Lecture 5-1: Facing Questions That Divide
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Call to Love the Truth
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds of Wrong Information and How They Work
- Lecture 1-3: Why We Are Fooled
- Lecture 1-4: Looking at My Information Habits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day of Information
- Lecture 2-1: Who Decides What I See
- Lecture 2-2: Why Anger and Fear Travel Fast
- Lecture 2-3: Bubbles and Echoes
- Lecture 2-4: Looking at My Screens and Adjusting Them
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Review a Day of Feed and Make One Change
- Lecture 3-1: Asking Where It Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: Pausing and Checking
- Lecture 3-3: Manipulated Photos, Video and Audio
- Lecture 3-4: Checking One Claim
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Check One Claim
- Lecture 4-1: What Travels in Church Circles
- Lecture 4-2: Why Conspiracy Theories Attract
- Lecture 4-3: Correcting Gently and Truthfully
- Lecture 4-4: One Step Before Answering a Rumour
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Answer a Rumour in the Group Chat
- Lecture 5-1: Facing Questions That Divide
- Lecture 5-2: At the Table and in the Comments
- Lecture 5-3: Truth and Love Together
- Lecture 5-4: Preparing for a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Rehearse a Hard Conversation
Every family, congregation and town has questions that divide it. Some are about public life. Some are about how a community should spend its money, use its land or teach its children. Some are about what an old text means. People who love God and love each other give different answers to them.
Weeks 1 to 4 were about what comes to me: how false information works, how feeds shape what I see, how to check a claim, how rumours move in church. This week is about what goes from me. How do I speak when the question is contested and the people in front of me care about it?
This first lecture gives you one skill that makes the rest easier: to sort a question before arguing about it. Many quarrels last a long time because three different kinds of question are tangled together, and the people in them do not know it. When the kinds are separated, some quarrels end, and the ones that remain are easier to bear.
This course does not tell you which position on any public question is right. It teaches how to check and how to speak. Where a law or your community's own rules say something about voting or about supporting a candidate, follow them.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Separate a question into matters of fact, of value and of interpretation, using an invented case.
- Explain why faithful believers may judge a value question differently.
- State a view you do not hold in the form its own supporters would accept.
- Explain why labels end a conversation and name a plainer way to speak.
- Describe the difference between what a community holds together and what it leaves open.
He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17
World English Bible
Why do you see the speck that is in your brother’s eye, but don’t consider the beam that is in your own eye?" — Matthew 7:3
WEB
The first verse notes that the person who speaks first can sound right until the other side is heard. The second asks me to look at my own eye before I speak about my neighbour's. These are read here as principles about how to approach a hard question. They are not used to prove any position on a public matter, and this lecture does not use them that way.
1. Why some questions divide
Not every disagreement is a divided question. If two people disagree about the time of a meeting, they can look at a calendar. A divided question is one where each side has reasons it holds dear, and where looking at a calendar does not settle it.
Four things make a question divide.
It touches what people love. A question about the safety of children, the care of the old, the use of land, the fairness of work or the honour of a nation is never only a question. It is also about what a person loves.
It touches belonging. What I think about it is partly a sign of whom I stand with. To change my mind may feel like leaving my people.
It is complicated. Most public questions have facts, tradeoffs and unknowns that no ordinary person can see in full. Careful people weigh them differently.
Fear sits behind it. Under many strong opinions is a fear: of loss, of change, of being ignored, of being blamed. A person who is afraid hears an argument as an attack.
Knowing this does not solve the question. It changes how you stand. You are speaking to someone who loves something, belongs somewhere, sees part of a complicated picture and may be afraid. You may disagree with them. You are not entitled to treat them as if none of that were true.
2. Three kinds of question
A tool that helps very much is to ask, of any sentence in a quarrel: is this a matter of fact, of value, or of interpretation?
Three kinds of question
Fact: something that can in principle be checked. How many, when, who said it, what happened.
Value: what matters more, what we owe each other, what a good outcome would be.
Interpretation: what a text, an event, a silence or a person's action means.
