Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Judge the Scene, Write a Position Paragraph
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What the Word "AI" Points To
- Lecture 1-2: How a Language Model Makes Words
- Lecture 1-3: Sounding Right Is Not Knowing
- Lecture 1-4: Reading a Conversation Closely
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Read an AI Answer
- Lecture 2-1: Invented Facts
- Lecture 2-2: Old Knowledge, Missing Sources, Uneven Coverage
- Lecture 2-3: Scripture and Theology, Where to Be Most Careful
- Lecture 2-4: Building a Checking Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Find the Errors
- Lecture 3-1: Asking Well
- Lecture 3-2: Checking What You Are Given
- Lecture 3-3: What Must Never Be Typed In
- Lecture 3-4: Keeping Notes and Giving Credit
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Mend the Prompts, Mark the Secrets
- Lecture 4-1: Hand It Over, Help With It, Keep It
- Lecture 4-2: Office Work and Communication
- Lecture 4-3: Teaching and Study Materials
- Lecture 4-4: Where Teachers and Leaders Draw the Line
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Hand Over, Help, or Keep
- Lecture 5-1: Preaching and AI: A Theological Question
- Lecture 5-2: Care and Counselling
- Lecture 5-3: When Members and Young People Use AI
- Lecture 5-4: The Minister's Own Life
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Judge the Scene, Write a Position Paragraph
This is the fifth Practice Lab. The task has two small parts. First, read four invented scenes from preaching and care and judge each one: what may be handed over, what may be helped with, what must be kept in human hands, and what must move to a person. Second, write one short position paragraph that says where you stand in your own place.
You do not need an AI tool, a paid account, or any account at all. The scenes are printed here, and one contains an invented AI conversation that you read like a page of a book. Nothing in this lab asks you to type anything into any service. If you already have access to one and wish to use it, the third way into the lab says how, with the same ban on private information.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Apply the questions of this week to a scene: who is affected, what could go wrong, can it be checked, can it be disclosed, and who stays responsible.
- Sort a use into hand over, help with, keep, or move to a person.
- Recognise a scene in which no tool should be used at all, and say what to do instead.
- Write a short position paragraph that states a use, a limit, a check and a disclosure.
- Explain the four promises of privacy that govern this lab.
Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21
World English Bible
One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13
WEB
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
The first verse gives the method of the whole course. The second guards what must not be spread. The third is the reason the work is worth doing carefully: people carry burdens, and a minister is among those who help to bear them.
1. What the lab is for
You have spent a week on three matters: how far a tool belongs in preaching, how care stays between persons, and how to meet members and young people who use these systems. This lab asks you to use that learning on cases. A case is always harder than a principle, because it has particulars. That is the reason for practising it here, where nothing is at stake.
The lab does not look for the right answer. Where traditions differ on how far AI belongs in preaching, counselling or worship, the scenes are written to be judged by the common minimum of this course and not by one tradition's rule. The common minimum is do not deceive, keep confidences, and a person stays responsible. Your own tradition may ask for more, and you may say so in your paragraph.
2. The four promises
Read these before you begin. They hold for this lab and every lab in the course.
- Nobody reads what you write. The form is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. No one checks whether you were right.
- You may pass on any part. If you would rather not do a scene or a section, pass.
- The leader fills in a form too. A leader is learning alongside you.
Two further rules. Write on the form no name of a real person, congregation, company or service. And write no private information about anyone, including yourself: no names, contacts, health, family trouble, money or anything that identifies a person. If this lab brings back something that hurts or is harmful, such as abuse, violence, or a danger now, stop the lab. Speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number. The lab can wait.
3. Three ways into the lab
1. In your own place. If you preach, teach, lead or care for people, think of a kind of situation you meet and make a scene of it. Do not use a real event, a real name or anything you were told in confidence. Make it an invented example, then judge it with the form. Do this on paper, with no tool. If you already have free access to an AI service and you wish to see how it behaves, use only a general question that mentions no person and no private matter, never anything you know through care or confession, and read the result with the checks of this course. You are not asked to do this and nothing in the lab depends on it.
