Lecture 9-2: Criteria of Authenticity — What They Claim, and Their Limits
Criteria of authenticity are tools for weighing, not proving
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Criteria of authenticity are tools for weighing, not proving
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
John 21:25 admits that the Gospels are selective, and none of them claims to be a complete record. The Gospels were also written some decades after the events and shaped by each evangelist's purposes. That does not make them untrustworthy by default. But a historian cannot treat "the Gospels say Jesus said X" as proving itself without further argument.
Criteria of authenticity are rules of thumb for judging whether a saying or deed attributed to Jesus is more likely to go back to him. The alternative is a later development or invention by the early church. They aim to replace a scholar's own intuition about what "sounds like Jesus" with a disciplined method. This lecture takes up three: dissimilarity, multiple attestation and embarrassment.
A saying is more likely authentic if it is unlike both first-century Jewish thought and early Christian teaching. The logic is that neither community had a motive to invent it. Its most serious limit is that it risks an artificially strange Jesus, cut off from his Jewish context on one side and from his movement on the other. Many contemporary scholars, including much of the Third Quest, have become cautious about leaning on it too heavily.
A saying or deed is more likely authentic if it appears independently in more than one source, such as Mark and the hypothetical sayings source "Q", or the Synoptics and Paul. The word that matters is "independent". If two sources share a common ancestor, their agreement shows only that they share it. A scholar who accepts Markan priority and Q will count Mark and Q as two witnesses. A scholar who prefers the Farrer Hypothesis, which denies Q, may see one line of testimony.
Material that would have caused difficulty for the early church is more likely authentic, because the church had little motive to invent it. Examples are Jesus's baptism by John, the disciples' failures including Peter's denial, and the crucifixion, which Paul calls a stumbling block to Jews and foolishness to Greeks. Its limit is that "embarrassing to whom, and when" is not fixed. It takes judgment about a specific audience and moment.
Two limits apply to all three. Passing a criterion is evidence of authenticity, not proof, and it is weighed together with other evidence. Failing a criterion does not prove inauthenticity. An ordinary saying that fits its context and appears in one source could still be genuine. Treating the absence of positive criteria as negative evidence is a common misuse, on both the skeptical and the confident sides.
Unlike both Judaism and later church teaching. Risk: an uprooted, artificially strange Jesus.
Appears in independent sources. Risk: "independent" depends on disputed source questions.
Unlikely the church would invent it. Risk: "embarrassing" is not fixed across audiences.
Multiple attestation depends on genuine independence between sources, which depends on unresolved questions such as Markan priority and Q.
What does it mean for one criterion's reliability to rest on a separate, contested set of judgments?
Because the Gospels are selective, historians developed criteria to weigh individual sayings rather than accept or reject a Gospel wholesale. Dissimilarity risks an uprooted Jesus. Multiple attestation depends on contested judgments about independence. Embarrassment depends on knowing what was embarrassing to a specific audience. None is a mechanical test: passing one supports authenticity without proving it, and failing all three does not prove a saying was invented.