Lecture 2-2: Calling, Trying Out and Saying No
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Planning Worship Is, and Is Not
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Gathering
- Lecture 1-3: Shapes of a Service
- Lecture 1-4: Welcome, Transitions and Silence
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Read One Service
- Lecture 2-1: Who Serves
- Lecture 2-2: Calling, Trying Out and Saying No
- Lecture 2-3: Training, Rotas and Rest
- Lecture 2-4: Rehearsal and the Week Before Sunday
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Team
- Lecture 3-1: Choosing Songs
- Lecture 3-2: The Congregation's Voice
- Lecture 3-3: Leading Without Performing
- Lecture 3-4: Permission to Use Music
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Month of Songs
- Lecture 4-1: Where Traditions Differ on Art
- Lecture 4-2: Seeing, Moving, Reading Aloud
- Lecture 4-3: The Room
- Lecture 4-4: Worship Everyone Can Join
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Walk the Room
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Words and Sound
- Lecture 5-2: Recording and Streaming
- Lecture 5-3: Those Who Join Online
- Lecture 5-4: Testing a Tool
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Slide, One Broadcast
Every team has a door, and every door has a way through it. In some communities the door is a quiet question after the service: "Would you read next month?" In others it is a list on the notice board. In others it is a book that says who reads, who sings and who carries the candles. In others a young person simply starts to turn up and is never told to leave.
How a person comes to serve shapes what the team becomes. A door that is hard to find leaves the team small and tired. A door that opens only after a public test leaves out people whose gift is real and whose nerves are not. A door that cannot be closed from the inside leaves people serving who would have said no, had they been allowed.
This lecture asks how to invite, how to find out whether a person is ready, how to say no kindly in both directions, and how to write down who may serve. The aim is a team in which a person can say yes, not yet or no, and be treated the same way after each answer.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Describe four ways in which people come to serve, and one risk of each.
- Explain what an audition is for, what harm it can do, and name two alternatives.
- Give a person a "no" or a "not yet" about a role without judging them.
- State the disagreement about who may serve fairly, and say what a written policy must contain.
Moses said to the children of Israel, “Behold, Yahweh has called by name Bezalel the son of Uri, the son of Hur, of the tribe of Judah." — Exodus 35:30
World English Bible
He has filled him with the Spirit of God, in wisdom, in understanding, in knowledge, and in all kinds of workmanship;" — Exodus 35:31
WEB
He has put in his heart that he may teach, both he, and Oholiab, the son of Ahisamach, of the tribe of Dan." — Exodus 35:34
WEB
But it shall not be so among you, but whoever wants to become great among you shall be your servant." — Mark 10:43
WEB
Whoever of you wants to become first among you, shall be bondservant of all." — Mark 10:44
WEB
For the Son of Man also came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”" — Mark 10:45
WEB
In Exodus the craftsman is called by name, and the text adds that God put it in his heart to teach. The is not only to make; it is also to pass on. In Mark, Jesus says that those who lead are not to lord it over others, and gives himself as the pattern. A team that chooses its servers needs both passages.
1. Four ways in
Most people come to serve by one of four roads. Each is common, and each has a risk.
They are asked. Someone notices a gift or a willingness and asks by name. This is the most natural road and often the best. Its risk is that the asking circle is small. A leader asks the people the leader already knows, and the quiet, the newer and the older are never asked.
They offer. A person comes forward: "I play the flute. Can I help?" Its risk is that the team has no way to answer except yes or a hurtful no. A team that has nothing prepared for an offer will say "we will think about it" and then say nothing for six months.
They are assigned. In some communities a role is given by a book, an office, a rota or a decision of a leader: the cantor is appointed, the readers are named, the servers take their turn. This is not cold or unspiritual. For many people, being sent is a form of being trusted, and it frees a person from needing to feel ready. Its risk is that the assignment is made with no conversation, and the person is placed in a role without being asked whether they can bear it.
They grow into it. A child holds the book for the reader. A teenager carries the cables. After five years, the child is reading and the teenager is running the sound. This is the oldest road, and the slowest. Its risk is that no one ever says "you may now be asked to do more", so the person remains for ever at the edge.
