Lecture 4-2: Confession and Accountability
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Spiritual Discipline Is
- Lecture 1-2: Sabbath: The Gift of Stopping
- Lecture 1-3: Simplicity, Possessions and Time
- Lecture 1-4: Rest in a Busy Life
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: One Rest, One Letting Go
- Lecture 2-1: Meditation and Memory
- Lecture 2-2: Silence and Solitude
- Lecture 2-3: Journals, Reading and Study
- Lecture 2-4: Choosing Among Quiet Practices
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Five Minutes with a Verse
- Lecture 3-1: Fasting: Safety First
- Lecture 3-2: Other Fasts and Self-Control
- Lecture 3-3: Feasting and the Table
- Lecture 3-4: Fasting and the Neighbour
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Thing to Set Down
- Lecture 4-1: Worship, the Table and the Church Year
- Lecture 4-2: Confession and Accountability
- Lecture 4-3: Service, Hidden Giving and Hospitality
- Lecture 4-4: Practising Together Without Pressure
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Practice Partner
- Lecture 5-1: What a Rule of Life Is
- Lecture 5-2: How to Build One
- Lecture 5-3: Rules for Seasons
- Lecture 5-4: Rules in Real Lives
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A First Rule of Life
Of all the shared disciplines, this is the one that needs the most care. To say aloud what we have done wrong, or to ask another person to watch over our habits, is to give them power over us. Done well, it brings relief, truth and company. Done badly, it brings shame, control, gossip and, in the worst cases, harm.
This lecture looks at what the Bible says about confessing to one another, at the forms confession takes in Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant life, and at the modern practice of accountability. It sets out a short list of safety lines that apply in every tradition. It also says plainly what this course does not ask: no student is ever required to confess anything to anyone, to write down their sins, or to speak about their private life.
The central claim of the course sits underneath all of this. Confession is not a payment that buys forgiveness. It is a way of coming into the light, within a grace that is already offered, and of not carrying alone what was never meant to be carried alone.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Explain what James 5:16, Galatians 6:1-2 and Proverbs 27:17 say, and what they do not say.
- Describe sacramental confession, confession in the Orthodox Church, and confession and accountability in Protestant life, each in words its own people would accept.
- State the disagreement among Christians about confession fairly, and say what this course requires.
- Name the safety lines that apply to any confession or accountability arrangement.
- Tell the difference between accountability that helps and accountability that becomes surveillance.
Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The insistent prayer of a righteous person is powerfully effective." — James 5:16
World English Bible
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted. Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:1-2
WEB
Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance." — Proverbs 27:17
WEB
James speaks of confession and prayer together, and joins them to healing. Galatians speaks of a person "caught in some fault" and asks for gentleness and shared burdens. Proverbs gives the picture of two people making each other sharper, which is the best picture of accountability in the Bible. None of these verses names a form, a place, a person who must hear, or a list of sins. They state a direction, and the traditions have filled in the forms.
1. What the three verses say
Start with the words. James 5:16 says: "Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed." Three points are worth noticing.
First, the verb is plural and mutual: to one another. The verse does not say that one class of people confesses to another class. It describes a community in which people tell one another the truth and pray.
Second, confession and prayer are joined. The verse does not picture a list of faults read out to a person with a notebook. It pictures a person saying what is true, and others praying.
Third, the purpose is healing. Interpreters differ on the kind of healing in view, whether of body, of spirit, of relationship, or of all three. The verse does not say, and the lecture will not claim more than it says.
Galatians 6:1 is about a hard case: someone "caught in some fault". The instruction is to those who are "spiritual" to restore such a person "in a spirit of gentleness", while "looking to yourself". The next verse gives the principle: "Bear one another’s burdens". Notice what the verses leave out. They do not tell the community to publish the fault, to impose a penalty, or to keep a record. The goal is restoration, and the person doing it is warned to watch their own footing.
Proverbs 27:17 is not about sin at all. It says: "Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance." It describes friends who make one another better through honest contact. That is the heart of a healthy accountability partnership. Two people, each of whom is trying to grow, help each other by being honest and not afraid.
2. Confession in Catholic life
In the Catholic Church, confession is a , usually called Reconciliation or Penance. A baptised Catholic who has committed a serious sin is expected to confess it to a priest, who offers absolution (a declaration of forgiveness on behalf of Christ and the Church) and gives a penance, usually a prayer or a simple act. Many Catholics also use the sacrament more regularly, as a way of growing in the spiritual life.
The Church teaches that the priest is bound by the seal of confession: he may never reveal what he heard, and the Church holds this to be absolute. Catholics who value the sacrament describe it as a place of great safety, where a person can say the unsayable and hear "your sins are forgiven" spoken aloud. They say that the priest does not forgive by his own power but as Christ's servant, and that the grace received is Christ's gift.
