FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT708E Designing a Church Curriculum: A Workbook for Leaders of Teaching and Formation

Lecture 4-1: Judging a Published Curriculum

Contents 31
PT708E Designing a Church Curriculum: A Workbook for Leaders of Teaching and Formation
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Curriculum Is a Promise
  1. Introduction: A Curriculum Is a Promise
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Where to Begin
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Curriculum Is a Promise
  2. Lecture 1-2: Looking at What You Already Have
  3. Lecture 1-3: Who Plans With You
  4. Lecture 1-4: Starting Small: A One-Year Frame
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Survey of What We Have
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Writing Goals
  1. Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Doing, Becoming
  2. Lecture 2-2: Writing Goals You Can Observe
  3. Lecture 2-3: Goals and Your Tradition's Teaching
  4. Lecture 2-4: Goals for People Who Start From Different Places
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Three Goals for One Group
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Scope, Sequence and Unit
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Big Picture Across Ages
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Shape of a Year
  3. Lecture 3-3: Designing One Unit
  4. Lecture 3-4: Order, Pace and Return
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Unit on One Page
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Choosing and Adapting Materials
  1. Lecture 4-1: Judging a Published Curriculum
  2. Lecture 4-2: Adapting and Making Your Own
  3. Lecture 4-3: One Room, Many Ages
  4. Lecture 4-4: Cost, Time and Language
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking One Material
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Looking Back Honestly
  1. Lecture 5-1: What to Look For
  2. Lecture 5-2: Asking Teachers
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hearing Learners and Parents
  4. Lecture 5-4: Records and Privacy
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Questions to Look Back on One Unit
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Piloting, Supporting and Keeping
  1. Lecture 6-1: Piloting and Revising
  2. Lecture 6-2: Preparing and Supporting Teachers
  3. Lecture 6-3: Writing It Down So It Lasts
  4. Lecture 6-4: The Yearly Review
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Our Year on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

19 min

A coordinator has a catalogue open on a table. Three published schemes look good. One has bright pictures, one has a clear teacher's book, and one costs almost nothing. The teachers are waiting for a decision. The coordinator wonders how to choose when each scheme says it is the best.

This lecture gives a way to choose. The way is a checklist, and the checklist has one idea behind it: a published curriculum is somebody else's promise, and you are about to make it yours. The people who wrote it had a group of learners in mind, a tradition in mind and goals in mind. They may not be your learners, your tradition or your goals. So before you adopt it, you hold it against what you promised in chapters 1 to 3.

Nothing here is a verdict on any publisher or product, and no product is named. The checklist asks questions about the material in front of you. The answers belong to you.

What these 19 minutes give you

  • Explain why a published curriculum must be checked against your own goals before it is used.
  • Use a checklist of questions on Scripture, tradition, age, language, cost, teacher preparation, cultural fit and terms of use.
  • State fairly the case for bought material and the case for home-made material, and say what this course requires in both.
  • Decide, for one material, whether to use it as it is, adapt it, or leave it.

Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21

World English Bible

Now these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of the mind, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." — Acts 17:11

WEB

A simple man believes everything, but the prudent man carefully considers his ways." — Proverbs 14:15

WEB

The three verses fit together. Paul tells a church to test things and keep what is good. Luke praises people who listened eagerly and also checked. The proverb names the opposite of checking: believing everything. A coordinator who checks a material is not being suspicious. A coordinator who checks is doing what these verses ask of any teaching that comes to a congregation.

1. Why check what has been published

A published curriculum arrives with confidence. It has a title, a design, a teacher's book, and often a promise on the cover. All of that can be good. But it was made for a general reader, and your congregation is not general. It has a particular tradition, particular ages, particular teachers and a particular budget.

There is also a quieter reason. Every material teaches more than it says. It teaches what a lesson is, what a child is expected to do, what counts as a good answer, and how the Bible is read. (PT5E, Christian Education, explains this hidden side of teaching; here it is enough to say that a material has one.) If you do not look at it, it will form your learners in ways you did not choose.

So the first rule of this lecture is simple. Put your goals on the table first, then lay the material beside them. A material that is excellent but pulls in another direction is the wrong material for you, however good it is.

