Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking One Material
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Curriculum Is a Promise
- Lecture 1-2: Looking at What You Already Have
- Lecture 1-3: Who Plans With You
- Lecture 1-4: Starting Small: A One-Year Frame
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Survey of What We Have
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Doing, Becoming
- Lecture 2-2: Writing Goals You Can Observe
- Lecture 2-3: Goals and Your Tradition's Teaching
- Lecture 2-4: Goals for People Who Start From Different Places
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Three Goals for One Group
- Lecture 3-1: The Big Picture Across Ages
- Lecture 3-2: The Shape of a Year
- Lecture 3-3: Designing One Unit
- Lecture 3-4: Order, Pace and Return
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Unit on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: Judging a Published Curriculum
- Lecture 4-2: Adapting and Making Your Own
- Lecture 4-3: One Room, Many Ages
- Lecture 4-4: Cost, Time and Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking One Material
- Lecture 5-1: What to Look For
- Lecture 5-2: Asking Teachers
- Lecture 5-3: Hearing Learners and Parents
- Lecture 5-4: Records and Privacy
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Questions to Look Back on One Unit
This is the fourth Practice Lab of the course. Each week ends with one, and each asks you to do something rather than to agree with something.
Today's task is small. Put on one page the answers to the nine questions about one material, and decide whether to use it, adapt it or leave it. The material may be one you use now, one you have been offered, or one that is invented for this exercise. All three are real ways into the lab, and none is a lesser one.
The first four lectures of this week gave you ideas: a published curriculum is another group's promise, to be checked against your own (4-1); a session can be kept, changed, cut or added to, with a source note (4-2); a mixed room needs one story at several depths (4-3); and every plan lives within limits of money, time, space, teacher numbers and language (4-4). This lab asks you to hold those ideas against one actual material. Knowing a checklist and using it are different, and only the second changes what you will put in front of a teacher.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Complete the sheet "Checking One Material" for a real, observed or invented material.
- State the four promises of privacy that govern this lab.
- Reach one of three decisions (use it, adapt it, leave it) and give a reason in one sentence.
- Explain how to run the lab in a small group so that nobody is judged.
Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21
World English Bible
Keep this verse in front of you while you write. It has two halves, and the sheet follows both: first the testing, then the holding on to what is good. A sheet that only finds fault has done half the work.
1. Why a sheet, and why one material
A checklist in a lecture can look easy. It is much harder when a real book is open on the table and the teacher's page is dense. The lab uses one material because a general discussion ("we should check what we buy") slides past. One material has edges: a price, a number of pages, a reading level, an opening game that needs a field.
Notice what the goal is not. It is not to prove that the material is good or bad. It is not to find fault with the people who made it, or with the people who chose it. The goal is to see how a particular material sits beside your promise.
2. The four promises of privacy
Say these before you begin. If you are leading a group, say them out loud.
- Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer to write.
- You may pass on any part. Leave a box empty if you wish; that is a complete answer.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. The person at the front is not an examiner.
One more rule goes with these: do not write the name of a real teacher, learner, parent or colleague on the sheet. Write "a teacher of the youngest" or "a parent", not a name. The sheet is about a material, not about people. If you are looking at a material that someone in your community chose, you need not write who chose it. It also asks nothing about any learner's private life.
3. How to do it
The steps, whichever way you choose
Step 1. Choose your way from the three below. You may change your mind part way through.
Step 2. Copy the sheet in section 4 onto a page by hand, or reproduce its headings on a blank page. Do not skip the headings; they are the exercise.
Step 3. Read at least three sessions of the material. If you are using a material that exists only in your mind, read the sample in this lecture. Three sessions from different parts of a material show more than the cover.
Step 4. Answer each of the nine questions with one word: Yes, Partly, No or Don't know. Write one short line of note beside each.
Step 5. Write your decision and one sentence of reason. If you cannot decide, write "not yet" and say what you would need to find out.
Step 6. Read the sheet once and underline the answer that surprises you.
