Lecture 1-2: What Online Can and Cannot Do
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Letters Across the Distance
- Lecture 1-2: What Online Can and Cannot Do
- Lecture 1-3: Depth and Limits of Online Relationships
- Lecture 1-4: Mapping My Online Places
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Online Place
- Lecture 2-1: Purpose, Size and Rhythm
- Lecture 2-2: Welcome and Hosting
- Lecture 2-3: Sharing the Word Online
- Lecture 2-4: Writing a First-Gathering Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Gathering Plan
- Lecture 3-1: Honesty in What We Share
- Lecture 3-2: Video, Short Posts and Social Media: Uses and Limits
- Lecture 3-3: Comments, Quarrels and Criticism
- Lecture 3-4: Checking a Post Before I Send It
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Write and Check a Short Post
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Online
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Recording and Consent
- Lecture 4-3: Harassment, Harmful Content, Unsafe Contact
- Lecture 4-4: Our Safety Agreement
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Find the Gaps in a Safety Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: The Digital Divide and Access
- Lecture 5-2: Balance with Gathering in Person
- Lecture 5-3: Screens, Comparison, Notifications: Practising Restraint
- Lecture 5-4: Who Is Missing, and My Own Rest
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Find Who Is Missing; Plan My Rest
Most arguments about online ministry are really arguments between two exaggerations. One says that online gathering can do everything a room can do. The other says that it can do nothing worth doing. Both are easy to defend with a story, and both are wrong in ways that hurt real people.
This lecture sets out a more honest list. Online contact is good at some things and weak at others, and different kinds of online contact are good at different things. A leader who knows the list can choose the right means for a purpose. A leader who does not know it will use whichever means is nearest and then wonder why the group feels thin.
What these 14 minutes give you
- Name four strengths of online contact and four weaknesses.
- Describe four kinds of online gathering and say what each does best.
- Choose a suitable kind of contact for a stated purpose, and explain the choice.
- Explain why some situations, such as deep grief or serious conflict, should not be carried only online.
- Say who is easily left out when a group depends on one kind of contact.
Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance." — Proverbs 27:17
World English Bible
They continued steadfastly in the apostles’ teaching and fellowship, in the breaking of bread, and prayer." — Acts 2:42
WEB
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
WEB
Proverbs speaks of what happens between two people who stay in contact. Acts describes a community held together by teaching, fellowship, shared meals and prayer. Romans asks for a very ordinary skill: to rejoice and weep alongside others. These are read here as principles about what a community needs, not as rules about any medium.
1. Four strengths
Reach. A person who lives far away, who cannot travel, who works at odd hours, or whose community is small can still be part of a conversation. A group scattered over several countries can pray at the same hour. For a believer who is the only one of their church in a town, a regular contact may be the thing that keeps faith alive.
Access. Some people find it easier to take part from home: a parent with small children, a person with a long illness, someone who cannot climb stairs. Some people who are shy or anxious find it easier to speak when they are not in a crowded room. (Access also has a dark side, which lecture 5-1 takes up: the same tools leave out people who have no device, no signal, no money or no confidence with them.)
Records. A message can be read again. A recorded talk can be heard twice. A shared note of the passage and the prayer requests means that someone who missed the meeting can catch up. Records help people who learn slowly, people who listen in a second language, and people who work shifts.
Light contact. Between meetings a short message can say "I am thinking of you" at almost no cost. Ministry is often made of small acts repeated, and online tools make small acts easy.
2. Four weaknesses
Missed body signals. In a room you notice that someone has not spoken, has red eyes, shifts in a chair, is about to leave. Through a screen you may see a face and miss the rest, or see nothing at all. Through text you may see only words, and words can be read in the wrong tone.
Silence is hard to read. In a room silence is part of the conversation. Online, silence may mean thinking, a poor connection, a child in the room, a person who has left the call, or a person in trouble. You often cannot tell which.
Weight is hard to carry. Deep grief, fear, anger and serious conflict ask for faces, time and often touch. They can also ask for a trained person. A person who has lost a child is not helped by a group message with a heart symbol, however kindly meant.
Shared life is thin. A table, a meal, a walk to a car, the washing-up afterward: much of what holds a community together happens at the edges of the meeting. A screen has no edges. When people call a group "real," they often mean that they have shared the edges.
3. Two things the weaknesses do not mean
Do not conclude that online contact is shallow, or that it must be avoided. That is the exaggeration on the other side, and lecture 1-3 looks at it directly. The list says only that each means of contact has a shape, and a wise leader fits the purpose to the shape.
