Lecture 2-2: Searching, Asking and Checking
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Persons, Not Resources
- Lecture 1-2: Pastors, Staff and Volunteers: Roles and Understandings
- Lecture 1-3: Partners in Scripture: Delegating, Sending and Supporting
- Lecture 1-4: Who Has Authority Over Whom
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Role Map
- Lecture 2-1: Start With the Need: A Job Description
- Lecture 2-2: Searching, Asking and Checking
- Lecture 2-3: Offer, Pay and Written Understanding
- Lecture 2-4: Welcome and the First Year
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Job Description and Interview Questions
- Lecture 3-1: Supervision and Everyday Feedback
- Lecture 3-2: Appraisal That Is Fair and Caring
- Lecture 3-3: Training, Growth and Mentoring
- Lecture 3-4: Fairness and Voice: Staff Who Find It Hard to Speak
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Appraisal Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: Pay, Leave, Sabbath and Sabbatical
- Lecture 4-2: Reading the Signs of Exhaustion
- Lecture 4-3: The Minister's Household
- Lecture 4-4: Friends, Mentors and Support
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Care Plan
- Lecture 5-1: Conflict and Authority Among Staff
- Lecture 5-2: Misconduct and Fair Correction
- Lecture 5-3: Leaving: Resignation, Dismissal and Reduction
- Lecture 5-4: After a Departure
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing a Hard Conversation
Once a community knows the work, it has to find the person. This is where good intentions most often go wrong. A community searches among its friends, interviews a candidate it has already decided on, asks questions that should not be asked, or checks too little because "we know him". Each of these hurts someone: the applicant who never had a chance, the candidate who is judged on grounds that have nothing to do with the work, the congregation that later learns what a few questions would have told it.
This lecture treats the search as an act of justice and of care. It covers how to announce a role fairly, what friends' recommendations are good for and what they risk, which interview questions are fine and which to avoid, how to use references, why a role with children or vulnerable adults needs checks, and what to do when the result of an interview is already decided.
This lecture is not legal or employment advice. The law on advertising roles, on interview questions, on discrimination, on references and on background checks differs by country, region and year, and a minister's legal status differs too. Check locally and consult a qualified person.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Describe a fair way to announce a role, in small and in large communities.
- State the strength and the risk of recommendations from friends.
- Sort interview questions into those that serve the work and those to avoid.
- Explain why references and checks protect both the community and the candidate.
- Recognise an interview whose result is already decided, and say what is wrong with it.
This is a faithful saying: if a man seeks the office of an overseer, he desires a good work." — 1 Timothy 3:1
World English Bible
Moreover he must have good testimony from those who are outside, to avoid falling into reproach and the snare of the devil." — 1 Timothy 3:7
WEB
Let them also first be tested; then let them serve if they are blameless." — 1 Timothy 3:10
WEB
Lay hands hastily on no one, neither be a participant in other men’s sins. Keep yourself pure." — 1 Timothy 5:22
WEB
‘You shall do no injustice in judgment. You shall not be partial to the poor, nor show favoritism to the great; but you shall judge your neighbor in righteousness." — Leviticus 19:15
WEB
My brothers, don’t hold the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ of glory with partiality." — James 2:1
WEB
Paul gives Timothy a good work to desire and a plain instruction: let people be tested first, and do not lay hands on anyone in haste. Leviticus warns against partiality to the poor and to the great alike; James repeats the point for the church. Whether and how your tradition reads the qualities listed in 1 Timothy 3 for a particular office is a matter for that tradition's own order. What every reading shares is care before commitment, and fairness among candidates.
1. A fair announcement
Fairness begins before anyone is interviewed. Who gets to hear that the role exists? If only the people close to the leader hear, the pool is small and probably looks like the leader's circle.
A fair announcement has four marks.
- It says the truth about the role. It uses the job description from lecture 2-1: purpose, main tasks, line of reporting, whether the post is paid and roughly how, whether it is part-time, temporary or lasting. It does not promise what the community cannot give.
- It reaches beyond the usual circle. Depending on your setting: the church notice sheet and website, neighbouring congregations, a regional body or diocesan office, a denominational network, a school of theology, a mission agency's list. A small community may simply ask five other communities to tell their members.
- It gives a date, a way to apply and a name to ask. A person who must guess how to apply is excluded.
