Lecture 2-5: Reading the Bible's Most Difficult Ethical Texts
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Makes Ethics Distinctly Christian
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture, Natural Revelation, and Conscience — Frame's Triperspectival Method
- Lecture 1-3: Secular Ethical Theories — Utilitarianism, Deontology, and Virtue Ethics
- Lecture 1-4: Natural Law and General Revelation in Ethics
- Lecture 1-5: The Structure of Christian Moral Reasoning in Practice
- Lecture 2-1: The Structure of Old Testament Law
- Lecture 2-2: The Sermon on the Mount as Ethical Vision
- Lecture 2-3: Paul and the Indicative-Imperative Pattern
- Lecture 2-4: The Unity of the Whole Canon's Ethics
- Lecture 2-5: Reading the Bible's Most Difficult Ethical Texts
- Lecture 3-1: Christian Freedom and the Law
- Lecture 3-2: Vocation and Work
- Lecture 3-3: Marriage, Sexuality, and the Body
- Lecture 3-4: Truth-Telling, Speech, and Digital Communication
- Lecture 3-5: Money, Possessions, and Contentment
- Lecture 4-1: Patristic and Medieval Ethics
- Lecture 4-2: Reformation Ethics — Law, Gospel, and the Third Use
- Lecture 4-3: Modern Challenges — Weber's Protestant Ethic Thesis
- Lecture 4-4: Twentieth-Century Christian Ethics — Bonhoeffer and the Limits of Otherwise-Clear Commands
- Lecture 4-5: Niebuhr's Christ and Culture and the Church-World Relationship
- Lecture 5-1: Political Engagement and Civic Responsibility
- Lecture 5-2: Economic Justice and Poverty
- Lecture 5-3: War, Peace, and Just War Theory
- Lecture 5-4: Race, Immigration, and Reconciliation
- Lecture 5-5: Environmental Ethics and Creation Care
This chapter has argued that the Bible's ethical material unfolds across redemptive history, and that reading any part of it well requires knowing where that part sits within the story. That claim is easy to affirm in the abstract and hard to hold onto in front of the texts that actually test it. The conquest narratives, in which Israel is commanded to destroy entire populations occupying the promised land, and the laws that regulate rather than abolish slavery as an institution, are the two bodies of material this lecture takes up, because they are the two most frequently raised as reasons to doubt that the Old Testament's God and the New Testament's God can be the same God, or that any reading strategy can make honest sense of both without either explaining the texts away or treating them as timeless moral instruction. This lecture does not offer a solution that removes all discomfort — a redemptive-movement hermeneutic, engaged carefully below, offers real interpretive help without offering that. It states plainly what the approach gains a reader and where it demands real caution, because a method that only works on easy texts was never actually tested.
What these 20 minutes give you
- State the interpretive problem the conquest narratives and the regulation of slavery each pose, in terms specific enough to show you understand why they are genuinely difficult rather than only unpopular.
- Explain William Webb's redemptive-movement hermeneutic and distinguish it clearly from two other responses this lecture rejects: treating every ancient regulation as God's timeless final word, and dismissing the texts as embarrassments to be ignored.
- Walk through Exodus 21:2-6 as a case study, identifying at least one feature of the text that a redemptive-movement reading treats as evidence of an ameliorative trajectory relative to surrounding ancient Near Eastern practice, and one feature that still troubles a modern reader even after that trajectory is granted.
- State at least one real caution or limitation a redemptive-movement hermeneutic requires, in your own words, rather than treating the approach as a complete solution.
If you buy a Hebrew servant, he shall serve six years and in the seventh he shall go out free without paying anything. If he comes in by himself, he shall go out by himself. If he is married, then his wife shall go out with him. If his master gives him a wife and she bears him sons or daughters, the wife and her children shall be her master's, and he shall go out by himself. But if the servant shall plainly say, 'I love my master, my wife, and my children. I will not go out free;' then his master shall bring him to God, and shall bring him to the door or to the doorpost, and his master shall bore his ear through with an awl, and he shall serve him for ever." — Exodus 21:2-6
World English Bible
You shall remember that you were a slave in the land of Egypt, and Yahweh your God redeemed you. Therefore I command you this thing today." — Deuteronomy 15:15
WEB
There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." — Galatians 3:28
WEB
1. Stating the problem honestly
The conquest narratives (principally Joshua 6-11) describe Israel, under divine command, destroying the populations of Canaanite cities — Jericho's fate, "they utterly destroyed all that was in the city, both man and woman, both young and old" (Joshua 6:21), is representative rather than exceptional. Read plainly, these texts describe what a modern reader has no other vocabulary for except mass killing commanded by God, including of noncombatants. This lecture will not pretend the text says something gentler than it says, and will not resolve the difficulty by relocating it entirely into questions of ancient Near Eastern military rhetoric (some scholars have argued the destruction formulas are stock hyperbolic language rather than literal population totals, a genuinely relevant point that softens but does not eliminate the underlying moral question the narratives raise about divinely commanded warfare against a specific ethnic population).