No community needs to use only one road. A sound practice is to keep all four open and to know which one a person came by.
2. How to invite well
The way of asking matters as much as whom to ask. A good invitation has four parts.
- It is made to a person, by name, and not as a general announcement. "We need readers" is a plea to nobody. "Could you read in the first week of next month?" is a question to somebody.
- It says exactly what is asked. Which role, which dates, how many hours, what training will be given.
- It names the freedom to say no. In plain words: "You may say no, and it will change nothing."
- It gives time. "Think about it and tell me next week" is a gift.
Compare (an invented example):
Before: "We are really short of musicians. Everyone has to do their bit, and I know you can play."
After: "I noticed you play the flute. Would you be willing to join us on the first Sunday of next month, just for one hymn, and see how it feels? Say no if you would rather not; there is no pressure. If you do come, I will sit with you at the rehearsal and show you the order."
The first version makes a refusal costly: the person is told everyone must, and told the speaker already knows the answer. The second version is the same request, with a way out.
3. The audition: its purpose and its harm
An audition is a test: a person sings or plays or reads before one or more listeners, who then decide whether the person may serve.
The strongest case for it is kind. The people who sing must be able to follow. A leader who cannot keep a tune or hold a pulse cannot be followed, and the people have to carry the leader as well as the song. A reader who cannot be heard is no help to anyone who needs to hear. An audition is a way of making sure that the road has been cleared before the people walk it. In many communities with a great repertoire or a trained choir, some form of listening is a long-accepted practice and is done with care. This course does not say they are wrong.
The risks are also real.
- Fear. Many people who could serve well cannot perform in front of a panel. They will not volunteer. The team loses them without knowing.
- A "no" is heard as a verdict on the person. The audition judged a minute of a person's playing, but the person heard "you do not belong."
- It measures the wrong thing. A person may be a good ensemble player and a poor soloist. A person may be a wonderful leader of a prayer who will never hold a note. The audition finds the thing it was set up to find.
- It places power in the hands of a few. Those who judge become, in effect, those who decide who is in the community.
- Public judging. If the "no" is announced, or even seen, others learn that a person failed.
So the question is not "audition or not?". It is "what do we need to know, and what is the gentlest way to find out?"
4. Gentler ways to find out
These alternatives can be used instead of an audition or beside one.
Shadowing. The new person sits beside the one who does the role, for several weeks, and learns. Nobody is tested. By the end both know whether it fits.
A trial service. The person serves in one named service, which everyone understands as a trial. Afterwards the person and the leader talk, using three open questions: How did it feel? What would help? Would you like to do it again? The trial may end in yes, not yet or no, and each is honoured.
Playing together in rehearsal. The new musician joins a rehearsal and plays with the others, without any suggestion that this is a test. What is needed is quickly learned by the whole group.
A listening conversation. Sometimes a short talk is enough. "What do you like to do? What worries you? What would you not want to do?"
Starting at the edge. A person serves first in the back, at the welcome, in the preparation. Over a season it becomes clear where else the person might help.
None of these needs a panel. All of them can be done in a small place with few people.
5. Saying yes, not yet and no
The words "no" and "not yet" will have to be said. A team that cannot say them does harm.
Here is a sound way to say no to a volunteer (an invented example):
"Thank you for offering to lead the songs. I have thought about it, and I do not think it fits this term. The people in this gathering are used to a single quiet voice, and a larger change would be hard for them just now. I would like you to join the singing group, and perhaps we can talk again in the spring about leading one song."
This reply is about the role and the moment. It names a reason. It offers a place. It leaves the door open. It does not say "your voice is not good enough", and it is not given in front of others.
And the freedom runs the other way. A person who has said yes may say, at any time, "I need to stop." A volunteer who is pressed by guilt is not giving a gift. A leader who hears this should say thank you and mean it. The person's yes was not a promise for life.
Last, there is the person who has served for years and can no longer do it: the voice has gone, the hands shake, the eyes cannot read the page. This is a hard conversation. The team should thank the person for what has been done, and offer a different place. If an can no longer sing, perhaps there is a prayer to be said, or the choosing of readings, or the teaching of a child. The road was never only for the people at the front.
