FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM107E Spiritual Disciplines and a Rule of Life

Lecture 5-2: How to Build One

Contents 31
LM107E Spiritual Disciplines and a Rule of Life
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Training Within Grace
  1. Introduction: Training Within Grace
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Rest and Simplicity
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Spiritual Discipline Is
  2. Lecture 1-2: Sabbath: The Gift of Stopping
  3. Lecture 1-3: Simplicity, Possessions and Time
  4. Lecture 1-4: Rest in a Busy Life
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: One Rest, One Letting Go
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Scripture, Silence and Reading
  1. Lecture 2-1: Meditation and Memory
  2. Lecture 2-2: Silence and Solitude
  3. Lecture 2-3: Journals, Reading and Study
  4. Lecture 2-4: Choosing Among Quiet Practices
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Five Minutes with a Verse
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Fasting and Self-Control
  1. Lecture 3-1: Fasting: Safety First
  2. Lecture 3-2: Other Fasts and Self-Control
  3. Lecture 3-3: Feasting and the Table
  4. Lecture 3-4: Fasting and the Neighbour
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Thing to Set Down
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Disciplines with Others
  1. Lecture 4-1: Worship, the Table and the Church Year
  2. Lecture 4-2: Confession and Accountability
  3. Lecture 4-3: Service, Hidden Giving and Hospitality
  4. Lecture 4-4: Practising Together Without Pressure
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Practice Partner
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Building a Rule of Life
  1. Lecture 5-1: What a Rule of Life Is
  2. Lecture 5-2: How to Build One
  3. Lecture 5-3: Rules for Seasons
  4. Lecture 5-4: Rules in Real Lives
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A First Rule of Life
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Going the Distance — Health and Legalism
  1. Lecture 6-1: Grace and Discipline
  2. Lecture 6-2: Burnout, Depression and the Body's Signals
  3. Lecture 6-3: When Disciplines Are Used Against People
  4. Lecture 6-4: The Way Back
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Three-Month Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

Most people who try to keep a spiritual discipline begin with a burst of energy and a large plan. In the second or third week the plan breaks. Then they feel guilty, and some of them stop altogether. The failure is nearly always a failure of design, not of faith. The plan was made for the person they hoped to be on their best day, and it met the person they are on an ordinary Tuesday.

This lecture gives a way to build a rule of life that is made for the ordinary Tuesday. It has six steps: see what you really do, choose few disciplines, attach them to what you already do, set a floor and a normal, share the plan, and set a date to review it. The advice is common-sense advice about habits. It does not rest on any study, and it is not a technique that guarantees anything. It is a way of cooperating with how people actually live.

The lecture also takes up the words "rule of life", because some readers have good reasons to dislike them.

What these 24 minutes give you

  • List the six steps for building a personal rule and say what each one is for.
  • Explain why a large rule tends to fail and why a floor helps.
  • Give an example of attaching a practice to an existing habit, with a time, a place and a cue.
  • State the disagreement about the words "rule of life" in the terms of each side.
  • Say why a rule should be shared and reviewed, and by whom.

For which of you, desiring to build a tower, doesn’t first sit down and count the cost, to see if he has enough to complete it? Or perhaps, when he has laid a foundation, and is not able to finish, everyone who sees begins to mock him, saying, ‘This man began to build, and wasn’t able to finish.’" — Luke 14:28-30

World English Bible

The plans of the diligent surely lead to profit; and everyone who is hasty surely rushes to poverty." — Proverbs 21:5

WEB

And whatever you do, work heartily, as for the Lord, and not for men," — Colossians 3:23

WEB

An honest note on Luke 14:28-30 is needed. Jesus tells this small parable about the cost of following him, and the main point is about , not about timetables. We use it here only as an everyday picture of a wise person counting what they have before they build. It would be wrong to say that the passage is a lesson on habit design. Proverbs 21:5 praises careful planning and warns against haste, which is the same common sense. Colossians 3:23 reminds us that the ordinary work of life is itself done for the Lord, so a rule that treats only "religious" activities as spiritual has missed part of what the text says.

1. Why big rules fail

Think of three common stories. In the first, a person decides to rise at five in the morning for an hour of prayer, reading and silence. That works for nine days. Then a child is ill in the night, or a bus is late, or the person simply sleeps badly. On the tenth day the alarm rings and the person feels too tired. On the eleventh day the person feels bad about the tenth. By the end of the month the plan is gone, and what remains is a quiet sense of having failed.

In the second story, a person decides to practise five disciplines at once because all five are good. Five is more than the person can hold in mind, so none gets settled into a habit.

In the third, a person copies a rule from a book or from an admired person. It is a good rule for that person. It does not fit this person's job, body or household.

All three have the same cause. The rule was built for an imagined life, and it broke on the real one. Three plain remedies follow, and the six steps are built from them: begin with the real life; keep the rule small; and plan for the worst day as well as the best.

