Lecture 4-2: Why Conspiracy Theories Attract
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Call to Love the Truth
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds of Wrong Information and How They Work
- Lecture 1-3: Why We Are Fooled
- Lecture 1-4: Looking at My Information Habits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day of Information
- Lecture 2-1: Who Decides What I See
- Lecture 2-2: Why Anger and Fear Travel Fast
- Lecture 2-3: Bubbles and Echoes
- Lecture 2-4: Looking at My Screens and Adjusting Them
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Review a Day of Feed and Make One Change
- Lecture 3-1: Asking Where It Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: Pausing and Checking
- Lecture 3-3: Manipulated Photos, Video and Audio
- Lecture 3-4: Checking One Claim
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Check One Claim
- Lecture 4-1: What Travels in Church Circles
- Lecture 4-2: Why Conspiracy Theories Attract
- Lecture 4-3: Correcting Gently and Truthfully
- Lecture 4-4: One Step Before Answering a Rumour
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Answer a Rumour in the Group Chat
- Lecture 5-1: Facing Questions That Divide
- Lecture 5-2: At the Table and in the Comments
- Lecture 5-3: Truth and Love Together
- Lecture 5-4: Preparing for a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Rehearse a Hard Conversation
Lecture 4-1 looked at what travels. This lecture looks at one kind of story that travels very well and stays very long: the conspiracy theory. It is the story that says a hidden group is secretly arranging events, and that the ordinary explanation is a cover.
There are two mistakes here, and they pull in opposite directions. One is to believe such stories too easily. The other is to wave away every doubt as a conspiracy theory. The second mistake is as harmful as the first. Real wrongdoing is sometimes planned in secret and hidden afterward, and people who raised concerns have sometimes been told they were imagining things when they were not. A good reader needs to avoid both mistakes. This lecture gives the reasons such stories attract us, a description of the shape that makes them hard to correct, and four questions that help us tell a real concern from a theory that cannot be checked.
It also does something that matters in churches: it takes people seriously. Most who believe such stories are not fools or wicked. They are often frightened, sometimes hurt, and often sincere. The aim is to understand them, not to judge them.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Distinguish a real concern about hidden wrongdoing from a conspiracy theory, and explain why not every doubt is a theory.
- Give four reasons such stories attract sincere people, including believers.
- Describe the unfalsifiable shape of a conspiracy theory.
- Apply four questions to a claim: What is the evidence? Could it be shown wrong? Can it be corrected? Who gains?
- State fairly the different views on how far to read events through spiritual struggle, and say what the course asks of every reader.
Beloved, don’t believe every spirit, but test the spirits, whether they are of God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world." — 1 John 4:1
World English Bible
Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21
WEB
He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17
WEB
The first verse tells believers not to accept every spirit or message without testing it. The second says the same thing in the plainest terms: test all things and keep what is good. The third is about how any case sounds when only one side has spoken. Together they say that testing is a duty, not an insult. These verses are read here as principles about care in judgement. They are not used to prove that any particular claim is true or false.
1. What a conspiracy theory is, and what it is not
In this course, a conspiracy theory means a claim that a hidden group is secretly planning and causing important events, and that the usual explanation is a cover story. The words that matter are hidden, secretly and cover story.
That is different from three other things, and the difference matters.
- A real conspiracy. People do sometimes plan wrongdoing in secret and hide it afterward. Officials hide errors. Companies conceal dangers. Groups of people agree to deceive. Institutions of every kind, including churches, have sometimes hidden harm to protect themselves. History contains cases that were first called imagination and were later shown by documents and witnesses to be true. This is why the answer to every suspicion cannot be "that is only a conspiracy theory."
- An ordinary doubt. "I am not sure I trust this explanation" is a healthy sentence. Doubt that asks for evidence is the start of knowing.
- A rumour. A rumour is a passing story about a person or event. A conspiracy theory is bigger: it says that a hidden plan lies behind many events and that the doubter is being deceived.
The difference between a real concern and a theory is not found in how shocking the claim is. It is found in how the claim is held: whether it rests on evidence, whether it could be shown wrong, and whether it can be corrected. We will come to those tests below.
