Lecture 4-4: Our Safety Agreement
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Letters Across the Distance
- Lecture 1-2: What Online Can and Cannot Do
- Lecture 1-3: Depth and Limits of Online Relationships
- Lecture 1-4: Mapping My Online Places
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Online Place
- Lecture 2-1: Purpose, Size and Rhythm
- Lecture 2-2: Welcome and Hosting
- Lecture 2-3: Sharing the Word Online
- Lecture 2-4: Writing a First-Gathering Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Gathering Plan
- Lecture 3-1: Honesty in What We Share
- Lecture 3-2: Video, Short Posts and Social Media: Uses and Limits
- Lecture 3-3: Comments, Quarrels and Criticism
- Lecture 3-4: Checking a Post Before I Send It
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Write and Check a Short Post
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Online
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Recording and Consent
- Lecture 4-3: Harassment, Harmful Content, Unsafe Contact
- Lecture 4-4: Our Safety Agreement
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Find the Gaps in a Safety Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: The Digital Divide and Access
- Lecture 5-2: Balance with Gathering in Person
- Lecture 5-3: Screens, Comparison, Notifications: Practising Restraint
- Lecture 5-4: Who Is Missing, and My Own Rest
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Find Who Is Missing; Plan My Rest
The first three lectures of this week gave principles: how to protect children, how to protect privacy, how to respond to harm. Principles in a leader's head are useful, but they have a weakness. When the leader is ill, or away, or new, the principles are not there. When trouble comes, people disagree about what was promised. When a newcomer asks, "What are the rules here?", there is nothing to show.
A safety agreement is a short, written statement of how a gathering looks after its people. It turns private good intentions into shared, visible promises. It is not a legal document and it is not a way of avoiding responsibility. It is a page that says: this is how we treat one another, this is who to tell, and this is what we will do when something goes wrong.
This lecture sets out the parts of a good one-page agreement and the habits that keep it alive. Lecture 4-5 is a Practice Lab in which you look for the gaps in an invented agreement.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Name the eight parts of a one-page safety agreement.
- Explain why an agreement should be short, plain and written with its members.
- Write one section of an agreement in clear, positive language.
- Explain how members agree to it, and how it is kept alive.
- Say why an agreement can never replace the judgement and care of the people who use it.
Yahweh answered me, “Write the vision, and make it plain on tablets, that he who runs may read it." — Habakkuk 2:2
World English Bible
Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory." — Proverbs 11:14
WEB
Let all things be done decently and in order." — 1 Corinthians 14:40
WEB
These passages are read as principles: that what matters should be written plainly enough to be read quickly, that wise counsel protects a community, and that good order serves people. They say nothing about any particular technology.
1. What an agreement is for
An agreement does four things.
- It tells people what to expect. A newcomer, a parent, a young person, an older member who is nervous about the technology: each can see what kind of place this is.
- It makes the leaders accountable. A leader who has promised "two adults will always be present" can be asked whether that was done. A leader who has only intended it cannot.
- It gives words to the person who needs to speak. A member who is worried finds it easier to say, "The agreement says to tell the responsible person, so I am telling you," than to say, "I am sorry to make trouble."
- It settles disagreement before it starts. When a rule was agreed in calm, it is easier to keep in a storm.
An agreement does not make a gathering safe by existing. A page that nobody reads, or that leaders do not keep, is worse than no page, because it makes people believe they are protected. We return to this below.
2. The eight parts
A good one-page agreement has eight short parts. Each can be written in a few lines.
1. Who we are and what this is for. The name of the gathering, its purpose in a sentence, and who it is for. This tells people what they are joining and keeps the agreement from being used for something else.
2. Who leads, and who is the responsible person. The names of the hosts. The name and way to reach the responsible person: the one to whom concerns are brought, who is not a host of this group when the concern is about a host. A reader should not have to ask who this is.
3. Children and young people. The principles of lecture 4-1 in the community's own words: no private one-to-one contact, two responsible adults, parents informed, reviewable channels, no requests for personal details, concerns reported. If no children or young people take part, say so, and say what will happen if one asks to join.
4. Privacy, recording and sharing. The five promises of lecture 4-2. Whether meetings are recorded and how people will be asked. That nothing is shared outside the group without agreement. That confidence has limits when someone is in danger.
5. How we treat one another. A few positive sentences about conduct: we speak truthfully and kindly, we listen, we may disagree without insult, we do not mock or pressure anyone. And what the hosts may do if this is broken: mute, remove, close the meeting, report.
6. If something goes wrong. The order of response from lecture 4-3, in short form: who to tell, what to keep, and what happens next. Include one line that says plainly: if someone is in danger now, call the local emergency number; if someone may harm themselves, tell the responsible person at once and do not handle it in the group. Include the local emergency number for your place, written by someone who has checked it.
7. Who might be left out. A short promise about access. How a person without a device, a good connection or confidence with the technology can still take part or be cared for. How a person who must stay hidden for safety can join, with the camera off or a different name. This part matters because a safety agreement that treats only the people who are already online is a safety agreement for some.
8. How this is agreed, kept and changed. How members say yes. Who reads it again, and how often. How anyone can propose a change. The date it was last reviewed.
Eight parts on one page will each be short. That is the aim. If any part needs a page of its own, put the longer text in a separate document and keep the page.
