FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM307E Truth and Media Discernment

Lecture 6-3: Trust and Humility: I Might Be Wrong

Contents 31
LM307E Truth and Media Discernment
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Truth Is Love's Work
  1. Introduction: Truth Is Love's Work
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Why Truth Matters
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Call to Love the Truth
  2. Lecture 1-2: Kinds of Wrong Information and How They Work
  3. Lecture 1-3: Why We Are Fooled
  4. Lecture 1-4: Looking at My Information Habits
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day of Information
Chapter 2 · Week 2: How Feeds and Attention Work
  1. Lecture 2-1: Who Decides What I See
  2. Lecture 2-2: Why Anger and Fear Travel Fast
  3. Lecture 2-3: Bubbles and Echoes
  4. Lecture 2-4: Looking at My Screens and Adjusting Them
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Review a Day of Feed and Make One Change
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Habits of Reading and Checking
  1. Lecture 3-1: Asking Where It Comes From
  2. Lecture 3-2: Pausing and Checking
  3. Lecture 3-3: Manipulated Photos, Video and Audio
  4. Lecture 3-4: Checking One Claim
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Check One Claim
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Rumours and Conspiracy Theories in Church
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Travels in Church Circles
  2. Lecture 4-2: Why Conspiracy Theories Attract
  3. Lecture 4-3: Correcting Gently and Truthfully
  4. Lecture 4-4: One Step Before Answering a Rumour
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Answer a Rumour in the Group Chat
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Speaking Respectfully in Public Conversation
  1. Lecture 5-1: Facing Questions That Divide
  2. Lecture 5-2: At the Table and in the Comments
  3. Lecture 5-3: Truth and Love Together
  4. Lecture 5-4: Preparing for a Hard Conversation
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Rehearse a Hard Conversation
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Living with the Truth
  1. Lecture 6-1: Responsibility for What I Say and Pass On
  2. Lecture 6-2: Taking in News Without Wearing Out
  3. Lecture 6-3: Trust and Humility: I Might Be Wrong
  4. Lecture 6-4: My Three-Month Plan for Truthful Habits
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Three-Month Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Every lecture of this course has asked you to check what others say. A careless reader might take the wrong lesson from that: trust nobody. That would be a mistake, and in some ways a worse one than trusting everybody. This lecture puts the two mistakes side by side, describes a kind of trust that is neither of them, and then turns the question around. What if the one who is wrong is me?

The first half is about trust. Why we must trust others, how to trust well, what is wrong with trusting everything and with trusting nothing, and where readers honestly disagree about how far institutions and experts deserve trust. The second half is about humility: how to admit that I was wrong, why truth must come before my side, and why a Christian places truth above any group, including the group I love best.

The course returns, in every week, to one claim: Truth belongs to God and is part of loving our neighbour. So before I hear and pass something on, I pause and check; I admit humbly that I can be fooled; I say clearly what is confirmed and what is not; and when I speak the truth, I do it in love. This lecture is the second clause, I admit humbly that I can be fooled, taken as far as it goes.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Explain why both trusting everything and trusting nothing are shortcuts, and why neither is wise.
  • Describe the signs of well-founded trust and apply them to a source, an institution or an expert.
  • State fairly where readers disagree about how far to trust institutions and experts, and the common minimum.
  • Say "I was wrong" in a short, plain, unhurried way, and describe why this matters.
  • Apply a simple test to a claim that favours my own side, using a matched pair of invented messages.

Jesus said to him, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father, except through me." — John 14:6

World English Bible

Pilate therefore said to him, “Are you a king then?” Jesus answered, “You say that I am a king. For this reason I have been born, and for this reason I have come into the world, that I should testify to the truth. Everyone who is of the truth listens to my voice.”" — John 18:37

WEB

Why do you see the speck that is in your brother’s eye, but don’t consider the beam that is in your own eye?" — Matthew 7:3

WEB

The first two verses speak of truth in a way that places it above any group. The third speaks of how easily I see a small fault in another person and miss a large one in myself. They are read here as principles about humility and loyalty to truth. They are not used to prove who is right on any public question.

1. Two shortcuts

There are two easy ways to deal with the difficulty of knowing what is true.

The first is to trust everything that comes from my own side. My family, my congregation, my favourite speaker, the people who sound like me: if it comes from them, I believe it. This saves a great deal of effort. It also feels like loyalty, and it often feels like faith.

The second is to trust nothing that comes from a source with power. Experts, institutions, officials, large organisations, the established voices: whatever they say, I assume they are hiding something. This also saves a great deal of effort, and it feels like wisdom, since it seems that nobody can fool me. A person who holds this view often thinks of themselves as the one who sees clearly.

Notice what the two have in common. Both are ways of not having to check. The first lets my side do my checking for me. The second lets my suspicion do it. In each case I decide in advance who is reliable, and then I stop looking at the evidence. The naive person is easy for a liar to fool by dressing up as a friend. The cynic is just as easy to fool by dressing up as a rebel against the powerful. A clever deceiver can use either door.