4. The three ways into this lab
Way 1: In your own congregation. Use this way if you plan or lead teaching. Choose one material that your teachers use, or one that you have been offered. Fill in the sheet from the book itself. If your teachers use the material, you may also ask one teacher, in private and in her own time, whether she would tell you which of the nine questions has been hardest for her. Do not do this unless you are sure she will feel free to say no.
Way 2: The observer's way. Use this way if you do not plan teaching. Choose one material you can see for yourself, but only where the community's policy and the person responsible allow it. A teacher may let you look at the book she uses, or a library may hold a sample. You are looking at a book, not at a teacher or a class, and you should judge no teacher and no learner. Spend an hour with the book. If you cannot look at one, recall a material you once used as a learner or as a helper and fill in the sheet from memory; write "from memory" at the top and leave blank any box you cannot recall.
Way 3: The partner's way. Use this way if you have a trusted partner and no other way suits you. You will work with an invented congregation and an invented material, so that no real material is judged and no personal story is needed.
The congregation (invented). A small assembly of about forty people meets in a rented hall. It has one teacher for children, who also works in a shop, and a second who helps when she can. There are eleven children, aged 4 to 12, and three young people. The assembly has no money for craft supplies, and it follows no church year. Several families speak another language at home. The promise it wrote in chapter 1 is that the children will know the main stories, pray in their own words and learn to care for one another.
The material (invented). A printed scheme of twelve sessions for ages 7 to 10, with a teacher's page for each session. Seven sessions read a Bible passage; five use a single verse as a start. The sessions use a game, a worksheet to be copied, and a closing prayer written in a formal style. The sentences are long. The examples take place in a city. The cost is small, but the worksheets need 20 pages of copying each week.
Take turns. In the first round, one partner is the planner, who fills in the sheet for the invented assembly. The other is a sceptical teacher who asks "why?" after each answer, in a kindly way, and asks what she would have to do on Sunday morning. Then swap. Talk for five minutes about which question was hardest to answer from the page alone.
5. What usually goes wrong
Three reactions come up often. None means you have done it wrong.
"I cannot tell without trying it." Many questions cannot be answered fully from the page. Write "Don't know" and a note on how you would find out. That is a useful answer.
"Everything is Partly." This is common with a material that is decent but not made for you. It is often the right answer. The decision, use, adapt or leave, is where you commit. If the decision is adapt, the notes beside the Partly answers become your list of changes.
"I feel I should speak well of what we already use." The sheet is not a report to the community. If a material does not serve your goals, that is a fact about the material and your goals, not a failure in those who chose it.
A fourth reaction is less common and matters more. Sometimes a material that someone in your community loves, or wrote, comes up in the sheet as a poor fit. If that happens, do not announce it. Take the sheet to the person responsible for the teaching and talk through one question at a time, starting with what the material does well. A decision to leave a material is more likely to be accepted if the people who chose it have been heard first.
6. What the sheet gives you
When you have finished, look at the sheet as a whole.
You will probably see that one or two questions carry most of the weight. A single "No" on tradition may matter more than five "Yes" answers. The weight depends on your promise.
You will see what the material would ask of your teachers in time and in changes. This tells you whether "adapt" is truly within your teachers' power.
You will see what you do not yet know. The Don't know boxes are a short list of jobs: read the permission page, test a page with a reader, ask a teacher.
And you will have a decision with a reason. Keep it. Next year it will tell you what you thought and why.
