Lecture 5-2: The Church and Culture
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What the Church Is — Ekklesia and the New Testament's Images
- Lecture 1-2: The Church's Old Testament Roots and New Testament Founding
- Lecture 1-3: The Visible and Invisible Church
- Lecture 1-4: The Marks and Attributes of the Church
- Lecture 1-5: Church Membership and Boundaries
- Lecture 2-1: Why Polity Is a Theological Question
- Lecture 2-2: Episcopal Polity
- Lecture 2-3: Presbyterian Polity
- Lecture 2-4: Congregational Polity
- Lecture 2-5: The Offices of Elder and Deacon
- Lecture 3-1: Sacrament or Ordinance? Framing the Question
- Lecture 3-2: Baptism — Meaning and Mode
- Lecture 3-3: The Lord's Supper — Four Views
- Lecture 3-4: Who May Come to the Table, and How Often
- Lecture 3-5: The Sacraments as Means of Grace
- Lecture 4-1: A Biblical Theology of Gathered Worship
- Lecture 4-2: The Regulative and Normative Principles of Worship
- Lecture 4-3: Preaching and the Ministry of the Word
- Lecture 4-4: The Elements of Corporate Worship
- Lecture 4-5: Worship Across Cultures
- Lecture 5-1: Evangelism and Social Action
- Lecture 5-2: The Church and Culture
- Lecture 5-3: The Church and the State
- Lecture 5-4: The Church and Social Justice
- Lecture 5-5: Global Mission and the Church's Sending Task
Lecture 5-1 asked whether the church's mission is proclamation, social action, or both. This lecture asks a related but distinct question: however the church defines its mission, what is its posture toward the surrounding culture in which that mission is carried out — the art, politics, economics, family patterns, and shared assumptions of the society the church is planted inside? Every answer a Christian community gives to that question, whether stated explicitly or simply lived out in practice, shapes everything from what kind of music it sings to whether its members run for political office to how readily it borrows the wider culture's categories for describing its own faith.
The framework most theology students still meet first is H. Richard Niebuhr's Christ and Culture (1951), which sorted the historical options into five types: Christ against culture, Christ of culture, Christ above culture, Christ and culture in paradox, and Christ transforming culture. The typology has been so widely used, in seminary classrooms and beyond, that it is worth presenting fairly on its own terms before turning to its well-documented weaknesses — not least because more than one of Niebuhr's own five types has been claimed, at different times, by traditions represented among this course's readers.
The lecture's second half turns to a more recent development: the missional church movement, which argues that the question "how should the church relate to culture" already assumes a picture of the church as a settled, gathered community deciding how to engage an external world, when the more fundamental biblical claim is that the church's very identity is constituted by being sent — that mission is not one activity among the church's others but what the church, in its deepest identity, actually is. This connects directly to Lecture 5-5's material on global sending, without repeating it: 5-2 asks what "sentness" means for the church's posture toward its own culture; 5-5 asks what it means for the church's literal geographic sending across cultures.
What these 21 minutes give you
- State Niebuhr's five-fold typology accurately, with at least one historical or contemporary representative of each type, and explain what question the typology is trying to answer.
- State at least two well-documented criticisms of the typology (its oversimplification of complex historical positions, and the fact that each type claims biblical support) and explain why these criticisms do not make the typology useless, only limited.
- State the missional church movement's core claim — that the church's identity is constituted by being sent, not merely by gathering — and connect it to John 17:14-18's language of being sent into the world without being of it.
- Distinguish this lecture's church-and-culture question from 5-5's church-and-global-mission question, without treating either as a duplicate of the other.
I have given them your word. The world hated them, because they are not of the world, even as I am not of the world. I pray not that you would take them from the world, but that you would keep them from the evil one. They are not of the world even as I am not of the world. Sanctify them in your truth. Your word is truth. As you sent me into the world, even so I have sent them into the world." — John 17:14–18
World English Bible
Jesus's prayer holds two claims together without collapsing either into the other: his disciples are genuinely "not of the world," meaning their ultimate identity and allegiance do not derive from the surrounding culture's values, and yet Jesus explicitly does not ask the Father to "take them from the world" — remove them from it, or insulate them from ongoing contact with it. The verb tying the two together is "sent": exactly as the Father sent Jesus into the world, Jesus sends his disciples into the world in the same way, which is to say, not by withdrawing but by entering it on a specific mission. Every position surveyed below is, at bottom, an attempt to hold "not of the world" and "sent into the world" together without letting either one swallow the other.
1. Niebuhr's five types, stated fairly
Christ against culture treats the church and the surrounding culture as fundamentally in conflict, believers to separation from a world under sin's power. Niebuhr locates Tertullian here in the early church ("What has Athens to do with Jerusalem?") and, in more developed form, the Anabaptist tradition, whose radical-Reformation communities (Mennonite, Amish, Hutterite) sought to form visibly distinct communities unconformed to surrounding society, refusing state violence, oaths, and often broader civic participation. This type's strength is its seriousness about sin's grip on cultural institutions and its refusal to let cultural respectability dilute ; its characteristic risk is a withdrawal so complete that the church loses meaningful contact with, and witness to, the world it is supposedly sent into.
