FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry

Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture

Contents 31
PT738E Privacy and Confidentiality in Ministry
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Held in Trust
  1. Introduction: Held in Trust
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Entrusted Words
  1. Lecture 1-1: Secrets, Shame, Gossip and Trust in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: Confidence in the Traditions, and Where It Stops
  3. Lecture 1-3: What a Church Holds, and What Can Hurt
  4. Lecture 1-4: When the Community Must Know, and When It Must Not
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Map What Your Community Holds
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Collecting, Keeping, Using, Letting Go
  1. Lecture 2-1: Collect Less, and Say Why
  2. Lecture 2-2: Consent When the Asker Holds Authority
  3. Lecture 2-3: Keeping It: Places, Keys and Who Needs to See
  4. Lecture 2-4: Using, Sharing, Letting Go
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Fix One Form
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Notes, Prayer Requests and People at Risk
  1. Lecture 3-1: Writing Notes About People, and Not Writing Them
  2. Lecture 3-2: Prayer Requests and the Circle Around a Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: Children, Young People and Vulnerable Adults
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Exposure Can Endanger
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Rewrite the Note and the Request
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Digital Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: Accounts, Passwords and Devices
  2. Lecture 4-2: Group Chats, Social Media, Livestreams, Cameras and Photographs
  3. Lecture 4-3: Choosing Tools and Vendors, the Questions to Ask
  4. Lecture 4-4: Volunteers, Borrowed Devices and Handing Over Access
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, Audit One Day of Access
Chapter 5 · Week 5: When It Goes Wrong, and When Hands Change
  1. Lecture 5-1: When Something Goes Wrong: The First Hours
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking to the People Who Were Hurt
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hands Changing: Pastors, Leaders, Splits and Closures
  4. Lecture 5-4: Leaving, Moving, Dying, Asking: Requests About a Person's Record
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, The First Hour and the Handover List
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Policy and Culture
  1. Lecture 6-1: Writing a Plain Policy
  2. Lecture 6-2: Teaching and Culture: Making It Ordinary
  3. Lecture 6-3: Different Places, Different Rules: How to Ask
  4. Lecture 6-4: Known and Kept: A Theology of Being Held
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, My Rule and Our One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

30 min

A woman tells her pastor that her marriage is in trouble. Two days later a member of the congregation she hardly knows says, kindly, "I hear things are hard at home. I am praying for you." Nobody meant harm. Someone, somewhere, thought that sharing the news would help her be prayed for. She now feels that she has no place left in which to be quiet.

This lecture asks what scripture itself says about that situation. It does not give one simple rule, because scripture does not hold one simple good. It holds two. One is a community that knows its members and carries their burdens. The other is a person's freedom not to be exposed. Much of the work of this course is learning to keep both in view at once.

The whole course returns to one claim:

What people entrust to a church is theirs, and the church is its keeper. So a minister collects only what is needed, says why, lets only the people who must see it see it, uses it only for the reason it was given, lets it go when that reason ends, and, when something goes wrong, does not hide it and cares first for the people who were hurt.

Chapter 1 begins with the first part of that claim: what a person tells a church, and what the church writes down about that person, remains the person's; the church holds it in trust. This first lecture builds the biblical ground for it. This course is not legal advice, and nothing in it teaches the law of any country. It teaches how to think and act with care; the law where you serve is a separate question that you must ask separately.

What these 30 minutes give you

  • Describe how Proverbs speaks of the talebearer and of the person who keeps a confidence.
  • Explain the order of Matthew 18:15-17 and say why its first step is private.
  • Explain how James 5:16 and Galatians 6:1-2 support a community that knows and carries one another, and how that differs from exposing a person.
  • Recognise "sharing for the sake of prayer" as a common form of gossip, and say what is wrong with it.
  • Give an account of the tension between hidden things coming to light (Luke 12:2-3) and the protection of a person's shame (Genesis 3, John 8).

One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13

World English Bible

He who goes about as a tale-bearer reveals secrets; therefore don’t keep company with him who opens wide his lips." — Proverbs 20:19

WEB

If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother." — Matthew 18:15

WEB

But if he doesn’t listen, take one or two more with you, that at the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established." — Matthew 18:16

WEB

Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The insistent prayer of a righteous person is powerfully effective." — James 5:16

WEB

Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2

WEB

But there is nothing covered up, that will not be revealed, nor hidden, that will not be known." — Luke 12:2

WEB

Therefore whatever you have said in the darkness will be heard in the light. What you have spoken in the ear in the inner rooms will be proclaimed on the housetops." — Luke 12:3

WEB

The two proverbs set the trustworthy person against the one who "brings gossip". The Hebrew thought is plain: a confidence is something placed in a person's hands, and passing it on is a betrayal, not a favour. The second proverb adds advice about company: keep away from the person who cannot keep what he hears.