2. Why such stories attract
Here are four reasons. Each one is human, and none is a sign of weak faith or low intelligence.
1. A wish for order and explanation. Large events, such as a disaster, a collapse of prices, a death, or a sudden change of the rules, are painful to accept as the result of many small causes, mistakes and chances. A story with a hidden plan offers relief: someone is in control, and so there is a reason. Even a frightening explanation can feel better than none. This tends to be true of people in many cultures and many centuries.
2. A fit with stories we already trust. The Bible tells of real evil, of false prophets, of powers that work against God's people, and of plans made in secret. Many believers are therefore ready to see hidden evil in the world. That readiness is not wrong in itself, but it means that a story about hidden evil may find a ready home in us before we have checked whether it is true.
3. Belonging and special knowledge. A person who "sees what others miss" is part of a small circle. Within it there is trust, a shared language and a shared task. When people have been lonely, ignored or dismissed, such a circle can feel like warmth. A correction from outside the circle then feels like an attack on friends, not a question about facts.
4. Real betrayal. Some people distrust institutions because they have been harmed by them: by a hospital, an office, a government, a school, a church. Their distrust did not come from nowhere. A story that says "they hide the truth" can seem to confirm what they already experienced. Such people deserve to be heard before they are corrected.
Notice that a partly true story is the strongest kind. Many theories begin with something real: a true event, a real mistake, a real cover-up somewhere. Then they add more, and the added part borrows the credibility of the true part. A listener who knows that the true part is true may feel that the rest has been checked as well.
3. The shape that cannot be corrected
Here is the feature that most separates a theory from a concern. Most theories have a shape in which nothing can count against them.
- If there is evidence for the claim, it proves the claim.
- If there is no evidence, it proves how well the plan was hidden.
- If an expert disagrees, the expert is part of the plan.
- If someone corrects the story, that person has been fooled or is paid to deceive.
Read those four lines again. There is no outcome that the theory would accept as showing that it is wrong. When a claim is arranged so that every possible result supports it, it has stopped saying anything about the world. We can describe this by saying the claim is unfalsifiable: no possible fact could show it false.
A real concern does not have this shape. A real concern says: "If we look at this record and find nothing, I was mistaken." A real concern can be lost.
4. An invented example, in three forms
Here are three invented theories. Read them together. (An invented example. The groups and events are made up.)
- Theory A. "The rising price of bread is not an accident. A small secret circle of rich men plans it. Any report that says otherwise was written for them."
- Theory B. "The new rules about permits are not an accident. A small secret circle of officials plans to take away people's freedom. Any report that says otherwise was written for them."
- Theory C. (A diocese is a regional group of churches with one office.) "The diocese office is secretly planning to sell our building. If the office says it is not, that proves how secret it is."
A reader whose sympathies run one way will find A more believable than B. A reader whose sympathies run the other way will feel the opposite. Look at what is the same. Each names a small hidden group. Each treats the rise in price, the new rules, or the sale as a plan and not as a consequence of many causes. Each ends in a sentence that makes disagreement part of the plan. The shape is the same on every side. That is why a course that teaches how to check cannot be the servant of any one side: the questions are the same whichever side tells the story.
5. Four questions to ask
These four questions do not decide whether a claim is true. They help us see what kind of claim it is.
Four questions
1. What is the evidence? What would I see if this were true? Who saw it first-hand? Is there a document, a record, a person who was there and can be named? A claim that rests only on "everyone knows" or "they do not want you to know" has no evidence yet.
2. Could it be shown wrong? What fact would change my mind? If I cannot name one, and neither can the person telling me, the claim is unfalsifiable.
3. Can it be corrected? When someone shows an error in the story, does the story change? Or does the correction become part of the plot? A claim that welcomes correction is on the side of truth, even if it is wrong. A claim that cannot be corrected has left the world of checking.
4. Who gains? Ask who gains from the event, and ask who gains from the story. This question needs care: who gains from an event is not proof that they caused it. Many people gain from events they did nothing to bring about. But it is fair to ask who gains from telling this story to me now: attention, followers, money, belonging, or a sense of being right.
