무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

CH102E Medieval Church History

Lecture 4-3: The Black Death

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

20분

The plague reached Sicily in October 1347 on ships out of the Black Sea. Within four years it had crossed Europe to Norway and Russia, and somewhere between a third and a half of the population was dead.

Try to hold what that means. Not a bad epidemic — one person in every two or three you knew. Whole villages ended. In some monasteries the entire community died. There was no explanation available except a theological one, and the theological one did not work.

This lecture is about what the Black Death did to belief. It is the least institutional lecture in this chapter and possibly the most important, because Avignon and Basel were quarrels among clergy that most Europeans experienced at a distance, and this was not. The schism damaged the papacy's authority. The plague damaged the sacramental system in the hands of ordinary people, and those are different injuries.

이 20분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain why the plague created a crisis for the medieval understanding of providence.
  • Describe the flagellant movement and the anti-Jewish violence that accompanied it, and the church's official response.
  • Explain the *danse macabre* and the shift it marks in religious imagination.
  • Analyse the damage to the clergy and to the sacramental system, and the turn toward personal and mystical devotion that followed.

I will lift up my eyes to the hills. Where does my help come from? My help comes from Yahweh, who made heaven and earth." — Psalm 121:1–2

World English Bible

A psalm of confidence, and the fourteenth century recited it while burying half of Europe. Whatever this lecture describes, notice that the psalm was still being said.

1. The theology that could not absorb it

Medieval Europe had a working account of suffering, and it was not naive. God is just; God governs all things; therefore calamity is either punishment for sin, or a testing that purifies, or a mystery whose good is hidden. Plague, famine and war all fitted somewhere in that framework, and the framework had absorbed a great deal.

The Black Death broke it, for three reasons that people noticed at the time and said out loud.

The scale. Punishment implies proportion. When a third of everyone dies within four years, including newborns, the account of a fitting judgement stops being usable by ordinary people, whatever the theologians say.

It did not sort the wicked from the good. The devout died alongside the careless. Monasteries and convents — communities of people who had given their whole lives to prayer — were among the worst hit, precisely because they lived in close quarters and nursed the sick.

The clergy died at higher rates than the laity, and for an honourable reason: hearing confessions and anointing the dying meant sitting beside them. The men whose office was to explain the plague were being visibly consumed by it, which does not look like divine favour.

So the standard answer was available and did not fit. People kept saying it — the chronicles are full of this is for our sins — while behaving as though they did not believe it, which is generally the point at which a framework has failed.

Did disasters change belief

This is a point where readers will not agree. Eamon Duffy and others argue that the religious effect of the late medieval disasters has been overstated, and that the church's structures were far more vigorous than the older accounts suggested; church-building and endowments actually rose in some regions after 1350. Others hold that the recovery was in the forms and not in the confidence, and that the shift toward personal devotion in lecture 4-4 is the evidence. The safest statement is the narrow one: the plague did not make Europe less religious. It made Europe religious in a different way, with the institution nearer the edge of the picture.

2. The flagellants: taking the sacrifice into their own hands

The most visible response was the flagellant movement of 1348–1349.

Bands of laymen, sometimes several hundred strong, travelled from town to town. They processed, sang, and in the public square stripped to the waist and whipped themselves with scourges, often knotted with iron, for a set period — commonly thirty-three and a half days, one day for each year of Christ's life.

The logic was straightforward and entirely orthodox in its premises. God is angry; anger is appeased by penance; the church's ordinary penance has evidently not been enough; therefore we will offer more, publicly, and on a scale proportionate to the disaster.

But watch what the movement became within months, because the pattern is the same one lecture 2-1 identified.

The flagellants began claiming that their processions were themselves a means of forgiveness — that a man who joined and completed the discipline had his sins remitted. Some claimed heavenly letters authorising them. Increasingly they preached, heard something like confession from each other, and told congregations that the clergy were unnecessary. A lay movement had begun administering salvation without orders, without authorisation and without a bishop.

And then it turned murderous. Flagellant arrivals in the Rhineland and Switzerland coincided with, and often incited, massacres of Jewish communities accused of poisoning wells — at Strasbourg, Basel, Mainz, Cologne and elsewhere, in 1348 and 1349. In Strasbourg in February 1349 several hundred Jews were burned. This is the same violence lecture 2-2 traced from 1096, arriving again in a crisis, in the same region, against the same communities.

