FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM306E Digital Discipleship and Online Ministry

Lecture 5-2: Balance with Gathering in Person

Contents 31
LM306E Digital Discipleship and Online Ministry
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Door, Not a Master
  1. Introduction: A Door, Not a Master
Chapter 1 · Week 1: People Behind the Screen
  1. Lecture 1-1: Letters Across the Distance
  2. Lecture 1-2: What Online Can and Cannot Do
  3. Lecture 1-3: Depth and Limits of Online Relationships
  4. Lecture 1-4: Mapping My Online Places
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Online Place
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Building an Online Gathering
  1. Lecture 2-1: Purpose, Size and Rhythm
  2. Lecture 2-2: Welcome and Hosting
  3. Lecture 2-3: Sharing the Word Online
  4. Lecture 2-4: Writing a First-Gathering Plan
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Gathering Plan
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Sharing Faith by Video and Writing
  1. Lecture 3-1: Honesty in What We Share
  2. Lecture 3-2: Video, Short Posts and Social Media: Uses and Limits
  3. Lecture 3-3: Comments, Quarrels and Criticism
  4. Lecture 3-4: Checking a Post Before I Send It
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Write and Check a Short Post
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Safety and Protection
  1. Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Online
  2. Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Recording and Consent
  3. Lecture 4-3: Harassment, Harmful Content, Unsafe Contact
  4. Lecture 4-4: Our Safety Agreement
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Find the Gaps in a Safety Agreement
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Access, Balance, Restraint
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Digital Divide and Access
  2. Lecture 5-2: Balance with Gathering in Person
  3. Lecture 5-3: Screens, Comparison, Notifications: Practising Restraint
  4. Lecture 5-4: Who Is Missing, and My Own Rest
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Find Who Is Missing; Plan My Rest
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Online Ministry for the Long Run
  1. Lecture 6-1: Care and Connecting People
  2. Lecture 6-2: A Leader's Responsibility and Authority
  3. Lecture 6-3: Judging New Tools That Keep Changing
  4. Lecture 6-4: My Plan for the Next Three Months
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Three-Month Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

Sooner or later, every online group has to answer a question that sounds simple. Is what we do here a replacement for gathering in person, or a service to it?

Many people have answered by habit. Some say, "We meet weekly on the screen, so we are a church." Others say, "The screen is only a poor copy; real life is elsewhere." Both answers are shorter than the truth, and both leave someone out.

This lecture does three things. It sets out, fairly, how Christians who love Scripture and each other answer the question differently. It then names the minimum that this course asks of every reader whatever their tradition. And it turns to practical care: the member who lives far from any gathering, the member who cannot travel, the member who has drifted into watching without belonging.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • State fairly at least three different answers to the question whether online gathering can stand in for gathering in person.
  • State the common minimum this course asks of every leader, and say why it is less than any one tradition asks.
  • Describe how to help an online-only member find a community near them without pressure and without drawing members away from their own congregation.
  • Describe care for people who cannot travel, and name times when care or a sacrament (a sacred act such as baptism or communion) calls for presence.
  • Recognise the habits of a consumer of online content and how a leader can invite a member beyond them.

Let us consider how to provoke one another to love and good works, not forsaking our own assembling together, as the custom of some is, but exhorting one another; and so much the more, as you see the Day approaching." — Hebrews 10:24-25

World English Bible

Day by day, continuing steadfastly with one accord in the temple, and breaking bread at home, they took their food with gladness and singleness of heart," — Acts 2:46

WEB

Therefore, my brothers, when you come together to eat, wait for one another." — 1 Corinthians 11:33

WEB

Christians read these passages in different ways. The first two describe a community that meets, encourages and shares food. The third gives an instruction about how to come together to eat. None of them was written about a screen, and this course does not use any of them as proof that online gathering is allowed or that it is forbidden. They are read here as principles about what gathering is for: encouragement, shared life and care for one another.

1. Two short answers, and why neither is enough

Start with the two answers heard most often.

"Online is a real church." The strength of this answer is that it takes seriously what people actually experience. Prayer happens. Scripture is read. A lonely person is greeted by name. People who would otherwise be alone for the whole week receive a kind word. To call all of that "not real" would be unkind and untrue.

"Online is only a copy." The strength of this answer is that it takes seriously what a body is. People eat together. They touch hands. They sit beside the dying. They carry a coffin. The Word became flesh (John 1:14), and Christians have always thought that something about the faith cannot be done at a distance.

Each answer is right about something. Each, if it is the only answer, hurts someone. The first can quietly tell the person who cannot come that they have lost nothing, when they have. The second can quietly tell the person who can only come by screen that what they have is worthless, when it is not.

2. Where traditions stand

Readers will not agree here

This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is whether online gathering can be the same as gathering in person: whether it can be a church, whether it can carry worship, and whether the sacraments can be received through it. (A , or in some traditions an , is a sacred act such as baptism or communion.)

