Lecture 13-2: The Exegetical Machinery — Communicatio Idiomatum and "The Flesh Profits Nothing"
Each man built a real argument. Neither was simply choosing the reading he found more comfortable.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Each man built a real argument. Neither was simply choosing the reading he found more comfortable.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
The lecture uses this verse as Paul's own account of the institution, independent of the Gospels, showing that "this is my body" was the church's earliest received language for the rite.
When he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, 'Take, eat. This is my body, which is broken for you. Do this in memory of me.'" 1 Corinthians 11:24 · World English Bible
The lecture calls this the verse Zwingli treated as the interpretive key to the whole controversy, and says its central task is to show how he used it.
It is the spirit who gives life. The flesh profits nothing. The words that I speak to you are spirit, and are life." John 6:63 · WEB
Zwingli and others pressed a physical objection. Christ's body ascended into heaven and is seated at the Father's right hand. Being a genuine human body, it occupies a single location like any body. How, then, can it be present, whole and entire, in the bread on every altar where the Supper is celebrated?
Luther used the communicatio idiomatum, the teaching that in Christ's one person the properties of both his divine and his human nature belong to the same person. He extended it so that Christ's human nature shares the divine property of omnipresence through its union with deity. This is called ubiquity. On this reasoning Christ's body is not confined to one location and can be really present in the Supper.
Zwingli began from Christ's own comment at Capernaum: "The flesh profits nothing." He read it as Christ's instruction not to press "eating my flesh" into crude physical literalism. He then set beside it Scripture's other figures, such as "I am the door", "I am the true vine" and "the seed is the word of God". He concluded that "this represents my body" is the reading Scripture's own habits of speech recommend.
Luther and his allies disputed whether John 6 belongs in the argument at all, since the Supper had not yet been instituted when Jesus spoke at Capernaum. Zwingli's answer was that in both places Christ is teaching how his followers are to receive him, so John 6 supplies the lens for reading Matthew 26.
Christ's two natures are united in one person, properties communicate between the natures, the human nature shares omnipresence, and so his body can be present wherever the Supper is kept.
John 6:63 warns against crude physical literalism, Scripture elsewhere uses "is" to mean "signifies", this pattern is the lens for the words of institution, and so "this is my body" means "this represents my body".
That the personal union of the two natures entails the human nature's sharing in omnipresence, as a legitimate inference from Scripture and not an imported philosophical category.
That John 6:63, spoken in a different setting, is the correct lens for the words of institution, and not a separate teaching about unbelieving hunger for a miracle.
Luther's critics judged ubiquity an overreach that borrowed scholastic categories. Luther's side asked whether John 6 belongs in the argument at all.
Which of the two premises would you find harder to accept, and why?
Luther argued from the union of Christ's two natures, and Zwingli argued from John 6:63 and Scripture's figures of speech. Each argument depends on a premise the other side does not grant, and the lecture says neither dependency is illegitimate on its face. This is why the conversation at Marburg did not settle the matter.