Christ of culture reads Christ as culture's fulfillment or highest expression rather than its judge, identifying the best of a given culture's values — reason, moral progress, social harmony — closely with Christian truth. Niebuhr places nineteenth-century liberal Protestantism here, including theologians like Albrecht Ritschl, who read Christianity chiefly as the perfection of ethical culture and civilization. Its strength is a genuine desire to make faith intelligible and relevant to the surrounding world; its characteristic risk, evident in Lecture 5-1's account of the Social Gospel's own theological cousins, is that Christ's distinctiveness dissolves into whatever the culture already values, leaving no gospel left to proclaim that the culture could not have arrived at on its own.
Christ above culture (the "synthesist" type) holds that grace perfects rather than destroys nature, so that the best of human culture — philosophy, law, the arts — can be taken up into a larger Christian synthesis under the church's authority, with Christ crowning and completing what culture achieves on its own terms. Niebuhr's chief example is Thomas Aquinas, whose theological synthesis incorporated Aristotelian philosophy as a genuine, if incomplete, achievement of unaided reason, brought to fulfillment by revelation. Its strength is taking seriously that God's operates broadly in human culture, not the church alone; its characteristic risk is that the synthesis can harden into an institutional claim — a particular culture's philosophy and a particular era's social order treated as permanently, rather than provisionally, baptized.
Christ and culture in paradox (the "dualist" type) holds culture and gospel in a tension that is never finally resolved this side of Christ's return: believers live simultaneously under two orders — God's righteousness by faith, and the structures of a sinful world still under divine judgment and restraint — obeying both without expecting either to redeem the other on this side of glory. Niebuhr locates Martin Luther here, whose distinction between two kingdoms (taken up more fully in 5-3) resists collapsing the church's spiritual authority into civil authority, or vice versa, while insisting Christians remain obligated to both. Its strength is honesty about the ongoing reality of sin even within a believer's best cultural engagement; its characteristic risk, according to critics, is a resignation that can shade into passivity about actually working for cultural change, since paradox, unrelieved, offers little forward motion.
Christ transforming culture (the "conversionist" type) is Niebuhr's own preferred position: culture is genuinely fallen but not therefore to be abandoned or merely tolerated — it is to be actively converted, redirected toward Christ's purposes, in an ongoing historical process. Niebuhr names Augustine here (whose City of God reads history itself as the interpenetration of two loves, capable of being reordered by grace) and, among Reformation figures, John Calvin, whose Geneva attempted to reform civic life itself according to Christian conviction rather than simply withdrawing from or merely synthesizing with it. This type's strength is hope for real, historical cultural renewal without either capitulating to the culture or abandoning it; its characteristic risk, which the next section takes up, is optimism about how much transformation is actually achievable, and a temptation to underestimate how deeply particular cultural forms can be mistaken for the gospel itself.
2. Well-documented criticisms
The 's most persistent critique is that it oversimplifies genuinely complex historical positions into five tidy boxes that their actual representatives would not fully recognize. The Mennonite theologian John Howard Yoder argued at length, particularly in essays responding directly to Niebuhr, that the "Christ against culture" label caricatures the Anabaptist tradition: Anabaptist communities did not withdraw from cultural engagement wholesale, Yoder argued, but selectively refused specific practices (violence, oath-taking, hierarchical church-state alliance) they judged incompatible with following Jesus, while remaining deeply engaged in economic life, craft, agriculture, and social relationships with their non-Anabaptist neighbors — a much more discriminating posture than "against culture" suggests. If Niebuhr's own preferred category, "transforming culture," is even partly modeled on his own Reformed convictions, the typology risks smuggling in a value judgment (transformation is the mature, best option; the others are earlier or lesser stages) under the guise of neutral historical description — a criticism D. A. Carson develops at length in Christ and Culture Revisited (2008), which argues Niebuhr's categories, taken as a whole, do not sufficiently reckon with the full range of biblical material on culture (creation, fall, and consummation, not only ) and tend to flatten differences within each type that matter theologically.
A second, related criticism, worth stating plainly because it undercuts any attempt to simply "pick a type": each of Niebuhr's five positions can, and does, appeal to genuine biblical support. "Christ against culture" can cite 1 John 2:15's "do not love the world"; "Christ transforming culture" can cite the same material this chapter takes up in 5-5. No single verse settles which posture is correct, which is one reason careful theologians increasingly treat the typology less as a menu from which a church should select one item, and more as a set of emphases in constant tension that a single church, or even a single believer, may need to hold at different times and toward different aspects of the surrounding culture — resisting some cultural currents, redeeming others, and remaining honestly unresolved about still others.
