FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

ST7E Systematic Theology VII: Ecclesiology

Lecture 3-1: Sacrament or Ordinance? Framing the Question

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 31
ST7E Systematic Theology VII: Ecclesiology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Ecclesiology Is, and Why It Comes Seventh
  1. Introduction: What Ecclesiology Is, and Why It Comes Seventh
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Nature and Origin of the Church
  1. Lecture 1-1: What the Church Is — Ekklesia and the New Testament's Images
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Church's Old Testament Roots and New Testament Founding
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Visible and Invisible Church
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Marks and Attributes of the Church
  5. Lecture 1-5: Church Membership and Boundaries
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Church Government and Polity
  1. Lecture 2-1: Why Polity Is a Theological Question
  2. Lecture 2-2: Episcopal Polity
  3. Lecture 2-3: Presbyterian Polity
  4. Lecture 2-4: Congregational Polity
  5. Lecture 2-5: The Offices of Elder and Deacon
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Sacraments and Ordinances
  1. Lecture 3-1: Sacrament or Ordinance? Framing the Question
  2. Lecture 3-2: Baptism — Meaning and Mode
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Lord's Supper — Four Views
  4. Lecture 3-4: Who May Come to the Table, and How Often
  5. Lecture 3-5: The Sacraments as Means of Grace
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Worship and the Ordinary Means of Grace
  1. Lecture 4-1: A Biblical Theology of Gathered Worship
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Regulative and Normative Principles of Worship
  3. Lecture 4-3: Preaching and the Ministry of the Word
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Elements of Corporate Worship
  5. Lecture 4-5: Worship Across Cultures
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Church's Mission in the World
  1. Lecture 5-1: Evangelism and Social Action
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Church and Culture
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Church and the State
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Church and Social Justice
  5. Lecture 5-5: Global Mission and the Church's Sending Task
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Contemporary Issues in Ecclesiology
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Church Growth Movement and the Megachurch
  2. Lecture 6-2: Church Discipline and Accountability
  3. Lecture 6-3: Ecumenism and Christian Unity
  4. Lecture 6-4: The Digital Church and Technology
  5. Lecture 6-5: The Global Shift and the Future of the Church

Jump to the key points ↓

16 min

Ask a room of Christians from different traditions what baptism and the Lord's Supper actually do, and the room will not agree — but notice, before the disagreement even starts, that the room may not agree on what to call them either. A Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, or Anglican Christian will most naturally reach for the word "sacrament." A Baptist, most non-denominational, and many Presbyterian and Reformed Christians will reach for "ordinance," or will use both words but mean something different by "sacrament" than their Catholic or Lutheran neighbor does. This is not a trivial matter of dialect. The word a tradition reaches for first is already a small confession of faith about what is happening when water is poured, or bread is broken.

This lecture does not yet ask "what happens at baptism" or "what happens at the Supper" — those are 3-2 and 3-3's questions. Its task is narrower and comes first: to lay out the spectrum of possible answers to "how does a physical sign relate to the spiritual reality it signifies," in the abstract, so that the next two lectures can locate specific positions on a map the reader already has in hand. Readers should resist the temptation to decide, already in this lecture, which tradition is right — the point here is to understand the terms of the debate clearly enough to recognize each position in its strongest form when 3-2 and 3-3 name it.

What these 16 minutes give you

  • Explain what the word "sacrament" (from Latin *sacramentum*) and the word "ordinance" each emphasize, and why the choice of vocabulary is not merely stylistic.
  • State the spectrum running from *ex opere operato* through sacramental union and spiritual-but-real presence to memorialism, in the abstract, without yet applying it to a specific practice.
  • Explain why this course treats "sacrament" and "ordinance" as naming a genuine theological disagreement rather than as two interchangeable labels for the same two church practices.
  • Identify what all the traditions represented in this course affirm in common about baptism and the Supper, prior to any of their disagreements.
  • Explain how 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 functions as common textual ground that every position on the spectrum has to interpret, even though they interpret it differently.