2. The observer's way. Use the four invented scenes printed below. This needs no one else and no tool.
3. The partner's way. Find a trusted partner and take roles in turn: the asker reads a scene aloud and gives a first judgement; the answerer says where they would draw the line and why; the checker looks at the form (below) and asks, "Who stays responsible? Could it be disclosed? What would you check?" Change roles after each scene. No personal story is needed, and none should be told that you would not want repeated.
4. The four invented scenes
(Invented examples. No real person, church or company is meant.)
Scene A: The background note. A is preparing a Bible study on a passage from one of the letters. He asks a chat assistant for "background on the city and its customs." The answer includes a date, a custom and a short quotation attributed to an early Christian writer, all stated calmly. He plans to read the quotation to the group as a historical witness.
Scene B: The word for the week. A member of a small assembly shows her leader a printout. She had asked a chat assistant whether she should accept a new job far away. This is the invented conversation.
(Invented AI conversation.) Member: I have prayed about a job in another town. What does God want me to do? Assistant: God is leading you to take this step. The door is open and you should go with confidence. Trust the peace you feel.
She asks the leader: "Is this a word from the Lord?"
Scene C: The whole homily. A lay preacher, short of time, asks an assistant to write the whole homily for Sunday on the passage assigned for the day. It comes back in good order. He plans to read it as written. His community expects its preachers to write their own sermons, and he does not intend to mention how it was made.
Scene D: The message in the youth group. A youth leader is told by another leader that a teenager in the group has written, in a message to a friend, "I don't want to be here any more." The leader wonders about asking a chat assistant what such a sentence usually means and how to answer.
Do not read ahead to the notes under the sub-heading "After you have finished, compare." Make your own judgement first.
5. How to do it
Six steps
Step 1. Read the four promises. Say them aloud if you are with others.
Step 2. Copy the form. The form is in the first diagram below. Copy it onto paper by hand.
Step 3. Take a scene and ask the five questions. Who is affected? What could go wrong? Can it be checked? Could it be said openly to the people involved? Who stays responsible?
Step 4. Choose one mark for the scene: Hand over (a tool may do the task and you check the result), Help with (you do the work and use a tool for a part), Keep (a person does it from start to finish), or Move to a person (no tool at all, and someone must be reached now).
Step 5. Fill in the reason, the check and the disclosure. One line each.
Step 6. Write the position paragraph. Four to six sentences. Use the frame on the form.
6. What usually goes wrong
"I wanted to say the scene is simply wrong." Many of the scenes contain more than one problem. Choose the most serious and say why, and then you may mention a second.
"My answer depends on my tradition." It may. That is fine, and you can say so. The task is to say what the common minimum already requires, and then, if you wish, what your own tradition would add.
"I have no position." A position can be uncertain. "I would use it for this, I am not sure about that, and I will ask my teacher" is a position.
"I wanted to ask the tool what it thought." Do not. The point of the lab is that you judge, and that you stay the person responsible.
7. Setting a difference of tradition apart
Scene C touches a place where readers will not agree. A tradition that reads an approved or shared homily may see nothing wrong with the lay preacher reading words written by another, though it would still ask him to be honest about the source and to check the text. A tradition that expects each preacher to write his or her own may see the problem at once. A tradition that preaches without a script may see the whole plan as strange.
Do not decide which is right. Write what each tradition would say, then write what the common minimum requires: he must not deceive the hearers about whose words these are, every quotation and verse must be checked, and he answers for what is said.
8. After you have finished, compare
When you have finished all four scenes, compare your marks with the notes below. They are one reader's judgement, not an answer key. A different reader may place a mark differently and still be right.