2. The checklist, one question at a time

The checklist has nine questions. Each one is a short question that a tired coordinator can answer with the material open on the desk. Read the material itself, not only the cover and the introduction. Read at least three sample sessions from different parts of it.

1. How does it use Scripture? Look at three sessions. Does the session read the passage, or use one verse as a hook and then move to a topic? Does it let the story keep its own shape? Do learners meet the text itself, or only a summary of it? Is the Bible translation one your learners can read, and is the passage quoted accurately? None of these answers is a failure in itself. A topic-based session can be sound. The point is that you know which kind you are buying.

2. Does it fit your tradition? Every material has a view of what the church believes and does. Where does it speak about baptism, communion or the Eucharist, the saints, prayer, the church year, the authority of the church and of Scripture? Read the places where such things appear. If your church teaches something the material leaves out, you will have to add it. If the material teaches something your church does not, you will have to change or cut it. Either can be done. The question is how much work it will be, and whether you are willing to do it.

3. Does it fit your goals? Take the goals you wrote in chapter 2. For each goal for knowing, doing and becoming, ask whether the material has anything that helps toward it. Material that does not help with any of your goals is not wicked. It is simply for a different promise.

4. Does it fit the age? Check the age range on the cover against the activities inside. Would the children you know be able to do what is asked? Is the reading level right? Is the pace too fast for a group that meets once a month, or too slow for one that meets every week? Lecture 4-3 returns to rooms where the ages are mixed.

5. Is the language one your learners can use? If it is written in a language your learners do not speak well, it will fail even if every idea is sound. If it is in your learners' language, check whether the sentences are short and plain, or whether they need a native ear. A learner who must stop at every second sentence has no attention left for the story. Lecture 4-4 treats translation.

6. What does it really cost? The price on the cover is only part. Add printing or copying, craft supplies, books for each learner or for the teacher, training or meetings, and the teacher's preparation time. A cheap material that needs three hours of preparation every week may cost your teachers more than an expensive one that needs thirty minutes. Count time as a cost, because your teachers are volunteers.

7. How much preparation does it ask of teachers? Read one session as if you were a teacher who has never taught. Is it clear what to do first? Does it assume that the teacher knows the story well? Does it assume a trained voice, a musical instrument, a computer or a projector? A good teacher's book makes the teacher more able, not more anxious. Lecture 6-2 returns to teacher support.

8. Does it fit your culture and setting? Look at the examples, pictures, names, food, holidays, family patterns and games. Do they speak to the learners you have, or to learners somewhere else? A story that starts "On the way to school, by bus" means little to a child who walks six kilometres. A pattern that assumes both parents at home, or a house with a garden, may hurt a child who does not have one. You can adapt this, but you should know how much.

9. What are the terms of use? Can you copy the pages? Can you translate them? Can you change them? Can you put them on a screen or share them with a second congregation? Material of every kind comes with terms set by its makers, and the terms differ. Read them. Follow the permission terms the maker gives and the law of your own country, and the written policy of your community. This lecture gives no legal advice, because the rules differ from place to place.

3. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree: whether a congregation should buy a published scheme or make its own material. Some leaders prefer a published scheme, and their reasons are strong. A published scheme has been written by people with time and skill, often tested with many groups. It saves hours that volunteers do not have. It often comes with training, support and a teacher's book that makes the first year easier, and a scheme supplied by a denomination or diocese also keeps many congregations teaching the same thing. Other leaders prefer home-made material, and their reasons are also strong. Home-made material can be fitted exactly to these learners, this language, this tradition and these goals. It carries no cost for licences. It grows from the teachers' own knowledge of the people in the room, and the work of making it forms the teachers. This course does not choose between them. It requires less than either camp requires: whichever you use, check it against your goals, and respect the terms under which it was made. A bought scheme that nobody has checked can quietly replace your promise with someone else's. A home-made one that nobody has checked can be thin, can drift, or can copy what it had no right to copy.

4. Reading the checklist as a whole

Do not add up the answers to a number. A checklist is a way of seeing, not a test with a pass mark. One answer can outweigh the rest: a material that contradicts a central teaching of your church is a serious problem even if eight other answers are good. A material that is a little too expensive, but otherwise right, can be handled with a plan.

When you have answered all nine questions, you will find the material falls into one of three groups.