- It says how decisions will be made. "A committee of three will read the applications and invite a few to interview. The decision is taken by the elders, and any appointment follows our regular order." Applicants have a right to know the shape of the process.
Where your tradition fixes the appointment in another body, for example a bishop or a regional council, the announcement may be made by that body. The local community can still ask that it be open and truthful about the role.
2. Recommendations from friends
Most roles are filled by someone who is recommended. This is not wrong. In many places it is the only way a small community can learn about a stranger, and Paul himself relied on others to introduce him (see Acts 9:27 for Barnabas bringing Saul to the apostles). Good recommendations carry knowledge no application can.
The strength of a recommendation is that someone who knows the person's character and work speaks up.
The risk is that it favours friends. Leviticus 19:15 is aimed at this: do not show favour to the great. A community that hires only people already known to it will repeat the same kind of person, shut out the stranger and, over years, create a circle that no one outside can enter.
(an invented example) Mercy Hill Chapel needed a part-time administrator. Three members each knew someone. All three recommended persons from their own families or their own work circles. The elders decided to ask each recommender for a short letter saying what the person had actually done, and also to announce the role to other churches. Two further applicants appeared, one a recent migrant with strong organising experience whom none of the elders knew. The recommended friends were still interviewed, but on the same questions as the others.
Three practical rules:
- Recommendations may open the door; they do not decide the room. The recommended person is interviewed on the same terms as anyone else.
- Ask what the recommender saw, not only what they feel. "Tell me about a time you saw this person handle a hard situation."
- Name the relationship. Anyone on the selection group who is a friend, relative or business partner of a candidate says so, and does not vote on that candidate.
3. Questions in the interview
An interview is not a courtroom and not a casual chat. It is a structured conversation, in which both sides learn whether this work and this person fit.
Good questions are about the work and the person's way of doing it. For example:
- "Tell us about a time you had to work with someone who disagreed with you. What happened?"
- "Which of the tasks in this description would be new to you? How would you learn them?"
- "What would you do in your first three months?"
- "How do you work when you are tired or when the day goes wrong?"
- "What do you need from the people who supervise you?"
- "Is there anything about the hours, the place or the pay that you want to ask us?"
Ask the same core questions of every candidate, in the same order, and make short notes during or just after. This protects the candidate from being judged on mood, and it protects the community from a decision it cannot explain.
Questions to avoid are those that touch matters irrelevant to the work, or that the law in many places forbids or limits. Examples: about a woman's plans for pregnancy or marriage; about a person's age, health or disability unless the question is strictly about the task (such as "this role involves lifting; can you do it, with any help you might need?"); about race, nationality or family background, unless a legal requirement to work in the country has to be checked, in the way the law allows; about the spouse's plans or income; about debts. What the law allows and forbids differs widely; check locally. Even where nothing is forbidden, ask: "Does this question help us judge how they would do the work?" If not, leave it out.
(an invented example) A committee member asked a woman applicant, "You have three small children, so how will you manage evening meetings?" The chair stopped the question and offered a different one to every candidate: "This role includes two evening meetings a month. Is that possible for you, and if not, what would help?" The second version asks the same practical thing, treats the candidates equally and does not assume anything about a person's home.
Where a tradition limits an office to certain persons by its own theology (for example, by order, by sex or by marital status), that is a matter for that tradition's own order. This course does not rank traditions. It asks that the limits be stated openly in the announcement, so that no applicant is led on, and that persons be treated with respect.
4. References and checks
A reference is a conversation with someone who has seen the candidate work. Treat it as a way of learning, not a way of catching anyone out.
- Ask the candidate for permission and for names. Include at least one person who supervised them, not only friends.
- Ask the same questions of each referee. "What was this person's role? How did they work with others? Was there anything we should know to support them well? Would you work with them again?"
- Listen for what is missing. A referee who speaks warmly of the person's talents but says nothing about reliability may be telling you something.
- Write a short note of what was said, and keep it with the file (see below).
- If a reference raises a concern, ask the candidate about it before drawing a conclusion. Give them a chance to explain.
For any role that involves children, youth or vulnerable adults, more is needed: checks appropriate to your country, written protection rules, and a plain statement of these requirements in the announcement. The method belongs to the safety and compliance course and the church order course. The point here: do not skip these checks because the candidate is a friend, a known minister, or from a trusted community. Paul's counsel to Timothy, "Lay hands hastily on no one", is the oldest form of the same care. Nor should a candidate be offended by a check; it protects them as well, because it shows the community has done its duty.
