무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

PT729E Ceremonies in Practice: Weddings, Funerals and Baptisms

Lecture 5-2: Requests the Officiant's Community Does Not Settle

목차 31
PT729E Ceremonies in Practice: Weddings, Funerals and Baptisms
제 0 장 · Introduction: A Threshold and a Community
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Ceremonies at the Thresholds of Life
제 1 장 · Week 1: What a Ceremony Is
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Community Before God at a Threshold
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Logic of an Order of Service
  3. Lecture 1-3: Choosing and Writing Words
  4. Lecture 1-4: Room, Time, Music, Cameras and the Officiant's Place
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Order on One Page
제 2 장 · Week 2: The Wedding
  1. Lecture 2-1: Order and Vows
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Wedding Address
  3. Lecture 2-3: Meeting the Couple Before the Day
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Day Itself
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Vows and Questions
제 3 장 · Week 3: Baptism, Dedication and Membership
  1. Lecture 3-1: Order, Words and Water
  2. Lecture 3-2: Babies, Children and Adults
  3. Lecture 3-3: Traditions That Differ
  4. Lecture 3-4: After the Water: Welcome and Follow-Up
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Baptism or Dedication on One Page
제 4 장 · Week 4: The Funeral and Memorial Service
  1. Lecture 4-1: From the Death to the First Visit
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Order of a Funeral or Memorial Service
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Address and the Prayers
  4. Lecture 4-4: Customs, Ancestor Rites, Burial and Cremation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The First Visit and the Order
제 5 장 · Week 5: The Hard Places
  1. Lecture 5-1: Remarriage and Marriages Across Cultures and Faiths
  2. Lecture 5-2: Requests the Officiant's Community Does Not Settle
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hard Funerals
  4. Lecture 5-4: Divided Families and Mixed Crowds
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Answering a Hard Request
제 6 장 · Week 6: Care Before and After; Ethics
  1. Lecture 6-1: Fees, Gifts and Transparency
  2. Lecture 6-2: Records, Certificates and Privacy
  3. Lecture 6-3: Care After the Ceremony
  4. Lecture 6-4: Limits, Rest and Saying No
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Three Months of Ceremonies

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

25분

Some requests arrive at a place where the officiant's community has not reached one answer. In some cases the community has an answer, but the officiant does not hold it. In some cases the community has left the question to local judgment, and the officiant must decide. The clearest example today is a request from two people of the same sex for a wedding or a blessing. This lecture uses that request as its main case, because it is a case in which communities hold very different positions, in which people on every side are sincere, and in which the person asking is often braced for a hurt.

This lecture is not an argument about whether such a ceremony is right. It takes no position, and it will not give you one. The question belongs to your community, to its teaching, to its authorities and to your own conscience before God. What this lecture teaches is something narrower and more practical: how an officiant answers responsibly when the request is one the community does not settle, or settles in a way the officiant finds hard. The answer has the same shape as the answer in lecture 5-1. Know the rule. Say it honestly. Treat the person with dignity. Use no judging words. Offer a referral. Keep confidence.

A few terms. A blessing here means a prayer said over a person or a couple that does not itself create a marriage. A wedding means a ceremony in which the couple make marriage vows. Communities may use these words differently, and the law of the place may do the same. Conscience means the officiant's own settled sense, before God, of what they may and may not do.

이 25분으로 얻는 것

  • Describe the range of denominational positions on requests for a same-sex wedding or blessing without taking one as the answer.
  • State the five duties an officiant owes the person asking, whatever the community's position.
  • Explain why confidentiality matters more than usual in this kind of request.
  • Say an honest decline, or an honest yes, in plain words with no judging language.
  • Identify the phrases and habits that turn a pastoral conversation into a wound.

