Lecture 1-3: Depth and Limits of Online Relationships
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Letters Across the Distance
- Lecture 1-2: What Online Can and Cannot Do
- Lecture 1-3: Depth and Limits of Online Relationships
- Lecture 1-4: Mapping My Online Places
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Online Place
- Lecture 2-1: Purpose, Size and Rhythm
- Lecture 2-2: Welcome and Hosting
- Lecture 2-3: Sharing the Word Online
- Lecture 2-4: Writing a First-Gathering Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Gathering Plan
- Lecture 3-1: Honesty in What We Share
- Lecture 3-2: Video, Short Posts and Social Media: Uses and Limits
- Lecture 3-3: Comments, Quarrels and Criticism
- Lecture 3-4: Checking a Post Before I Send It
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Write and Check a Short Post
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Online
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Recording and Consent
- Lecture 4-3: Harassment, Harmful Content, Unsafe Contact
- Lecture 4-4: Our Safety Agreement
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Find the Gaps in a Safety Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: The Digital Divide and Access
- Lecture 5-2: Balance with Gathering in Person
- Lecture 5-3: Screens, Comparison, Notifications: Practising Restraint
- Lecture 5-4: Who Is Missing, and My Own Rest
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Find Who Is Missing; Plan My Rest
People who talk about online relationships tend to hold one of two stories. In the first, online friendship is shallow, and anyone who says otherwise is fooling himself. In the second, online friendship can be deeper than the ordinary kind, because people feel free to say what they never say in a room. Each story has been true for somebody. Neither is true as a rule.
This lecture does three jobs. It tests the two stories against what we know of people. It looks at honesty, anonymity and the double life, which online contact makes easy. And it asks what separates a contact from a disciple. It also describes honestly a question on which Christians disagree: whether gathering online is the same as gathering in person.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Explain why "online is shallow" and "online is deeper" are both too simple.
- Describe how distance and anonymity can help honesty and how they can harm it.
- Distinguish an online contact from a disciple.
- State fairly the main positions on whether online gathering is the same as gathering in person.
- State the minimum that this course asks of every reader on this question.
Therefore putting away falsehood, speak truth each one with his neighbor. For we are members of one another." — Ephesians 4:25
World English Bible
For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there I am in their midst.”" — Matthew 18:20
WEB
Let us consider how to provoke one another to love and good works, not forsaking our own assembling together, as the custom of some is, but exhorting one another; and so much the more, as you see the Day approaching." — Hebrews 10:24-25
WEB
Ephesians asks for truth between members of one body. Matthew 18:20 and Hebrews 10:24-25 are often quoted in debates about gathering. In this lecture they are read as principles about what a community is for. They are not used to settle whether any online practice counts as the church gathered.
1. Two stories, and what is wrong with each
Story one: online is shallow. The believer in this story has seen people post a cheerful face and say nothing true. He has seen friendships run on short messages and then vanish when one person stops writing. He has also seen people who are active online and absent in the hour of need. His conclusion: the screen produces acquaintances, not friends.
Story two: online can go deeper. The believer in this story has found that she could say, in writing, what she could never say in front of people. A lonely person found someone who listened at midnight. A member who felt stared at in a room could take part in a group where nobody looked at her. Her conclusion: the screen can open a door that the room kept shut.
Both stories contain observations that deserve respect. The mistake is to turn an observation into a rule. Depth does not belong to a medium. It belongs to what two people do over time: how long they keep going, how truthfully they speak, how much they risk, how they act when it is costly. Some people share ten years of life in a room and never say anything true. Some people share a year of careful writing and know each other well. What a screen changes is not whether depth is possible but which kinds of depth are easy and which are hard.
2. What distance helps and what it harms
Distance can help honesty. Some people find it easier to write about fear, doubt or failure than to say it aloud. A person who stammers, who is ashamed, or who has been mocked in groups may speak more freely in text. A leader who knows this will leave room for it.
Distance can also harm honesty. It is easy to show only the best side. It is easy to type something sharp that you would never say face to face. It is easy to disappear. When a person cannot see the other's reaction, the ordinary brakes that keep us gentle are weaker. Ephesians 4:25 says, "putting away falsehood, speak truth each one with his neighbor." The reason it gives is "we are members of one another." Truth in a community is not only a matter of not lying; it is a matter of owing the truth to people who belong to you.
3. Anonymity, hidden names and double lives
Some online spaces ask for no name at all. Some allow a made-up name. Anonymity has two faces.
For some people, a hidden name is a protection. A believer who lives where faith is dangerous, a person escaping harm, or a young person who does not want a family to know yet, may need to use a different name. A leader must not demand that such a person reveal themselves. Safety comes before openness. Ask what the person is comfortable with, and keep what they tell you private.
For other people, a hidden name is a mask for behaviour they would not own in public. A person may be gentle in the group and cruel elsewhere. A person may take on a second identity and a second story, and the group never learns that the second story is invented. This is not a problem of technology; people have lived double lives for as long as there have been towns. But a screen makes the second life cheaper to keep, and so the habit needs naming.
A simple test applies. Would I be willing for the people who know the other side of my life to read what I write here, and would I be willing for these people to read what I write there? If the answer to either is no, something needs attention.
