Lecture 9-3: Contemporary Approaches — The Jesus Seminar and the Third Quest
목차 94
- Lecture 1-1: What "New Testament" Means
- Lecture 1-2: Canon Formation as a Real Historical Process
- Lecture 1-3: Textual Transmission and the Modern Critical Text
- Lecture 2-1: The Parties of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 2-2: Synagogue, Temple, and Messianic Hope
- Lecture 2-3: Rome, Hellenism, and the Fullness of Time
- Lecture 3-1: Source Criticism and the Shared Material of the Synoptic Gospels
- Lecture 3-2: Form Criticism and Redaction Criticism
- Lecture 3-3: Evangelical and Canonical Responses to Critical Method
- Lecture 4-1: What Kind of Book Is a Gospel?
- Lecture 4-2: The Synoptic Problem
- Lecture 4-3: John's Distinct Relationship to the Synoptics
- Lecture 5-1: Matthew's Structure, Audience, and Fulfillment Citations
- Lecture 5-2: The Sermon on the Mount and Matthew's Kingdom Theology
- Lecture 5-3: The Great Commission and Matthew's Theology of Mission
- Lecture 6-1: Mark's Author, His Secret, and His Hurry
- Lecture 6-2: The Hinge at Caesarea Philippi
- Lecture 6-3: The Ending of Mark
- Lecture 7-1: Luke's Preface — A Historian's Method
- Lecture 7-2: Luke's Distinctive Emphases — the Poor, Women, the Spirit, and the Nations
- Lecture 7-3: Luke-Acts as One Continuous Work
- Lecture 8-1: John's Distinct Style and Theology
- Lecture 8-2: The Authorship Debate
- Lecture 8-3: John's Stated Purpose and Its Sign-Structured Design
- Lecture 9-1: The Quests — Old, No Quest, and Third
- Lecture 9-2: Criteria of Authenticity — What They Claim, and Their Limits
- Lecture 9-3: Contemporary Approaches — The Jesus Seminar and the Third Quest
- Lecture 10-1: Who Wrote Acts, and Why the Pronouns Change
- Lecture 10-2: Acts 1:8 — The Book Outlines Itself
- Lecture 10-3: How Reliable a Historian Is Luke?
- Lecture 11-1: Paul's Life and the Chronology Behind His Letters
- Lecture 11-2: The Pauline Authorship Debate
- Lecture 11-3: Letter Form and Paul's Central Convictions
- Lecture 12-1: Occasion and Structure of Romans
- Lecture 12-2: Sin, Justification, and Israel's Place
- Lecture 12-3: Romans and the New Perspective on Paul
- Lecture 13-1: Corinth and the Letter's Occasion
- Lecture 13-2: Key Issues Paul Addresses
- Lecture 13-3: 1 Corinthians 13 in Argumentative Context
- Lecture 14-1: Occasion — The Painful Visit, the Severe Letter, and Reconciliation
- Lecture 14-2: Paul's Defense of His Apostolic Ministry Against the "Super-Apostles"
- Lecture 14-3: Is 2 Corinthians One Letter or Several? The Partition-Theory Debate
- Lecture 15-1: The Occasion — The Judaizing Controversy
- Lecture 15-2: Audience and Date — The North Galatia/South Galatia Debate
- Lecture 15-3: The Argument — Justification by Faith and Christian Freedom
- Lecture 16-1: The Structure of Ephesians
- Lecture 16-2: The Authorship of Ephesians
- Lecture 16-3: One New Humanity — Ephesians' Theology of Reconciliation
- Lecture 17-1: Paul in Chains, Philippi in Partnership
- Lecture 17-2: The Christ Hymn — Self-Emptying and Exaltation
- Lecture 17-3: Joy Amid Suffering
- Lecture 18-1: Colossians — Occasion, the Colossian Heresy, and the Authorship Question
- Lecture 18-2: Colossians' Christology — The Supremacy of Christ
- Lecture 18-3: Philemon — Onesimus, and What the Letter Does and Does Not Say About Slavery
- Lecture 19-1: 1 Thessalonians — Occasion and the Eschatology of Comfort
- Lecture 19-2: 2 Thessalonians — Occasion and the Eschatology of Correction
- Lecture 19-3: The Authorship Debate over 2 Thessalonians
- Lecture 20-1: The Pastoral Epistles as a Category
- Lecture 20-2: The Authorship Debate