He has shown you, O man, what is good. What does Yahweh require of you, but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?" — Micah 6:8

World English Bible

So then, let us follow after things which make for peace, and things by which we may build one another up." — Romans 14:19

WEB

Neither verse settles the question of the request. They are here because they describe what a fair-minded officiant owes the person in front of them whichever way the community decides: justice, mercy, humility, and a search for what builds up. Some who read this will find those words a comfort. Others will find them too small for the weight they carry. Both reactions are honest, and the lecture asks you to hold them in the room together.

1. Why this case is taught

The course teaches this case for a practical reason. An officiant who has never thought about it before the day will usually answer in the first thirty seconds, and the first thirty seconds will set the tone for everything that follows. People who have asked and been wounded remember, sometimes for decades, a single phrase.

It also matters for a second reason. The officiant is not asked to adopt a position here. The officiant is asked to behave in a certain way inside whatever position they hold. A reader who holds a firm view that such ceremonies cannot be held by their community can do this well. A reader who holds the opposite view can do this well. A reader who has not yet made up their mind can do this too. The skills are the same.

2. The range of positions

This is a point where readers will not agree. Several positions exist among Christian communities today, and each is held by people who take Scripture, tradition and seriously.

  • Communities that permit and celebrate same-sex weddings. They hold that the gospel's welcome and the Church's blessing of faithful, lifelong commitment belong to couples of the same sex as to others, that they read the relevant passages in their historical and literary setting and give weight to the witness of faithful couples, and that to refuse is to withhold a blessing from people who seek God. They hold that the exclusion of such couples has done real harm.
  • Communities that do not permit it. They hold that marriage, as their tradition has received it from Scripture and from the long practice of the Church, is the union of a man and a woman, and that an officiant cannot honestly pronounce a rite that their community understands to mean something different from what the couple intend. They hold that their position is not a rejection of any person, that they are bound to the teaching they have received, and that the same love that welcomes a person also tells the truth as the community understands it.
  • Communities that offer a blessing but not a wedding. They distinguish between a prayer for two people and the act of marrying them, and offer the first in a form their authorities have approved.
  • Communities that leave it to the local congregation or to the officiant's conscience. They do not issue a single rule, and each parish, assembly or minister decides. The officiant in such a community carries a weight no rule can lift.
  • Communities that offer pastoral care and welcome but no ceremony. A person may sit in worship, be prayed for, receive care and serve, but the community does not hold a ceremony for the couple.

Beyond these, there is variety within each family of communities, and some communities are in the middle of the discussion and have not decided. The positions are held for reasons of Scripture, of tradition, of experience and of conscience; and in many places also by law, which differs greatly. In some places a same-sex marriage is legal and a religious body may or may not be free to decline it; in some places it is not legal; in some places a person who asks is at risk of harm. Check locally: what the law allows, what the community allows, and what is safe.

What this course requires is less than any of these positions require. It does not ask you to change your community's rule. It does not ask you to defend or attack any position. It asks that you not present your position, or the position that differs from yours, as the only one a faithful Christian could hold. It asks that you answer within your community's rules and your conscience, and that you do so in the way described below.

3. Five duties, whatever the answer

An officiant owes five things to a person who makes a request of this kind, whether the answer is yes, no or "not from me."

1. Dignity. The person is a person before they are a question. Greet them as you would greet anyone who has come with a serious request. Do not look away, do not lower your voice as if embarrassed, do not change the subject. Use the names they use for themselves and for each other.

2. No judging words. This is the duty that is most often broken, and it is easy to break without meaning to. Do not use words such as sin, sinful, disordered, abomination, unnatural, lifestyle, choice or agenda of the person or of their relationship. Do not say I love you but. Do not say hate the sin. Do not tell the person that they will be prayed for to change. Equally, do not use words of dismissal for people whose view differs from yours (the insulting labels that people use for each other in public quarrels). A fair officiant keeps the same discipline in both directions. If your community teaches something, you may say plainly what the community teaches, as a statement about the community, not as a verdict on the person.