Some traditions, notably Catholic and Orthodox ones and many others that hold that the Eucharist (communion, the Lord's Supper) is received by people who are physically gathered, with a bishop or a priest, hold that the sacrament and the life of a parish (a local church community) need people to be physically present. For them, following a service on a screen can be a real help to prayer, especially for the sick or those far away, but it is not the same thing as taking part, and it does not replace the gathering. They would say a community is formed around an altar and not around a signal.

Other traditions, among them many Protestant, Pentecostal and independent churches, hold that a church is the people who gather in the name of Christ and that what matters is that they are really together in him. Some in these traditions say that an online group meeting to pray, read Scripture and care for one another is a true gathering, and may be a church or part of one, particularly where distance, illness, law or danger makes meeting in person very hard. Others in the same traditions are more cautious: they welcome online meetings as a good addition but think a community should also gather in person, because baptism, the Lord's Supper and mutual care need bodies.

Still others hold something between the two: that online gatherings are a real expression of fellowship but are not the whole of it, and that they should lead toward meeting when meeting is possible. In some places, believers have only a screen or a letter to hold them together, and nobody should tell them that what they have is worthless.

What this course requires is less than any of these positions requires. It requires only this: online gathering is never taught as making bodily fellowship unnecessary, and those who cannot gather in person are not abandoned. Beyond that, leaders will follow the teaching of their own tradition, and this course does not rank them.

A leader should know where their own tradition stands, in writing if possible, and should not claim for the group more than that tradition allows. A leader should also not speak harshly of another tradition's answer. A Catholic member and a Pentecostal member in the same online group may mean very different things by "church". The task is not to settle that dispute in a chat room but to be honest about what the group is.

3. Saying honestly what the group is

A practical test makes the question less abstract. Complete these sentences for your own group, and write the answers down.

  • "We are a ______" (for example, a study group, a prayer circle, a part of a parish, a branch of a congregation, a group of friends).
  • "We are not a ______" (for example, a replacement for worship, a place where sacraments are given, a church in itself).
  • "The people who belong to a congregation near them are connected to it by ______."
  • "If someone needs a sacrament, a hospital visit or a funeral, they will be put in touch with ______."

A group that can fill in these lines honestly is much less likely to drift into confusion. It also does not mislead its members. Someone who joins a "church" online and believes that everything a church does is happening there may later find that something they thought was covered was not.

4. Connecting online-only members to a local community

Online groups often include people who live far from you and whom you may never meet. Some of them belong to a congregation. Some belong to none. Some have left one, perhaps after being hurt. A leader should hold a few simple habits.

Ask, without pressing. "Is there a community where you live that you are part of, or would like to be?" is a good question. It is asked once, kindly, and the answer is accepted. A person is not obliged to explain.

Do not take someone away from where they already belong. If a member belongs to a parish, a congregation or a fellowship near them, the online leader supports that. The online group is not a rival. A leader who, even without meaning to, makes the online group more exciting than the member's own congregation does harm.

Help find a community, if the member wants it. The leader can say, "I do not know your area, but I can ask someone in our wider network" or "Your own church's website or office may be able to help". A leader should not recommend one named congregation to a stranger unless they know it to be safe, and they should not hand a person's contact details to anyone without that person's agreement.

Remember that some cannot. There are members for whom no community of their kind exists within reach. Some live where their faith is not tolerated. Some live in small places where nothing of their tradition exists. For them, the online group may be very large. A leader should honour that, and should connect them to other believers in the same situation if it can be done safely, and with care for their safety, never by publishing their names or places.

Do not count them as yours. An online group is not a flock to be counted, and the leader should not keep the member in the group merely to keep numbers up. If the person finds a place near them and slowly leaves, that is a good ending.

5. People who cannot travel

Some members cannot come in person: the sick, the very old, the disabled, the carers who cannot leave someone, those in prison or in hospital, the people whose daily life is walled in by distance or danger. For them the screen is not a convenience but a door that was otherwise shut.

A leader's task here has two sides. First, the screen should be used generously. Offer the door (lecture 5-1), and do not make anyone feel a burden. Second, the screen must not be allowed to become an excuse for not coming to them. A person who cannot travel is not helped most by a better video link. They are helped most by someone who comes, or by someone who sends someone. The point of the link is to carry the community to the person, and the point of a visit is to remind the person they are known with a body and a face.

For sacraments and ordinances, practice differs by tradition. Some traditions bring communion to the sick at home or in hospital by a priest, a or an authorised lay person. Some provide a pastor to pray beside a bed. Some give counsel only in person. A leader who is not clergy does not decide these matters. Their task is to tell the right person: the priest, the pastor or the responsible leader, in good time, and with the person's agreement.