3. Writing it so that it is read
Habakkuk was told to "make it plain on tablets, that he who runs may read it." The measure of a safety agreement is whether a busy, anxious or tired person can read it quickly and know what to do. A few habits help.
Keep it to one page. If it is longer, few will read it, and fewer will remember it.
Use plain words and short sentences. Many of your members read in a second language. Avoid words that need a lawyer or a dictionary.
Say what we do, not only what we fear. "We keep two adults present at all times" is clearer and kinder than "Adults must not be alone with children or this will lead to action."
Write in the community's own voice. "We" and "our" invite members in. "Users must" and "violations will" keep them out.
Do not quote laws. Laws differ between places and change over time. Write: "We follow local law and our community's written rules." Leave the specifics to those who know them, and have someone who does check the page.
Put it where people can find it. The invitation to a meeting should link to it or print it. Read the main points aloud at the start of the first meeting, and again when newcomers arrive. Keep a printed copy for people who prefer paper or have no device.
Offer it in the languages your members speak.
Let us look at one section, before and after. (An invented example.)
Before: "Members are prohibited from engaging in conduct that may be construed as harassment and any violation will be dealt with in accordance with the rules."
After: "We speak to one another kindly and truthfully. We do not mock, pressure or follow anyone. If this is broken, a host may mute or remove the person, and the matter goes to our responsible person. If you are hurt by something here, tell us. You will not be blamed."
The second version says what to do, who decides and what a hurt person can expect. It is also shorter in meaning, although longer in words, because nothing in it has to be interpreted.
4. Writing it with the people it is for
An agreement imposed from above is easily ignored. One written with members is more likely to be kept, because they own it. A few ways to involve people:
- Draft it with the hosts and at least one member who is not a leader.
- Where young people take part, ask the parents and, in words they can follow, the young people, what would make them feel safe.
- Ask someone who has found online gatherings difficult, for example an older member or one who speaks the community's language as a second language, to read it and say what is unclear.
- Ask a person who understands the local rules on safeguarding and privacy to check it.
Wise counsel is a form of protection: "in the multitude of counselors there is victory." An agreement written by one person is one person's view of safety. One written by several is nearer to everyone's.
5. How members agree
A long form with boxes to tick is a poor way to agree to anything. People tick without reading and feel no obligation.
A better way is simpler. At the first meeting, the host reads the main points aloud in a minute or two and asks, "Is everyone willing to meet like this?" Members answer in their own way: a spoken yes, a written yes or a nod. Someone who is not willing says so, and the host talks with them. For parents, the invitation contains the page, and the leader asks them to say yes before the young person joins.
An agreement is a place where people say what they will do, and then do it.
6. Keeping it alive
An agreement is a living thing, and it can die of neglect. Three practices keep it alive.
- Read it again at set times. Many communities review at a regular point in the year, and after any serious incident. Put a date on the page.
- Keep what you promised. If you say that two adults will always be present, and one evening only one can come, the meeting waits. This is the moment that shows whether the page is real.
- Learn from what happens. When something goes wrong or nearly goes wrong, ask what the agreement said and whether it was enough. Change it if it was not.
7. What an agreement cannot do
Last, the limits. A safety agreement cannot:
- Replace judgement. No page foresees every situation. A host who meets a case it does not cover must still think, ask and act with care.
- Make a dangerous person safe. A person who intends harm will not be stopped by a page. The protections, such as two adults, open channels and honest reporting, are what make harm difficult.
- Take the place of local law or professional help. It sits beside them.
- Be used to hide a failure. "It was in the agreement" is not an answer to a person who was hurt.
An agreement is a promise that a community makes to its members. Its value is the keeping of it.
Diagram 1. The eight parts of a one-page safety agreement
In short
- An agreement tells people what to expect, makes leaders accountable, gives words to the one who must speak, and settles disagreement in advance.
- Eight parts: who we are; who leads and the responsible person; children and young people; privacy and recording; how we treat one another; if something goes wrong; who might be left out; how it is agreed, kept and changed.
- Keep it to one page, in plain words, in the community's own voice, saying what we do and not only what we fear.
- Do not quote laws. Write that you follow local law and your community's written rules, and have someone who knows them check the page.
- Members agree by a spoken or written yes, not a long form. Read it again at set times.
- An agreement cannot replace judgement, local law or professional help, and it is worth only as much as it is kept.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four uses of an agreement | Tells people what to expect; makes leaders accountable; gives words to the one who must speak; settles disagreement early. |
| The eight parts | Who we are; leaders and responsible person; children; privacy; conduct; if something goes wrong; who might be left out; agreed, kept, changed. |
| How to write it | One page, plain words, our own voice, what we do, no quoted laws. |
| Its limit | It cannot replace judgement, local law or help, and is worth only as much as it is kept. |
One sentence to remember An agreement is a promise a community makes to its members, and its value is in the keeping.
This week's action Write one section of an agreement, such as "If something goes wrong", in five plain sentences or fewer.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The lecture gives four things an agreement does. Which one matters most in a group you know? Why?
- Which of the eight parts do you think communities most often leave out? What would be lost?
- Rewrite one stiff sentence from a rule you have seen, in plain and positive words.
- Who in your community should be asked to read a draft before it is finished? Why them?
- Why does the lecture prefer a spoken "yes" to a long form with boxes to tick?
- Part 7 is about people who might be left out. Who, in your community, would be left out by an agreement that assumes everyone has a device and a good connection?