Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Hand Over, Help, or Keep
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What the Word "AI" Points To
- Lecture 1-2: How a Language Model Makes Words
- Lecture 1-3: Sounding Right Is Not Knowing
- Lecture 1-4: Reading a Conversation Closely
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Read an AI Answer
- Lecture 2-1: Invented Facts
- Lecture 2-2: Old Knowledge, Missing Sources, Uneven Coverage
- Lecture 2-3: Scripture and Theology, Where to Be Most Careful
- Lecture 2-4: Building a Checking Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Find the Errors
- Lecture 3-1: Asking Well
- Lecture 3-2: Checking What You Are Given
- Lecture 3-3: What Must Never Be Typed In
- Lecture 3-4: Keeping Notes and Giving Credit
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Mend the Prompts, Mark the Secrets
- Lecture 4-1: Hand It Over, Help With It, Keep It
- Lecture 4-2: Office Work and Communication
- Lecture 4-3: Teaching and Study Materials
- Lecture 4-4: Where Teachers and Leaders Draw the Line
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Hand Over, Help, or Keep
- Lecture 5-1: Preaching and AI: A Theological Question
- Lecture 5-2: Care and Counselling
- Lecture 5-3: When Members and Young People Use AI
- Lecture 5-4: The Minister's Own Life
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Judge the Scene, Write a Position Paragraph
This is the fourth Practice Lab. Like the others, it asks you to do something rather than to agree with something.
Today's task is to sort six invented tasks into the three groups of lecture 4-1 (hand over, help with, keep), using the five questions, and to say what you would check in each. There is no tool to open. There is no account to hold. Everything you need is printed below.
The lab can be done in three ways, and all three are complete. Choose the one that fits your life. You do not need to teach, lead or hold any office to do this lab.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Apply the five questions to a task and place it in one of three groups.
- Name, for a task in the middle group, the one check that matters most.
- Explain why two honest people may sort the same task differently, and what they must still agree on.
- Explain how the lab is run, and the four promises of privacy that govern it.
Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22
World English Bible
The verse is about plans that fail without counsel and succeed with many advisers. The lab is a small act of taking counsel: you will compare your sorting with another person's, or with the reasons printed here.
1. What this lab is for
In lecture 4-1 you read the five questions. In 4-4 you read about where leaders draw their lines. This lab asks you to use them on cases that are not yours, so that you can feel where the questions help and where they do not. The goal is not to reach the one right answer. For some of the cases below, careful people will differ. The goal is a sorting you can defend with reasons.
2. The four promises
Say these before you begin, aloud if you are in a group, or silently if you are alone. They are part of the lab.
- Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no pass or fail on a sorting.
- You may pass on any part. If a step does not suit you, leave it and go on.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. If someone leads, they do the same work and are open to the same difficulty.
A rule for this lab: use no private information. The six cases below are invented, and you will not need to describe a real person, family, congregation, meeting or message. If a case reminds you of someone, do not write their name or any detail that could identify them. Think of the principle only. If you try the optional hands-on way described below, the same rule holds with full force.
If anything in this lab brings back something painful, or you realise that someone is being harmed or is in danger, stop. Speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person this week. If there is danger now, call your local emergency number first. A person who is in despair or in danger is not to be left to a tool, and not to you alone.
3. The six invented cases
Each is a task that a person in a ministry might consider giving to an AI system. All names and settings are invented.
Case A. (An invented example.) A youth leader wants ten ideas for a theme for a summer evening: titles, colours, games. She has no fixed plan. Nothing that comes out will be sent until she has chosen.
Case B. (An invented example.) A small church wants to send its monthly newsletter, written in English, to families who read another language. The newsletter contains the service times, a reminder of a Bible study, and a short paragraph describing what the church believes about baptism.
Case C. (An invented example.) A pastor must write to a family whose grandmother has died. He did not know her well. He is very tired and the funeral is on Saturday. He considers asking a tool to write the letter and signing it.
Case D. (An invented example.) A catechist has a one-page handout on the written by a theologian in a careful style. Her learners are new readers of the language. She asks for a plainer version. The tool gives this (the passage is invented):
Original (extract): "The one God exists eternally as Father, Son and Holy Spirit, each fully God, not three gods and not one person appearing in three ways."
Tool's plainer version (invented): "God is one God in three parts: the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. Each part is a piece of God, and together they make one God."
Case E. (An invented example.) A volunteer who answers the church's messaging inbox finds a message from a member who says that everything is hopeless and that no one would miss them. The volunteer is not trained for this and thinks of asking a tool what to write in reply.
Case F. (An invented example.) A parish administrator has to send a reminder to the hall-hire list that the hall will be closed for painting on three dates. She has the dates in her calendar. She wants a clear, polite message of about four sentences.
4. Before you begin
Have ready: the sorting sheet in the diagram below, copied by hand onto a sheet or reproduced on a blank page; a pencil; about forty minutes in a quiet place. Have your notes from lecture 4-1 (the three groups and the five questions).
5. The first way: in your own place
This way is for those who have a ministry, however small, where such tasks arise.
- Read the six cases once. Do not decide yet.
- Take case A. Put it through the five questions. Write a short answer to each in the columns of the sheet.
- Choose the group: hand over, help with, or keep. Write it in the last column.
- For a help with, write the one check that matters most. For a keep, write who does the task, and what a person would say.
- Do the same for cases B to F.
- Go back to one case you found hardest. Write one sentence on why it was hard, and what would change your answer.
