is further hurt by strangers. If you moderate a space, the rule is that the vulnerable are protected before the argument is won.
The leaders. A pastor or volunteer who is abused online should not be left to read it alone. The community should decide who reads the worst messages, so it is not always the one targeted, and should say plainly that leaders may take a break. Messages that threaten should be kept (not deleted) and given to the proper authorities, as the safe church course explains.
A few practical habits help.
- Two people with access to the church's accounts, so that no leader needs to act alone and a message can be passed to someone else.
- A written rule, posted where people can see it, on what will be removed: threats, cruelty about a person, personal details, and the like. A rule made in the heat of a fight looks like revenge.
- A short, kind, standard reply to those who are rude but may have a point: "Thank you for writing. We will look into this."
- A pause before answering anything that makes you angry. Proverbs 15:1 is a plain description of what a quick reply does.
- Do not argue with a person in a thread that others are reading unless you must. Move to a private message or a phone call.
6. Being spoken against well
First Peter 3:15-16 speaks of readiness to give an answer for hope, with gentleness and respect, and with a good conscience, so that those who slander may be put to shame. The text asks something particular: to be able to say why we do what we do, without hostility. A community that is criticised for something it has done well can say so, briefly and kindly. A community that is criticised for something it has done badly should say so and mend it. Both are witness. What it should not do is use the language of faith to turn criticism into persecution when the criticism is simply true.
This is sometimes hard, because it is easy to think of any opposition as an attack on the faith. Some opposition is. Much is not. A person who says "your volunteers were rude to my mother" is not persecuting Christ. They are telling us something.
7. In communities of different kinds
(an invented example) A house church of ten has a phone number on a flyer. A neighbour, annoyed by cars parked on his street, sends angry messages. There is no policy. The pastor reads the first, answers once by phone, listens, and promises to ask visitors to park elsewhere. The messages stop. The only rule needed was to answer the person with a real question.
(an invented example) A large congregation has a social media team. A post about a service is flooded with comments arguing about a doctrine, some cruel to a named teenager who read at the service. The team hides the comments that name her, tells her family, posts a short note that comments about individuals will be removed, and does not argue about doctrine in the thread.
(an invented example) A mission agency is accused by an anonymous account of mishandling funds. The accusation is partly wrong and partly points to a real slip in a report. The agency corrects the slip, says so briefly, does not reply to the anonymous account, and gives the donors who wrote a direct answer. Accounting questions belong to the church finance course.
(an invented example) A parish hears a rumour that a catechist has left because of a quarrel. The truth is that she is ill. The priest does not announce her illness (it is hers to tell) but asks the parish council to say, if asked, that she is well cared for and that people should not guess.
8. Where to go from here
Leading a congregation through conflict belongs to the change-and-conflict course; counselling and crisis support to the crisis, mental-health and counselling ethics courses. Lecture 6-3 turns from conflict to the person at the keyboard: rest and sustainability.
Diagram 1. How to read a critical message
Diagram 2. What a community may and may not decide not to answer
| A community may decide in writing not to answer | A community may not decide not to answer |
|---|---|
| Messages that only insult and ask nothing | A person who says they were harmed |
| Demands to argue doctrine in a comment box | A question of fact about a time, place or service |
| Repeated messages from someone already answered | A request to remove a photograph or personal detail |
| Messages plainly meant to provoke | A threat to anyone's safety (it goes to the proper authorities) |
In short
- Ask four questions of a critical message: is it about something that happened, can it be checked, what does it want, and who is it from.
- A rumour is fed by a long public defence; answer it with a short, true word if people are being hurt, and never with an untruth.
- Matthew 18:15-17 shows an order that begins close and small; it is not a ban on open speech and never a reason to silence a harmed person.
- A community may decide in writing not to answer pure insult, but not a harmed person, a question of fact, or a request to remove personal details.
- Protect the vulnerable first when moderating, and do not leave a leader to read the worst messages alone.
- Leading conflict belongs to the change-and-conflict course; this lecture is not legal advice.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Fair criticism or attack | Ask: about what happened, can it be checked, what does it want, who is it from. |
| Feeding a rumour | A long public defence gives it fuel; a short true word, or quiet work, is better. |
| Matthew 18:15-17 | An order that begins close and small; not a ban on open speech, not a reason to silence the harmed. |
| Freedom not to answer | Allowed for pure insult and provocation; not for a harmed person, a fact question or a removal request. |
One sentence to remember Listen for the part of every criticism that is true, protect the vulnerable before you win the argument, and do not answer every fire with wood.
This week's action Write down, in one list, which kinds of messages your community will always answer and which it may leave, and who reads the hardest ones.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of criticism you once received that was unfair, and criticism that was fair. What did each feel like at first? What helped you tell them apart?
- When has a rumour about a community you know been fed by an answer? What might have been said instead?
- Does your community have a written rule about what will be removed from its online space? Who decides, and who reads the worst messages?
- Matthew 18:15-17 begins close and small. Where does your community send a person who wants to complain, so that they do not have to go public?
- Why might a pastor use the language of persecution for criticism that is true? How could your community notice when it is doing that?