Lecture 4-1: Goals You Can Obey
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Planning an Act of Faith?
- Lecture 1-2: Mission, Vision and Values: Telling Them Apart
- Lecture 1-3: Discernment in Scripture: Praying, Planning, Being Blocked
- Lecture 1-4: Discerning Together: Who Is in the Room
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Draft Calling Statement
- Lecture 2-1: Starting From What You Have
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to Your Neighbours
- Lecture 2-3: Your Story, Your Wounds, Your Limits
- Lecture 2-4: People, Time, Money and Health: Counting Your Capacity
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Picture
- Lecture 3-1: Writing a Vision People Can Say
- Lecture 3-2: Priorities, and What to Stop
- Lecture 3-3: Reaching Agreement in Different Structures
- Lecture 3-4: Counting the Cost and Taking a Risk
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Three Priorities and One Thing to Stop
- Lecture 4-1: Goals You Can Obey
- Lecture 4-2: Calendar and Rhythm
- Lecture 4-3: Roles, Volunteers and Resources
- Lecture 4-4: Plan and Budget Together
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Year Plan
- Lecture 5-1: What to Count and What Not to Count
- Lecture 5-2: Reviews That Teach
- Lecture 5-3: Honest Reporting
- Lecture 5-4: Evaluating Work Without Judging Persons
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Year-End Review
By week 4 a community has done a good deal of quiet work. It has asked what it was given to do (week 1). It has looked honestly at itself and its neighbours (week 2). It has agreed on a direction and chosen what to stop (week 3). Now someone says, "Fine. What are we actually going to do this year?"
That is the moment when many plans go wrong. A direction, which was prayerful and humble, is turned into a list of targets, which are not. The targets are often numbers. They are often about results that no leader controls. And a year later the community is tired, or proud, or ashamed, depending on what the numbers said.
This lecture asks a different question of every goal: can we obey this? A goal we can obey is one that describes what we will do, and that we are able to do. What God does with it is his. The lecture separates three things that planners often mix together: aims, activities and hopes. It then looks at the old argument about numbers, and ends with a way of starting small.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- Tell an aim, an activity and a hope apart, and say who answers for each.
- Rewrite a goal about results into a goal about obedience, using a before-and-after sentence.
- State the three positions on numerical goals fairly, and say what this course requires whichever you hold.
- Choose a small first set of goals that a community of your size could carry for one year.
I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase." — 1 Corinthians 3:6
World English Bible
So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase." — 1 Corinthians 3:7
WEB
He who is faithful in a very little is faithful also in much. He who is dishonest in a very little is also dishonest in much." — Luke 16:10
WEB
Commit your deeds to Yahweh, and your plans shall succeed." — Proverbs 16:3
WEB
Paul does not say that planting and watering are unimportant. He says that they are not the whole story, and that the part which is not ours is the part that matters most. Read Proverbs 16:3 with that in mind: "commit your deeds" is something we do. What "succeed" will look like is not ours to define. Luke 16:10 gives the measure that fits a goal we can obey: faithfulness in what is in front of us.
1. Three words that planners mix together
Most planning documents use the word "goal" for three different things. Separating them removes much confusion.
An aim is a direction we are heading. It comes from the and the vision that the community worked on in weeks 1 and 3. It is broad. "That our neighbours know they are welcome here" is an aim. It is not finished in a year, and perhaps never.
An activity is something we will do, with a time and a person attached. "On the first Saturday of each month, a team of four will visit the households on Mill Lane" is an activity. It is concrete. At the end of the year anyone can see whether it happened.
A hope is what we pray will result. "We hope that some of those households will come to trust us" is a hope. It is real and it matters. But the community does not control it. Another person's heart, a harvest, a court decision, a government's budget, an illness: all of these are in the hope, and none of them is in our hands.
Now the key point. A community answers for its aims and its activities. It prays about its hopes. The aim tells us why. The activity tells us what we will do. The hope tells us what we are asking God for. Only the middle one can be checked in December as a question of obedience: did we do it, or not?
2. What we control and what we do not
Paul and Apollos are a useful pair. Each had a task. Paul planted, Apollos watered. Each did his own work faithfully. Then Paul says that the growth was God's (1 Corinthians 3:6-7). He is not saying that the work was optional. In the next verse he says that each will receive a reward according to his own labour. Our labour counts. The increase does not belong to us.
This protects a community from two opposite mistakes.