6. Times when presence is called for

Nobody can give a complete list that every tradition would accept, but there are moments that nearly every tradition treats as for a person to be present, if at all possible.

  • A serious illness, a death and the days after it.
  • A birth, a baptism or other sacramental or ordinance moment, according to the tradition.
  • A deep grief or a family break.
  • A disagreement that has hurt several people and that needs peace made face to face.
  • A person who has stopped answering messages and who may be in trouble.
  • Any case where there is a sign that someone is not safe (lecture 4-3).

In each case the online group's task is not to replace the person who comes but to send them. A leader's most useful message in such a moment is often short: "I will call you at six. Someone from the congregation near you will come to see you on Thursday. Is that all right?"

7. Watchers and members: the consumer habit

Online life makes it easy to become a consumer. A person can watch a hundred talks without meeting a single member of a congregation. They can choose the speaker whose manner suits them. When the talk becomes dull or the subject becomes hard, they can leave with one click. Nobody follows them up. Nobody knows that they stopped.

This is not a vice peculiar to the young or to the careless. It is the shape the tools give to anyone who uses them without thinking. Notice what is missing in the pattern. Nobody is accountable to anyone. Nobody serves. Nobody is served except by choice. And nobody sits beside someone they would not have picked.

A leader cannot cure this with a rule, but can give invitations:

  • Ask a member to do something small for others, such as reading, greeting, preparing the summary or phoning an absent friend. A person who serves is no longer only a watcher.
  • Invite members to give the group something other than attendance, such as a question or a prayer.
  • Make sure the group knows each other's names, and that people are missed when they are absent.
  • Say, from time to time and without scolding, what the group exists to do: to build up people and lead them toward fellowship that has a body.

8. An invented case

(An invented example.) Priya leads a weekly online Scripture group of about fifteen people. Over a year it has grown. Members live in several countries. Two of them, Daniel and Mei, say the group is "their church".

Priya is happy but uneasy. She does something simple. She writes four short sentences in the group's welcome note: "We are a Scripture study and prayer group. We are not a replacement for worship in a congregation or for the sacraments of your own tradition. If you do not have a community near you, tell me and I will try to help you find one. If you cannot travel, tell me and I will find someone to visit you."

Daniel writes back that he lives an hour from the nearest congregation of his kind and had stopped going. He says nothing more. A month later he says he went. Mei, who lives where her faith is hidden, writes only: "Thank you for saying the first sentence. It helps me not to ask for what cannot be given."

The case shows that honest limits are not cold. They can be a gift to people who are tempted to ask a screen to be what only a body can be, and a comfort to people who have no other choice.


Diagram 1. Serve, not replace

Does the Online Group Serve or Replace? Traditions answer differently; the common minimum is shared Presence is required Sacrament and parish need bodies together; the screen helps prayer, not replaces Both are real Online fellowship is real but not the whole; it should lead toward meeting Online can be a gathering People together in Christ, especially where distance, illness or danger forbid more What this course asks of everyone Never teach that bodily fellowship is unnecessary. Never abandon those who cannot gather. The leader's practice Say what the group is. Send a person to those who cannot come. Point members to a place near them.

In short

  • "Online is a real church" and "online is only a copy" are each right about something and each hurts someone when it is the only answer.
  • Traditions differ on whether online gathering can be a church, can carry worship or can give the sacraments. This course does not rank them.
  • The common minimum: online gathering is never taught as making bodily fellowship unnecessary, and those who cannot gather are not abandoned.
  • A leader says in writing what the group is and is not, and does not draw members away from the community where they already belong.
  • For people who cannot travel, the aim is to carry the community to them; for illness, death and sacramental moments, send a person.
  • Invite watchers to serve: a small task turns a consumer into a member.
Front Back
Where readers will not agree Whether online gathering can be a church, carry worship or give the sacraments.
The common minimum Bodily fellowship is never made unnecessary, and those who cannot gather are not abandoned.
Online-only members Ask once, kindly; do not draw them from where they belong; help them find a place if they wish.
When presence is called for Serious illness, death, sacramental moments, hurt needing peace, a person gone silent. Send a person.

One sentence to remember The online group is there to serve fellowship that has a body, and not to replace it, and it must say honestly what it is.

This week's action Write four lines saying what your group is, what it is not, and who a member should turn to for what only a body can give.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the short answers ("online is a real church" or "online is only a copy") is closer to your own habit of speech? What does it leave out?
  • Why does the lecture say the minimum asked of every leader is smaller than what any single tradition asks?
  • Fill in the four lines in "Saying honestly what the group is" for a group you know.
  • A member says, "Your group is better than the congregation near me." How might a leader respond?
  • Name two times when a leader's best action is to send a person and not to send a link.
  • What small service could you invite a quiet member of an online group to do?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.