It should be recorded plainly that the church's official response was correct and courageous, and that it failed. Clement VI issued bulls in 1348 protecting Jews, pointing out the plain fact that Jews were dying of the plague in the same proportions as everyone else, and forbidding the killing on pain of excommunication. In October 1349 he condemned the flagellant movement outright and ordered its suppression.

A pope in Avignon telling a German town to stop was, by 1349, a pope with no leverage. The killings continued. Set that beside lecture 4-1 and the sequence is exact: the papacy had spent seventy years converting its authority into revenue, and when it needed authority to save lives it did not have any left.

3. The dance of death

Something changed in the religious imagination of Europe after 1350, and it is easiest to see in art.

The danse macabre — the dance of death — appears across the fifteenth century: a painted or printed sequence in which a skeletal figure of Death takes by the hand, in turn, a pope, an emperor, a cardinal, a king, a bishop, a merchant, a labourer, a child, and leads each away dancing. Related forms include the transi tomb, which shows the deceased in effigy above and as a decaying corpse below, and the vast literature of the ars moriendi, the art of dying well.

Two features of the danse macabre matter for this course.

It is universal, and it is levelling. The pope goes first, and he goes exactly as the labourer goes. In a century when the pope's authority was in dispute and the church's hierarchy was the most visible fact of life, an image of that hierarchy being dissolved by death, and being dissolved in order, was not a neutral piece of decoration.

It is not despairing. The point of the ars moriendi was practical instruction: how to prepare, what to say, how to resist temptation on a deathbed. And crucially, much of it is addressed to the dying person and to whoever is in the room, not to a priest. That is a small change with a long future.

4. The sacramental emergency

Here is the most concrete damage, and the least often discussed.

Medieval salvation ran through the sacraments, administered by ordained priests. At the end of life this meant confession, absolution, the Eucharist as viaticum, and anointing. To die unshriven — without confession and absolution — was a genuine terror.

The plague attacked exactly that system at exactly the point of maximum need.

  • Priests died in enormous numbers, and English diocesan records from 1349 show replacement rates so high that the same parish might be presented with three or four new incumbents in a single year.
  • Replacements were ordained fast and young, with training abbreviated or abandoned. The bishops had a choice between an underqualified priest and no priest, and they chose the priest.
  • Some clergy fled, and contemporaries said so bitterly; others died at their posts, and contemporaries said that too. Both were true, and the failures were remembered longer.
  • People died without a priest in large numbers, simply because there was nobody to come.

The church's response to that last problem is the most theologically interesting thing in this lecture. In January 1349 the bishop of Bath and Wells, facing parishes with no clergy, instructed that those unable to obtain a priest should make confession to a layman — "even to a woman if no man is available" — and be assured that God would accept it.

Read that carefully. It was framed as an emergency measure and grounded in older canonical opinion, and it was not intended to change anything permanently. But the church had told ordinary people, in writing, that in extremity the ministry of a layman would do, and that God's forgiveness was not held hostage to the availability of a priest.

You cannot say that to a population and then take it back. Once the necessity of clerical mediation has been publicly suspended in the case that matters most, the theological question has been opened in every case. That question is answered, loudly, in the sixteenth century.

5. Where the religion went

The plague did not empty the churches. It moved the centre of gravity of religious life, in three directions that all lead into lecture 4-4 and chapter 5.

Inward. If the institution cannot be relied upon to be there, what remains is the individual before God. The devotional literature of the later fourteenth century is markedly more personal, more interior, more concerned with the direct relation of the soul to Christ.

Toward the laity. Lay confraternities, lay endowments, lay reading, lay communities. People organised their own religious lives at a scale not seen before.

Toward mysticism. The great flowering of vernacular mystical writing in northern Europe belongs to exactly these decades. Julian of Norwich, an English anchoress, received her visions in May 1373 during a severe illness, in a city that had been repeatedly ravaged by plague, and wrote the first known book in English by a woman — a book whose most famous sentence is all shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well.

That sentence is not a platitude. It is a theological claim made by someone who had watched a third of her city die, and it is worth taking as seriously as anything in this chapter.

6. What actually happened here

The Black Death is not a religious event in the way that Avignon or Constance are. Nobody chose it, and no theology caused it.