The cynic's position deserves a word of sympathy, because it comes from something real. Institutions and experts do make mistakes. Sometimes they conceal things. Sometimes they are led by their own interests or blind to their own errors. People who feel they were let down by an official body have good reason to be careful. It is not wrong to be careful. What is wrong is to turn a wise caution about particular failures into a rule that nothing from any such source can ever be believed.

2. What well-founded trust looks like

We cannot do without trusting others. I did not measure the bridge I drive across. I did not read the whole of the notice before I signed. I did not trace the history of the account I am reading. Almost all of what I know, I know on trust. So the question is not whether to trust. It is how to trust in a way that has reasons.

Here are some signs of a source that has earned trust. None is enough alone, and none is a guarantee.

  • It can be checked. It gives its reasons, shows its sources and allows others to look. A claim that cannot be examined at all deserves less trust than one that can.
  • It can be corrected. It has a way of admitting and repairing its mistakes, and it uses it in the open. A source that never corrects anything is not more reliable; it is only less honest about its errors.
  • It is accountable. Someone else can ask it questions, and there are consequences for it when it is wrong. A person or body that answers to nobody is harder to trust, however capable.
  • It has a record. Over time, it has been right about the kind of thing it now claims. A track record is evidence, though it is not proof.
  • It knows its limits. It says what it does not know, and it does not speak with the same firmness about everything.
  • It does not stand alone. Others who have no reason to agree with it have examined the same question and come to something similar.

It matters that trust has degrees and purposes. I may trust an engineer very far about bridges and very little about the history of the church. I may trust a neighbour on the news of our street and not on matters of law. A good habit is to ask not "is this person trustworthy?" but "how far, and about what?" Lecture 3-1 said the same of sources. It holds equally for institutions and experts.

A particular case needs a sentence. When an expert body changes its advice as new evidence comes in, some readers take this as proof of lying. It may be. But it is also what honest work looks like when evidence grows: a source that never changed its view in a changing field would be the more worrying one. So the thing to ask is not "did they change?" but "did they say openly that they changed, and why?"

On health, law and money, this course gives no advice. The principle for such matters is that a circulating claim is a poor reason to set aside the advice of qualified professionals and reliable institutions who know your situation. Take your questions to them.

3. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is how far a believer should trust institutions and experts.

Some hold that, as a general rule, trust is the right starting point. Institutions and experts gather and test knowledge that no single person can. They are accountable in ways that an anonymous voice is not. Most of what they say is right, and a person who doubts them on principle ends by trusting worse sources. On this view, humility means recognising that on most matters I know less than those who have studied them.

Others hold that wariness is the right starting point. Power tends to protect itself, and Scripture speaks often of rulers who deceive and of false prophets who flatter. History gives real cases of cover-ups. On this view, humility means recognising that those with power are no less fallible than I am, and that an independent mind is a part of loving the truth.

Others place the emphasis on nearness. They trust most the people they know and the communities they belong to, such as a family, a parish or a congregation, and they trust far institutions less. Catholic and Orthodox readers add a distinct question that is outside this lecture: how to regard the teaching authority of their own church on matters of faith and morals. That is a question about doctrine. Here the subject is only claims about facts in the world: what happened, what was said, what is known.

Each of these positions holds something true, and each has a risk when pushed too far: the first can become a habit of not asking, the second a habit of not believing, the third a habit of not looking beyond my circle. What this course requires is smaller than any of them. Trust by reasons, in degrees, and about particular things; keep the ability to examine; and do not let anyone, whether a friend, an institution or a critic of institutions, push you to either extreme.

4. Admitting I was wrong

The other half of this lecture is about me. A person who checks others without ever being willing to be checked is a poor witness to truth.

Matthew 7:3 is a familiar warning, about the speck in a brother's eye and the beam in my own. It is usually read as a warning against judging. It also has a plain bearing on information. I am quick to see a mistake in a claim I do not like, and slow to see one in a claim I do like. The more I agree with something, the less I check it. This is not a character fault in a few people. It is how most minds work, and lecture 1-3 described it. The fix is not to feel guilty. The fix is to know that I have this tilt, and to look hardest at what I most want to be true.

Admitting error is harder than it sounds, and its reasons are mostly social. I fear looking foolish. I fear that my side will think less of me. I fear that if I give way on one thing, I will have to give way on all. These fears are real. Here are some ways to meet them.

  • Say it short and plain. "I was wrong about that. I have looked again and it is not so." No long account of how it was reasonable. No "but."
  • Say it when it is cheap. A small correction made early costs little. The same correction made after a year of defending the mistake costs a great deal.
  • Separate the claim from the self. I am more than any one thing that I said. A person who says "I was wrong" is showing that their regard for truth is greater than their regard for their own image.
  • Treat another person's correction as a gift, even when it is clumsy. Someone took the trouble to look.

A test for the correction habit

If I cannot remember the last time I said "I was wrong" about something that mattered, I should not conclude that I am rarely wrong. It is more likely that I am not looking.

5. Truth before my side

A hard moment comes when a true thing hurts my side, or a false thing helps it. Here is where loyalty to truth is tested. Consider this pair.

(An invented example.) Two messages arrive in the same week, in two different groups.

