Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Doing, Becoming
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Curriculum Is a Promise
- Lecture 1-2: Looking at What You Already Have
- Lecture 1-3: Who Plans With You
- Lecture 1-4: Starting Small: A One-Year Frame
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Survey of What We Have
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Doing, Becoming
- Lecture 2-2: Writing Goals You Can Observe
- Lecture 2-3: Goals and Your Tradition's Teaching
- Lecture 2-4: Goals for People Who Start From Different Places
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Three Goals for One Group
- Lecture 3-1: The Big Picture Across Ages
- Lecture 3-2: The Shape of a Year
- Lecture 3-3: Designing One Unit
- Lecture 3-4: Order, Pace and Return
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Unit on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: Judging a Published Curriculum
- Lecture 4-2: Adapting and Making Your Own
- Lecture 4-3: One Room, Many Ages
- Lecture 4-4: Cost, Time and Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking One Material
- Lecture 5-1: What to Look For
- Lecture 5-2: Asking Teachers
- Lecture 5-3: Hearing Learners and Parents
- Lecture 5-4: Records and Privacy
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Questions to Look Back on One Unit
A children's teacher is asked by her coordinator, "What is the goal of the autumn term?" She thinks for a moment and answers, "To finish the book." The coordinator nods. It is an honest answer, and many teachers would give it. But finishing a book is a statement about the teacher's work, not about what the children are to receive. The book can be finished and nothing be given.
Chapter 1 asked you to look at what you have and to plan with the people who will live with the plan. This chapter turns to the heart of the promise from lecture 1-1: goals. A goal says what the congregation hopes will be true of a learner after the teaching. This first lecture offers a simple way to see the range of what a congregation might hope for. There are three kinds: knowing (the story and the teaching), doing (practices and habits), and becoming (the direction of the heart and character). A curriculum that names only one of them promises less than the congregation really means.
This lecture does not argue about what a curriculum is or why a church needs one. That belongs to PT5E, Christian Education. It is a workbook lecture: it gives you three words to sort your hopes, and it asks you to write each kind humbly and honestly.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Describe knowing, doing and becoming as three kinds of goals, with one example of each.
- Explain what is lost when a curriculum names only one kind.
- Write a "becoming" goal in humble words that promise a direction and not a result.
- Sort a list of mixed goals into the three kinds.
He has shown you, O man, what is good. What does Yahweh require of you, but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?" — Micah 6:8
World English Bible
But be doers of the word, and not only hearers, deluding your own selves. For if anyone is a hearer of the word and not a doer, he is like a man looking at his natural face in a mirror; for he sees himself, and goes away, and immediately forgets what kind of man he was. But he who looks into the perfect law of freedom, and continues, not being a hearer who forgets, but a doer of the work, this man will be blessed in what he does." — James 1:22-25
WEB
Don’t be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may prove what is the good, well-pleasing, and perfect will of God." — Romans 12:2
WEB
Micah names what is to be known ("He has shown you"), what is to be done ("act justly, love mercy") and the direction of a life ("walk humbly with your God"). James warns against hearing without doing. Paul speaks of a change that is slow and inward. None of the three passages is a plan for a curriculum. They are used here as three reminders that a faithful community hopes for more than information.
1. Three questions a goal can answer
Suppose a congregation has an eight-year-old learner, a sixteen-year-old and a woman of seventy who has just joined a study group. After a year of teaching, what does the congregation hope for each of them? If you ask leaders this question aloud, three kinds of answer come up, usually mixed together.
- "I hope they know the story. They should know who Jesus is, what the church says about God, how the Bible fits together."
- "I hope they do something. They should pray, come to worship, forgive, help a neighbour, read Scripture on their own."
- "I hope they become a certain kind of person: someone who loves, who is honest, who is humble, who trusts God."
These are not three rival theories. They are three questions that every goal answers in some measure. Knowing asks, "What should this person understand and remember?" Doing asks, "What should this person practise?" Becoming asks, "In what direction should this person's heart and character be growing?"
An invented example
A small assembly in a rented hall teaches its children about the parable of the lost sheep. The teacher's plan for the term says only: "Children will hear the stories of Luke 15." That is a plan about hearing. When the leaders talk about it, they say what they really hope: that the children can retell the three stories (knowing), that they learn to say "I am sorry" and to welcome someone who has been left out (doing), and that over the years they come to trust that they are sought and found (becoming). The written plan said one-third of what the leaders meant.
2. What goes wrong when only one kind is named
Each kind of goal, left alone, produces a recognisable weakness. Notice that this is a matter of what a curriculum tends to produce when it names only one kind; it is not a rule that every community falls into each trap.
Only knowing. The curriculum becomes a course of information. Learners may be able to list the books of the Bible and recite a creed, yet nobody has asked what they pray or how they treat the person beside them. The opposite danger is just as real: a community that distrusts "head knowledge" may leave its people without the story and the teaching that give practice its meaning. Knowing is not a lesser goal. It is a goal that cannot stand alone.
Only doing. The curriculum becomes a list of activities: serve a meal, visit the sick, say the daily prayers. These are good, but without the story and the teaching a learner may not know why they are done, and a practice with no reason is hard to keep when it becomes hard. The practice may also carry its own hidden teaching, which is easier to see when the reasons have been spoken.
Only becoming. The curriculum speaks in large phrases such as "a heart for God" or "Christlike character." No one is wrong to hope for these. But a goal that nobody can describe is a goal nobody can work towards, and teachers are left to guess. A congregation can also drift into measuring the heart by outward signs it has never agreed on, which is a quiet way of judging people.