But it is the reason those events had the consequences they did. A church whose authority is already in question can survive an argument about jurisdiction. What it cannot survive is a catastrophe during which its explanations do not work and its ministers are not available — because that is not a dispute among clergy. That is every family in Europe, finding out what the system is worth under load.

And here is the chapter's principle arriving from the other side. The institution did not notice this loss either, because it was measured in nothing the institution counted. The parishes were refilled, the endowments rose, the Masses were said. The buildings were fuller and the belief in the building had moved.

An institution can lose its authority faster than it built it, and no one inside notices in time.


The Black Death, 1347–1351 Between a third and a half of Europe. Not a dispute among clergy — every family. 1 · Providence Punishment implies proportion. The devout died with the careless — and the clergy died fastest of all. 2 · The flagellants Lay penance becomes lay absolution, then anticlericalism, then massacres of Jews at Strasbourg, Basel, Mainz 3 · The sacramental system Priests die faster than they can be replaced; the replacements are young and untrained. People die unshriven. 4 · The imagination The danse macabre takes the pope first and the labourer last — the whole hierarchy dissolved, in order Bath and Wells, January 1349: confess to a layman — "even to a woman if no man is available" An emergency measure. But once clerical mediation is publicly suspended where it matters most, the question is open everywhere. Where the religion went — inward · toward the laity · toward mysticism Julian of Norwich, 1373, in a plague city: "all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well" The buildings were refilled. The belief in the building had moved.

Diagram 1. Summary table

Wound What happened What it left
A calamity too large and too indiscriminate to read as proportionate judgement An explanation still spoken and no longer relied on
The flagellants Lay penance claiming to remit sin, turning anticlerical and murderous Anti-Jewish massacres; a papal condemnation nobody obeyed
The clergy Death rates above the laity; rushed, untrained replacements Visible decline in the quality of parish ministry
The sacraments People dying with no priest available Lay confession permitted in extremity — and remembered
The imagination Danse macabre, transi tombs, ars moriendi Death as the leveller of hierarchy; dying as a lay skill

5. Going to the Sources

  • Boccaccio, the introduction to the Decameron — an eyewitness on Florence in 1348. Read the passage on the abandonment of the dying by their own families.
  • Clement VI, the bull Sicut Judaeis (1348) — the papal defence of Jews against the well-poisoning accusation. Short, correct, and ignored.
  • The chronicle of Heinrich of Herford on the flagellants — a contemporary watching the processions and growing uneasy.
  • Julian of Norwich, Revelations of Divine Love, the short text — the first known book in English by a woman, written in a plague city.

핵심 요약

  • The Black Death reached Sicily in 1347, and between a third and a half of Europe died. The usual teaching that suffering is punishment or testing did not fit its scale.
  • It did not separate the wicked from the good, and the clergy died in higher numbers, since they sat beside the dying.
  • Flagellants began to treat their own scourging as a way to forgiveness and then incited massacres of Jews. Clement VI protected Jews and condemned the movement, but had little leverage left.
  • The danse macabre shows death levelling all ranks in order, including the pope, and the ars moriendi (art of dying well) addressed the dying person and those in the room.
  • With priests dying or replaced hastily, the bishop of Bath and Wells in 1349 allowed confession to a layman, even a woman, in an emergency. That opened a lasting question.
  • Religious life moved inward, toward the laity, and toward mysticism, as in Julian of Norwich. Historians such as Duffy argue the plague did not make Europe less religious, only differently so.

Topic: What the Black Death did to medieval belief, the clergy and the sacramental system, and where religious life then moved.

Remember: The plague did not make Europe less religious. It made it religious in a different way, with the institution nearer the edge.

Caution: Historians disagree about how far religion was shaken. Eamon Duffy and others say the effect is overstated, since church building and endowments rose in some regions after 1350.

One line to carry into ministry: When explanations fail and ministers are unavailable in a crisis, a church must not rely on office alone; people will look for God elsewhere.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • The chronicles say "this is for our sins" while describing behaviour that suggests nobody believed it. How would you recognise, from inside, that an explanation you still recite has stopped working?
  • Clement VI defended the Jews and condemned the flagellants, and was ignored. Trace the connection between that failure and the seventy years described in lecture 4-1.
  • The bishop of Bath and Wells permitted lay confession in extremity. Was that a faithful pastoral judgement, a dangerous precedent, or both? What would you have written?
  • Julian of Norwich wrote "all shall be well" after watching a third of her city die. Is that a claim you could make, and on what grounds?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.