6. The second way: the observer's way
This way is for those who do not lead or teach, and for anyone who would like to see the frame from outside. The six cases are your material, together with this short table of reasons. Read the table after you have sorted the cases yourself, not before.
| Case | One sorting that can be defended |
|---|---|
| A | Hand over. Small harm, easy to mend, nothing sent until chosen, no relationship. Even so, she reads the list before using it. |
| B | Help with. The translation needs a reader who knows both languages. The paragraph on baptism needs the most care: translated by a person, or checked against the church's own text. |
| C | Keep. The letter is the act of presence, and the cost of a tool's polished sentences is that no one came. A short plain note is better than a long one. |
| D | Help with, and the check fails. The tool's version teaches a mistake about the Trinity ("three parts"). A rewrite must be compared with the original, line by line, and with the church's own source. |
| E | Keep. This is not a task for a tool, nor for the volunteer alone. The volunteer should move at once toward a person responsible (a pastor or the person named in the church's policy), and if there is danger now, the local emergency number. |
| F | Help with, near hand over. The dates are checked against the calendar, and she reads the message before it goes. |
Now compare. Where did your sorting differ? For each difference, ask: which question did we answer differently? That is where the thinking lies.
You are not marking anyone. The cases are invented so that you can practise on something that cannot be hurt.
7. The third way: the partner's way
This way needs one trusted person. You do not need to share any personal story. Each of you takes a turn at each role.
Partner A is the asker. Partner B is the checker.
- Partner A reads case A aloud and gives a sorting with a one-sentence reason.
- Partner B asks one question only: "Which of the five questions decided it?"
- Partner A answers. They do not defend; they explain.
- Together decide: do you both agree? If not, what is the difference? Is it one of the five questions, or is it a matter of conscience?
- Swap roles for the next case. Continue to F.
Where you differ, do not argue. Name the question you answered differently. Often the difference is not in the answers but in how large the harm seems to each of you.
8. An optional hands-on way
You do not need an AI tool or any account to do this lab. If you already have access to a free tool and want to try, you may do the following with case F only, and with invented content. Give the tool the facts of case F in your own words, using invented dates. Read what it returns. Check each fact against what you gave. Note any detail it added that you did not give. Do not type in a real name, a real date from your own calendar for a real event, a message from a real person, or anything about a real congregation. If you are unsure whether something is private, leave it out. This way is not required, adds nothing to your mark (there is none), and is not better than the other three.
9. What usually happens
A few things come up almost every time this lab is run. None of them means you have done it badly.
"Everything went into help with." That is common, because most real tasks do. Look again for the one check that matters most, and ask whether you could carry it out.
"I could not decide on case B." It holds three tasks: times, a reminder and a doctrinal paragraph. Sort them separately. They may land in different groups.
"I kept case E for myself." Notice what the case says: a person who is not trained should not hold this alone. Keeping a task does not mean doing it single-handed. It means it goes to a person, and the right person.
"My partner sorted a case differently, and we both had good reasons." This is the most useful result of the lab. The five questions are not a machine. They are a way of finding out where the real disagreement lies.
10. Leader's note, for running this in a small group
Privacy comes first
Say the four promises aloud before anyone writes. Say them even if you said them last time. People write honestly only when they are sure of them.
Fill in your own sheet. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination. Sit down and write.
Plan about an hour. Five minutes for the promises and a welcome. Fifteen minutes in silence for the sheet. Fifteen minutes in pairs (the third way). Fifteen minutes together on the hardest case. Five minutes to close.
Do not collect the sheets. Do not ask anyone to read theirs aloud. Say, "If you would like to say your sorting, you may. If not, pass."
Do not ask for real examples. If someone begins to describe a real message, a real family or a real person in difficulty, gently stop them: "Let us keep to the invented cases. If you would like to speak about that, let us speak afterwards."
Treat case E with care. Read it once, soberly. Do not discuss methods or details of harm. Say clearly what the case is for: to decide who should be told, not what to say. Know in advance the name of the person responsible for such matters in your community, and the number of the local emergency service.
If something painful surfaces, do not rush on and do not try to deal with it yourself in the room. Say, "Thank you. Let us speak afterwards." Afterwards, help the person to a pastor, a priest or a safeguarding person. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
Diagram 1. The sorting sheet
Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises aloud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Kept to the invented cases and asked for no real examples | [ ] |
| Did not collect the sheets or ask anyone to read theirs | [ ] |
| Offered a real chance to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Handled case E soberly, with no discussion of methods | [ ] |
| Knew whom to send a person to if something painful surfaced | [ ] |
| Did not rank sortings that were defended with good reasons | [ ] |
핵심 요약
- The lab practises one skill: putting a task through the five questions and placing it in one of three groups.
- Six invented cases are printed. No tool or account is needed, and no private information may be used.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with a table of reasons, and the partner's way. An optional hands-on way uses invented content only.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- Careful people may sort a case differently. The useful question is which of the five questions was answered differently.
- A task that concerns a person in despair or danger goes to a person, and the right one, and never to a tool.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Sorting tasks into hand over, help with, keep, using the five questions. |
| The three ways | In your own place; the observer's way with a table of reasons; the partner's way. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| If a partner sorts differently | Name the question you answered differently. |
One sentence to remember The five questions do not give the answer; they show where the real disagreement is.
This week's action Sort one real task from your own week on paper, using the five questions, and write the one check that matters most. Do not write any name.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What was it like to sort the cases? Answer with a feeling or an observation, not with a case.
- Which of the five questions did you find hardest to answer?
- Which case did you sort most quickly? Was the speed a good sign?
- If you used the partner's way: what did your partner notice that you did not?
- If you used the observer's way: where did your sorting differ from the table, and what does that show?