Do not conclude either that the weaknesses can be solved by better equipment. Some of them can be eased by habit: asking people how they are, checking in privately afterward, leaving room for silence. Others belong to the medium itself.
4. Four kinds of online gathering
The tools change quickly. The kinds do not. We will describe four, using plain names.
| Kind | What it does best | What it does poorly |
|---|---|---|
| Live video (everyone sees and hears each other at the same time) | Warmth, faces, turn-taking, praying together at the same time | Needs a steady connection and a device; tiring; hard in large groups; easy to exclude |
| Live voice (a call without pictures) | Simple, low data, works for people who dislike being seen or who have poor connections | No faces; harder to tell who is speaking; harder to read mood |
| Text conversation (a messaging group) | Light daily contact, time to think, a record, people in different time zones | Tone is lost; a long thread is hard to follow; can run late at night; the quiet vanish |
| Recorded word (a talk or reading that people watch or hear when they can) | Teaching that can be repeated, access at any hour, reaching those who cannot attend | One-way; no response; the speaker cannot see anyone |
Notice what the table does not say. It does not say that any kind is the best. It says that each is good for something.
5. Choosing by purpose
Here is how a leader might think. (An invented example.) A small group of seven adults has met in person for years. Two members have moved away and one is housebound after surgery. The leader wants to know how to keep them all together. She lists what the group needs.
- To pray and read together once a week. A live meeting with voice and, if people wish, video suits this. The housebound member can join. A written summary goes to anyone who missed it.
- To stay in light contact between meetings. A text group, kept small, with a simple agreement about hours.
- To support a member whose husband has died. This should not be handled in the group chat. The leader and one other member visit, or at least telephone her, and ask what she needs.
- To share a short teaching with those who live in a place with weak signal. A recorded word, available in a form that downloads easily, and a printed copy for the one member who has no device.
In four needs, the leader has used four different means, and in one of them she has chosen to go beyond a screen. That is what skill looks like here: not "which tool" but "which purpose, and so which tool."
6. What to move out of the screen
Some matters should not be carried by an ordinary group channel, whatever its quality.
- Deep grief and loss. Go to the person, call them, sit with them.
- Serious conflict between members. Meet the people concerned privately, in person where possible, and with another trusted person present.
- Danger. If someone says they are thinking of ending their life, or tells of being harmed by another person, the group is not the place to handle it. Lecture 4-3 and lecture 6-1 deal with the order of response. In short: move toward a responsible person, a pastor, a qualified professional, and the local emergency number if the danger is now.
- Confidences. Anything told in trust should not be passed around a group.
None of this says that online contact is unworthy. It says that some things need a face, and some need a trained helper.
7. Who is easily left out
When a group chooses one kind of contact, it chooses who can join. Live video leaves out those without a steady connection or a device. Text leaves out those who cannot read well or whose first language is another. Voice leaves out the hard of hearing. Recorded words leave out those who need to be answered. The older, the poor, the disabled and the anxious are the people most likely to be missed.
A good habit is to ask of every plan: "Who can this not reach?" and to prepare, in advance, a second way. A printed summary, a telephone call, a visit and a trusted person who passes the news on are all legitimate second ways. Lecture 5-1 returns to this at length.
Diagram 1. Four kinds of gathering, by strength
In short
- Online contact has four strengths: reach, access, records and light contact; it has four weaknesses: missed body signals, unreadable silence, difficulty carrying heavy things, and thin shared life.
- Four kinds of gathering, live video, live voice, text and recorded word, are each good for different purposes.
- Choose the means by the purpose, not by habit or convenience.
- Deep grief, serious conflict, danger and confidences should be moved toward a person, not carried by a group channel.
- Every choice of means leaves someone out; ask who cannot be reached, and prepare a second way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four strengths | Reach, access, records, light contact. |
| Four weaknesses | Missed body signals; silence that cannot be read; heavy things are hard to carry; thin shared life. |
| Four kinds | Live video, live voice, text conversation, recorded word. |
| What moves out of the screen? | Deep grief, serious conflict, danger and confidences go toward a person. |
One sentence to remember Online contact is not good or bad as a whole; each kind has a shape, and a wise leader fits the purpose to the shape.
This week's action For one group you belong to, list its needs and match each to a kind of contact, then name who that choice leaves out.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four strengths has helped you or someone you know? Which weakness has caught you out?
- Think of a time when silence in a message group or call troubled you. What might it have meant?
- In the invented example, the leader chose to visit the widow rather than use the group chat. What reasons might she have had?
- Which kind of online gathering do you use most? Which kind do you avoid, and why?
- For a group you know, answer honestly: who can the current way of meeting not reach?