Lecture 2-3: Bubbles and Echoes
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Call to Love the Truth
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds of Wrong Information and How They Work
- Lecture 1-3: Why We Are Fooled
- Lecture 1-4: Looking at My Information Habits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day of Information
- Lecture 2-1: Who Decides What I See
- Lecture 2-2: Why Anger and Fear Travel Fast
- Lecture 2-3: Bubbles and Echoes
- Lecture 2-4: Looking at My Screens and Adjusting Them
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Review a Day of Feed and Make One Change
- Lecture 3-1: Asking Where It Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: Pausing and Checking
- Lecture 3-3: Manipulated Photos, Video and Audio
- Lecture 3-4: Checking One Claim
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Check One Claim
- Lecture 4-1: What Travels in Church Circles
- Lecture 4-2: Why Conspiracy Theories Attract
- Lecture 4-3: Correcting Gently and Truthfully
- Lecture 4-4: One Step Before Answering a Rumour
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Answer a Rumour in the Group Chat
- Lecture 5-1: Facing Questions That Divide
- Lecture 5-2: At the Table and in the Comments
- Lecture 5-3: Truth and Love Together
- Lecture 5-4: Preparing for a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Rehearse a Hard Conversation
Lecture 2-1 showed that what reaches me is a selection. Lecture 2-2 showed which kinds of items tend to win. This lecture looks at what happens when the selection narrows over a long time: I hear mostly voices that are like mine, I hear my own view come back to me from many mouths, and I begin to think that this is what everybody believes. People call this a bubble, and the returning of my own view an echo.
A bubble is not only a matter of screens. A family can be one, a congregation can be one, and so can a circle of friends who have eaten together for thirty years. This lecture looks at bubbles in church and family with care and without blame. Belonging is good. Close friendship is good. A congregation that knows its own mind is good. The difficulty begins only when belonging replaces hearing, and when agreement is taken for confirmation.
The lecture also faces a question on which readers do not agree: who is responsible for the information environment, and how much? Some say each of us. Some say those who build and run the services. Some say society as a whole. The lecture states these positions fairly and then asks of the reader something smaller and firmer: that my own share is real.
The course's claim applies here in its humble form: I admit that I can be fooled. A bubble is one of the ways it happens, because from inside a bubble nothing looks wrong.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe a bubble and an echo, and say why each feels like ordinary life from inside.
- Distinguish a healthy circle of belonging from a bubble that no correcting voice can enter.
- Describe how sharing can work as a sign of belonging, and what that does to disagreement.
- State fairly three positions on who is responsible for the information environment, and what this course requires whichever one a reader holds.
- Name two practical ways of hearing people face to face who see things differently.
Therefore putting away falsehood, speak truth each one with his neighbor. For we are members of one another." — Ephesians 4:25
World English Bible
Why do you see the speck that is in your brother’s eye, but don’t consider the beam that is in your own eye?" — Matthew 7:3
WEB
Paul speaks of putting away falsehood and speaking truth, and gives the reason: "we are members of one another." The word is not "members of those who agree with me." The saying of Jesus in Matthew 7 asks each of us to look first at our own eye before we are busy with another's. Both verses are used here as principles about how a believer stands among others, not as arguments in any public dispute.
1. What a bubble is
A bubble is a setting in which I hear mostly voices that are like mine. An echo is what happens inside it: a view I already hold comes back to me, repeated by others, until it seems to be everywhere. (You may meet the terms filter bubble, a screen narrowed by what a service selects for me, and echo chamber, a group where the same views are repeated back.)
A note of caution belongs here. People who study these questions disagree about how strongly online services narrow what most people see; some find that many readers still meet a good deal of disagreement. This lecture does not claim to measure it. It treats the bubble as something that can happen to anyone, online or not, and that is worth watching for in one's own life.
Three things make a bubble hard to see from inside.
First, it feels like normal life. If everyone I speak to agrees with me, I do not feel that I am in a small circle. I feel that I am among sensible people.