Jesus begins a hard matter between two people, alone. A wider circle comes in only if the first step fails, and even then it is "one or two more", not the whole group. The order is a form of respect.

Both texts describe a community in which people tell one another the truth about themselves and are held up. Neither says who must hear it, how widely, or what the listeners may do afterwards. Those questions are left to wisdom, and the rest of this course is wisdom applied to them.

Jesus says that nothing hidden stays hidden for ever. This is a warning to hypocrites, and also a comfort to the wronged. It is not an instruction to expose people. We will come back to how it can be read and misread.

1. Two goods in tension

It is easy to build a theology of confidence out of one half of scripture. A person who loves secrecy can quote the proverbs on the talebearer. A person who loves openness can quote James 5:16 and the many passages on bearing burdens. Each is quoting scripture. Neither has the whole.

The argument of this lecture is that scripture holds two goods which sometimes pull against each other.

The first good is a community that knows and bears. Believers are not isolated. They confess to one another, they correct one another, they carry one another's weights, and they rejoice and suffer together. A person who can never tell anyone anything is alone, and the church is not meant to be a place of loneliness.

The second good is the protection of the person from being exposed. Scripture treats shame as a real wound, and it treats the betrayal of a confidence as a real wrong. The one who "brings gossip betrays a confidence." The one who is "of a trustworthy spirit" keeps a secret. The verbs matter: betray and keep. Something is entrusted and something is done with it.

Neither good cancels the other. A church that keeps everything secret can leave a person unsupported, and a church that shares everything can leave a person exposed. The skill is to know, in each case, whose story it is, what they want done with it, and who truly needs to hear it. That is a matter for judgement, and judgement can be taught with cases. It is also a matter on which this lecture reasons from scripture and does not claim a text settles everything. Where it uses a neat summary, treat it as the teacher's way of arranging the texts, not as a finding in the texts themselves.

2. What the proverbs say about talk

Proverbs says a good deal about speech, and the verses on secrets are among the clearest. Look again at the two above. Proverbs 11:13 sets two kinds of person side by side. One "brings gossip", and the verse calls this a betrayal of a confidence. The other is trustworthy in spirit, and the verse calls this keeping a secret. Notice that the verse does not say that the gossip is false. A true thing, passed on, is still gossip. The wrong lies in the passing on, not in an error of fact.

A third proverb comes from a context of dispute.

"Debate your case with your neighbor, and don’t betray the confidence of another;" — Proverbs 25:9 (WEB)

"lest one who hears it put you to shame, and your bad reputation never depart." — Proverbs 25:10 (WEB)

The setting here is a quarrel. You may argue your case with your neighbour, but you may not win it by revealing what another person told you in trust. The verse names a cost: the one who hears it may "put you to shame", and your bad reputation may not leave. It is a prudential warning as well as a moral one. A person who is known to spill confidences will find that no one tells them anything, and a church known for leaking will find that its members stop speaking to it honestly.

This point deserves to stay in view through the whole course. Trust is the condition for pastoral work. People tell a minister what they would tell no one else, and they do so because they believe it will be kept. A single careless disclosure can harm the person concerned, and it can also teach a whole community to say less.

3. Matthew 18: the order is the point

Matthew 18:15-17 is often read as a rule about discipline, and it is. It is also a rule about information. Read it again with that in mind.

First, the matter is between "you and him alone". The person who has been wronged goes to the one who did wrong, privately. Nobody else knows yet. The aim is stated in the verse: "you have gained back your brother." The purpose is restoration, not punishment, and privacy serves it, because a person who is not being watched has more room to listen.

Second, if that fails, "one or two more" are taken along. The group grows by the smallest amount. These people are witnesses, so that "every word may be established", and they are also companions to the process.

Only then does the matter go to the assembly. The verse that follows says that if the person refuses even the assembly, he is to be treated as an outsider. We will come back to this verse in Lecture 1-4, because the way a congregation handles a public matter is a hard question of its own.

For now, notice the pattern: the circle widens only when a smaller circle has failed, and it widens only as far as it must. That is an ancient form of what this course will call the smallest circle that serves the purpose. It is not a modern invention bolted onto scripture. It is already here.

It is worth saying what Matthew 18 does not authorise. It does not say that every sin must be taken to the congregation if the person refuses to repent. It does not say that a pastor who learns something in private must take it to a group. It describes one kind of case, a sin by one believer against another, and a method for that case. When a person confides something to a minister, the passage does not tell the minister to pass it on at the first sign of difficulty.

4. Confession and carrying: the community that knows

James 5:16 says: confess your offences to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed. Galatians 6:1-2 speaks of restoring a person who is caught in a fault, "in a spirit of gentleness", and of bearing one another's burdens.

"Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1 (WEB)

These verses have shaped the life of the church. They justify the practice of a small group that speaks honestly, of a minister who hears a private confession, of a friend to whom you can say what you did. They also assume that something is said to someone. A burden cannot be carried by a person who has not been told that it exists.

But look at who confesses to whom. "To one another." The text does not describe a person's offences being collected by an office and announced. It describes people choosing, in trust, to speak. The confessing is the confessor's act. If a congregation wants to build a culture of confession, it must keep in mind that what is said in such a culture is only as safe as the listener's discretion. When a confession becomes material for the next conversation, people stop confessing, or they confess only what is harmless. That is not healing; it is theatre.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some traditions, including many congregational and house-church communities, understand James 5:16 as a call for fairly open mutual confession among members, with the expectation that what is shared is held by the group for the sake of prayer and accountability. Others, including Catholic, Orthodox and many Lutheran and Anglican practices, place confession in private before a priest or pastor, with a strict duty of silence, and understand openness before the whole body to be a different thing. Reformed and Baptist churches differ among themselves, with weight on trust and church order. Each has a serious reason. The open tradition says that burdens carried alone are too heavy and that a community which never hears its members' failures cannot love them truly. The private tradition says that exposure before many can crush the very person it means to heal, and that a sure silence is what makes honest confession possible. This course does not rank them. It asks every tradition for the same minimum: no one is made to speak, what is said is held for the purpose it was said, and no one is exposed by carelessness.

5. Shame in the garden and in the temple court

Two scenes in scripture show how shame works, and how God treats it.

In Genesis 3, after the man and woman have eaten, their eyes are opened.

"Their eyes were opened, and they both knew that they were naked. They sewed fig leaves together, and made coverings for themselves." — Genesis 3:7 (WEB)

They hide. God comes and calls out a question.

"Yahweh God called to the man, and said to him, “Where are you?”" — Genesis 3:9 (WEB)

"The man said, “I heard your voice in the garden, and I was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid myself.”" — Genesis 3:10 (WEB)

The man's answer shows that his fear and his shame are tied together: "I was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid myself." Shame makes a person hide. A church that wants to be a place where people come out of hiding must see that, and it must see that how it receives what it learns will decide whether anyone comes forward again.

The same chapter has a detail that we will meet again in Chapter 6. After the verses of judgement, God makes clothing for the couple and clothes them. We will not lean on that verse here, but note that the story does not end with exposure.

The second scene is in John 8. A woman is brought into the temple court by those who say she was caught in adultery. They set her in the middle, in front of everyone, as a test for Jesus. Her shame is being used as an instrument. Jesus answers with a sentence.

"But when they continued asking him, he looked up and said to them, “He who is without sin among you, let him throw the first stone at her.”"

The accusers leave one by one. Then:

"Jesus, standing up, saw her and said, “Woman, where are your accusers? Did no one condemn you?”" — John 8:10 (WEB)

"She said, “No one, Lord.” Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go your way. From now on, sin no more.”" — John 8:11 (WEB)

Several things are worth seeing here. First, the crowd's interest was not in her. It was in using her case to trap him. A person's exposure can serve other people's purposes and have nothing to do with their good. Second, Jesus does not use the occasion to reveal anything further. He does not ask her to say more, and he does not announce her record to those who remain. Third, he does not pretend nothing happened: "Sin no more." The scene holds judgement and mercy, and it does so in private, "Jesus was left alone with the woman."

It is fair to add a note on method. This passage is a story about a particular woman and a particular crowd, and it is not a rule about church records. We use it as a picture of how Jesus handles a person's exposure, not as a manual. A reader who wants a text for every question will not find one here.

6. Hidden things come to light: reading Luke 12:2-3

The strongest argument against everything said so far is Luke 12:2-3. Nothing covered up will not be revealed, and what is whispered in inner rooms will be proclaimed on the housetops. Does that mean secrets are, in the end, a mistake?

The context helps. Jesus is speaking to disciples, and the verse just before warns against the "yeast of the Pharisees, which is hypocrisy". The point is that a double life will not last, and that those who speak the truth openly need not fear what is said against them in secret. It is a promise about what will finally be seen, by God, and about the disciples' own words, which will be heard. It is not a command to dig up other people's private matters.

A person could still say: if everything will come to light, why strain to guard anything? The answer is that "God will reveal it in his time" is a very different claim from "I may reveal it now". A church member who tells herself that she is only helping the light along is doing something that scripture does not command. In some communities, reasoning of this kind has been used to justify prying and public shaming. Put the text alongside Matthew 18 and Proverbs 25, and it asks something quite different: live so that nothing you hide is shameful, and do not make yourself the one who unveils what others hide.

