Lecture 5-4: Rules in Real Lives
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Spiritual Discipline Is
- Lecture 1-2: Sabbath: The Gift of Stopping
- Lecture 1-3: Simplicity, Possessions and Time
- Lecture 1-4: Rest in a Busy Life
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: One Rest, One Letting Go
- Lecture 2-1: Meditation and Memory
- Lecture 2-2: Silence and Solitude
- Lecture 2-3: Journals, Reading and Study
- Lecture 2-4: Choosing Among Quiet Practices
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Five Minutes with a Verse
- Lecture 3-1: Fasting: Safety First
- Lecture 3-2: Other Fasts and Self-Control
- Lecture 3-3: Feasting and the Table
- Lecture 3-4: Fasting and the Neighbour
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Thing to Set Down
- Lecture 4-1: Worship, the Table and the Church Year
- Lecture 4-2: Confession and Accountability
- Lecture 4-3: Service, Hidden Giving and Hospitality
- Lecture 4-4: Practising Together Without Pressure
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Practice Partner
- Lecture 5-1: What a Rule of Life Is
- Lecture 5-2: How to Build One
- Lecture 5-3: Rules for Seasons
- Lecture 5-4: Rules in Real Lives
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A First Rule of Life
Steps and principles are useful, but a rule of life is built by a particular person with a particular week. In this lecture we watch three people do it. They are invented. Each one makes a first draft, finds that it does not work, and changes it. We follow them through the six steps of lecture 5-2 and through the seasons of lecture 5-3. We include their mistakes on purpose, because the mistakes are where most of the learning is.
Then we ask what to do when a rule is not working, and how to tell whether the trouble is in the rule, the season, or something else that needs care from a doctor or a counsellor.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Follow three examples of a rule being built, and name the mistake in each first draft.
- Explain how a cue can follow a person's real life (waking time, a child's nap, a hearing aid) and not the clock.
- Use a short list of questions to find out why a rule is not working.
- Distinguish a problem with the design of a rule from a sign that a person needs medical or counselling care.
- Say what Luke 10:38-42 does and does not teach about work and attention.
As they went on their way, he entered into a certain village, and a certain woman named Martha received him into her house. She had a sister called Mary, who also sat at Jesus’ feet, and heard his word. But Martha was distracted with much serving, and she came up to him, and said, ‘Lord, don’t you care that my sister left me to serve alone? Ask her therefore to help me.’ Jesus answered her, ‘Martha, Martha, you are anxious and troubled about many things, but one thing is needed. Mary has chosen the good part, which will not be taken away from her.’" — Luke 10:38-42
World English Bible
Commit your deeds to Yahweh, and your plans shall succeed." — Proverbs 16:3
WEB
The story of Martha and Mary has been read in several ways, and we should say so. Some older interpreters, in several traditions, took the two sisters as two kinds of , an active one and a contemplative one. Others have read it as two moments in one life: there is a time to serve and a time to sit and listen, and anyone can be Martha in the morning and Mary in the evening. Many have pointed out that Jesus does not tell Martha that her work is worthless. He names her anxiety and her distraction. For a rule of life, the safest thing to take is modest: the passage does not set work against prayer, and it warns against a worry that fills the whole mind. Proverbs 16:3 invites a person to bring their plans and their deeds before God, which is what a rule does when it is made with prayer. The verse does not promise that every plan will work out as the person hopes, and the course does not read it that way.
1. Three people
The three people below are invented examples. They are put together to show common problems. None is a real person. Their ages and circumstances are chosen to be very different, so that you can see the same steps at work in different lives.
2. Tomasz, who works in shifts
(An invented example.) Tomasz works in a factory on a rotating shift: mornings for a week, then afternoons, then nights. He is in his thirties, he lives with his sister, and he is a member of a small church that meets on Sunday morning, which he can attend only on some weeks.
First draft. He reads a book on and writes a rule: rise at six, thirty minutes of Bible reading and prayer, a verse learned each day, and silence for ten minutes before bed at ten.
What went wrong. On his early weeks, six o'clock was fine. On afternoon weeks, he was asleep at six. On night weeks, six o'clock was the end of his shift, and ten at night was the start of it. By the third week he had kept the rule on perhaps five days in twenty, and he felt that he was no good at it. He had made the commonest mistake: he had tied the practices to the clock, and his life does not follow the clock.
Revision. Tomasz went back to Step 1 and made three small maps, one for each shift. He saw that the one thing that is the same every week is waking up: whenever he wakes, there is a first ten minutes before he has to do anything. He also saw that the bus ride to work is fifteen minutes on any shift. So the cue became "after I wake, with the first drink" and "on the bus."