3. Honesty. If you cannot or will not do what they ask, say so, and say why in the words of your community's rule or your conscience. Do not hide behind a scheduling problem, a vague "it's not a good time," or a promise to think about it that you have already decided not to keep. People can bear a clear no more easily than a long silence. If your answer is yes, say that as plainly, and also say whatever limits there are: what your community will recognise, what the law will recognise, what the ceremony can and cannot be called.

4. Referral. If you cannot help, help the person find someone who can, if they wish. A referral is not a way of getting rid of someone. It is a practical act of care: a name, a place, a time. Ask your colleague before you give their name. If you do not know anyone, say so, and offer to find out.

5. Confidence. What you are told in the meeting is told to you, not to your congregation, your leaders, the person's family or your colleagues, except where a person is in danger or a child is at risk, and then only to the right authority. This duty matters more here than in most cases. In some places, a person whose relationship becomes known may lose a home, a job or a family, or may face danger. A leader who tells "to help" may cause that harm. A person who comes to ask may be telling you something they have told no one else. Do not pass it on, do not hint, and do not let a conversation in the corridor become a rumour.

Five words: dignity, no judgement, honesty, referral, confidence. Keep them on a card if you need to.

4. What these duties do not require

They do not require you to perform a ceremony your community does not recognise. They do not require you to hide what you or your community believe. They do not require you to agree. They do not forbid a respectful statement of what your community teaches and why. They also do not permit you to perform a ceremony your community's authorities have forbidden, because you personally think the rule is wrong. If you are in that position, the honest course is to say so to the right person in your community, not to act alone. And if you are in the opposite position, and your community permits what your conscience will not do, you may be able to decline and refer, or you may be bound to follow the community's decision, depending on how your community understands the office. Know which of those you are, before the day. An officiant who has not thought it through will be pushed into an answer by the shortest conversation.

5. Words that wound, and words that serve

Here is a short list in two columns, drawn from the kinds of replies people often report receiving. Do not use the left column.

Wounds Serves
"We can't help people like you." "Our community does not hold this ceremony, and I wanted to tell you that plainly."
"I'll pray that you see the truth." "I'm glad you asked me. May I pray for you both as you are?" (if you can say it honestly)
"It's not me, it's the church." "That is the rule of my community, and I hold to it. I am not saying it to hurt you."
"I need to think about it." (and then no answer) "I need until Friday to speak to my overseer. I will call you on Friday whatever the answer."
"Does your family know?" "I'll keep what you tell me private. Is there anything you would like me not to share, even with a colleague?"

Notice that the right-hand column is not more permissive than the left. A person can decline and still serve. A person can say yes and still wound, for example by treating the couple as a case or a cause.

6. Someone else asks

Sometimes the person asking is not one of the couple. A parent asks: My daughter wants a blessing. Is it allowed? What should I do? A friend asks on behalf of someone who is afraid to come. A member of the congregation asks what the church's position is, and is really asking whether they themselves can stay. In each case, the same duties apply, and the matter of confidence is even sharper. Never promise a third party that you will tell them how the conversation went. Never invite one of the couple to an interview because a relative asked you to. If the person who asks is afraid, give them your honest answer about what the community teaches and offer them a conversation of their own.

7. An invented conversation

(an invented example) Two women, Elena and Rue, come to a pastor in a community that does not hold same-sex weddings but permits a private pastoral prayer. The pastor has prepared for this.

Pastor: Thank you for coming to see me. I want to start by saying that I'm glad you asked, and that whatever I say, I will not repeat this conversation to anyone without your permission.

Elena: Thank you. We want to be married in church. We have been together for several years. We want to do it with God, not just at a registry.

Pastor: I hear that. I want to be honest with you. In our community, we do not hold a wedding for two women. That is the rule that my community holds and that I hold to. I'm not telling you this as a judgment on you or your relationship. I'm telling you because you deserve a clear answer and not a long silence.

Rue: Is there anything you can do?

Pastor: There is. I can offer you a private prayer, if you wish, where we ask God's care for your life together. It is not a wedding and I will not call it one. There are also communities nearby that do hold such services, and I know a colleague who would welcome you. I can ask her whether she would be willing to speak with you, and I will do nothing until you tell me you want that.

