Lecture 4-3: Paul and the Law — The New Perspective on Paul
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Vocabulary of Salvation
- Lecture 1-2: History of the Doctrine, Part One — Pelagius, Augustine, and Orange
- Lecture 1-3: History of the Doctrine, Part Two — the Reformation, Trent, and Dort
- Lecture 1-4: History of the Doctrine, Part Three — Wesley, and Catholic and Orthodox Soteriology
- Lecture 1-5: The Ordo Salutis — Three Maps of the Same Journey
- Lecture 2-1: The General Call
- Lecture 2-2: The Effectual Call
- Lecture 2-3: Prevenient Grace
- Lecture 2-4: The Mechanics of Regeneration
- Lecture 2-5: Regeneration, the Word, and Its Evidence
- Lecture 3-1: The Double Structure of Conversion — Repentance and Faith
- Lecture 3-2: The Constituents of Saving Faith — Notitia, Assensus, Fiducia
- Lecture 3-3: The Object and Instrumental Nature of Faith
- Lecture 3-4: The Assurance of Faith
- Lecture 3-5: Union with Christ
- Lecture 4-1: Justification as Verdict, Not Renovation
- Lecture 4-2: The Great Exchange — Imputation
- Lecture 4-3: Paul and the Law — The New Perspective on Paul
- Lecture 4-4: Justification and Works — Paul and James
- Lecture 4-5: Adoption
- Lecture 5-1: Definitive and Progressive Sanctification
- Lecture 5-2: The Synergistic Structure of Sanctification
- Lecture 5-3: The Conflict of the Flesh and the Spirit
- Lecture 5-4: The Perseverance of the Saints and the Preservation of God
- Lecture 5-5: The Church's Hardest Warning Passages
- Lecture 6-1: Religious Pluralism and the Fate of the Unevangelized
- Lecture 6-2: The Therapeutic Reduction of Salvation in Secular and Consumer Culture
- Lecture 6-3: Individual and Social Dimensions of Salvation
- Lecture 6-4: Ecumenical Dialogue on Justification — the Joint Declaration
- Lecture 6-5: Soteriology in Preaching and Evangelism
For most of Protestant history, "works of the law" in Galatians and Romans was read as shorthand for legalism generally — the attempt to earn favor with God by moral achievement, of which the Judaizers Paul opposed were simply one first-century instance. Starting in the 1970s, a body of scholarship now generally called the New Perspective on Paul argued this reading rests on a mistaken picture of the Judaism Paul actually knew, and proposed instead that "works of the law" names something narrower and more historically specific: badges of Jewish ethnic identity, not a general theology of earning salvation by merit. This lecture states both readings' case from the actual text of Galatians and Romans, because — unusually for this course — this is a debate that runs within the Protestant scholarly tradition, not only between Protestant and Catholic, and serious, conservative evangelical scholars stand on both sides of it.
이 17분으로 얻는 것
- State E.P. Sanders's description of Second Temple Judaism as "covenantal nomism" and explain what work that phrase is doing against the older "Judaism as legalism" picture.
- Explain how N.T. Wright and James D.G. Dunn apply Sanders's historical claim to "works of the law" in Galatians and Romans, and identify at least one specific text each reading depends on.
- State at least two arguments the traditional Reformation reading (as defended by D.A. Carson and John Piper) brings against the New Perspective's account, from the actual wording of Galatians or Romans.
- Explain why this debate is not simply "New Perspective versus the Bible" — that serious, textually engaged scholarship exists on every side of it.
yet knowing that a man is not justified by the works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ, even we believed in Christ Jesus, that we might be justified by faith in Christ, and not by the works of the law, because no flesh will be justified by the works of the law." — Galatians 2:16
World English Bible
This single verse names "works of the law" (Greek erga nomou) three times in one sentence — an emphasis that shows how central the phrase is to Paul's actual argument in this letter, and it is the closest thing either side of this debate has to a shared starting point. Both readings agree the phrase is being excluded as a ground of . They disagree, sharply, about what the phrase actually names: a general principle of law-based , or a specific, historically located set of -boundary practices.
