Lecture 3-4: Erasmus and the Reformation — Alliance and Rupture
Erasmus and Luther moved from cautious alliance to permanent rupture over free will, and over how certain theology can be.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Erasmus and Luther moved from cautious alliance to permanent rupture over free will, and over how certain theology can be.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Before 1517 Erasmus had mocked indulgence-sellers, relic-hawking and scholastic hairsplitting in his Praise of Folly, and his Enchiridion had argued for an inward, Scripture-formed piety. In a 1519 letter to Elector Frederick of Saxony he wrote that Luther's chief offense seemed to be attacking the pope's crown and the monks' bellies. Yet Erasmus attacked abuses, not the papacy as an office, the sacramental system or the authority of councils.
Catholic critics pressed him for a clear condemnation and reform-minded correspondents pressed him to say publicly that he agreed. He refused both. His reasons were a conviction that the church could be reformed from within through better education and texts, a horror of settling questions by force, and a concern for his own network of patrons and freedom of movement. He denied the last, and the lecture treats it only as a plausible pressure among several.
Pressed in 1523, Erasmus chose the freedom of the will and avoided justification by faith, the priesthood of all believers and the sacraments. His 1524 Diatribe said he disliked assertions on matters he judged obscure. He argued that Scripture has evidence on both sides, citing Deuteronomy 30:19, and that the fathers are divided. A small, unmerited freedom of the will, he said, is more defensible and more pastorally survivable than Luther's flat denial.
Scripture is mixed on the question, so claim little: the will has a small capacity to turn toward or away from grace, contributing nothing to salvation's substance but something to its occasion.
Apart from grace the will is bound to sin and cannot turn toward God in even the smallest particular. His deeper objection was Erasmus's reluctance to assert anything: the Holy Spirit is no skeptic.
The lecture says Luther read this verse as evidence for his case, that the natural man's mind cannot receive the things of the Spirit, the incapacity he thought Erasmus's account of a cooperating will did not take seriously enough.
Now the natural man doesn't receive the things of God's Spirit, for they are foolishness to him, and he can't know them, because they are spiritually discerned." 1 Corinthians 2:14 · World English Bible
The lecture says Erasmus warned that theological certainty pursued without love, in the words knowledge puffs up, divides the church over a question Scripture itself leaves obscure in his judgment.
Now concerning things sacrificed to idols: We know that we all have knowledge. Knowledge puffs up, but love builds up." 1 Corinthians 8:1 · WEB
Erasmus's caution is sympathetic: a scholar who valued the church's unity and the limits of certain knowledge more than being on the winning side.
Faced with the moment that demanded costly commitment, he retreated into qualification and let braver, cruder men settle the argument. The lecture does not choose between them.
The break was about method and temperament as well as doctrine: Erasmus weighed both sides and valued concord, while Luther treated doubt on this question as unbelief. Both had serious reasons, and scholars disagree about Erasmus's caution. Erasmus died in 1536, estranged from the reform movement.