- Lecture 20-3: The Pastorals' Shared Purpose
- Lecture 21-1: Ephesus and the False Teachers Timothy Must Oppose
- Lecture 21-2: Church Order — Overseers, Deacons, and 2:11-12
- Lecture 21-3: Sound Doctrine and Godliness as One Concern
- Lecture 22-1: 2 Timothy — A Final Charge from a Man Who Expects to Die
- Lecture 22-2: Titus — Order for a Rougher Mission Field
- Lecture 22-3: A Composite Portrait of Pastoral Ministry
- Lecture 23-1: Hebrews — Genre and the Question of Authorship
- Lecture 23-2: Hebrews — Christ Superior to Angels, Moses, and the Priesthood
- Lecture 23-3: Hebrews — The Warning Passages and the Apostasy Debate
- Lecture 24-1: James — Author and Genre
- Lecture 24-2: James and Paul on Faith and Works
- Lecture 24-3: James' Practical Ethics — the Tongue, Wealth and Poverty, and Prayer
- Lecture 25-1: 1 Peter — Author, Audience, and Occasion
- Lecture 25-2: 1 Peter — Suffering, Hope, and Submission Within Hostile Structures
- Lecture 25-3: 1 Peter — The Household Codes and the Spirits in Prison
- Lecture 26-1: Who Wrote 2 Peter?
- Lecture 26-2: Jude — Contending for the Faith
- Lecture 26-3: 2 Peter and Jude Together
- Lecture 27-1: Occasion — A Denial "in the Flesh," and Kinship with John's Gospel
- Lecture 27-2: The Tests of True Faith — Love, Obedience, Right Belief
- Lecture 27-3: The Theology of Assurance — "That You May Know"
- Lecture 28-1: 2 John — The Elect Lady and the Danger at the Door
- Lecture 28-2: 3 John — Gaius, Diotrephes, and the Politics of Hospitality
- Lecture 28-3: The Johannine Letters and the Authorship Question — Returning to Chapter 8
- Lecture 29-1: The Genre of Revelation: Apocalypse, Prophecy, and Letter
- Lecture 29-2: Who Wrote Revelation? The Ancient Case for a Second John
- Lecture 29-3: Four Ways to Read Revelation's Visions
- Lecture 30-1: The Architecture of Revelation
- Lecture 30-2: The Beast, the Number, and Babylon — Reading One Symbol Four Ways
- Lecture 30-3: The Thousand Years and the World Made New
At the center of Matthew's account of Caesarea Philippi, Simon Peter answers Jesus's question — "who do you say that I am?" — with a confession this course's chapter 6 already examined in Mark's version: "You are the Christ, the Son of the living God" (Matthew 16:16). That sentence names, in miniature, exactly what this chapter's whole inquiry is circling: a claim about who Jesus was that goes well beyond anything historical method alone can verify or falsify, made by a first-century follower, about a first-century teacher, inside a first-century narrative a historian can nonetheless study with the ordinary tools this chapter has been building.
This is a point where readers will not agree, and this lecture's purpose is not to settle that disagreement but to present it honestly, in the words and reasoning of real scholars on both sides. Two identifiable, contemporary camps in historical-Jesus scholarship read a great deal of the same first-century evidence and reach substantially different conclusions about how much of the Gospels' portrait historical method can confirm. One is the Jesus Seminar, associated especially with Robert Funk and John Dominic Crossan, whose working method starts from considerable skepticism about how much of the Gospel material goes back to Jesus himself. The other is often grouped under the Third Quest label introduced in lecture 9-1, represented here by N.T. Wright and James Dunn, whose work argues for substantially greater historical confidence in the Gospels' portrait, using many of the same tools discussed in lecture 9-2. Both are real, serious, peer-engaged scholarship. Neither is presented here as this course's own settled answer.