A promise that names all three is harder to write and easier to keep. It tells teachers what to teach, what to practise and what to hope for, in that order of concreteness.
3. Knowing
Knowing goals are the most concrete. They say what a learner should be able to recall, explain or find. Examples (invented): "retell the story of the exodus in their own words"; "say the Lord’s Prayer from memory" (for a community that prays it); "explain in two sentences what our church means by baptism."
Two cautions. First, knowing is more than reciting. A child may say a creed perfectly and not know what it says. A good knowing goal often has two parts: the words and the meaning. Second, the community decides what is to be known. A liturgical community may name a creed or ; a free-church community may name a set of Bible stories and the church’s own short statement of faith. Lecture 2-3 returns to this.
4. Doing
Doing goals name practices and habits: something a person does, repeatedly, so that it becomes part of life. Examples (invented): "pray a short prayer before meals"; "come to the weekly gathering and take part"; "give a part of their pocket money or income to those in need"; "read a short passage of Scripture most days."
Doing goals are easier to see than becoming goals, and this is their strength. They also carry a risk. A habit can be kept for the wrong reason, or kept only while an adult is watching. The curriculum cannot make a habit last; it can introduce a practice, explain it, let learners try it and leave the door open. Practices differ by community. A parish may name the sign of the cross, fasting in particular seasons or the of confession; an assembly may name testimony, fellowship meals or prayer for the sick. The three kinds of goal do not tell you which practices to teach. Your tradition does.
5. Becoming
Becoming goals are the hardest to write. They name the direction of a life: growth in love, in honesty, in patience, in trust. Paul’s phrase "the renewing of your mind" and the belong here. Most congregations hope above all for becoming, and most find it the least describable.
There are good reasons for care. The first is that becoming is not fully in anyone’s hands. A teacher can teach and a community can practise, but a person’s heart is changed by more than a curriculum, and Christians who differ on much else agree that it is God who gives growth. The second is that a person cannot be fully seen from outside. What looks like patience may be fear, and what looks like indifference may be grief. The third is that a becoming goal can easily be turned into a standard against which people are ranked. Lecture 5-1 returns to what can be honestly seen.
Because of this, a becoming goal is best written as a direction and a hope, not as a result. Compare:
| Written as a result (avoid) | Written as a direction (better) |
|---|---|
| "Learners will be humble." | "We hope that learners grow in humility; we will give them chances to practise listening before speaking." |
| "Learners will love their neighbours." | "We hope that learners grow in love for their neighbours; we will give them real ways to help someone." |
| "Learners will have strong faith." | "We hope that learners grow in trust in God; we will tell the stories of those who trusted God, and let them pray." |
Notice what the better version does. It says "we hope", which is honest. It says what the congregation will do, which is what the congregation can promise. And it does not promise to produce a person. This is not a way of escaping accountability. It puts the accountability where it belongs: on what the community offers.
6. A way to use the three words
When you write or read a goal, ask which question it answers. Then ask whether the other two questions have been answered somewhere in the plan. You do not need one goal of each kind for every lesson. Over a unit or a year, a curriculum should show all three.
Sorting goals (an invented list)
- "Learners will name the five books of the Law." → Knowing.
- "Learners will take part in the weekly offering for the poor." → Doing.
- "We hope learners grow in gratitude." → Becoming.
- "Learners will explain why the church keeps the day of rest." → Knowing (with a link to doing).
- "Learners will practise forgiving a friend in a role-play." → Doing, serving a becoming hope.
Items 4 and 5 show that the kinds overlap. That is no problem. The test is whether the plan, taken as a whole, has all three.
7. In different kinds of congregation
In a large parish with a catechetical programme, knowing goals may be set by a catechism, doing goals by the rhythm of the sacraments and the church year, and becoming goals by the long hope of formation in the faith. In a small assembly with one teacher, the same three words fit on a single sheet of paper, and the teacher may only be able to name one goal of each kind for a whole year. That is enough. A short list that all three kinds appear in serves better than a long list of one kind.
Diagram 1. Three kinds of goal, side by side
In short
- Goals answer three questions: what should learners know, what should they do, and in what direction should they become.
- A curriculum that names only one kind promises less than the congregation means: information without practice, activity without reasons, or large words without a way in.
- Knowing goals include the words and their meaning, not recitation alone.
- Doing goals name practices that your own tradition and community choose; the three kinds do not choose them for you.
- Becoming goals are written as a direction and a hope, naming what the community will offer, not as a result promised in a person.
- Over a unit or a year, the plan should show all three kinds; one lesson need not.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The three kinds of goal | Knowing (story and teaching), doing (practices and habits), becoming (direction of heart and character). |
| What goes wrong with only one kind? | Information without practice, activity without reasons, or large words nobody can work towards. |
| How to write a becoming goal | As a direction and a hope: "We hope learners grow in ...; we will offer ...". |
| When must all three appear? | Across a unit or a year; one lesson need not carry all three. |
One sentence to remember A promise that names what we hope learners will know, do and become is harder to write and easier to keep.
This week's action Take one goal from a plan you know, decide which of the three kinds it is, and write one goal of each of the other two kinds beside it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of one teaching group you know. If you asked its leaders what they hope for, which of the three kinds would they name first? Which would they leave out?
- Which of the three kinds of goal do you find easiest to write, and which hardest? What does that suggest about your habits as a planner?
- Take the sentence "Learners will love one another." Rewrite it as a direction and a hope, naming what the congregation will do.
- Is there a risk in your community that "doing" is valued above "knowing", or the other way round? How would you notice?
- Why might a community be cautious about writing "becoming" goals as results? Do you agree with the caution? Where does it stop being helpful?