3. Confession in Orthodox life
In the Orthodox Church, confession is also a mystery of the Church. It is made to a priest, who stands before an icon of Christ together with the penitent, and who prays for forgiveness. Orthodox writers stress that the priest is a witness and a physician of the soul, and that it is God who forgives. Many Orthodox Christians have a spiritual father or spiritual mother who knows them over years. Practice varies by country and by community, in how often a person confesses and how the preparation for Communion is arranged.
4. Confession in Protestant life
Protestants hold that every believer may come to God directly in Christ, with no priest between. Luther did not abolish private confession. He valued it, and the Lutheran tradition has kept a place for it, so that a person who wishes to may speak to a pastor and hear a word of forgiveness. In practice, many Lutheran churches today use a shared confession and absolution at the start of the service, with private confession available.
Anglican churches keep confession in forms from a general confession in worship to private confession to a priest, which some Anglicans use regularly and others never.
In Reformed, Baptist, Pentecostal and many free churches, there is usually no office whose duty it is to hear confessions. Confession is made first to God (1 John 1:9 is often cited), and then, when it is wise, to a trusted friend, a pastor, an , or a small group. Some Protestants practise mutual confession in a group, following James 5:16. Many practise accountability: an agreement between two or three people to ask each other regularly how they are doing with a particular habit or struggle.
5. Where Christians differ on confession
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians, including Catholic and Orthodox readers and many Lutherans and Anglicans, hold that confession to a priest is a gift that Christ gave to his Church. Their case, in its strongest form, is this: John 20:23 records Jesus giving his disciples authority concerning the forgiveness of sins; a person who has said the words aloud to another human being and heard the words of forgiveness spoken back has been helped in a way that silent prayer often does not manage; and the seal of the confessional makes a safe place for the most shameful things. For them, to leave out the sacrament is to leave out a gift.
Other Christians, including many Reformed, Baptist, Pentecostal and free-church readers, hold that the believer needs no human mediator and that confession to a priest is not required. Their case, in its strongest form, is this: Scripture speaks of one mediator (1 Timothy 2:5); Christ's forgiveness is promised to those who confess to God (1 John 1:9); the New Testament's picture of confession is mutual and between equals (James 5:16); and a required system, in the wrong hands or in a careless church, can put too much weight on one human hearer, so that a person feels forgiveness depends on finding the right one. Catholic and Orthodox teachers answer that the priest acts only as Christ's servant, and that the safeguards of the tradition (such as the seal) exist to protect the penitent.
Some Christians hold that confession is private and between a person and God only, and that nobody else should be asked. Others hold that sins which harm others must be confessed to those harmed.
What this course requires is less than any of these traditions requires. It requires only that you can state the disagreement fairly, that you do not mock the practice of another tradition, and that you never force a person into confession, in either direction. You are free to practise the form your own church teaches, and you are free to practise none.
6. Safety lines
The following lines apply in every tradition and every arrangement. They are not an exhaustive list of what a wise church will say, but they are a minimum.
- Confession is never forced. Nobody should be pressed, pushed, bargained with or shamed into confessing. A church, a leader or a partner who insists has stopped practising confession and has begun something else. A child or teenager should never be required to confess to an adult.
- A person chooses whom to tell. Choose someone trustworthy, mature, kind and, where possible, trained for this (a priest, a pastor, a counsellor, a long-standing friend). Do not tell everything to someone who gossips, who is curious in an unhealthy way, or who has power over you in daily life, such as an employer.
- Privacy matters. Whatever is told in a group or partnership stays there. A listener who tells others, even as a "prayer request", has broken the thing that made the confession safe.
- You say as much as you wish and no more. You may say "I have struggled with something" and stop. You do not owe details. Details can wound the listener, others named, or yourself.
- Abuse and crime are not secrets to keep. If you are told that a child or any person is being harmed, or that someone is in danger, a promise of secrecy does not cover it. The responsible persons (a safeguarding officer named in your church's written policy, the authorities where the law requires it, your local emergency number if there is danger now) must be told. Churches have different rules about how the sacrament of confession is treated in this case, and this course does not decide that question. For lay partners, group leaders and pastors outside the sacrament, the line is clear: do not promise secrecy before you have heard what it is about, and do not keep a secret that leaves someone in danger.
- A person who has been harmed is not asked to confess for it. If someone has been abused, they have no need to confess the abuser's act, and should never be told to "own their part". They need a safe person, and in many cases professional help.
- Nobody is made a judge of another's soul. A confessor may offer counsel. It is not the confessor's place to rule on a person's salvation or to demand a penalty that harms.
- Confession is not a treatment. Some people struggle with guilt that does not go away, however often they confess. If you confess the same thing again and again and feel no peace, this may be scrupulosity or a form of anxiety, and a doctor or a counsellor can help along with a pastor. This is not a failure of faith.
7. When accountability helps, and when it becomes surveillance
Many modern Christians use accountability partnerships. Two or three people agree to meet and to ask each other how they are doing with a habit (for example, with time online, anger, money, or a daily reading). Done well, this is Proverbs 27:17. Done badly, it becomes a means of control.