6. Who may serve: a written policy
Every community has a rule about who may serve, spoken or unspoken. A rule that is never written is applied unevenly. The leader's friends are asked; the newer person is not; the one who disagreed with the leader last year is overlooked. The cure is to write the policy down.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some communities require that those who serve in certain roles be baptised, or confirmed, or professing members, or in good standing in the community. Their reason is that those who lead the people in worship should share the faith the people confess, and that the roles carry a trust that the community has a right to protect. Other communities invite anyone with a gift, whether or not the person belongs. Their reason is that the gift is God's, that a visitor's service is a welcome, and that a door that opens only to members can close the community upon itself. Still others distinguish between roles: leading prayer, reading Scripture and presiding may need membership, while setting up chairs, playing an instrument or running the sound may not. Each position is held for reasons that its people can state. This course does not choose among them. It requires only that whatever the rule is, it is written, it is applied the same way to every person, and no one's standing is discussed in public.
A useful policy is a single page. It says:
- which roles there are, and what is asked of a person for each (membership, baptism or confirmation, a period of attendance, a conversation with the leader, nothing);
- who decides, and how, and how long it takes;
- how a person may ask again after "not yet";
- where roles involve children or young people, what checks or conditions the local law and the community's own safeguarding rules require;
- how an appeal or a concern can be raised, and with whom.
A policy of this kind is not a barrier. It is a promise that the door is the same for everyone.
7. Fairness, and not lording it over others
Mark 10 is about power. The disciples had been arguing about who would be greatest. Jesus said that the rulers of the nations lord it over them, "but it shall not be so among you." The great one is the servant.
A team has small power: it decides who plays, who reads, who sits at the front. That power can become lordship in small ways. The same three people are always asked. The shy are not noticed. A new idea is dismissed because of who made it. A person who disagreed once is left off the rota without a word.
Three habits keep it honest. Ask the same questions of everyone. Write down why a decision was made, even if only one line, so that it can be looked at later. Let someone other than the leader hear a concern, so that a person who is hurt by the leader has somewhere to go.
None of this makes the team slow. It makes it a place where a person may risk offering, because the answer will be fair.
Diagram 1. An invitation, from asking to answer
Diagram 2. What a one-page policy on serving says
| Question | The policy must answer |
|---|---|
| What roles are there? | A list, with what is asked for each |
| Who decides? | A named person or group, and how long it takes |
| After "not yet"? | How and when a person may ask again |
| Children and young people? | The checks and conditions required by local law and community rules |
| A concern or appeal? | A person other than the leader who can hear it |
핵심 요약
- People come to serve by being asked, by offering, by being assigned or by growing into it; each road has its own risk.
- A good invitation is made by name, says exactly what is asked, names the freedom to say no, and gives time.
- An audition is meant to protect the people's singing and hearing, but it can frighten, wound and exclude; gentler ways to find out exist.
- A no or a not yet speaks of the role and the moment, never of the person, and is never made public.
- Communities differ on who may serve: members only, anyone with a gift, or a split by role. All need a written policy applied the same way to everyone.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four ways in | Asked, offering, assigned, growing into it. |
| A good invitation | By name; says what is asked; names the freedom to refuse; gives time. |
| Alternatives to an audition | Shadowing, a trial service, playing together, a listening conversation, starting at the edge. |
| A written policy on serving | Roles; who decides; how to ask again; conditions for children's work; a place to raise a concern. |
One sentence to remember A team is fair when a person can say yes, not yet or no, and is treated with the same respect after each.
This week's action Write one invitation to a role in your gathering, in two or three sentences, that names the role, the dates and the freedom to say no.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- By which of the four roads did you come to any role you hold? What was good or poor about that road?
- Rewrite one invitation you have heard or given so that it names the role, the time and the freedom to refuse.
- If your community uses an audition, which of the five harms does it guard against? If it does not, how does it find out whether a person is ready?
- Think of one person who might be told "not yet". What reason about the role, not the person, could be given?
- Is the rule about who may serve in your community written down? If not, what would be the first line?