His new rule had two parts. After waking, with the first drink: one psalm verse, read slowly. On the bus: a short prayer of thanks for three things. His floor: one sentence ("God, be with me today") said at any point. He also decided to protect his sleep above everything else, and wrote that into the rule: "If I have had less than my usual sleep, the rule is only the floor." He shared the plan with his sister, who asked him on Sundays how it went. Once a month he sets a review at the end of a rest week.
The lesson: a cue should follow the real shape of a life. For a shift worker, "after waking" is better than "at six."
3. Mei, who has small children
(An invented example.) Mei has two children under five. Her husband works long hours. She does not attend a church regularly at the moment, because the children make it hard, though she is part of an online prayer group that meets every second week.
First draft. She hears a talk on silence and solitude. She writes a rule with three practices: twenty minutes of silence while the children nap, a chapter of the Gospels in the evening, and a weekly fast from social media.
What went wrong. The nap was the only time in the day when she could do anything for herself. Within a week the silence had turned into scrolling, and she felt guilty. The chapter in the evening was beyond her energy. The fast from social media was the one thing that worked, and she kept it, but it seemed too small to count. By the fourth week she felt that she was failing at all three.
She had several problems at once. The first was Step 2: she chose by what the talk had praised, not by what she needed. The second was that she had put a practice into the only free time of the day, and then the practice competed with sleep and with rest. The third was that her view of "counting" was wrong. The one practice that was working did count.
Revision. She asked herself what she needed. She wrote: "I need to feel less alone, and I need to hear a word that is not about the next task." Her revised rule was one practice with a floor and a partner. Practice: a verse written on a card by the kettle, read when she makes her first drink, and said again when she is putting the children to bed. Floor: look at the card. Partner: a friend from the online group, who sends a message on Thursday: "How was the week?" She kept the fast from social media, since it was working, but she left it in her mind as a bonus and not a requirement. She explicitly gave herself permission to use the nap for sleep or rest.
Later she added, in a calm season, a short walk with the children and a prayer for the neighbours as she passed their houses.
The lesson: choose by need, not by admiration. Do not take the only rest of the day for a discipline. Count what is working.
4. Chidi, who is retired and in poor health
(An invented example.) Chidi is seventy-four. He was a teacher. He has a heart condition, painful joints and some hearing loss. He lives alone. He used to attend church weekly, and now goes about twice a month, when his daughter can drive him.
First draft. He remembers what he did in middle age: memorising long passages and fasting on Fridays. He writes a rule that includes learning a psalm each week by heart, silence for half an hour, and a weekly fast.
What went wrong. Memorising was slow now, and he found it painful to fail at what had once been easy. Thirty minutes of silence made him anxious and sleepy. And the fast was a real problem. Chidi takes medicine that is tied to meals. A person in his position should not fast from food without speaking to a doctor first, and he had not done so. Luckily he spoke to his daughter, who asked him to talk to the doctor. The doctor advised against it.
Revision. In the second draft, the pattern was built on what he can do and enjoy. He cannot see small print well and does not hear well in a group, but he can hear a recording through headphones. So the rule became: morning, one psalm read aloud on a recording while seated with a drink; afternoon, a telephone call on Tuesdays with a friend from church, five minutes of talk and a short prayer; evening, a written line of thanks in a notebook he keeps by the chair. Floor: he says the Lord's Prayer, or, if he cannot, simply says "thank you." No fasting from food, and no silence beyond a minute or two if it comes naturally. When his hearing is poor on a given day, the psalm is read from large print and not heard.
He told his daughter and his pastor the plan, and asked the pastor if someone could visit once a month. He sees the rule as including receiving: from the visitor, and from his daughter's driving. He has set his review for the first week of each new season.
The lesson: a rule built from what you used to do may not fit what you can do now. The change is not a loss of faith. There is no shame in a smaller rule, and some practices simply belong to another season. Physical disciplines are chosen with a doctor.
5. What the three have in common
- Each began with a draft that was too large or tied to the wrong cue.
- Each noticed the problem within a few weeks, because there was a plan to compare with the life.
- Each went back to the real week, shrank the rule, set a floor, and shared the plan.
- None treated the first draft as a failure of faith.
- None of the three rules is better than the others. Each is a good rule for that life.