Signs that accountability is helping:
- It is chosen by those who take part, and anyone may stop.
- It is mutual. Everyone is asked as well as asking.
- It is about the person, not only the behaviour. The partner asks "how are you?" before "did you?".
- It leads to kindness, not shame. When someone has slipped, the response is "what would help?" and not "how many times?".
- It has limits on what is asked and shared, and those limits are respected.
- The partners are equals, or the leader is plainly bound by the same rules.
Signs that it is becoming surveillance:
- One person monitors another with reports, apps or daily checks, and the other cannot say no.
- Questions go into private matters that are no one else's business, such as a spouse's behaviour, a person's body or thoughts.
- It is used to rank, compare, or publish a person's failures to others.
- The "accountable" person fears the partner, or feels they cannot speak truthfully because it will be used against them.
- A person with power over you (a pastor, an employer, a parent of an adult) is the partner, and refusing would cost you something.
- The purpose has shifted from care to catching.
An invented example: Two friends, Amos and Tomas, meet on Thursday evenings. They agreed to ask each other one question: "How was your week with the thing you named?" Amos named his habit of late-night scrolling. Tomas named his temper at home. They also agreed that either may say "I don't want to talk about it this week", and that nothing said goes anywhere else. One Thursday Amos says he hardly slept and did not manage anything. Tomas says: "That sounds hard. What would help this week?" They decide to look for an earlier bedtime together. Nobody is scored. That is accountability serving friendship.
A second invented example: a youth group leader, Dana, asks each teenager to text her every night about whether they looked at certain things online, and tells the group which of them missed. The teenagers feel watched, and some begin to lie. This is not accountability. It is surveillance and public shaming, and it harms. A responsible church would stop it, and teenagers should never be asked to report private matters to an adult in this way.
8. Where confession leads
Confession is not meant to end in a heap of shame. In the Catholic and Orthodox traditions, it ends in absolution and the peace of forgiveness. In Protestant life it ends in the word of the gospel: "If we confess our sins, he is faithful and righteous to forgive us the sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness" (1 John 1:9). In friendship it ends in a hand on the shoulder and a prayer. Where confession leaves a person more afraid, more watched or more ashamed, something has gone wrong with the practice, and the person should step back and speak to someone safe, such as a pastor, priest, doctor or counsellor.
Diagram 1. Choosing someone to tell, and what to say
Diagram 2. Help and harm in accountability
| Accountability that helps | Accountability that turns into surveillance |
|---|---|
| Chosen; anyone may stop | A person cannot say no |
| Mutual: all are asked and all are asking | One person monitors the other |
| Starts with "how are you?" | Starts with "did you?" |
| Answers a slip with "what would help?" | Answers a slip with "how many times?" |
| Keeps privacy | Reports to others or ranks people |
| Equals, or a leader bound by the same rules | A person with power over the other's daily life |
In short
- James 5:16 describes mutual confession joined to prayer, for healing. Galatians 6:1-2 asks for gentleness and shared burdens. Proverbs 27:17 pictures friends who sharpen one another.
- Catholic and Orthodox Christians confess to a priest in a sacrament or mystery; Protestants vary from private confession to a pastor, to confession to God, to mutual confession and accountability.
- This course requires only that you state the disagreement fairly, mock no practice, and force no one in either direction.
- Safety lines: never forced, a trustworthy person, privacy, say only what you wish, abuse and crime are not secrets to keep, and a harmed person is not asked to confess for it.
- Accountability helps when it is chosen, mutual, kind and private. It becomes surveillance when it is forced, one-sided or used to rank.
- Guilt that never lifts may need a doctor or counsellor as well as a pastor. That is not a failure of faith.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| James 5:16 | Confess to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed. Mutual, joined to prayer. |
| Forms of confession | Catholic: Reconciliation, to a priest. Orthodox: to a priest or spiritual father. Protestant: to God, a pastor, a friend, or in mutual groups. |
| The safety lines | Never forced; a safe person; privacy; say only what you wish; no secrecy over harm; a harmed person need not confess for it. |
| Accountability that helps | Chosen, mutual, kind and private; it asks "how are you?" before "did you?". |
One sentence to remember Confession brings us into the light within a grace already given, and it is never forced, never a payment, and never a secret that leaves someone in danger.
This week's action Choose a safe person you might one day talk to, and write only their role (not their name) on a private sheet. Nothing needs to be said to anyone.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What do James 5:16 and Galatians 6:1-2 say that is different from what many people expect to hear about confession? What do they leave out?
- In your own words, state the strongest case for confession to a priest and the strongest case for confession directly to God and to trusted friends. Can you state each so that its supporters would agree?
- What qualities would make a person safe to tell? Which would make a person unsafe, even if they were well-meaning?
- Think about the difference between "how are you doing with this?" and "did you do this?". What would each question feel like to the person being asked?
- Why does this course say that a promise of secrecy never covers harm to a child or another person? What should a listener do instead?