The kinds need different handling.
- A question of fact is settled by checking. Lectures 3-1 and 3-2 told you how. If I do not know, "I do not know" is a good answer.
- A question of value is not settled by checking. It is settled, if at all, by speaking, listening and weighing. Two people may agree on every fact and still disagree about what matters more.
- A question of interpretation is settled by reading carefully, by asking what other readers say, and often by admitting that the evidence leaves room for more than one reading.
Most quarrels mix all three, and most people quarrel as if everything were a question of fact. They bring a fact to answer a value ("But the figures show...") or bring a value to answer a fact ("It cannot be true, because it would be unjust"). The conversation then goes round and round.
3. A worked example
(An invented example.) The town of Eastfield owns an old playing field. The council proposes to build a covered market on it. Church members in Eastfield are on both sides, and the question has reached the congregation's message group.
Here are six sentences from that group, sorted.
| Sentence | Kind |
|---|---|
| "More than a hundred families use the field every week." | Fact (it can be counted, and the number may be wrong) |
| "Traders have nowhere dry to sell, and the rain ruins their goods." | Fact (it can be checked, and it may be partly true) |
| "Children matter more than commerce." | Value |
| "A town that does not help its traders is not helping its poor." | Value (and it joins two things that may not belong together) |
| "The council kept the plan quiet, so it must be hiding something." | Interpretation (of a silence) |
| "Anyone who opposes the market simply does not care about hardworking people." | Interpretation (of motives), and a label |
Look at what sorting does. The first two sentences can be checked, and people on either side should want them to be right. The next two are about what matters, and they cannot be checked; they can only be discussed. The last two are readings of other people's hearts. Nobody in the group can check them. They also close doors: a person who is told they do not care will not go on speaking.
Notice also that the two sides have both said a sentence of each kind. A reader who favours the market might forward the sixth sentence. A reader who opposes it might forward the fifth. The sorting is the same for both, and so is the question it asks: what is actually known here, and what are we guessing about each other?
4. Why good believers judge value questions differently
A value question asks me to weigh goods that are both real. Children's play is good. A dry place to trade is good. The congregation does not have a verse that says how many families outweigh how many traders. Scripture gives us principles (justice, mercy, care for the weak, honest dealing, humility), and every one of them applies in Eastfield. The hard work is applying them to a particular place with particular people.
For this reason, careful believers in the same pew, reading the same Scripture and praying the same prayers, may reach different judgments. This is not always a sign that one of them is unfaithful. It may be that each is weighing real goods in a different order, or sees different facts, or trusts different people.
Some value questions are not like this. Some things are plainly wrong, and Scripture and the Church say so. The skill is to tell the difference, and the next sections say more about how. For now, one caution. When I find myself saying "no faithful person could think otherwise," I should stop and ask whether I have checked, or whether I only have not met them.
5. Stating the other view in its strongest form
Proverbs says that a person who speaks first seems right until another comes and questions them. The proverb is not an attack on anyone who speaks first. It tells me that I have heard only a part until I have heard the other part.
A habit that follows from it is to state a view you do not hold in a form its own supporters would accept. This is sometimes called stating the strongest form, and it takes three steps.
- Listen for the reason, not only the conclusion. Behind "the market is a bad idea" there may be a worry about where children will play, or a memory of a promise the town once made.
- Say it back. "So you are worried that children will have nowhere safe to play, and that the town has already lost other places like this. Is that right?" If the person says "Yes, exactly," you have it. If they say "No, it is more that...," you have not yet.
- Ask what would change their mind, and what they would give up. This shows that you take them as a thinking person, and it often shows them something about their own view.
Doing this does not mean you agree. It means you are no longer arguing with an imaginary person who is easier to defeat. A believer who can state the other side's reasons has shown respect, and has shown that they can be trusted to speak truthfully about people who are absent. That matters when the next question comes.
Not the same as agreeing
Stating a view fairly is not the same as accepting it, and it is not a trick to win. If you say someone's view back in order to knock it down, they will know, and the exercise will have cost you trust. Do it to understand.