A related matter is being seen. In a room people see our age, our clothes, our tiredness, our children. Through text, they see none of it. That may be a relief. It may also mean that the people who know us here never learn what we carry. If a friendship is to bear weight, at some point the other person needs to see something of the real shape of our life, as far as it is safe to share.
4. A contact is not yet a disciple
A contact is someone with whom you share messages. A disciple, in the sense of this course, is a person who is being built up in faith, with others, over time. A disciple has people who know them, who pray for them, who would notice their absence and who are willing to be corrected and to correct.
The two overlap, but they are not the same. A large number of people may read what a leader posts, and the leader may not know a single one of them. A small group of five who meet each week and know one another's troubles is a smaller thing and a deeper one. Several questions help tell them apart.
- Do these people know one another's names and circumstances?
- Would anyone notice if one of them disappeared for a month?
- Is there someone who can say a hard thing to another, and be heard?
- Is there someone who would sit with another in trouble?
- Is this a group in which a person can grow, or only a place where a person can watch?
If the answer to most is no, you have an audience. That is not wrong, and an audience can be served well. But call it what it is, and do not tell yourself that you are discipling people you do not know.
5. A question on which readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. Is gathering online the same kind of thing as gathering in person? In particular, does a shared act of worship, prayer, or the sacraments, held through a screen, count as the church gathered?
Some Christians say yes, or mostly yes. They hold that Christ's promise to be present where two or three are gathered in his name is not tied to a room (Matthew 18:20), that the early church met in many shapes, and that refusing to count online gathering leaves the housebound and the scattered outside. They also point out that many believers have gathered by letter, by shared reading and by common prayer at a set hour, across great distance.
Others say no, or not in the full sense. They hold that the church is a bodily assembly, that the very word for the church means a people called together, and that Hebrews 10:25 speaks of "assembling together." They hold that the sacraments need bodies, bread, water and a gathered people, and that a screen can serve the church but cannot be the church. Some of them add that to count online gathering as full gathering will, in time, make the room seem unnecessary.
A third group holds a middle position. They accept online contact as real fellowship and valuable service, but they reserve words like "church," "worship" and "communion" for what happens when people are physically together, or they allow online participation only in particular cases, such as illness, imprisonment or great distance, and under the guidance of those responsible.
Each of these can be held with love and care for the Scripture, and each has strengths. The first protects those who cannot travel. The second protects the body. The third tries to hold both. This course does not decide among them, and no lecture here will tell you that your community's practice is wrong. Your own tradition, and those who have authority in it, are the proper place for that question.
What this course asks is something less than any of the three positions requires, and something that all three can accept.
- Online gathering is never taught as making bodily fellowship unnecessary.
- Those who cannot gather in person are not abandoned or treated as lesser members.
- A leader follows the rules of the community in which they serve, and does not invent new practices for worship or the sacraments on their own.
If a reader finds that the minimum is too little, that is to be expected. It is meant to be a floor and not a ceiling.
6. A worked example
(An invented example.) A small group in a town has met on the first evening of every month for years. During a bad winter several members cannot travel, and the group begins meeting by voice call. After a few months, one member, Daniel, says that he would rather not return to the room. "I say more here," he says. "I do not have to see anyone's face."
The leader does not rush to correct him or to praise the call. She asks him what is easier for him in this way of meeting, and what he misses. He says he misses the tea and the cold walk home. She asks whether he would come once, to sit at the back and not speak. He agrees. A few weeks later, Daniel is in the room. The call continues for those who cannot come.
The leader did not claim that the call was the same as the room. She did not claim that it was worthless. She listened to what the call gave Daniel, and she made a gentle path toward the room without shaming him.
Diagram 1. Contact, group, disciple
In short
- "Online is shallow" and "online is deeper" are both too simple; depth belongs to what two people do over time, not to a medium.
- Distance can help honesty and can harm it; truth is owed to people who belong to one another.
- A hidden name may protect a person; a leader must not demand that such a person reveal themselves.
- A contact is not yet a disciple; a disciple is known, prayed for, missed and willing to be corrected.
- Readers will not agree whether online gathering equals gathering in person; the course asks that online never make bodily fellowship unnecessary and that those who cannot gather are not abandoned.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Where does depth belong? | To what two people do over time, not to a medium. |
| A contact versus a disciple | A disciple is known, prayed for, missed and open to correction; a contact is someone you exchange messages with. |
| Why a hidden name may be needed | Safety: faith may be dangerous, a person may be escaping harm. Never demand it be dropped. |
| The common minimum | Online never makes bodily fellowship unnecessary, and those who cannot gather are not abandoned. |
One sentence to remember Depth is made by what people do over time, and a screen changes only which kinds of depth are easy.
This week's action Pick one group you serve and say honestly whether it is an audience, a set of contacts or a place of discipleship, and what one change would deepen it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the two stories, "online is shallow" or "online can go deeper," is closer to your own experience? What does your experience leave out?
- What does distance make easier for you to say? What does it make easier to say badly?
- Why must a leader not force a hidden-name participant to reveal themselves? What would a respectful question look like?
- Think of a group you lead or belong to. By the questions in this lecture, is it an audience, a group of contacts, or a place where disciples are built up?
- In your own words, state each of the three positions on online gathering as its holders would state it. Where does the minimum in this course sit among them?