The regulation of slavery poses a different but related problem. Exodus 21:2-6, quoted above, does not institute a slave economy from nothing — Israel inherited debt-servitude as an existing feature of the ancient Near Eastern economic world it lived inside, the way every ancient Near Eastern society did — but it regulates the practice rather than abolishing it, and the regulation itself contains features a modern reader finds genuinely troubling on top of the underlying fact of legally sanctioned human bondage: verse 4's provision that if a master gave a male servant a wife during his six years and she bore children, "the wife and her children shall be her master's" while the man himself "shall go out by himself" — a provision that could separate a man from his own wife and children at the point of his release, using the family bond itself as leverage to induce him into permanent servitude via the ear-piercing ceremony of verse 6. A reading that calls this text merely a humane improvement and stops there has not reckoned with what verse 4 actually requires of the man choosing between his freedom and his family.
Naming both problems honestly, without softening either one, is the necessary first step. A hermeneutic that arrives at a comfortable answer too quickly has probably not actually engaged the texts it claims to be interpreting.
2. Two responses this lecture rejects
One response treats every Old Testament regulation, including these, as God's timeless final word — a standard applicable without qualification to any age, so that the specific provisions of Exodus 21 would, on this view, describe an institution Scripture endorses as good in itself rather than merely permits under specific ancient conditions. This lecture rejects that response because it cannot be squared with 2-1's own account of how Old Testament civil law functions: no serious reader of this course's own tradition applies Exodus 21's provisions today, which already concedes that "God commanded it in this text" cannot by itself mean "God intends this specific arrangement for every age" — the very civil-law category 2-1 established exists because Scripture itself, through its own later movement culminating in the New Testament, does not treat every regulation this way.
A second response goes to the opposite extreme and treats these texts as embarrassments best minimized, explained away as later scribal additions without manuscript evidence for that claim, or quietly dropped from serious engagement and hoped nobody asks about them directly. This lecture rejects that response too, for a reason stated plainly in this chapter's own opening principle: if the Bible's ethical material only counts when it is comfortable, the doctrine of Scripture doing any real interpretive work has already been abandoned, whatever theological language is used to describe what is happening instead. A hermeneutic that only survives contact with easy texts was never actually tested by the hard ones.
3. William Webb's redemptive-movement hermeneutic
William Webb's Slaves, Women and Homosexuals: Exploring the of Cultural Analysis proposes a third path: reading a text's trajectory — the direction it moves its original audience relative to the surrounding ancient culture, rather than the text's literal provisions considered as a fixed, final destination — as itself ethically significant and potentially normative for how the text's underlying concern should be honored today, even where its specific ancient provisions are not directly repeated.
Applied to Exodus 21:2-6, a redemptive-movement reading points to several features as evidence of a real ameliorative trajectory relative to surrounding ancient Near Eastern law. A mandatory release after six years (a limit unmatched in most contemporary ancient Near Eastern law codes governing debt-servitude, which frequently had no fixed release provision at all) caps what could otherwise become permanent, inherited bondage. Deuteronomy 15:13-14's supplementary instruction — that a departing servant must not be sent away "empty" but "furnished liberally" from the master's own flock, threshing floor, and wine press — adds an economic provision aimed at preventing the released servant's immediate return to the very debt that produced servitude in the first place, an active concern for the servant's actual future rather than merely a technical release. And Deuteronomy 15:15's grounding of the whole provision in Israel's own memory of slavery in Egypt — "you shall remember that you were a slave... and Yahweh your God redeemed you" — ties the regulation's motive explicitly to Israel's own redemption, giving the law a theological rationale (empathy grounded in shared experience of bondage and deliverance) that ancient Near Eastern law codes, largely concerned with property and social order rather than memory, did not share. Webb's approach reads this cluster of features as movement in a specific direction — toward limitation, provision, and a stated rationale rooted in the servant's dignity rather than merely the master's property interest — and argues that Scripture's own trajectory, not simply the specific six-year figure or the specific ancient economic arrangement, is what a modern reader honoring the text's redemptive direction should carry forward, which is exactly why Galatians 3:28's "neither slave nor free man" and the New Testament's eventual full abolition of slave status "in Christ" can be read as a continuation of a trajectory Exodus 21 itself begins, rather than an unrelated New Testament innovation contradicting a fixed Old Testament position.
4. What the trajectory reading does not remove
Granting a real ameliorative trajectory does not remove the difficulty verse 4 poses. A trajectory relative to a worse surrounding practice is not the same claim as a trajectory toward a fully acceptable one, and this lecture will not blur that distinction. Verse 4's provision, even read charitably as protecting a master's investment in a wife and children he provided rather than as deliberately engineered cruelty, still describes a legal mechanism that could pressure a man into permanent servitude by holding his family as the price of his freedom — a feature no plausible reading turns into something a modern reader should regard as a model to emulate rather than an ancient reality Scripture regulated without fully resolving. The honest conclusion is not "Exodus 21 turns out to be acceptable once properly understood" but "Exodus 21 shows real movement toward limiting an entrenched ancient institution's worst features while still operating, necessarily, within a world that institution structured — and Scripture's own further trajectory, completed rather than contradicted in the New Testament, is what carries the movement the rest of the way, not the ancient text considered by itself."
