무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

← 전체 강의

CH401E · 6장

Lecture 6-2: Scripture and Tradition in the Medieval Church — A Dispute About the Dispute

This lecture is a dispute about a dispute: historians disagree about what the medieval church as a whole believed on Scripture and tradition. Getting that right changes how fairly you can read the Reformation and Trent.

The History of Christian Doctrine

12장 전체 강의 18분

옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →

이 강의에서 배우는 것
  • Distinguish a historiographical dispute (a disagreement about how to characterize a historical period) from a theological dispute (a disagreement about what is true), and explain why this lecture is mainly about the former.
  • State Heiko Oberman's distinction between "Tradition I" and "Tradition II" in your own words, with an example of each.
  • Explain the significance historians have found in the drafting history of Trent's Fourth Session — specifically the change from "partly... partly" language to "and" in the final decree — for the question of which model Trent itself was actually adopting.
  • Name at least one way this historiographical question changes how fairly a reader can approach the Reformation's sola scriptura principle in the next lecture.
Kind of question

Historiography, not theology

The question is not first whether the medieval church held Scripture alone or Scripture plus a second source. It is what kind of historical claim we can responsibly make about what the church believed across roughly a thousand years. Historians who have looked hard at the sources disagree. That is a dispute about how to characterise the past, not about what is true, and getting it wrong changes how fairly you read the Reformation and Trent.

핵심 Both kinds of dispute matter, and this lecture teaches the first.
Scripture

Why 2 Thessalonians 2:15?

The lecture notes that Paul treats his oral teaching and his letters as one category, "whether by word, or by letter". It says the verse assumes the two cohere, so neither side of the dispute should claim Paul as a straightforward ally.

So then, brothers, stand firm, and hold the traditions which you were taught by us, whether by word, or by letter." 2 Thessalonians 2:15 · World English Bible
At a glance

Oberman's two traditions

Tradition I

Scripture is materially sufficient. Tradition is the church's Spirit-guided interpretation and transmission of that one content, not a second source.

Tradition II

Alongside Scripture is a partly independent stream of unwritten apostolic tradition that can supply content Scripture does not state.

Oberman's argument

Look period by period

The older account read the whole medieval period as holding Tradition II. Many Protestant historians liked it because it made sola scriptura a clean break, and many earlier Catholic theologians liked it because it made Trent an unbroken continuation. Heiko Oberman asked for a period-by-period look. He argued Tradition I was more common earlier and that Tradition II hardened mainly in the later Middle Ages, under pressure from schism and conciliar crisis.

핵심 If he is right, neither older story survives intact.
A second witness

Yves Congar

The Catholic theologian Yves Congar worked independently on the history of tradition and reached broadly compatible conclusions. Much of the patristic and early medieval evidence treats tradition as Scripture's faithful transmission and interpretation, not an independent source of content. Stronger two-source language develops more clearly later. That two historians from different confessional starting points converged is part of why Oberman's typology became the standard reference.

핵심 Convergence from both sides gives the typology its standing.
Trent's drafts

From "partly... partly" to "and"

Surviving drafts of Trent's Fourth Session decree said the truth of the gospel is contained partim... partim, partly in written books and partly in unwritten traditions. That states Tradition II about as clearly as a sentence can. The approved text of 1546 replaced it with et, "and", which lists two carriers without saying how far they overlap. Historians disagree whether this was a deliberate softening or a stylistic revision that later readers have over-interpreted.

핵심 The lecture states the disagreement as live, not resolved.
Why it matters

Telling the story with its real texture

A Protestant reader should not assume the whole medieval church rejected Scripture's sufficiency before Luther. A Catholic reader should not assume Trent merely restated what the church had always taught, since the drafting suggests the council was choosing among live options. Neither concession requires giving up the position either tradition holds today. It only requires telling the medieval story as the sources show it.

핵심 Keep the historical question and your tradition's stake in it apart.
Think about it

A flattened story

Readers on every side have had an interest in flattening this period into one simple story.

Which simple version of the medieval story were you taught, and what in this lecture complicates it?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Oberman's Tradition I treats tradition as Scripture's interpretation, and Tradition II adds a partly independent stream, which he argues hardened later in the Middle Ages. Trent's change from "partly... partly" to "and" is evidence, but historians disagree how much it proves. Tell the history with its variety, and keep it separate from your own tradition's stake in it.

이것은 강의가 아니라 개요입니다.

이 카드는 짧은 미리보기입니다. 읽은 기록은 전체 강의를 읽을 때만 남고, 장 퀴즈와 시험은 전체 강의의 내용을 묻습니다.

전체 강의 읽기 →

1 / 12