  • Message A says that a measure favoured by one kind of public outlook has secretly failed, and that those who supported it have been hiding the facts. It has no named source.
  • Message B says exactly the same of a measure favoured by the opposite outlook. It also has no named source.

A reader who favours the first measure will want to doubt A and believe B. A reader who favours the second will want the reverse. Both readers will feel that they are only being sensible. Yet the two messages have the same weakness: neither names a source, neither shows a document, and each says what its readers would like to hear.

The test is simple to say and hard to keep. Would I treat it the same way if it came from the other side? If I would forward B without a question and ask five questions about A, then my filter is my side and not my judgement. This is not an argument for treating all claims as equally likely. Some are true and some are false, whichever side they favour. It is only an argument that the checking should be the same.

The same goes for what I would be glad to be false. A true statement that is awkward for those I love is still true. To pass it over, or to say it is false because it is unwelcome, is to prefer the group to the truth.

6. Before the God who is truth

Why does a Christian put truth above a side? John 14:6 records Jesus saying, "I am the way, the truth, and the life." In John 18:37 he says that he came into the world to testify to the truth, and that everyone who is of the truth listens to his voice. Believers hold these words in different ways, and traditions give them different weight in their teaching. What they share is the claim that truth is not the property of any party or any group. It belongs to God, and so it stands above my side, my church, my country and my own reputation.

The verses must be used with care. They do not give me a ready answer to every claim I meet. Nothing in them tells me which report about an event is correct, which study is sound or which official is honest. Those are matters I must still check, humbly, and in many cases I will not be able to settle them. They must not be used as a weapon against someone who disagrees with me either: "everyone who is of the truth listens to my voice" was said by Jesus about himself, and was not said by me about me. What the verses do give me is an order of loyalty: truth before my side. And they give me a reason for humility: if truth belongs to God, I cannot own it, and I am not the last judge of it.

7. Words that build trust

Finally, a few habits that make a person's word worth believing, and that a group can keep together.

  • Name where it came from. "I read this in a report from the council's office," or "My neighbour told me this."
  • Say how sure I am. The four phrases of lecture 6-1 serve here too.
  • Say what I do not know. A person who admits the edge of their knowledge is believed more on the inside of it.
  • Correct in the open. A group where corrections are plain is a group whose words can be relied on.
  • Be kind. An accurate word said with contempt does not persuade, and rarely helps anyone to hold the truth. Truth and love belong together, as lecture 5-3 said.

Diagram 1. Two ditches and the road between

TWO SHORTCUTS AND THE ROAD BETWEEN Both shortcuts are ways of not having to check Trust everything from my own side My side checks for me. Feels like loyalty. Easy to fool by someone who dresses as a friend. Trust with reasons It can be checked. It can be corrected. It is accountable. It has a record. It knows its limits. It does not stand alone. How far, and about what? Trust nothing from those with power My suspicion checks for me. Feels like wisdom. Easy to fool by someone who dresses as a rebel. The same test for both sides Would I treat it the same way if it came from the other side? If not, my filter is my side, not my judgement.

Diagram 2. Signs of well-founded trust

Sign The question to ask
It can be checked Does it give reasons and sources, and allow others to look?
It can be corrected Does it admit and repair mistakes in the open?
It is accountable Does someone else ask it questions, and is there a cost when it is wrong?
It has a record Has it been right about this kind of thing before?
It knows its limits Does it say what it does not know?
It does not stand alone Have others who have no reason to agree reached something similar?

In short

  • Trusting everything from my side and trusting nothing from those with power are both ways of not having to check.
  • Almost everything I know, I know on trust; the question is how, how far and about what.
  • Well-founded trust can be checked, corrected and held to account, has a record, knows its limits and does not stand alone.
  • Readers differ on how far to trust institutions and experts; the common minimum is trust by reasons, in degrees, with the ability to examine.
  • I check least what I most want to be true; I say "I was wrong" short, plain and early.
  • Truth belongs to God, so it stands above my side; test a claim by asking whether I would treat it the same if it came from the other side.
Front Back
Two shortcuts Trust everything from my side, or trust nothing from those with power; both avoid checking.
Signs of well-founded trust It can be checked, corrected and held to account; it has a record; it knows its limits; it does not stand alone.
Common minimum on trust Trust by reasons, in degrees, about particular things, and keep the ability to examine.
The other-side test Would I treat this claim the same way if it came from the other side?

One sentence to remember I trust for reasons, I check what I like as hard as what I dislike, and I put truth before my side.

This week's action Think of one thing you said recently that you now doubt, and say "I was wrong, or I am not sure" to someone about it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which shortcut is more tempting to you, trusting what comes from my own side or trusting nothing from those with power? What does it save you from doing?
  • Think of a source you trust a great deal. About what matters do you trust it, and about what matters would you hesitate?
  • When have you seen someone change their view openly and give their reasons? How did it affect your trust in them?
  • Read the three positions in the section on where readers will not agree. Which is closest to your own habit? Say what is strongest in one of the other two.
  • What would make it easier for you, or for your group, to say "I was wrong" in a plain sentence?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.