The same caution applies, in a different shape, to the conquest narratives. A redemptive-movement reading has less obvious purchase here than with slavery, since a trajectory argument depends on identifying a directional movement across texts, and the conquest material does not offer the same kind of before-and-after comparison Exodus 21 and Deuteronomy 15 supply for servitude law. What can be said, with real but limited force, is that the conquest is presented throughout its own narrative context as a specific, bounded, and unrepeated act of judgment tied to a specific land promise and a specific historical moment (Genesis 15:16's "the iniquity of the Amorite is not yet full" frames the conquest, centuries earlier, as delayed judgment rather than an ethnic hostility without further theological rationale) rather than as an ongoing pattern the New Testament extends or that the church is ever instructed to imitate — indeed Jesus's own teaching moves explicitly in the opposite direction on the use of force against enemies (a point this course's Chapter 5 treatment of just war and pacifism will engage directly). This is a narrower and more limited claim than the trajectory argument available for slavery, and this lecture states that limitation honestly rather than forcing the same interpretive tool to do more work than it can actually bear on both bodies of material equally.
5. The real caution a redemptive-movement hermeneutic requires
Webb's own proposal, read carefully, is not a license to treat every uncomfortable text as merely provisional and every comfortable New Testament development as the trajectory's obvious terminus decided in advance. The approach requires real interpretive judgment about which features of a text mark genuine movement and which do not, and that judgment is vulnerable to being quietly steered by what a modern reader already wants a text to say — precisely the danger of an elegant-sounding trajectory that clicks together too neatly is exactly the kind of connection worth doubling back on. A responsible use of the hermeneutic states its trajectory claims modestly, grounds them in specific textual features rather than an assumed cultural arc from primitive to enlightened, and — as this lecture has tried to do with the conquest narratives — admits plainly when the tool's evidential basis is thinner for one body of material than for another, rather than reaching for the same confident conclusion regardless of what the specific texts actually support.
5. Going to the Sources
- The Belhar Confession (1986), drafted by the Dutch Reformed Mission Church in South Africa against apartheid — a modern confessional document explicitly built on the conviction that Scripture's own trajectory toward justice and reconciliation (rather than isolated proof texts on either side) is what the church is bound to confess, making it a concrete recent example of a confessional body applying something functionally close to a redemptive-movement argument to a real and costly ethical crisis, not merely an academic proposal.
In short
- The conquest narratives (Joshua 6-11) describe destruction commanded by God, and Exodus 21:2-6 regulates slavery without abolishing it. The lecture names both problems honestly first.
- Two responses are rejected: treating every Old Testament regulation as God's timeless final word, and minimizing or explaining away hard texts.
- William Webb's redemptive-movement hermeneutic (reading a text's direction of movement, not only its fixed rules) finds limits and care in Exodus 21 and Deuteronomy 15 compared with surrounding ancient law.
- Galatians 3:28 is read as continuing that direction. Still, verse 4 troubles a modern reader, because a man's family could be held as the price of his freedom.
- For the conquest the method has less force. The lecture says only that it is presented as a bounded, unrepeated judgment (Genesis 15:16).
- The method needs caution: its judgments can be steered by what the reader wants the text to say, so claims must be modest and tied to the text.
Topic: How to read the conquest narratives and the slavery laws honestly, using Webb's redemptive-movement approach without treating it as a complete solution.
Remember: Movement toward limiting an entrenched institution is not the same as movement toward a fully acceptable arrangement. Scripture's further movement, completed in the New Testament, carries it the rest of the way.
Caution: The lecture does not claim the approach removes all discomfort, and it says the evidence is thinner for the conquest than for slavery. It also warns against deciding the trajectory's end in advance.
One line to carry into ministry: When a hard text comes up, name the difficulty plainly first, and do not rush to a comfortable answer.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- This lecture states the conquest and slavery problems honestly before offering any interpretive help. Why does the lecture insist on doing this in that order, rather than leading with Webb's hermeneutic first? What would be lost by reversing the order?
- Restate, in your own words, why this lecture treats the redemptive-movement hermeneutic's evidential basis as stronger for the slavery material than for the conquest narratives. Do you find that asymmetry honest, or does it look like special pleading to make the easier case first?
- This course's method warns that an elegant-sounding connection probably came from the reader's structure rather than the source. Where in this lecture's own trajectory argument about Exodus 21 would you press hardest to test whether the argument is genuinely textual or has been shaped to reach a comfortable conclusion?