6. Avoiding labels
A label is a short word used to put a person in a box so that their views need not be heard. It may be a name for a camp, a party, a type of believer or a type of person. Labels are fast, and that is their danger. A label turns a person who loves, belongs and fears into a symbol.
Labels fail for three reasons.
- They are often wrong. The people placed under a label rarely agree with each other, and many of them hold the view for different reasons.
- They end listening. A person who hears the label thinks: "I know what you are going to say."
- They invite the same in return. A conversation of labels is soon a conversation of insults.
A plainer way is to describe the view and not the person. Say "some people think the field should stay as it is, because..." and not "the sentimental crowd." Say "some people think the market should go ahead, because..." and not "the money people." If you do not know the reasons, ask for them. If you do know them, say them.
This applies equally to the people you agree with. You should be as careful with the label for your own side as for the other. If you would not like a sentence read aloud to the people it describes, do not say it.
7. What a church must hold together, and what may differ
A congregation can hold a great deal of difference. It cannot hold everything. There are things a community holds together, such as its worship, its confession of faith, its way of caring for the weak, and its basic honesty in speech. And there are things on which it lets its members differ, such as how to vote, how to judge a particular public plan, or how to read a disputed question in the news.
The danger runs both ways. If I make my own judgment on an open question into a test of faith, I divide the community over something it never required. If I treat a matter the community does hold as if it were only opinion, I weaken what holds it together.
How much is open?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians differ about how much of life lies in the open space. Some traditions hold that the Church's teaching has different weights: some things are defined and binding, some are taught with authority, and some are matters of practical judgment on which faithful members may disagree. Some traditions hold that what must be held is received within the common life of the Church, its worship, councils and teachers, and is not settled by any one member's opinion on public affairs. Many Protestant communities speak of a core that all must hold and a wider area in which freedom is given, though they do not all draw the line in the same place. Some communities draw the line more tightly than others, and some leave it to each congregation.
This course does not say where your community should draw it. It asks only for a common minimum: know what your own community holds as required, do not enlarge your own opinions into that list, and do not shrink the list to avoid an uncomfortable conversation. If you do not know where your community draws the line, ask a pastor or a teacher.
8. What this lecture does not do
It does not tell you which side of any public question to take. It does not say that every question is only a matter of opinion. It does not ask anyone to stay silent about what they believe. It teaches something earlier: to sort a question, to hear the reasons, to state the other side fairly, to leave out labels, and to know what your community holds together. The next two lectures put these into the table, the chat and the conversation with someone close.
Diagram 1. Sorting a divided question
In short
- Many quarrels tangle three kinds of question: fact, value and interpretation. Sorting them helps.
- Facts are checked, values are discussed, interpretations are read carefully and held with doubt.
- Good believers may weigh real goods differently, and this is not always unfaithfulness.
- State another view in a form its own supporters would accept; do it to understand, not to win.
- A label ends listening. Describe the view and leave out the label.
- Know what your community holds together, and do not enlarge your own opinions into it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Fact, value, interpretation | Fact can be checked; value is what matters more; interpretation is what a text, event, silence or motive means. |
| Strongest form of a view | A statement of it that its own supporters would accept, made to understand and not to win. |
| Why labels fail | They are often wrong, they end listening, and they invite the same in return. |
| Required versus open | A community holds some things together and leaves others open; do not enlarge your opinions into the first list. |
One sentence to remember Before I answer a divided question, I sort it, hear the other side's reasons, and describe views instead of labelling people.
This week's action Take one disagreement you have heard this week and sort its sentences into fact, value and interpretation.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a quarrel you have seen, in any setting, with no names. Which sentences were facts, which were values and which were interpretations?
- Which of the four things that make a question divide (love, belonging, complication, fear) is strongest in you when you hear a view you dislike?
- What is a view you do not hold, and how would its own supporters state it?
- Which label do you use most easily? What plainer description could take its place?
- Where does your community draw the line between what it holds together and what it leaves open? If you are not sure, whom could you ask?