There is a fair opposing view, and it should be stated in its strongest form. Some communities have suffered because secrets were kept for the sake of reputation: abuse concealed, leaders protected, victims silenced. In those places, "what is hidden will be known" is a cry for justice, and the plea for confidentiality has been used as a shield. This is true and serious. It is why this course will insist, in Lecture 1-2, that confidence has limits, and that safety comes before secrecy. A confidence is not a cover. The question is always what is being kept, from whom, and for whose sake.

7. "Sharing for the sake of prayer"

There is one form of speech that deserves a name early, because it will return, especially in Lecture 3-2. It is the sharing of a person's trouble in the name of prayer.

(An invented case.) Marta is a group leader. A young woman in the group, Elena, tells her in confidence that her father has lost his job and has started drinking. After the meeting Marta mentions it to two friends in the church. "I only told them so they could pray," she says. She truly believes it. One of the two repeats it to another friend, "so she can pray too". By the end of the week, Elena's father is the subject of kind and concerned talk in a dozen houses. Elena stops coming to the group.

Nothing in this chain required malice. At every step, someone thought that praying was good. And praying is good. But look at what was decided without her: who would know, how far it would go, and how long it would last. The story was hers. The one point at which she was asked was the first, and what she was asked was only to tell Marta.

The test is simple to say and sometimes hard to keep. If you want to share a person's trouble in order to pray, ask the person first: may I tell anyone, whom, and in what words? If they say no, you can still pray alone, by name, in silence. God does not need to be briefed. And if the person is not able to be asked, share the minimum with the minimum number of people. Lecture 3-2 will return to this at length.

8. What these texts ask of us together

Taken together, the texts argue for a set of dispositions, which we will build on through the course.

A person's trouble is theirs before it is the church's. A confidence is a thing entrusted, and the keeper's task is to keep it. Where a matter must go wider, the circle grows only by as much as the purpose requires, and the person is part of the decision wherever that can be done. A community should be a place where it is safe to tell the truth, and what makes it safe is not a rule against speaking but a habit of care in what is done with what is spoken. And where hidden harm is real, the keeping of a secret may not be allowed to shelter it.

It would be too neat to say that scripture teaches one policy on this. It does not. What it gives is a set of pictures and warnings, and we are drawing from them a pattern that we find wise. Where you see the pattern, treat it as our argument, which you may test against the texts.


Diagram 1. Two goods and the circle that widens

Two goods that scripture holds together A community that bears burdens, and a person who is not exposed A community that knows and bears Gal 6:2, Jas 5:16: carry one another. Risk if alone: the person is left unsupported and hidden. A person who is not exposed Prov 11:13, John 8: keep what is told. Risk if alone: the person is shamed and stops telling the truth. tension Matthew 18: the circle widens only as far as it must You and him alone first step One or two more if that fails The assembly last, and only then Caution: "I only told them so they could pray" is still telling. Ask the person first. Safety comes before secrecy where someone may be harmed (Lecture 1-2).

In short

  • Scripture holds two goods in tension: a community that knows and bears burdens, and a person's protection from being exposed. Neither cancels the other.
  • Proverbs treats passing on a confidence as a betrayal even when what is passed on is true; trust is the condition of pastoral work.
  • Matthew 18 widens the circle only when a smaller one fails, and only by as little as needed.
  • Confession is the confessor's own act; a culture of confession is only as safe as the listener's discretion.
  • "Sharing for the sake of prayer" is a common form of gossip. Ask the person first.
Front Back
Topic How scripture treats keeping and betraying a confidence, and how a community can both know its members and protect them.
Remember Two goods are held together: a community that bears burdens, and a person who is not exposed. The circle widens only as far as the purpose needs.
Caution "Sharing for the sake of prayer" is a common form of gossip. Hidden things coming to light is God's work, not a licence to expose.
One line to carry into ministry Before telling anyone what you were told, ask the person whose story it is.
Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Proverbs 11:13 does not say that the talebearer tells lies. Why does that matter for how you think about gossip that is "only true"?
  • In Matthew 18:15-17 the circle widens step by step. Think of a situation in a church you know, in general terms and without names, where it widened too fast. What was lost?
  • Which tradition's account of confession in this lecture is closest to your own? State the strongest reason for the one you are furthest from.
  • In John 8, the woman is brought forward to serve someone else's purpose. Where might a person's trouble be used for a purpose that is not their good in a church today?
  • How would you explain to a well-meaning friend why "I only shared it so we could pray" can still harm someone, without making the friend feel accused?
  • Luke 12:2-3 says hidden things will be made known. How might that verse be misused, and how might it rightly comfort someone who has been wronged?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.