무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

← 전체 강의

CH202E · 6장

Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working

Before 1914 progress looked like a description of reality. The war exposed that a theology built on a culture's values has no place to stand against that culture.

The Church in the Modern World

14장 전체 강의 24분

옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →

이 강의에서 배우는 것
  • Describe how confidence in historical progress and liberal theology reinforced each other before 1914, and state the strongest version of that theology's own case.
  • Explain how the kingdom of God came to be understood as a moral and social achievement within history, and what that reading gained and lost.
  • Explain why the killing of 1914–18 was experienced as a specifically modern catastrophe rather than a relapse into barbarism, and why the churches' conduct made it a theological crisis and not only a moral one.
  • State precisely which claims the war actually undermined and which it left untouched, and trace the theological logic that led from that reckoning towards a theology of revelation.
Before the war

Progress as a background fact

Educated Europeans believed in progress the way we believe in gravity. Between 1850 and 1910 life expectancy rose, anaesthesia and germ theory arrived, literacy in western Europe passed ninety per cent, and slavery was abolished across most of the world. In 1910 Norman Angell argued that a major European war had become economically impossible. If you had been asked in 1900 to defend the idea that history moves forward, you would have needed a list, not a philosophy.

핵심 The confidence rested on real evidence.
Theology joins in

God inside history

German Protestant theology had taken history seriously and located religion in human experience. Schleiermacher grounded faith in the feeling of absolute dependence. Harnack's What Is Christianity? reduced Jesus's message to three things, including the infinite value of the human soul and the commandment of love. The lecture says his motive was pastoral: to keep educated people in the church.

핵심 The motive was pastoral, not cynical.
The Social Gospel

A caricature to correct

Rauschenbusch's Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907) turned this theology toward tenements, sweatshops and child labour. The Social Gospel is often said to believe that humanity would build the kingdom by moral improvement. The lecture says Rauschenbusch wrote at length about a kingdom of evil and super-personal forces of evil in institutions, which is a considerably darker view. Still, the kingdom had become something enacted in history through human moral agency.

핵심 Salvation had become, in large part, a project.
At a glance

What the trade bought and cost

What it bought

A Christianity an educated modern could hold without dishonesty, and something concrete to say about factories and slums.

What it paid

A weaker vocabulary for anything that human moral agency cannot fix.

Fifty-two months

Rational barbarism

The war did not feel like a relapse into savagery. The rail networks that mobilised millions had knit Europe together. The chemical industry that fed German agriculture also made the chlorine gas released at Ypres, and Fritz Haber, who directed that attack, had invented the process for fixing nitrogen. On the first day of the Somme the British Army took around 57,000 casualties. Total military deaths are usually put near ten million. Churches in every belligerent country blessed the effort.

핵심 The same science fed millions and killed them.
The manifesto

To the Civilised World!

On 4 October 1914 an appeal appeared over the names of ninety-three German scientists, artists and scholars. It denied that Germany had caused the war and denied reports of atrocities in Belgium, several of which were in fact true. Harnack signed it. A young Swiss pastor in Safenwil, Karl Barth, saw that his teachers had put their names to a defence of the war without noticing any tension. Their theology had no independent place to stand.

핵심 The problem was not wickedness but a missing place to stand.
At a glance

What the war refuted and what it did not

What it did refute

A reliable direction of moral improvement. And a theology grounded in a culture's moral consciousness that is meant to stand against that culture at war.

What it did not refute

Historical criticism of the Bible, the social consequences of faith, or human capacity for good. It also did not hit every country equally.

Scripture

Why Zechariah 4:6?

The lecture uses this verse as a correction of where the outcome comes from, not a rebuke of effort. It reads it against a generation that had great might and power and used it to level a continent.

Then he answered and spoke to me, saying, “This is Yahweh’s word to Zerubbabel, saying, ‘Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit,’ says Yahweh of Armies." Zechariah 4:6 · World English Bible
The logic

From ruin to revelation

If God is known through the highest reaches of human moral experience, then that experience sets the limits of what God can say. God cannot contradict us, so God has no way to say no to the war. Younger theologians reached for a God who addresses human beings from outside. Such a God can judge them, and can therefore also forgive them. H. Richard Niebuhr summed up the quarrel in 1937: a God without wrath, a Christ without a cross.

핵심 A God who cannot stand over against you cannot rescue you either.
Think about it

What is your background?

Europe was so confident about progress in 1910 that the confidence worked as background, not as a claim.

What is your own church so sure of that it functions as background rather than as a claim?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A theology that reaches God by extending human moral experience has no place to stand when a culture goes to war. That is why a theology of revelation seemed necessary. The lecture adds that the war removed the plausibility of a mood rather than refuting a list of propositions, and that the correction has its own costs.

이것은 강의가 아니라 개요입니다.

이 카드는 짧은 미리보기입니다. 읽은 기록은 전체 강의를 읽을 때만 남고, 장 퀴즈와 시험은 전체 강의의 내용을 묻습니다.

전체 강의 읽기 →

1 / 14