Second, the echo feels like confirmation. When I hear the same claim from five people, I feel as though five separate checks were made. But if all five received it from the same source, or from each other, there was only one voice, and it was repeated. Repetition makes a claim feel stronger without making it any better supported. Lecture 1-3 spoke of repetition; the point here is that a bubble supplies it for free.
Third, the other view reaches me only in the form that my circle gives it. If I hear about people who disagree with me only from people who agree with me, then I hear a description written by those who oppose them. Proverbs 18:17 comes back: the one who speaks first seems right until another comes and asks questions. In a bubble, nobody comes.
(An invented example.) A woman named Grace is part of a church message group that has run for years. The members are of similar age and background. When an alarming claim appears about a public matter, it is passed from member to member, with warm greetings and prayers, and nobody doubts it; to doubt it would feel like doubting a friend. Two months later she mentions it to her niece, who lives in another city and has never seen the claim. The niece says, "I think that was corrected a long time ago." Grace is surprised, not because she was careless, but because in her circle the correction had never arrived.
The story names no group and takes no side. A circle on any side of any question can be the kind of circle in the story.
2. Bubbles in church and family
It is worth being specific about where bubbles form, because the church is not exempt and in some ways is especially open to them.
- Family chats. Older and younger relatives often receive information from different places. The family chat can become the only place where they meet, and it can carry whatever any one member brings in.
- Congregation message groups. These are made of people who trust each other, which is why a claim passes through them so easily. The warmth that makes the group good also makes doubt feel like disloyalty. (The running of such groups, their rules and safety, is taught in and Online Ministry, LM306E. This lecture is only about what flows through them.)
- Traditions. A Catholic, an Orthodox believer, a Pentecostal and a Baptist can each spend nearly all their reading and listening with their own tradition's voices. There is much good in that. It becomes a bubble in the sense of this lecture only when I never hear how my tradition's account of an event, a question or a person sounds to someone outside it.
- Age, language and region. A congregation of people who speak the same language and come from the same area may all hear the same radio, read the same papers, and trust the same few teachers.
None of these is wrong in itself. The question is only whether any voice in the circle is able to say, "I do not think that is right," and be heard with kindness.
3. Belonging and the badge
There is a further feature that is easy to miss. In a close group, passing something on can be a way of saying "I am one of you." A forwarded message, a shared picture, or a repeated phrase may work as a sign of belonging. The person who passes it on may care less about whether it is accurate than about whether the group will welcome them.
This is not usually conscious, and it is not shameful. Human beings need to belong. But a sign of belonging does not need to be true in order to work, and the cost of not sharing it may feel high. A person who pauses, who says "I have not been able to check this," may feel that they are letting the group down.
So the practice of this course will sometimes cost something. This lecture does not pretend otherwise. It asks the reader to consider that belonging and honesty are not enemies and that a group in which one cannot say "I am not sure" is a poorer group than one in which one can.
4. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. If our information environment is crowded with items that are quick, strong and arranged for attention, who is responsible for the result?
Many who stress personal responsibility argue that every reader is a free adult who chooses what to read and what to pass on. In their view, blaming a system for my choices weakens the very conscience that Scripture addresses; I will answer for what I said and sent. Many who stress the design of services argue that the arrangement of what I see is built by those who run the services, who have knowledge and power an ordinary person lacks, and that it is unjust to place the whole weight on the one who is shown the item. Many who look to society as a whole argue that the environment is shaped also by schools, public institutions, laws, the habits of news makers and the shared customs of a community, so that responsibility is spread and must be taken up together. Some in each group would add that the others are right about something. Readers also differ about how far public rules should shape any of this, and this course takes no side on that.
Each of these positions can be held with care and each can be used to avoid a duty. Someone who says "it is all up to the individual" may overlook the real power of design. Someone who says "it is all the services" may excuse themselves from every choice. Someone who says "it is all society" may wait for a change that never comes.
What this course requires is smaller than any one of them and is not in dispute among them: my own share is real. Whatever others owe, I am one of those who receive, choose, and pass on. When I forward a message, I add my voice to what others will see, and I answer for it. That does not mean I carry the whole burden. It means that I do not hand all of it away.