1. The setting: what provoked the New Perspective
E.P. Sanders's 1977 book Paul and Palestinian Judaism is the New Perspective's founding text, though Sanders himself did not fully anticipate everything later scholars built on it. Working through a large body of surviving Second Temple Jewish literature, Sanders argued that first-century Palestinian Judaism was not, as much older Protestant scholarship had assumed (often reading later rabbinic Judaism, or worse, medieval Catholic legalism, back into Paul's own context), a religion of earning God's favor through accumulated law-keeping. Instead, Sanders described its actual "pattern of religion" as covenantal nomism: God graciously chose and established a covenant with Israel first, prior to and apart from any merit; obedience to the law (nomos) was Israel's grateful response to a covenant already graciously in place — a badge and maintenance of covenant membership already given, not a means of earning entry into it in the first place. If Sanders is right about the historical picture, then a Judaism understood as crude legalism — the assumed backdrop against which the Reformers read Paul's polemic against "works of the law" — may simply not be the Judaism Paul actually confronted.
James D.G. Dunn, who coined the phrase "New Perspective on Paul" in a 1982 lecture, took Sanders's historical picture and asked what it should mean for : if Paul's opponents were not legalists in the medieval sense, what was Paul actually objecting to when he insisted no one is justified by "works of the law"? Dunn's answer: Paul's target is specifically the boundary markers separating Jew from Gentile — circumcision, food laws, and Sabbath observance chief among them — which some Jewish Christians in Galatia were requiring of Gentile converts as necessary badges of full covenant membership. On this reading, Galatians is not fundamentally a treatise against earning salvation by works in general; it is an argument that Gentiles do not need to become culturally and ritually Jewish (via these specific "works of the law") in order to belong fully to God's people in Christ.
N.T. Wright has developed a related but distinct version, emphasizing "righteousness of God" as covenant faithfulness (previewed in 4-2) and framing the whole doctrine of justification less as "how is an individual sinner saved" and more as "who belongs to the single, Jew-and-Gentile family God promised Abraham" — a shift Wright describes as recovering the doctrine's original covenantal and ecclesiological shape rather than reading it through the individualistic lens of Luther's own struggle with guilt before God, which Wright and others (following a suggestion first associated with Swedish scholar Krister Stendahl) argue may not be Paul's own primary concern at all.
2. The New Perspective's textual case
Advocates point to specific features of Galatians and Romans that they argue fit their reading better than the traditional one. In Galatians, the letter's occasion is transparently a dispute over circumcision (Galatians 5:2-6, 6:12-13) and, at Antioch, over Jewish and Gentile believers eating together (Galatians 2:11-14) — not a dispute over whether moral effort in general can save. Paul's charge against Peter at Antioch is not "you are trying to earn salvation by works" but that his withdrawal from table fellowship with Gentiles was "not walking uprightly according to the truth of the Good News" (Galatians 2:14) — a social and covenantal failure, they argue, more than a soteriological one. In Romans, advocates point to Romans 3:29-30's immediate move from "no flesh will be justified by works of the law" to "is God the God of Jews only? Is he not the God of Gentiles also?" — a Jew/Gentile inclusion argument, they say, standing right beside the works-of-the-law statement, suggesting the two are the same argument rather than two separate ones.
3. The traditional Reformation reading's textual case
D.A. Carson, together with Peter O'Brien and Mark Seifrid, edited the two-volume project Justification and Variegated Nomism (2001-2004) specifically to test Sanders's "covenantal nomism" thesis against the full range of surviving Second Temple texts — and the project's conclusion was that the actual literature is considerably more varied than a single uniform pattern; some texts read closer to Sanders's grace-first covenantal nomism, and others read closer to a real, meritorious self-righteousness the older reading assumed. If the literature itself is "variegated," they argue, no single historical picture can settle in advance what Paul must have meant.
On the text of Galatians and Romans themselves, John Piper and other defenders of the traditional reading press several points. First, Galatians 3:10's citation of Deuteronomy 27:26 — "cursed is everyone who doesn't continue in all things that are written in the book of the law, to do them" — is an argument from the impossibility of complete law-keeping, not from the wrongness of using boundary markers to exclude Gentiles; the curse falls on anyone who fails to keep the whole law, a scope broader than circumcision, food laws, and Sabbath alone. Second, Romans 4's argument that Abraham was justified by faith rather than works (developed further in 4-4) deliberately reaches back before the Mosaic law and circumcision were even given (Romans 4:9-12 makes the timing of Abraham's circumcision, after his faith was already reckoned as righteousness in Genesis 15:6, part of the argument), which suggests Paul's target is broader than Israel's specific boundary-marking laws — it is the very principle of establishing righteousness by one's own doing, of whatever kind, set against receiving it by faith. Third, Romans 4:4-5's language of "wages" owed to "him who works," contrasted with "him who doesn't work, but believes," reads most naturally, Carson and Piper argue, as a general principle about merit and grace, not a narrower statement limited to circumcision and food laws.