The first mistake is to treat growth as our product. If a team plans well and works hard, the argument goes, the results must follow. When they do, the team is proud. When they do not, the team decides it must have planned badly, or prayed badly, or lacked faith. This is a quiet form of the thinking that says: be diligent and you will be blessed. Scripture does not teach it. Faithful people have laboured for years in hard places and seen little. Others have seen a great deal with little visible effort. The text gives us no formula.
The second mistake is to hear "God gives the increase" and conclude that planning is pointless. If it is all God's, why set any goal? But Paul himself planted. A farmer who says "God gives the harvest" and then does not sow has not understood either God or farming. Proverbs 16:3 puts the two halves in one sentence: commit your deeds to the Lord, and let your plans be made.
A goal you can obey sits between the two mistakes. It takes our work seriously and leaves the result with God.
3. A test: can we do it by ourselves, in the time we have?
Here is a simple test for any goal. Ask three questions.
- Is it something we do? Or is it something someone else must do, decide or become?
- Can we do it with the people, time and money we really have? Not the ones we hope to have.
- Will we know in a year whether we did it? Can someone who was not there see the evidence?
If the answer to the first question is no, the goal is a hope. Move it to the prayer list, where it belongs. It is not worthless. It is just in the wrong place.
An example makes this clearer.
(An invented example.) The elders of a church in the town of Dalmere meet to set goals for the year. A first draft reads:
- "Our Sunday attendance will reach double its present size."
- "Twenty new families will join the church."
- "Our youth will be revived."
Read the three lines with the test in mind. Each one is about what other people will do or become. No can make a family join. No team can revive anyone. After some discussion the elders rewrite the list:
- "Each month, two elders and two members will visit one household that has not been to church for a year or more, if they are willing to be visited."
- "In the autumn we will hold four evenings for young people on the questions they bring, led by two adults who have been asked to do it and have said yes."
- "Every Sunday someone will be named at the door to greet newcomers and ask if they would like to be introduced to a family."
The hopes did not vanish. They moved to the prayer list at the front of the plan, where they were named honestly. The goals are now things the elders can do, can finish, and can look at in December. Notice that the new list is also less exciting. That is not a defect. Excitement is not the test.
4. What a goal for obedience looks like
A goal you can obey tends to have five marks.
It begins with a verb that we do. Visit, teach, repair, pray, meet, write, train, eat together, give.
It names who. Not "the church will..." but "the Hope Street group will..." or "Ana and Daniel will...". Lecture 4-3 comes back to this.
It names when. A month, a season, a day of the week.
It fits the capacity we counted in week 2. If lecture 2-4 showed that only six people can give an evening a week, the plan may not ask for twelve.
It says what we will look at afterwards. Not a verdict on anyone, only a plain record: it happened, it partly happened, it did not happen, and why.
Compare the sentences before and after.
| Before (a result) | After (an act of obedience) |
|---|---|
| "End hunger in our district." | "Every Thursday we will cook and share a meal in the church hall, and keep a list of those who would like help finding work." |
| "Grow the prayer life of the church." | "We will meet for prayer at 6 a.m. on Tuesdays and Fridays, and invite a different household each week to join." |
| "Be a missionary church." | "We will pray by name for the two workers we send, write to them each month, and ask them what they need." |
| "Raise our giving." | "In March we will explain in plain words what the church spends and why, and invite questions." |
The right-hand column is smaller. It is also real.
5. This is a point where readers will not agree: numerical goals
This is a point where readers will not agree. Should a church or agency set numerical goals?
Some hold that numbers keep us honest. A community that says "we want to reach our neighbours" and never counts anything may find, after ten years, that it has reached no one and has not noticed. Numbers, on this view, are a plain way of looking at the truth. They fit the habit of : a steward gives an account, and an account includes figures. Paul himself writes with some precision about collections (2 Corinthians 8). Those who hold this view are usually not driven by pride. They fear vagueness that hides unfaithfulness.
Some hold that numbers distort. When a number becomes the target, people begin to be counted instead of seen. Worship becomes a performance to fill seats. Visitors become figures. Leaders feel they are failing when the figure falls, and are tempted to inflate it. A community that counts everything may lose sight of the one person who does not fit a column. Those who hold this view are usually not careless about results. They fear that the measure will take over the work.
Some hold a middle path: use numbers only for what we control. "We will visit twelve homes" is a number about our own work. "Forty people will come" is a number about other people's choices. The first can be a fair part of a plan. The second belongs to the hope.