A reference can also reveal something more serious: a hint of misconduct, financial wrongdoing or a past complaint. Do not settle it quietly. Follow the proper authority and any legal reporting duty (these differ by country; check locally). A candidate with an unresolved matter of this kind is not offered a role in the hope that it will go away.
5. Privacy and records
Applications, notes and references are private. Share them only with those who need them for the decision. Keep notes factual: "described conflict with a colleague and how she resolved it" is a note; "seems difficult" is not. Do not pass impressions around the congregation. A rejected applicant should be told kindly and promptly, and not learn the result from rumour. Keep records for as long as your local rules require and no longer; check locally what applies.
6. The interview whose result is already decided
This is a quiet sin and a common one. The committee has chosen a person in advance, perhaps the pastor's friend, a member's relative or the one who has been acting in the role. The interviews of others are a form. Candidates spend a day of preparation, travel at their own cost and are hurt when they discover what happened.
Signs: the decision-makers say, before the interviews, "It will be her, of course." The other candidates receive shorter time and less serious questions. The questions given to the favourite are easier. The announcement has been drafted to match one person.
What to do:
- If you cannot honestly consider other candidates, do not hold a search. Say openly: "We have asked X to take this role, and the community has agreed." That may be a legitimate way to appoint in some traditions and small communities, where a person is known and called. It is honest.
- If you hold a search, keep it open. Name a person on the group who will say aloud if the process is not fair.
- Do not use "prayer" to cover a decision already made. Prayer is not a way to avoid asking questions.
7. In communities of different shape
A house church may have no formal interview at all. It may be a conversation among five people about who will take the role of leader or a sharing of tasks. The same care applies: ask the person what is being asked, ask what they need, ask someone outside the group for a view, and be careful of the pull of friendship.
A parish within a diocese often receives a person assigned by a bishop or an office. The parish does not interview. It can still prepare a clear description of its needs, give the office an honest picture of its situation and welcome the person well (lecture 2-4).
A mission agency or non-profit board searches across large areas and often through networks. The risk is closed networks, which draw only from the same schools or circles. The remedy is to publish the role widely and to be accountable for why a candidate was chosen.
A large congregation has a committee. The risk is process becoming a shield: forms and scoring sheets that look fair but are filled in after the choice. Keep notes made during the interviews, and let the committee compare what was seen.
Diagram 1. The search, step by step, with checks
Diagram 2. Recommendation: strength and risk
| Strength | Risk | Safeguard | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Friend's recommendation | Real knowledge of character and work | Favours the known; shuts out strangers | Same questions for all; say who is a friend |
| Reference from a supervisor | Has seen the person work | May be too kind or too harsh | Same questions for each referee |
| Reference from a friend | Knows the person's heart | Little knowledge of the work | Always add a supervisor |
핵심 요약
- A fair announcement tells the truth about the role, reaches beyond the usual circle and explains how the decision is made.
- Recommendations may open the door but do not decide the room; say openly who is a friend of a candidate.
- Ask the same work-related questions of each candidate; avoid questions that do not help judge the work.
- References, including a supervisor, and checks for work with children or vulnerable adults protect everyone.
- A serious concern is never settled quietly; follow the proper authority and any legal duty (check locally).
- If the choice is already made, say so openly; do not stage an interview for show. This lecture is not legal advice.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A fair announcement | Truth about the role, reach beyond the usual circle, a date and way to apply, and how the decision is made. |
| Recommendations | They may open the door; the recommended person is interviewed like anyone else, and friends of candidates say so. |
| A question to avoid | One that does not help judge the work, such as plans for marriage or children (law differs: check locally). |
| The decided interview | Either appoint openly or search honestly; do not stage a search whose result is fixed. |
One sentence to remember A search is fair when a stranger with the right gifts could really be chosen.
This week's action Write five questions that serve the work for a role you know, and cross out any that would not help you judge how the person would do it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- How does your community announce a role? Who would never hear of it? What could widen the circle?
- Have you seen a recommendation open a door that should have stayed shut, or close one that should have opened? What was missing?
- Rewrite one interview question you have heard (or might hear) that does not help judge the work, so that it asks the practical thing and treats everyone equally.
- Why might a long-trusted friend find a protection check insulting, and how can a community explain it with respect?
- When is it more honest to appoint a known person openly than to hold a search for show?