이 18분으로 얻는 것
- Describe the Jesus Seminar's method and summarize Robert Funk's and John Dominic Crossan's positions in your own words.
- Describe N.T. Wright's and James Dunn's Third Quest arguments for greater historical confidence in the Gospels.
- Identify at least two specific points of disagreement between these two approaches, stated fairly on both sides.
- Explain why this course presents this disagreement as genuinely open rather than resolving it.
- Connect this lecture's debate back to the criteria of authenticity discussed in lecture 9-2.
Matthew 16:16 — "Simon Peter answered, 'You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.'" (World English Bible)
This confession, set by Matthew at the same narrative hinge this course's chapter 6 examined in Mark (8:29), states in a single sentence the theological claim standing behind every historical-Jesus debate this chapter has surveyed. Neither the Jesus Seminar nor Third Quest scholarship can prove or disprove Peter's confession by historical method alone — it is a statement of faith, not a historically testable proposition in the ordinary sense — but both camps have real, differing things to say about how the historical Jesus relates to a claim like this one, which is precisely where this lecture's disagreement lives.
1. The Jesus Seminar: Robert Funk, John Dominic Crossan, and disciplined skepticism
The Jesus Seminar was founded in 1985 by Robert Funk, an American New Testament scholar, as a working group of scholars who met regularly to vote, using colored beads, on the historical likelihood that specific sayings and deeds attributed to Jesus in the Gospels (and, notably, in the non-canonical Gospel of Thomas, which the Seminar treated as a potentially independent early source) actually originated with him. A red bead meant a scholar judged the saying almost certainly authentic; black meant almost certainly not; pink and gray marked degrees of uncertainty in between. The Seminar's published results, most famously in The Five Gospels (1993), judged only a small minority of sayings attributed to Jesus in the Gospels — roughly one in five by the Seminar's own count — as likely authentic in anything close to their recorded form.
Funk's own stated purpose was not simply destructive. He argued that historical-critical scholarship had a responsibility to communicate its findings to a wider public rather than remain confined to academic journals, and that the church's traditional portrait of Jesus had, in his judgment, accumulated substantial later theological overlay that responsible historical method should be willing to strip away and say so publicly, however unwelcome that might be to traditional believers. Applying something close to a strict version of the dissimilarity criterion discussed in lecture 9-2, along with heavy weight on form-critical judgments about which sayings show signs of later church composition (chapter 3's Bultmann connection is not incidental here — the Seminar's method sits in a direct line from Bultmann's form criticism, even where it departs from Bultmann's theological conclusions), Funk and his colleagues concluded that the historical Jesus emerging from this stripped-down evidence looked considerably less like the apocalyptic, miracle-working, self-consciously messianic figure of the Gospels' full narrative and considerably more like an itinerant, subversive wisdom teacher whose later followers progressively layered supernatural and messianic claims onto a comparatively modest original figure.
John Dominic Crossan, another prominent Seminar member, developed an influential version of this reconstruction in works like The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant (1991), combining the Seminar's saying-by-saying method with social-historical study of first-century Galilean peasant life. Crossan's Jesus is a social and religious radical — an itinerant Jewish Cynic-like sage practicing "open commensality" (table fellowship without regard for social status) and a program of "brokerless" access to God that bypassed the Temple's religious authority structures — whose crucifixion, on Crossan's reading, resulted from direct confrontation with Roman and Temple power rather than from theological blasphemy claims the Gospels later emphasized. Crossan's work is careful, extensively researched, and takes first-century Jewish and Greco-Roman social history seriously; it is not casual skepticism, and presenting it as such would be exactly the kind of flattening to avoid.