7. A filled-in sample (an invented example)
| Question | Answer | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Scripture | Partly | Seven of twelve sessions read the passage |
| 2. Tradition | Partly | Baptism worded differently from ours; no prayers we know |
| 3. Goals | Partly | Helps "knowing"; little on praying in their own words |
| 4. Age | Yes | Fits 8 to 10; younger children will need a helper |
| 5. Language | Partly | Long sentences; families with another home language will struggle |
| 6. Cost | Partly | Cheap, but 20 pages to copy each week |
| 7. Teacher preparation | Yes | One clear page; about 40 minutes |
| 8. Culture | No | City examples, buses, shops |
| 9. Terms of use | Don't know | Read the permission page; ask about copying and translation |
| Decision | Adapt | Keep the seven passage sessions; replace examples; shorten sentences; add a prayer activity; check terms before copying |
How to read it: the answers do not add to a score. The two serious matters are tradition and terms of use; everything else can be adapted. What it is for: the sample shows the shape of a finished sheet, not the right answers for your material.
8. Leader's note, for running this in a group
Running the lab so that nobody is judged
Say the four promises of privacy first, out loud. Before anyone picks up a pen, say: nobody will read what you write; nothing is marked; you may pass on any part; I am filling in a sheet too. Say it even if you said it last week.
Fill in your own sheet. Sit down and write alongside the group, for a material you really know. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination.
Let each person choose their way. In one group there may be a coordinator using Way 1, a person who has looked at one book using Way 2, and a pair using the invented assembly of Way 3. All are equal. Do not ask anyone to say which way they chose.
Provide the material. If several people are using Way 3, have copies of the invented description ready, so that no one has to invent from nothing. If anyone uses a real book, make sure it is theirs to use or that the person responsible has allowed it.
Give twenty quiet minutes for writing, then ten minutes in pairs for anyone who chose Way 3. Do not fill the silence with comment.
Ask about the work, never about the contents. Do not ask "What did you write?" Ask: "What was it like to fill that in?" or "Which question was hardest to answer from the page?" Then allow anyone to pass. Say: "If you would rather not say anything, just pass," and move on without a pause that makes passing costly.
Do not name a real publisher, product or person. If someone begins to name one, say gently, "You do not need the name. Tell us the pattern: what kind of question was it?" The sheet is about the shape of a decision.
Do not answer a disagreement with a ruling. If two people reach different decisions about similar material, that is not an error. Their promises and limits differ.
Do not turn the lab into a decision for the community. The sheet is for seeing. Decisions are made, as chapter 1 said, with the people who plan, not in one evening in a lab.
Diagram 1. The form: Checking One Material
Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises of privacy out loud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Let each person choose their way and did not ask which | [ ] |
| Had the invented description ready for those who chose Way 3 | [ ] |
| Asked "What was it like to fill that in?" and not "What did you write?" | [ ] |
| Offered a real option to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Did not let anyone name a real publisher, product or person | [ ] |
| Did not turn the evening into a decision for the community | [ ] |
In short
- The lab holds the ideas of the week against one material: nine questions, three sessions read, and a decision.
- There are three equal ways in: your own congregation, the observer's way, and the partner's way with an invented congregation and material.
- Four promises of privacy: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills one in too.
- Never write the name of a real teacher, learner, parent or colleague, and name no real publisher or product.
- The decision is use, adapt, leave or not yet, with one sentence of reason; "Don't know" is a useful answer and becomes a job to do.
- Running it: promises first, the leader writes too, ask "What was it like to fill that in?", and never turn the evening into a community decision.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three ways in | Your own congregation; the observer's way; the partner's way with an invented congregation and material. |
| Four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills one in too. |
| The decision | Use it, adapt it, leave it or not yet, with one sentence of reason. |
| The leader's question | Not "What did you write?" but "What was it like to fill that in?" |
One sentence to remember Test the material, hold on to what is good, and write down why you chose.
This week's action Fill in the sheet on an actual page for one material, and write the three jobs your "Don't know" answers have left you.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What was it like to fill that in? Answer with a feeling, not with the contents.
- Which question was easiest to answer, and which was hardest from the page alone? What might that tell you?
- Which one or two questions carried the most weight against your promise?
- If you chose the observer's way, what did you notice that you had not noticed before? If you chose the partner's way, what did the sceptical teacher make you see?
- If you wish to say what you decided, do so. If you would rather not, pass.