4. What is genuinely at stake, stated without a false resolution
If the New Perspective is substantially right, "works of the law" in Paul is a narrower, more historically specific category than classical Protestant exegesis assumed, and Galatians's central concern is less "how am I, an individual, right with God" than "on what terms do Jews and Gentiles belong together as God's one people" — a shift that does not deny individual justification by faith (every major New Perspective scholar affirms it) but relocates its center of gravity and connects it more explicitly to ecclesiology. If the traditional reading is substantially right, Paul's target includes but is not limited to boundary markers; he is also excluding any human doing, of whatever kind, as a ground of righteousness before God — which is the reading that underwrote 4-1's and 4-2's forensic, imputed doctrine of justification most directly. Both readings affirm salvation is by grace through faith and that no human work merits it; the genuine, unresolved dispute is how wide Paul's target actually is, and how much of classical Reformation soteriology's technical apparatus ( as Paul's own primary category, versus a broader emphasis on covenant inclusion) rests on getting that scope right.
Two readings of Paul
This is a point where readers will not agree. E.P. Sanders, James D.G. Dunn, and N.T. Wright's covenantal-nomism reading of "works of the law" stands against the traditional Reformation reading defended by D.A. Carson, John Piper, and the wider Justification and Variegated Nomism project. This course states the disagreement rather than resolving it, and asks readers to notice that both sides are doing careful exegesis of the same Greek text, not one side reading Scripture and the other reading it away.
5. Going to the Sources
Read Galatians 2:11-21 in full, in one sitting, before reading any secondary literature about it — notice for yourself whether Paul's argument with Peter reads to you as primarily about table fellowship and Jew/Gentile boundaries, or primarily about the principle of faith versus works in general, or (the position this lecture leaves open) inseparably both. Then, if you want each side's fullest case, read N.T. Wright's What Saint Paul Really Said (1997) for the New Perspective and John Piper's The Future of Justification: A Response to N.T. Wright (2007) for the traditional reading — the two were written substantially in direct conversation with each other.
핵심 요약
- Galatians 2:16 names "works of the law" three times. Both readings agree it is excluded as a ground of justification, but disagree about what it names.
- E.P. Sanders described Second Temple Judaism as "covenantal nomism" (God's covenant first, law-keeping as grateful response). James Dunn applied this: Paul targets boundary markers such as circumcision, food laws and Sabbath.
- N.T. Wright frames justification as being about who belongs to God's one Jew-and-Gentile family. The New Perspective cites Galatians 2:11-14 and Romans 3:29-30.
- D.A. Carson's Justification and Variegated Nomism project found the Jewish literature more varied than Sanders held. Carson and Piper cite Galatians 3:10, Romans 4:9-12 and Romans 4:4-5 for a broader target.
- Both readings affirm salvation by grace through faith, and no major New Perspective scholar denies justification by faith.
- The unresolved dispute is how wide Paul's target is. Serious, textually careful scholars, including conservative evangelicals, stand on both sides.
Topic: Two scholarly readings of "works of the law" in Paul, the New Perspective and the traditional Reformation view, and the texts each relies on.
Remember: Both sides agree justification is by grace through faith and not by merit. They disagree about whether "works of the law" means boundary markers or any human doing.
Caution: This is not "New Perspective versus the Bible." The lecture says careful exegesis of the same Greek text exists on every side, and it does not pick a winner.
One line to carry into ministry: Describe the other side's view in terms its own scholars would accept, remembering that both affirm grace through faith.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Read Galatians 2:11-14 again. Does Paul's rebuke of Peter read to you as being about earning salvation, about Jew/Gentile boundary markers, or does the text simply not force a choice between them? Defend your answer from the wording.
- E.P. Sanders's historical claim (that Second Temple Judaism was not crude legalism) and Paul's own theological argument (about what "works of the law" excludes) are technically two different questions. Why might someone accept Sanders's history but still side with Carson and Piper on the exegesis — or reject Sanders's history but still find Dunn and Wright's exegesis persuasive on other grounds?
- This lecture states that "every major New Perspective scholar affirms" justification by faith rather than works. Why does this shared affirmation matter for how a reader from a tradition suspicious of the New Perspective should describe it to others, even while disagreeing with it?