2. Step 1: See what you really do

Before choosing anything, look at an ordinary week. You do not need a spreadsheet. A simple map will do: write the days, and beside each, the times that are fixed (work, school, travel, meals, the care of other people) and the times that are loose. Then notice where there is already a gap or a pause: the minutes while the kettle boils, the ride to work, the time after the children are asleep, the time before the first message arrives.

Here is a short example (an invented example). Dina works in a shop on three days a week and cares for her mother on two evenings. When she maps a week, she finds that she has no unbroken half hour on any day. But she has a bus ride of fifteen minutes on her shop days and a quiet ten minutes after her mother is settled for the night. That is the real material of her rule. A plan that began with "an hour every morning" would have ignored it.

Two points about this step. First, you are not looking for a time to be better. You are looking for a time that exists. Second, if the map shows that you have no gap at all, that is also information. A person who has no room may need to ask first about rest, and about whether the load is right (lectures 1-2 to 1-4 looked at that), before adding any discipline.

3. Step 2: Choose few

Next, choose a small number of disciplines. A common suggestion, and the one this course uses for the lab, is no more than three. For a first rule, one or two are often better. It helps to draw from different kinds. Lecture 1-1 described one common way of grouping disciplines: those that work inwardly, such as meditation on Scripture or silence; those that work outwardly, such as simplicity, rest or service; and those that are shared with others, such as worship or a practice partner. A rule with one from each kind is balanced in the way that Benedict's four elements were balanced. But there is no law about this. Some people will do best with a single practice for a whole season.

Choose by asking three questions.

  • What do I need most now? For a tired person it may be rest. For a person who is anxious it may be a short, safe way of reading a psalm. For a person who feels alone it may be a weekly partner.
  • What do I like, or at least not dread? A practice you dread will not last. This is not self-indulgence. A discipline that can be kept is better than a better one that cannot.
  • What does my body allow? Anything that touches the body is chosen with care. Fasting from food is not for everyone, and lecture 3-1 gave a list of people who should not do it, or should ask a doctor first. Silence is not for everyone either. Early waking should never cut into the sleep you need. If any of these is doubtful, choose something else. Other practices are always available.

4. Step 3: Attach each practice to something you already do

This is the part of the advice that is closest to ordinary common sense. A new habit is easier to keep if it is tied to an old one than if it stands alone. The old habit acts as a cue. Instead of "I shall read a psalm every day", the plan says, "When I pour the first cup of tea, I shall read one verse." Instead of "I shall be thankful", it says, "On the bus home, I shall name three things I was given today."

Each practice needs three small answers:

  • When (a time, or better, a cue: after the tea, on the bus, when the children are down).
  • Where (a seat, a corner, a path).
  • How long (a number of minutes that is honestly small).

Make the first version smaller than you think necessary. Five minutes is plenty. If you find after a month that you have more room, you may add more, and that is a happy change. The reverse, cutting back because the first plan was too large, feels like failure, though it is in fact only good adjusting.

For the person with shifts, the cue must follow the waking time and not the clock. For the carer, it may be tied to something done for the other person, like a medicine round or a mealtime. For the person with a long commute, it may belong to the journey. One test of a cue is whether it happens on a bad day. A cue that vanishes when life is hard is a poor anchor.

5. Step 4: Set a floor and a normal

This is the most useful single idea in the lecture. For each practice, decide two levels.

  • The normal is what a reasonably good ordinary week looks like. It is the plan you aim at without strain.
  • The floor is the least you will do on the worst day. It should be so small that it is almost impossible to fail. A floor might be one breath and one sentence: "God, be with me today." It might be a single verse read aloud. It might be a moment of thanks before sleep.

A floor does three things. It keeps the thread unbroken, so that a bad week does not become a lost month. It removes the all-or-nothing choice that tempts a tired person to do nothing. And it tells the truth, which is that the reason for the rule is to stay with God, and a minute spent with God counts as spending time with God.

Notice what a floor is not. It is not a trick to feel good, and it does not make the rest of the rule optional. It simply says that the days on which you can only do the floor are part of the rule, not outside it.

There may also be days on which even the floor is not possible: a night in hospital, a funeral, a day of travel, a bout of illness. Then the rule is set down, with no guilt. Lecture 6-4 deals with the way back.

6. Step 5: Share the plan

A rule that is kept entirely in secret is easy to drop quietly. So the fifth step is to tell the plan to someone you trust: a friend, a spouse, a pastor or priest, a spiritual director if you have one, or a practice partner (lecture 4-4). You do not need to report your progress. You only need to say what the plan is, and ask that person to ask you now and then how it is going, in a way that does not become a test.

Two cautions. Sharing the plan is not the same as sharing everything about your inner life, and you may keep private whatever you wish. And if you belong to a community with its own guidance about prayer, fasting or worship, tell the person responsible for it what you are planning, and take their guidance seriously. A rule you build for yourself sits inside a larger life, and a church or a family may already shape much of it.

7. Step 6: Set a review date

The last step is a date in the calendar, perhaps a month or two away, on which you will look at the rule again. At the review ask three simple questions. What has been easy? What has been hard? What shall I change: add, drop, shrink, move? The review is not for deciding whether you have been good. It is for deciding whether the rule still fits.