3. The missional church movement
A more recent development shifts the question itself. Missiologist Lesslie Newbigin, returning to Britain after decades of missionary work in India, argued in works like The Gospel in a Pluralist Society (1989) that Western Christians had come to treat their own societies as "Christian" territory requiring maintenance rather than mission territory requiring the same kind of engagement missionaries bring to an unreached culture — a habit of mind Newbigin thought urgently needed to change as Western culture became demonstrably post-Christian. Building on this and on the earlier missiological category of (God's own mission, which the church joins rather than originates — developed further in Lecture 5-5), a body of writers associated with the "missional church" label, including Darrell Guder's edited volume Missional Church: A Vision for the Sending of the Church in North America (1998) and the missiologist David Bosch's comprehensive Transforming Mission (1991), argued that mission is not one program among a church's other activities (worship, education, fellowship, mission) but constitutive of what the church actually is: a community called into being by, and for the sake of, God's sending purpose in the world.
On this account, Niebuhr's whole framing — a settled church deciding how, and how much, to engage an external culture — already gets something wrong, because it treats "gathering" as the church's default state and "sending" as a subsequent, optional activity layered on top. The missional church movement inverts the order: sentness is the church's identity from the start, gathering exists to equip and re-form the community for the sake of being sent back out, and a congregation that gathers faithfully but has lost any sense of being sent has not simply chosen a passive posture toward culture — on this reading, it has become something less than the church Christ founded, whatever its confessional soundness otherwise. This is a strong claim, and not every tradition represented among this course's readers frames ecclesiology in exactly these terms; but even traditions with a more settled, institutional self-understanding generally recognize something true in the underlying worry Newbigin, Guder, and Bosch are naming.
4. Holding the two together
John 17:14-18's prayer resists both an unqualified embrace of any single Niebuhrian type and a purely institutional self-understanding untouched by the missional critique. "Not of the world" rules out simply identifying with whatever the surrounding culture already values (against the risk in "Christ of culture") and rules out an uncritical synthesis that treats a particular culture's achievements as permanently baptized (against the risk in "Christ above culture"). "Sent into the world," precisely as the Father sent the Son — who did not stay apart from the world he came to save, but entered fully into it — rules out withdrawal (against the risk in "Christ against culture") while not by itself resolving how much transformation of a given culture is realistically achievable this side of Christ's return (the very question "Christ and culture in paradox" and "Christ transforming culture" continue to dispute). What the missional movement adds to this is not a sixth Niebuhrian type to slot in alongside the other five, but a reminder that the "sent" half of John 17:18 is not incidental to the church's mission — it is a claim about what the church, gathered or scattered, actually is.
5. Going to the Sources
Vatican II's pastoral constitution Gaudium et Spes ("The Church in the Modern World," 1965) opens with the often-quoted line that "the joys and the hopes, the griefs and the anxieties of the people of our time... are the joys and hopes, the griefs and anxieties of the followers of Christ as well," and devotes its length to the church's relationship with contemporary culture, science, the economy, and political life — a genuinely conversionist, culture-engaging document in Niebuhr's terms, written by a body no single one of his five types was designed to describe in advance. It matters here because it shows a major world communion working out its own answer to this lecture's question in real institutional detail, at a scale well beyond a single theologian's typology, and because several of this course's readers belong to communions directly shaped by it.
In short
- The lecture asks what posture the church should take toward the surrounding culture. It starts from H. Richard Niebuhr's five types: against culture, of culture, above culture, in paradox, and transforming culture.
- Each type has a named representative, a strength and a risk. Examples are Tertullian and the Anabaptists, Ritschl, Aquinas, Luther, and Augustine and Calvin.
- Critics say the typology oversimplifies. John Howard Yoder argues it caricatures the Anabaptists, and D. A. Carson says it misses the full biblical material and favours "transforming."
- Each type can cite Scripture, so careful theologians treat the types as emphases a church may hold in tension, not as a menu.
- The missional church movement (Newbigin, Guder, Bosch) says mission is not one activity among others. The church's identity is being sent.
- John 17:14-18 holds "not of the world" and "sent into the world" together. Not every tradition frames ecclesiology in missional terms.
Topic: This lecture compares Niebuhr's five types of Christ and culture, the criticisms of them, and the missional church claim that the church's identity is being sent.
Remember: John 17:14-18 holds two claims together: believers are not of the world, and they are sent into it. Each Niebuhr type tries to keep both.
Caution: The five types simplify real history, and each finds biblical support. The missional claim is strong, and not every tradition states ecclesiology in those terms.
One line to carry into ministry: Ask honestly how your church actually treats its culture, resisting some things, redeeming others, and never forgetting that it is sent.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of Niebuhr's five types, if any, best describes the posture your own church tradition actually takes toward the surrounding culture — not what it officially claims, but how it behaves in practice? Does naming it change how you evaluate it?
- Yoder argues Niebuhr caricatures the Anabaptist "against culture" position. Reread the paragraph on that type above: does it strike you as a fair or an oversimplified account of any tradition you know well?
- The missional church movement claims sentness constitutes the church's identity rather than being one of its optional activities. If that claim is right, what would change about how your own congregation organizes its time, budget, and priorities?