For I received from the Lord that which also I delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night in which he was betrayed took bread. When he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, 'Take, eat. This is my body, which is broken for you. Do this in memory of me.' In the same way he also took the cup, after supper, saying, 'This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink, in memory of me.' For as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes." — 1 Corinthians 11:23-26

World English Bible

Paul is not writing a treatise on sacramental theology here; he is correcting the Corinthian church's conduct at its own common meal. But the text he hands down — "received from the Lord," a formula signaling a fixed, authoritative tradition rather than Paul's own improvisation — is the single passage every position this lecture surveys must interpret. "This is my body" and "the new in my blood" state a connection between the bread and cup and Christ's body and blood that no tradition in this course denies exists; what is disputed is the nature of that connection, not whether one is claimed. 3-3 returns to this text at length. Here it establishes only that whatever the four views considered later say, they are all reading the same words.

1. Two words, two instincts

"" descends from the Latin sacramentum, a term with a pre-Christian legal and military sense — a soldier's oath of allegiance, a solemn pledge with binding force. Early Latin-speaking Christians used it to translate the Greek mysterion ("mystery"), and by the time the word settles into medieval theology it carries the sense of a sign that does not merely represent a sacred reality but is bound up with actually conveying it. Peter Lombard's twelfth-century definition — a sacrament is a sign of a sacred thing that also causes what it signifies — becomes the scholastic starting point for the developed Catholic doctrine 3-3 will engage directly.

"," by contrast, foregrounds the practice as something ordained — commanded by Christ, to be kept in obedience to that command. An ordinance, on this account, does not need to be denied any spiritual significance at all to be called an ordinance rather than a sacrament; the emphasis simply falls differently. The practice's force is chiefly located in the church's obedience to Christ's institution and in the act's function as memorial and proclamation (exactly the vocabulary 1 Corinthians 11:26 itself uses — "you proclaim the Lord's death") rather than in the sign's operating as an instrument that confers the grace it pictures.

Common misreading

It would be a mistake — and this course will not make it — to hear "ordinance" as meaning "just a symbol, nothing more," or to hear "sacrament" as meaning "magic performed on inert matter." Serious Baptist and Zwinglian theologians insist the Supper and baptism are weighty, Spirit-attended acts, not empty gestures; serious Catholic and Lutheran theologians insist the sign never operates independently of faith, and that no one benefits from the sacrament who receives it in unbelief. The vocabulary marks a real difference of emphasis and mechanism, not a difference between people who take these practices seriously and people who do not.

2. The spectrum

Four points along one line will recur, by name, in 3-2 and 3-3. Stating them here, in the abstract, is this lecture's central task.

Ex opere operato ("by the very fact of the action's being performed") is the classical Catholic formula: a validly administered sacrament confers the grace it signifies by virtue of Christ's own institution and the sacrament's own valid performance, not by virtue of the minister's or the recipient's personal holiness or subjective faith at the moment of reception — though the Catholic tradition is equally insistent that the recipient must not place an active obstacle (obex) in grace's way, and that the sacrament's fruit in an adult recipient depends on the disposition with which it is received. The formula addresses a specific historical anxiety — the Donatist controversy's question of whether a sacrament administered by an unworthy or heretical minister is thereby invalid — by locating the sacrament's efficacy in Christ's own institution and act, not in the minister's personal worthiness.

Sacramental union, the Lutheran account, holds that in, with, and under the earthly element, the heavenly reality is truly and objectively present and received — not because the sign causes the reality mechanically, but because Christ's own word of institution ("this is my body") is trustworthy and effective in itself. Luther insisted on this against what he took to be an evacuation of Christ's own words in more memorialist readings, while also rejecting the Catholic doctrine of 's Aristotelian account of how the change occurs.

Spiritual-but-, the Reformed account chiefly associated with John Calvin, holds that the believer, through the Spirit's power, truly feeds on Christ's body and blood — not by any local or physical transfer of Christ's glorified body to the elements (which Calvin insisted must remain in heaven until his return), but through a real spiritual communion the Spirit effects, received by faith. Calvin was explicit that he wanted a middle path between what he judged errors on both sides: neither Zwingli's supper as a merely mental exercise of memory, nor Rome's or the Lutherans' insistence on a presence tied to the elements themselves.

, associated with Huldrych Zwingli and the majority modern Baptist and non-denominational position, holds that the Supper is a commemorative and proclamatory ordinance — a vivid, commanded remembrance of Christ's death, and a public proclamation of it to the gathered church, in which no distinct mode of Christ's presence beyond his ordinary presence wherever believers gather (Matthew 18:20) is claimed for the elements themselves.