A review date matters because it gives a missed week a place to go. Without one, every missed week feels like an accusation. With one, it is something to bring to the next review, and it can be dealt with calmly.

8. The words "rule of life"

This is a point where readers will not agree. The word "rule" is used by many Catholic, Orthodox and Anglican writers, and in books on spiritual formation across many churches, as a plain name for a pattern, and the long history of monastic rules gives it dignity. Those who defend the word say that a frame is a gift, that without it the strong demands of the day fill all the room, and that the word reminds us that we belong to a long line of people who have tried to live this way. Many Protestants, on the other hand, do not like the word. Some link it to the monastic vows that the Reformers criticised, and to a fear that a rule can become a way of earning favour. Others associate "rule" with a law that binds the conscience, and they hold that only Scripture binds the conscience. Those who hold this view often prefer words like "pattern", "rhythm", "plan" or "way of life", and many of them are doing the very same thing under those names. A third group points out that a monastic rule is a community's law, and that a personal frame is quite different: it is self-made, it can be changed on a Tuesday, and it binds no one but the person who wrote it.

Each position has a real concern. The first is that without a deliberate frame, the loudest voices win. The second is that a frame can become a burden or a price. The third is that borrowed language may suggest more authority than the thing deserves.

This course requires much less than any of these. It asks that a rule be treated as a tool, not a law; that it be kept flexible; and that a student honour the guidance of their own community where it exists. If the word is a hindrance, use another. Nothing in the course depends on it.

9. A note on work

Colossians 3:23 reminds us that work done "as for the Lord" is part of the life we offer. A rule of life is not only made of prayer and Bible reading. It can include how you do your work (a pause before the first task, a prayer before a difficult conversation) and how you care for people (a plan to listen well). The list in Step 2 should not be read as a list of religious activities alone. If the rule has no place for your work and your home, it is probably describing a different life from yours.

10. A small worked example

Take Dina, from above (an invented example). Her map shows a bus ride on shop days and ten quiet minutes after her mother is settled. She has a small chronic back problem, and her doctor has told her to rest more, so she excludes anything that cuts sleep. Her draft:

  • Purpose: to stay close to God and to be patient with my mother.
  • Practice one: one psalm verse on the bus. Normal: read it, say it twice. Floor: read it once.
  • Practice two: thanks before sleep. Normal: name three things. Floor: say "thank you" once.
  • Practice three: a call with a friend on Sunday evening, to ask how the week was. Normal: ten minutes. Floor: a message.
  • Review: the first Sunday of next month.

This is a small rule. It fits on a card. It will survive a bad week. It leaves room to grow.


Diagram 1. Six steps to a first rule

Six Steps to a First Rule Start with the real week, keep it small, and plan for the worst day 1. See your week Fixed times, loose times, real gaps and pauses 2. Choose few No more than three; fit the need, the body 3. Attach to a habit When, where, how long; begin smaller than needed 4. Floor and normal The least on the worst day, the aim on a good week 5. Share it Tell the plan to someone you trust, not your progress 6. Review date What was easy, what was hard, what to change Anything touching the body is chosen with care. Sleep is never the price of a rule.

Diagram 2. Floor and normal: an example

Practice Normal Floor
One verse on the bus Read it, say it twice Read it once
Thanks before sleep Name three things Say "thank you" once
Sunday call with a friend Ten minutes A message

(An invented example.)


In short

  • Big rules tend to fail because they are built for an imagined life. Start with the real week, keep the rule small and plan for the worst day.
  • Choose few disciplines, often one to three, by need, by what you can bear to keep, and by what your body allows.
  • Attach each practice to an existing habit, with a time or cue, a place and a short length.
  • Set a normal and a floor. The floor is the least you will do on the worst day.
  • Share the plan with someone trusted and set a review date, so a missed week has a place to go.
  • The words "rule of life" are disputed. The course asks only that a rule be a flexible tool, not a law.
Front Back
Why big rules fail They are made for the best day, not the ordinary one, and they break on the first bad week.
Attach to a habit Tie each practice to a time or cue you already have, with a place and a short length.
Floor and normal The normal is a good ordinary week; the floor is the least on the worst day.
Share and review Tell the plan to someone you trust, and set a date to look at it again and change it.

One sentence to remember Build the rule for your ordinary Tuesday: few practices, tied to what you already do, with a floor for the worst day and a date to review it.

This week's action Map one ordinary week in a few lines, mark the real gaps, and choose one practice and one cue for it, without starting yet.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a plan that you began with energy and dropped. Looking back, was the failure one of faith or of design? What would you change in the design?
  • Where are the real gaps in your ordinary week? Is there any gap at all? If there is none, what does that tell you?
  • What would be a floor for a practice that you value? Is it small enough that you could do it on your worst day?
  • Which of the three positions on the words "rule of life" is closest to your own? What is the strongest concern of the position that is furthest from it?
  • Who is someone you could tell about a plan, in a way that would not turn into an examination?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.