2. The Third Quest: N.T. Wright, James Dunn, and historical confidence
N.T. Wright, an English New Testament scholar already named in this course's chapter 3 for his "critical realism," has argued at length — most extensively in his multi-volume Christian Origins and the Question of God series, particularly Jesus and the Victory of God (1996) — that the Jesus Seminar's method systematically underweights first-century Jewish apocalyptic expectation as the actual framework within which Jesus's ministry makes historical sense. Wright's own reconstruction places Jesus firmly within a first-century Jewish narrative of Israel's story — exile, expectation of restoration, and the coming reign of God — and argues that Jesus's own actions (the Temple demonstration, the choice of twelve disciples symbolically evoking Israel's twelve tribes, his crucifixion under the charge "King of the Jews") make far more historical sense as the deliberate, coherent actions of someone claiming a decisive, climactic role in that story than as a later theological overlay imposed on a simpler original wisdom teacher. Wright is explicit that this argument proceeds by ordinary historical method, using many of the same tools (multiple attestation, coherence with a plausible first-century Jewish context) discussed in lecture 9-2, applied with what he argues is greater care for that Jewish context than the Jesus Seminar's method allows.
James Dunn, another major Third Quest voice, has made a related but distinct argument in works including Jesus Remembered (2003), the first volume of his own Christianity in the Making series. Dunn's specific contribution concerns the nature of oral tradition itself: rather than picturing the Gospel material as passing through a long chain of unstable retelling in which each transmission risked significant distortion — the assumption Dunn argues underlies much of the skepticism running from Bultmann through the Jesus Seminar — Dunn draws on studies of oral tradition in traditional societies to argue that communally significant material, retold within a community that valued its accuracy, tends to be preserved with far more stability than the "broken telephone" model assumes, particularly regarding a teacher's characteristic emphases and patterns even where exact wording varies. On Dunn's account, the Gospels' variation in precise wording across parallel accounts is not primarily evidence of unreliable transmission but is itself a normal, expected feature of how oral tradition preserves a remembered teacher's voice — which, if correct, would license considerably more historical confidence in the Gospels' overall portrait than the Jesus Seminar's method assumes.
3. What is actually at stake
What is at stake
This is a point where readers will not agree. The disagreement is not simply "skeptics versus believers," a framing both sides would reject as a caricature of their actual scholarship — Crossan and Funk are working historians engaging first-century evidence with real method, not dismissing the question; Wright and Dunn are equally working historians making arguments from evidence, not simply asserting confessional conclusions. The actual disagreement runs deeper, into several specific, identifiable points: how much weight first-century Jewish apocalyptic expectation should carry in reconstructing Jesus's own self-understanding (Wright argues for a great deal; the Jesus Seminar's reconstruction generally minimizes apocalyptic material as later addition); how stable oral tradition actually is before being written down (Dunn argues for real stability; the Jesus Seminar's method assumes considerably more instability and theological reshaping); and how much interpretive weight the non-canonical Gospel of Thomas should carry as potentially independent, early evidence (the Jesus Seminar gave it substantial weight; Wright and Dunn, along with a considerable body of other scholarship, judge it later and more dependent on the canonical tradition than the Seminar's use of it assumes).
It is worth naming plainly, in the interest of fairness, that the Jesus Seminar's methods and conclusions have drawn substantial criticism even from scholars who do not share Wright's or Dunn's more traditionally confident conclusions — the practice of voting with colored beads, in particular, has been criticized broadly across the field, including by scholars with no particular theological stake in the outcome, as an odd way to represent nuanced historical probability judgments in a simple public vote. It is equally worth naming that Wright's and Dunn's arguments, while methodologically serious and widely engaged in the field, are themselves contested by other historians, including some Third Quest scholars who share their basic Jewish-context method but reach more moderate conclusions than either Wright or Dunn on specific points. Neither side has "won" the field in any sense a fair-minded survey of contemporary scholarship could claim, and a course that told its readers otherwise would be doing exactly what this lecture should not do: resolving a contested question by asserting a preferred answer as settled fact.