Elena: We would like to think about it.

Pastor: Of course. You are welcome here, whatever you decide. I'm sorry that my answer is not the one you hoped for.

The pastor does not pretend the community has a different rule. She does not use a judging word. She says what she can offer and does not oversell it. She does not push. She does not say who she would tell. In the same position, an officiant in a community that celebrates such weddings would say a different yes, with the same manner: honest about what the ceremony is, careful about what the law will recognise, careful about who is told.

8. When you are not sure what you think

An officiant may reach this lecture and find that they have no settled view. Their community may be silent, or divided, or in the middle of a long conversation. That is not a failure. It is, for many people, the honest condition of the question. If you are in it, three things help.

First, say so, in your own words, to the person asking, if it is true and if it serves them. "I don't know yet what our community will do. I will find out, and I will tell you." Second, ask the people in your community who carry responsibility for the question, and do not decide alone what the community should do. Third, do not hurry an answer to ease your own discomfort. The person asking may have waited years to ask. A week's honest delay will not hurt them as much as a hasty reply you have to take back.

9. A short invented text, where a blessing is offered

(an invented text, not from any service book)

God of mercy, you know these two people and you know their lives. We ask you to be with them, to keep them honest and kind with each other, and to hold them in your care. Amen.

This text does not claim to be a wedding. It does not say what the community teaches about marriage. It asks for God's presence, honesty and kindness. A community that offers a blessing will usually have its own approved wording and may require that it be used; if it does, use it. This is only an example of the plain, short manner a blessing can have.


Diagram 1. Answering a request your community does not settle

ANSWERING A REQUEST YOUR COMMUNITY DOES NOT SETTLE Lecture 5-2 -- five duties, whatever the answer Dignity Greet the person as you would anyone with a serious request. Use the names they use. No judging words Say what your community teaches as a statement about the community, never as a verdict on a person. Honesty Yes, no or not from me, said plainly, with the limits of what the community and the law will recognise. Referral Ask a colleague first, then give a name, a place and a time. Offer to find someone if you do not know one. Confidence What you were told stays with you, except where a person is in danger or a child is at risk. Do not Act against your community's rule alone. Hurry an answer. Promise a third party a report on the talk.

핵심 요약

  • Communities hold very different positions on a same-sex wedding or blessing. This course takes none of them as the answer.
  • The officiant answers within the community's rules and their own conscience, and owes the person five things: dignity, no judging words, honesty, referral and confidence.
  • Judging words fail in both directions. Say what your community teaches as a statement about the community, never as a verdict on a person.
  • A clear honest answer, even a no, serves a person better than a long silence or a vague delay.
  • Confidence matters more here than usual, because exposure can cost a person their home, work, family or safety.
  • Do not act against your community's rule alone, and do not decide by haste. Find out who in your community holds the question.
Front Back
Does this course say which position is right? No. It requires only that you answer within your community's rules and conscience and treat the person well.
The five duties Dignity; no judging words; honesty; referral; confidence.
Why is confidence stressed? A person whose relationship is made known may lose a home, work, family or safety.
A fair way to state your community's teaching As a statement about the community ("our community teaches X"), not as a verdict on the person.

One sentence to remember Whatever your community decides, the person in front of you is owed dignity, honesty, a way forward and silence about what they told you.

This week's action Write the one plain sentence you would use to say what your community does and does not do for this request, with no judging word in it.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Which of the five duties would be hardest for you to keep in a real conversation? Why?
  • Can you state a position you do not hold in a form its own members would recognise? Try with one of the positions in this lecture.
  • What is the difference between saying what your community teaches and passing a verdict on a person?
  • Why does confidence matter more in this kind of request than in many others?
  • If your community leaves the answer to the officiant's conscience, what would you want in place before the first request came?
  • A relative asks you what a couple said to you. What do you say, and what do you do next?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.