What does this course require? Less than any of the three demands. First, numbers never replace seeing persons. Whatever you count, you must still be able to say a name and a story. Second, goals are for what we can obey. If you use a number, let it describe your own act. Third, results are God's. Say so in the plan, in plain words, so that nobody in December reads a low figure as a verdict on a person's faith or a high figure as a reward. Lecture 5-1 returns to this when it asks what to count and what not to count.
6. Start small
A community that has never written a year plan should not write a long one. Three or four goals are enough. Sometimes two.
There are good reasons. A small plan can be kept. It leaves room for the unexpected, which will arrive (lecture 6-1). It leaves time for rest. And it lets a community learn how it plans, which is a skill, before it asks the skill to carry a great deal.
(An invented example.) A house church of twelve people meets in the home of the Okafor family. It has no budget and no staff. Its year plan has three lines. First: meet every Sunday evening and share a meal. Second: pray each week for the three families on the street who have been ill, and visit when asked. Third: in September, invite the neighbours to a harvest supper. That is the whole plan. It fits on half a page. It is a real plan, and the twelve can obey it.
(An invented example.) A mission agency with a board of nine has a different scale and the same principle. Its year plan has six lines, each with an owner, because the agency has staff, partners and donors. But the board has also written one sentence at the top: "Our hopes are in God's hands; this plan lists what we will do." The size of the plan differs. The habit is the same.
(An invented example.) A parish in a diocese does not write its own plan from nothing. The diocese has set priorities for the year, and the parish council asks how to carry them in its own street. Its goals are smaller and local. The parish still has to ask the same question of each: can we do this, here, with these people, and will we know in December?
7. Care with goals that touch people
A few cautions belong here.
Do not set a goal that depends on a person's private change in a way that presses on them. "Five baptisms this year" can quietly turn a pastor's visits into a campaign, and a neighbour into a target. Listening to a neighbour is service, not market work. If you hope for a person to come to faith, you pray, you live honestly beside them, you answer their questions. These are acts. The result is not yours to schedule.
Do not set a goal that trades safety for speed. If a children's programme needs trained and checked adults, the goal waits until they are in place. A date on a plan is never a reason to lower a protection.
Do not set a goal that leaves no room for rest. A community that plans every evening has planned itself into trouble. Lecture 4-2 says more.
Write the goals in words that the least experienced member can read. A plan that only the leaders understand has been made by a few and carried by a few.
8. Where this fits in the course
One sentence to keep the picture clear: leading a community through change, and through the conflict that change sometimes brings, is the subject of the change-and-conflict course; this lecture only asks how to state what you will do. Meetings, votes and who may decide are the subject of the church order and law course. And a later chapter in this course, week 5, will ask how to look back on the goals you set here.
Diagram 1. Aim, activity and hope
Diagram 2. Rewriting a result as an act
| Question | If the answer is no |
|---|---|
| Is it something we do? | It is a hope. Put it on the prayer list. |
| Can we do it with the people, time and money we really have? | Make it smaller, or move it to next year. |
| Will we know in a year whether we did it? | Add a time, a person, a number of times. |
핵심 요약
- A goal can mean an aim, an activity or a hope. They are different, and mixing them causes confusion.
- A community answers for its aims and activities. It prays about its hopes.
- Paul planted and Apollos watered; the increase is God's (1 Corinthians 3:6-7). Work is real; results are not ours.
- Test a goal: is it ours to do, within our real capacity, and will we know in a year whether we did it?
- On numbers, readers differ. This course requires that numbers never replace seeing persons, goals be for what we can obey, and results be left to God.
- Start small: three or four goals a year are enough, and a small plan can be kept.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Aim, activity, hope | Aim: where we are heading. Activity: what we will do. Hope: what we pray for, and do not control. |
| Who answers for what | We answer for aims and activities. We pray about hopes, and the results are God's. |
| The three-question test | Is it ours to do? Can we do it with the people we really have? Will we know in a year? |
| Numerical goals | Readers differ. Never let a number replace seeing a person. |
One sentence to remember A goal you can obey describes what we will do; what God gives from it is his.
This week's action Take one goal from your community's present plans, write it as a hope, an aim and an activity, and see which of the three you can actually answer for.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a goal your community has set in the past, written as a result. Rewrite it as an activity. What did you have to give up in the rewriting, and what did you gain?
- In your own words, what is the difference between answering for an activity and praying about a hope? Where have you seen the two confused?
- Which of the three positions on numerical goals is closest to your instinct? Say the strongest honest case for one of the other two.
- Paul says the increase is God's, yet he planted. What would it look like in your community to take both halves seriously?
- What is the smallest plan that your community could really carry for a year? What would you leave off?