  • Use it as it is. The answers are good and any small gaps are easy to fill.
  • Adapt it. The material is mostly right, but some parts must be changed, cut or added. Lecture 4-2 shows how.
  • Leave it. The gaps are larger than the gain, or the cost in money, time or teacher stress is too high.

Say which of the three you chose, and write one sentence of reason. Next year you will want to know why.

5. A sample checklist (an invented example)

The table below is filled in for an invented boxed scheme for children aged 7 to 10, twelve sessions long. It does not describe any real product.

Question Answer Note
1. Scripture Partly Seven sessions read a passage; five use one verse as a starting point
2. Tradition Partly Teaches baptism in a way our church would word differently; says nothing on the church year
3. Goals Yes Helps our "knowing" goal; little for "doing"
4. Age Yes Tasks suit 8 to 10; six-year-olds will need help
5. Language Partly Our learners read it, but several long sentences need explaining
6. Cost Partly Cheap to buy; 20 pages to copy per week
7. Teacher preparation Yes A clear teacher's page; about 40 minutes
8. Culture No Examples assume a city with buses and shops
9. Terms of use Don't know Need to read the permission page
Decision Adapt Change the examples; reword the baptism session; add two "doing" activities; read the terms before copying

How to fill it in. Open the material and read at least three sessions. Write one word for each question: Yes, Partly, No or Don't know. Add a note of one line, so that next year you can see why you said it. Give a decision at the bottom.

What it is for. The table makes you look, and it makes the decision something you can explain to the other teachers. It does not decide for you.

6. The same work in two kinds of community

In a large parish with a catechetical programme, a diocese or a central office may already have chosen a scheme. The checklist is still useful. It shows where the local teachers will need to add or explain, and it gives a way to tell the office what the parish needs. In a small assembly or a house church, there may be only one material in the cupboard, given years ago. The checklist is the same, but the decision is often "adapt", and the time you can spend is short. Check the three biggest questions first: Scripture, tradition and cost. Then do the rest as time allows.


Diagram 1. The checklist at a glance

Checking a Published Material Your goals first; the material is laid beside them Start from what you promised (chapters 1 to 3) 1 How does it use Scripture? 2 Does it fit your tradition? 3 Does it fit your goals? 4 Does it fit the age? 5 Can your learners use the language? 6 What does it really cost (money and time)? 7 How much must a teacher prepare? 8 Does it fit your culture and setting? 9 What are the terms of use? (read the permission page; follow local law and your community's policy) Use it small gaps only Adapt it change, cut, add (lecture 4-2) Leave it the gap is larger than the gain A checklist is a way of seeing, not a test with a pass mark. Write one sentence of reason.

In short

  • A published curriculum is another group's promise; check it against your own goals before it becomes yours.
  • Nine questions: Scripture, tradition, goals, age, language, cost, teacher preparation, culture, and terms of use.
  • Read the material itself, at least three sessions, and count teachers' time as part of its cost.
  • Bought and home-made material each have strong supporters; this course requires that either be checked and that its terms be respected.
  • A checklist is a way of seeing, not a score; one serious conflict with your tradition can outweigh many good answers.
  • The decision is one of three: use it, adapt it, or leave it, with one sentence of reason.
Front Back
First rule of choosing Put your own goals on the table, then lay the material beside them.
The nine questions Scripture, tradition, goals, age, language, cost, teacher preparation, culture, terms of use.
Bought or home-made? Both have strong reasons; whichever you use, check it against your goals and respect its terms.
The three decisions Use it, adapt it, or leave it, with one sentence of reason.

One sentence to remember Before you adopt someone else's promise, check it against your own.

This week's action Take one material your teachers use and answer the nine questions in a single line each, using at least three sessions.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a material your teachers use now. Which of the nine questions have you never asked about it? Which would you ask first?
  • Where in the material does the hidden teaching sit: in the pictures, the activities, the way a good answer is rewarded? What does it teach that nobody wrote on purpose?
  • In your tradition, what must a material never leave out? What must it never say?
  • Do you lean toward bought material or toward home-made material? What is the strongest argument for the other side, in the words of someone who holds it?
  • What is the true cost of the material you use, once you count the teacher's time?
  • Who would you ask to read the permission terms of a material with you, if the language of the terms is hard?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.