Scene A. Help with. The deacon may use the answer as a lead, but he cannot read an unchecked date, custom or quotation to the group as history. He should find the quotation in the writer's own work or leave it out, and check the date and custom in a source his community trusts. He answers for what he reads aloud.
Scene B. Keep, and test. The reply is not a word from the Lord. It continues language the way such replies usually go, it does not know the member, and it was never in the place of prayer. The leader can say so kindly, and ask her what she has prayed, what she has weighed, and who knows her well. The decision belongs to her with God and with people who know her. The leader should not claim to know what God wants either; the leader's task is to help her test and to sit with her.
Scene C. Not as planned. Even in a tradition where another person's text is normal, the plan to read it unchecked and to say nothing is a problem. He may use the draft as a lead, read the passage himself, rebuild the homily in his own words, check every verse and quotation, and be honest with his community about what he did, in the way its custom allows.
Scene D. Move to a person. No tool. The leader speaks to the teenager soon, kindly and directly, asks plainly how he is, and tells the person responsible under the community's written rules. If there is any sign of danger now, call the local emergency number. The leader does not ask a tool what the words mean and does not type the teenager's words into any service.
9. Leader's note, for running this in a group
Privacy first, and the leader writes too
Say the four promises aloud first. Do it even if you said them last week.
Fill in your own form. Sit and work as the others do. Do not stand over them.
Do not require anyone to use a tool. The lab works with paper and conversation. If some members have access and some do not, do not let it divide the room.
Read the scenes as they are written. Do not add real names, real congregations or real events. If a story from someone's own life begins to come out, thank them and keep to the invented scene.
Hold the minimum, not a side. If members begin to argue which tradition is right about preaching, say that the lab asks only for the common minimum and for each person to name what their own tradition would add.
Take Scene D slowly. It may touch someone's own pain. Allow anyone to pass. Do not discuss real cases in the group.
If anything said in the room points to a person who is in danger now, or to a child who is being harmed, stop the lab at once. Stay with the person, involve the person named in your community's written rules, and call the local emergency number if there is danger now. After the lab, speak privately with anyone who was distressed.
Diagram 1. The form: My Judgement Sheet
Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises aloud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own form alongside the group | [ ] |
| Required no tool and no account from anyone | [ ] |
| Kept to invented scenes and used no real names | [ ] |
| Held the common minimum and did not argue which tradition is right | [ ] |
| Took Scene D slowly, allowed anyone to pass, and had the emergency number and the responsible person's name to hand | [ ] |
| Spoke privately with anyone who was distressed | [ ] |
핵심 요약
- The lab practises judging a scene: who is affected, what could go wrong, whether it can be checked and disclosed, and who stays responsible.
- Four marks: hand over, help with, keep, or move to a person. Scene D shows that some cases need no tool at all.
- The lab never requires an AI tool, an account or a payment. Nothing private is written or typed.
- Where traditions differ, state the common minimum: do not deceive, keep confidences, a person stays responsible.
- A position paragraph states a use, a limit, a check and a disclosure.
- Four promises: nobody reads the form, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader fills in a form too.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four marks | Hand over; help with; keep; move to a person. |
| The five questions | Who is affected; what could go wrong; can it be checked; can it be disclosed; who stays responsible. |
| The common minimum | Do not deceive, keep confidences, a person stays responsible. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a form too. |
One sentence to remember Judge the scene by who is affected and who stays responsible, and when a person may be in danger, no tool is used at all.
This week's action Write your position paragraph on paper and keep it. Read it again in a month and see whether it still says what you mean.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which scene was hardest to judge? Answer with what made it hard, not with a personal story.
- In which scene did you want to say "it depends"? On what?
- What does "Keep" mean in your own place? Name a kind of task, not a person.
- In Scene B, what could the leader say that is honest, kind and does not claim to know God's will?
- If you wish to share a line from your position paragraph, do so. If not, pass.
- What is one habit from this week that you will start or stop?