None of these questions is a trick. All four can be asked kindly, even of a story we like. The test of whether we mean them is whether we ask them of the stories that favour our side as readily as those that do not.
6. The ladder between "confirmed" and "false"
There is a useful way to avoid both mistakes. Between "this is certainly true" and "this is certainly false" there are several steps, and an honest speaker can say which step a claim is on.
- Confirmed. Independent sources that I can name agree, and there is first-hand evidence.
- Reported but not confirmed. Someone credible has said it, but I cannot yet check it.
- Claimed. Someone has said it, and I do not know how they know.
- Rumoured. It is going round, and nobody can say who first said it.
- Shown to be false. Evidence shows that it is wrong.
Most of what arrives in a message group sits on the third or fourth step. To say so is not to call the story false. It is to say where the claim honestly stands. The sentence "I do not know" is more truthful than "it is true" or "it is a lie" when it is what you know.
7. How people who hold such views should be treated
A reader who has followed this lecture may feel tempted to think less of those who believe such stories. The course asks that you not do so. Most people who spread them do so from fear, from love or from hurt. Many are people who, in other parts of life, are careful and kind. To call them stupid or wicked ends the conversation and is not true. It also confirms the story's own claim that "the others look down on you."
What helps is attention to what lies beneath: the fear, the loss, the sense of being ignored. Often the real subject is not the theory at all. Lecture 4-3 shows how to speak to such a person with care.
Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. How far should believers read events through spiritual struggle? Some believers hold that unseen spiritual powers are real and active, and that events in the world, including events in nations, may be shaped by them. For them, to ignore spiritual causes is a weakness. Others hold that the New Testament speaks of spiritual struggle chiefly as a matter of the believer's own life and the church's faithfulness, and they warn that naming a particular human group as the instrument of evil has often led Christians into harm. A third view holds that spiritual realities are real, and that every claim about which people are acting in them must be tested like any other claim. Each of these views is held in many churches and traditions, and each is the position of faithful people. This course does not decide among them. It asks of every reader a common minimum: do not state an unconfirmed claim about a person or a group as certain, even if you believe the spiritual setting; do not name a human group as "the enemy" on rumour; and do not move people by fear.
8. What to do with this
This lecture does not ask for a new emotion. It asks for four habits:
- Hold real concerns seriously, and take them to those who can check them: a responsible leader, a record, a reliable institution, the proper authorities.
- Test the shape. Ask whether the claim could ever be wrong.
- Say where it stands. Use the ladder.
- Keep the person. The one who believes an unprovable story is still your neighbour.
Diagram 1. A concern and a theory, side by side
In short
- A conspiracy theory claims that a hidden group plans events and that the usual account is a cover; real conspiracies and cover-ups also exist, so not every doubt is a theory.
- Four reasons draw people: a wish for order, a fit with stories of evil, belonging and special knowledge, and real betrayal; a partly true story attracts most.
- The mark of a theory is its shape: evidence, lack of evidence and correction are all made to support it.
- Ask four questions: What is the evidence? Could it be shown wrong? Can it be corrected? Who gains?
- On spiritual struggle, traditions differ; the common minimum is to state nothing unconfirmed about people as certain and to move no one by fear.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A conspiracy theory | A claim that a hidden group secretly causes events and that the usual account is a cover story. |
| Why not every doubt is a theory | Real wrongdoing has been planned and hidden, and some doubts have been proved right. |
| The four questions | What is the evidence? Could it be shown wrong? Can it be corrected? Who gains? |
| Unfalsifiable | No possible fact could count against the claim; every result is made to support it. |
One sentence to remember Take real concerns seriously and test the shape of every story, including the ones that favour my side.
This week's action Choose one claim you believe about hidden motives, and write down what fact would change your mind.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why is the answer "that is only a conspiracy theory" sometimes unfair? Can you think of a case from history, or from a community you know, where a doubt turned out to be justified?
- Which of the four reasons for the attraction of such stories do you find easiest to understand? Which is hardest?
- Take the invented Theory C about the diocese office. Apply the four questions to it. What would you want to see before believing it, and what would change your mind?
- Why is "who gains?" a question that must be used with care?
- How do the three views about spiritual struggle differ? What is the minimum that all three could agree on?