Lecture 4-3: The Black Death
The plague did not make Europe less religious. It made Europe religious in a different way, with the institution nearer the edge.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
The plague did not make Europe less religious. It made Europe religious in a different way, with the institution nearer the edge.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
The plague reached Sicily in October 1347 on ships out of the Black Sea. Within four years it had crossed Europe to Norway and Russia. Somewhere between a third and a half of the population was dead. Whole villages ended, and in some monasteries the whole community died.
The lecture uses this psalm of confidence because the fourteenth century recited it while burying half of Europe. The lecture asks the reader to notice that the psalm was still being said.
I will lift up my eyes to the hills. Where does my help come from? My help comes from Yahweh, who made heaven and earth." Psalm 121:1–2 · World English Bible
Medieval Europe taught that God is just and governs all things. So calamity was either punishment for sin, a testing that purifies, or a mystery whose good is hidden. The Black Death broke this framework for three reasons. The scale was too large for a fitting judgement. It did not sort the wicked from the good. And the clergy died at higher rates than the laity, because hearing confessions and anointing the dying meant sitting beside them.
In 1348-1349 bands of laymen travelled from town to town and whipped themselves in public as penance. Their logic was orthodox: God is angry, penance appeases anger, and the church's ordinary penance had not been enough. But they began to claim that their processions were themselves a means of forgiveness, and that the clergy were unnecessary. Then the movement turned murderous, and its arrival in the Rhineland and Switzerland coincided with massacres of Jewish communities accused of poisoning wells.
Clement VI issued bulls in 1348 protecting Jews. He pointed out that Jews were dying of the plague in the same proportions as everyone else, and he forbade the killing on pain of excommunication. In October 1349 he condemned the flagellant movement. But the killings continued. After seventy years of converting authority into revenue, the papacy had no authority left when it needed it to save lives.
After 1350 the danse macabre appeared in art. A skeletal figure of Death takes by the hand, in turn, a pope, an emperor, a king, a bishop, a merchant, a labourer and a child. The pope goes first, and he goes exactly as the labourer goes. It is not despairing. The literature of the ars moriendi, the art of dying well, gave practical instruction, and much of it was addressed to the dying person and whoever was in the room, not to a priest.
Medieval salvation ran through sacraments given by ordained priests, and to die without confession and absolution was a real terror. Priests died in great numbers. Replacements were ordained fast and young, and many people died without a priest at all. In January 1349 the bishop of Bath and Wells told those who could not find a priest to make confession to a layman, even to a woman if no man was available, and to trust that God would accept it.
If the institution cannot be relied on to be there, what remains is the individual before God. Devotional writing became more personal.
Lay confraternities, lay endowments, lay reading and lay communities. People organised their own religious lives at a scale not seen before.
Vernacular mystical writing flowered in northern Europe. Julian of Norwich received her visions in 1373 during a severe illness.
Julian was an English anchoress. She wrote the first known book in English by a woman. Her most famous sentence is "all shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well." She lived in a city that had been repeatedly ravaged by plague. The lecture says this is not a platitude but a theological claim made by someone who had watched a third of her city die.
The chronicles say "this is for our sins" while describing behaviour that suggests nobody believed it.
How would you recognise, from inside, that an explanation you still recite has stopped working?
A church whose authority is already in question can survive an argument about jurisdiction. It cannot survive a catastrophe in which its explanations do not work and its ministers are not available. The buildings were fuller, and the belief in the building had moved. Historians such as Eamon Duffy say the effect on religion is easy to overstate, so keep to the narrow claim: Europe became religious in a different way.