5. What face to face gives
There is a very old remedy for a bubble, and it needs no technology. Hear people in the flesh who see things differently from me.
It works because a person in a room is harder to reduce to a label. I see their face, I hear their tone, I learn what they are afraid of and what they love. I find that they have reasons, and often reasons that began from something good. I cannot mute them or scroll past them. And they can ask me a question that a stranger's post never will.
Some practical ways:
- Share a meal, or a walk. Invite someone from another circle, and ask what they have been reading lately and why it matters to them. Listen to the answer to the end, and do not try to win. Ask one more question than you would normally.
- Say what you heard. Before you reply, say back what you understood: "You are saying that..." If you have understood badly, they will tell you.
- Hold the point back. A first meeting is not the time to correct anything. The aim is to learn how the world looks from there.
A caution is needed. Meeting in person does not guarantee honesty or breadth. A gathering where everyone agrees can be as much a bubble as a screen. And some readers live far from others, or are unwell, or cannot easily travel; for them a voice call, a letter, or a visit by a friend can carry some of the same good. The aim is real contact with persons, by whatever way is open.
6. Not a call to doubt one's friends
The last caution is about proportion. This lecture does not ask you to distrust the people you belong to, or to leave them. Most of what circles of friends pass on is ordinary and kind. Ephesians 4:25 says that we put away falsehood and speak truth, because we are members of one another. The reason is belonging, not distance. A member who speaks truth carefully is serving the body, and a member who pretends in order to be liked is not.
Matthew 7:3 sets a task for the reader before it sets one for anyone else: look first at my own eye. A reader who finishes this lecture thinking of someone else's bubble has missed it. The question for this week is about mine.
Diagram 1. A bubble and an opened circle
Diagram 2. Three positions on responsibility, and the one minimum
| Position | What it stresses | A risk if used alone |
|---|---|---|
| Personal responsibility | Each reader chooses what to read and pass on, and answers for it | Overlooks the real power of how services are arranged |
| The design of services | Those who build and run services shape what I see and know more than I do | Can excuse me from every choice |
| Society as a whole | Schools, institutions, laws and customs together shape the environment | Can leave me waiting for a change I could begin to make |
| What this course requires | My own share is real |
In short
- A bubble is a setting where I hear mostly voices like mine; an echo is my own view coming back repeated. From inside, both feel like ordinary life.
- Bubbles form in families, message groups, traditions and regions. Belonging is good; the difficulty begins when no correcting voice can be heard.
- Passing something on can be a sign of belonging, and a sign need not be true to work. Belonging and honesty are not enemies.
- Readers disagree about who is responsible: individuals, those who run services, or society. This course requires only that my own share is real.
- Hearing people face to face who differ from me, listening to the end and saying back what I heard, is an old remedy.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Bubble and echo | A setting of mostly like voices, and my own view returned to me, repeated, until it seems everywhere. |
| Why an echo misleads | Repetition feels like confirmation, though it may come from one source. |
| Three positions on responsibility | The individual; those who build and run services; society as a whole. |
| What the course requires | My own share is real: I receive, choose and pass on. |
One sentence to remember Whatever others owe, my share in what I receive and pass on is real, and a correcting voice should be welcome in my circle.
This week's action Invite one person who sees a question differently from you to a meal or a walk. Ask what they have been reading and why, and say back what you heard.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a circle you belong to: a family, a group chat, a congregation. What good does it do? Is there a voice in it that can say "I do not think that is right"?
- The lecture says an echo feels like confirmation. Can you think of a time when five voices said the same thing and you found that they had one source?
- Have you ever passed something on because you wished to belong more than because you had checked it? How might a group make it easier to say "I am not sure"?
- State each of the three positions on responsibility the way its holder would most want it stated. Which of them do you find yourself leaning on when you want to excuse something?
- Who is one person from another circle whom you could listen to this month, and what would you ask?