3. What every position shares

Before 3-2 and 3-3 set these positions against each other on specific questions, it is worth being precise about what unites them. Every tradition in this course affirms that Christ himself instituted both baptism and the Supper, that neither practice is optional for a healthy church's obedience, that both practices are signs — physical, sensible acts that point to and are bound up with spiritual realities — and that neither practice benefits a recipient who approaches it in unbelief or hardened impenitence, whatever account is given of how that benefit is normally conferred. No position surveyed in this course holds that the sign is a bare, disconnected symbol with no relationship at all to the reality it pictures; the disagreement is over how tight, and how mechanically or spiritually mediated, that relationship is — not over whether one exists.

This is a point where readers will not agree does not appear as this lecture's own tag, because 3-1 is framing the terms of the disagreement rather than presenting a specific contested claim readers must weigh for themselves; that work begins in 3-2. But readers should notice already that the vocabulary they reach for instinctively — "sacrament" or "ordinance" — is itself evidence of where they already stand on the spectrum this lecture has just drawn, before 3-2 asks them to think about baptism specifically at all.


One Spectrum, Before It Is Applied to Anything Ex opere operato Sign confers grace by valid administration, Christ's own institution Catholic Sacramental union In, with, under the element, by the power of Christ's own word Lutheran Spiritual presence Real feeding on Christ by the Spirit's power, received by faith Reformed (Calvin) Memorial Commanded remembrance and proclamation Zwinglian / Baptist Sign causes Sign signifies 3-3 places all four points on this exact line, applied to the Lord's Supper specifically.

5. Going to the Sources

Read the Belgic Confession's Article 33, "Of the Sacraments," a compact Reformed statement written a generation after the Reformation began. It defines a sacrament as a visible sign and seal God has added to the promise of the gospel "to nourish and strengthen the faith" of believers, explicitly stating that the signs are "not empty and vain" while just as explicitly denying that the sign and the reality signified are simply identical. It is worth reading here specifically because it occupies a stated middle position on 3-1's spectrum — closer to sacramental union than memorialism, while resisting Rome's account of the mechanism — making it a useful anchor for seeing that the spectrum is a genuine line with more than two points on it, not a forced binary between "sacrament means it does something" and "ordinance means it does nothing."


In short

  • "Sacrament" comes from the Latin sacramentum, an oath. It points to a sign that conveys what it signifies. "Ordinance" stresses that Christ commanded the practice. The two words mark a real difference of emphasis.
  • Neither word means what critics assume. An ordinance is not "just a symbol," and a sacrament is not "magic." Serious theologians on both sides say the sign does not help someone who comes in unbelief.
  • The lecture sets out four positions: ex opere operato (Catholic), sacramental union (Lutheran), spiritual-but-real presence (Calvin, Reformed) and memorialism (Zwingli, most Baptists).
  • All traditions here agree that Christ instituted baptism and the Supper and that both are signs tied to spiritual realities. They differ on how tight that tie is.
  • 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 is the shared text. All four positions read the same words and disagree about the nature of the connection, not whether one is claimed.

Topic: This lecture frames the sacrament-or-ordinance question by laying out four positions on how a physical sign relates to the spiritual reality it signifies.

Remember: The positions run along one line, from the sign causing grace to the sign signifying it. The word you reach for first already shows where you stand.

Caution: Do not hear "ordinance" as "empty symbol" or "sacrament" as "automatic magic." The lecture does not say which tradition is right.

One line to carry into ministry: Before you argue about baptism or the Supper, ask what each person means by "sacrament" or "ordinance," and remember that everyone shares the same Scripture.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Before this lecture, which word — "sacrament" or "ordinance" — did you instinctively reach for, and what does your answer suggest about where you already stood on the spectrum this lecture describes?
  • Explain, in the strongest terms you can, why the Catholic doctrine of *ex opere operato* is not a claim that a sacrament works automatically regardless of the recipient's disposition. What historical controversy did the formula originally answer?
  • All four positions on 3-1's spectrum affirm that 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 is authoritative Scripture. Why, then, do they read "this is my body" so differently? What does this suggest about the relationship between having the same text and having the same interpretation of it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.