4. Where this leaves the reader
This lecture cannot tell a reader whether Peter's confession at Caesarea Philippi — "You are the Christ, the Son of the living God" — is something the historical Jesus himself would have recognized and accepted, or a claim that developed later and was read back into the narrative, or something historical method simply cannot adjudicate either way. What it can do, and has tried to do, is show that this disagreement is carried by real scholars using real historical method, disagreeing about specific, nameable things — apocalyptic expectation, oral tradition's stability, the weight of one non-canonical source — rather than a simple split between scholarship and faith. A student who wants to go further with either side has, in Funk, Crossan, Wright, and Dunn, four specific scholars and specific books to read rather than a vague impression of "some scholars think."
핵심 요약
- The Jesus Seminar, founded in 1985 by Robert Funk, voted with colored beads (red/pink/gray/black) on the likely authenticity of sayings attributed to Jesus, including in the non-canonical Gospel of Thomas, and judged only about one in five authentic in The Five Gospels (1993).
- John Dominic Crossan's version, in The Historical Jesus (1991), reconstructs Jesus as an itinerant Jewish Cynic-like sage practicing "open commensality" and "brokerless" access to God, crucified for confronting Roman and Temple power rather than for blasphemy claims.
- N.T. Wright, in Jesus and the Victory of God (1996), argues the Jesus Seminar underweights first-century Jewish apocalyptic expectation, and reads Jesus's Temple demonstration, choice of twelve disciples, and crucifixion as "King of the Jews" as coherent actions claiming a climactic role in Israel's own story.
- James Dunn, in Jesus Remembered (2003), argues from studies of oral tradition in traditional societies that communally valued material is preserved with more stability than a "broken telephone" model assumes, so wording variation across Gospel parallels reflects normal oral transmission, not unreliable transmission.
- The two camps disagree on three specific, nameable points: how much weight first-century apocalyptic expectation should carry, how stable oral tradition is before being written down, and how much interpretive weight the Gospel of Thomas deserves — not simply "skepticism versus faith."
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Two contemporary camps read the same first-century evidence to very different conclusions. The Jesus Seminar (Robert Funk, John Dominic Crossan), voting by colored beads, judged roughly one in five Gospel sayings authentic and reconstructed Jesus as an itinerant wisdom teacher whose apocalyptic and messianic claims were layered on later; Crossan specifically pictures a sage practicing "open commensality" crucified for confronting Roman and Temple power. Third Quest scholars N.T. Wright and James Dunn argue for much greater confidence: Wright reads Jesus's actions (the Temple demonstration, twelve disciples, "King of the Jews") as deliberately claiming a climactic role in Israel's story, while Dunn argues oral tradition preserves a remembered teacher's voice reliably despite wording variation. The real disagreement is not "scholarship versus faith" but three specific, nameable disputes: apocalyptic weight, oral tradition's stability, and how much the Gospel of Thomas should count as evidence.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Both the Jesus Seminar and Third Quest scholars claim to be using disciplined historical method rather than simply reading their own conclusions into the evidence. What specific methodological choice — not a difference in starting belief — most explains why they reach such different portraits of Jesus?
- James Dunn argues that variation in wording across parallel Gospel accounts is normal for oral tradition and does not by itself indicate unreliable transmission. Does this argument, if accepted, change how you would read a case where two Gospels report the same saying with noticeably different wording?
- This lecture named specific criticisms of both the Jesus Seminar's method and of Wright's and Dunn's conclusions. Why might it matter, for a student trying to evaluate this debate fairly, to know that each side has real critics within the field itself rather than treating the disagreement as simply "scholarship versus faith"?