6. Reading Luke 10 with the three
It is natural to ask which of the three is Martha and which is Mary. The honest answer is that each is both. Tomasz works with his hands and his body for most of his waking hours, and his rule includes a moment of sitting. Mei's day is entirely service, and her rule includes one word from outside the day's tasks. Chidi's life has plenty of quiet, and his rule brings in company and a phone call. In each case the rule does not take a person out of their work. It adds a small, unhurried point of attention, so that the work is not all that is there. That is a modest reading of the passage, and it does not claim to settle the old question about the two ways of life.
7. When the rule is not working
Sometimes a rule is not working even though it has been shrunk and a floor has been set. Before deciding that you have failed, ask some plain questions. Go through them in order.
- Is it too big? Cut it in half. Then cut it in half again. If you could keep the smaller one for a month, the size was the problem.
- Is the cue wrong? Does it depend on a time or a place that does not exist on your bad days? Find a cue that does.
- Is it the wrong practice? Do you dread it? Does it make you anxious, sad, ashamed or sleepy in a way that grows worse? Then try another one, or leave it for now. Anyone may skip silence, long reading, breathing exercises or fasting.
- Is it the wrong season? Has something changed, such as an illness, a bereavement, a new baby or a move? Then the rule may need to become a minimum rule for a while.
- Is it a rule for someone else? Have you borrowed a plan from a book or another person without asking whether it fits?
- Is something else going on? This question needs particular care. Sometimes a rule that cannot be kept is not a design problem at all. If for several weeks you have felt low, hopeless or numb; if your sleep or appetite has changed a great deal; if you cannot concentrate on anything; if prayer and every other practice feel empty and you cannot imagine that changing, then the matter is not a spiritual failure. It may be a sign of illness, and a doctor or counsellor is the right person to talk to, along with a pastor. A rule of life is not a treatment for depression, anxiety or burnout, and being unable to keep one while depressed is not a lack of faith. If you ever think of hurting yourself, please speak at once to a trusted person, and call your local emergency number or a crisis line.
A rule is a help. If the help has become a weight, change it.
8. A caution about comparing
When you tell a friend that your rule is small, you may feel a pull to explain or to apologise. Tomasz's rule has two lines. Chidi's has no fasting. Mei's is a card by the kettle. In any church, a few people will have long rules, and some will be impressive. That is not a competition. The measure of a rule is not how much it asks. The measure is whether it fits a life and turns it, a little, toward love of God and neighbour.
Diagram 1. Three first drafts and three revisions
Diagram 2. Questions to ask a rule that is not working
| Question | If yes | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Is it too big? | The size is the problem | Halve it, then halve it again |
| Is the cue wrong? | It fails on bad days | Choose a cue that happens anyway |
| Is it the wrong practice? | It brings dread or distress | Change it, or leave it for now |
| Is it the wrong season? | Life has changed | Move to a minimum rule |
| Is something else going on? | Low mood, lost sleep, hopelessness | Speak to a doctor or counsellor and a pastor |
In short
- Tomasz's rule failed because it followed the clock. A rotating shift needs a cue tied to waking, with sleep protected.
- Mei chose by admiration and put a discipline into her only rest. Her revision chose by need and counted what already worked.
- Chidi's draft was a younger self's rule. His revision fitted his hearing and heart, left out food fasting and added company.
- When a rule fails, ask in order: too big, wrong cue, wrong practice, wrong season, borrowed from another.
- Low mood, lost sleep or hopelessness are not design problems. See a doctor or counsellor, and speak to a pastor.
- Luke 10:38-42 does not set work against prayer. It warns against an anxiety that fills the whole mind.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A cue that follows the life | Tie a practice to waking, a journey or a task that happens every day, not to a clock time that does not. |
| The first draft | Expect it to be too big. Notice, shrink it, set a floor and share the plan. |
| Questions for a failing rule | Too big? Wrong cue? Wrong practice? Wrong season? Borrowed? Or is something else going on? |
| When it is not a design problem | Long low mood, lost sleep or hopelessness need a doctor or counsellor; a rule is not a treatment. |
One sentence to remember A rule that fails is usually a rule that did not fit, and the fix is to shrink it and tie it to the real week, not to blame yourself.
This week's action Pick one practice you have found hard to keep, and ask the six questions about it in order, writing only a one-word answer to each.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the three people is closest to your own life? What would you change in that person's first draft?
- Tomasz's cue changed from a clock time to "after waking." What is a cue in your own week that happens even on a bad day?
- Mei's one working practice seemed too small to count. Is there something in your life you do not count because it seems small?
- Chidi's first draft was a rule written for his younger self. What practices have you let go of because of age, health or season, and what has taken their place?
- Luke 10 can be read as two callings or as two moments in one life. Which reading helps you more, and does either one make a rule easier to keep?