Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
Contents 25
- Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
- Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
- Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
- Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
- Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
- Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
- Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
- Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
- Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
- Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
- Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
- Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
- Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
- Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
- Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
A treasurer has served a small congregation for eleven years. Everyone agrees that she is careful, honest and tired. She counts the offering on Sunday afternoon, takes it home, enters it in the book, pays the bills from the bank account, reads the bank statement when it arrives, and gives the yearly report. (An invented example.) No one has ever doubted her. For that very reason, no one has ever looked over her shoulder.
Is that a picture of trust? In one sense it is. But look at what it leaves her with. If she makes an honest mistake in March, there is no one to notice it until it has grown. If she falls ill, no one knows where anything is. If a rumour starts, she has nothing to show that would end it. The congregation has put all its trust, and all its risk, on the shoulders of one tired person.
This lecture teaches one idea and some ways to carry it out. The idea: do not let one person receive, approve, pay, record and check the same money. The ways: separate the jobs, ask for a second approval that is real, change who does what from time to time, and, where the congregation is very small, find a second pair of eyes from outside. The lecture also states fairly the disagreement over whether such care shows trust or distrust.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Name the four jobs that should not rest with one person: approving, holding, recording and checking.
- Explain what makes a second approval real and what makes it only a signature.
- Describe how rotation and time away protect both the work and the worker.
- Suggest two or three workable safeguards for a congregation too small to separate the jobs fully.
- State fairly the two views on whether controls show trust or distrust, and say what this course requires.
One witness shall not rise up against a man for any iniquity, or for any sin, in any sin that he sins. At the mouth of two witnesses, or at the mouth of three witnesses, shall a matter be established." — Deuteronomy 19:15
World English Bible
Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their labor." — Ecclesiastes 4:9
WEB
For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow; but woe to him who is alone when he falls, and doesn’t have another to lift him up." — Ecclesiastes 4:10
WEB
Again, if two lie together, then they have warmth; but how can one keep warm alone?" — Ecclesiastes 4:11
WEB
If a man prevails against one who is alone, two shall withstand him; and a threefold cord is not quickly broken." — Ecclesiastes 4:12
WEB
The first passage comes from the law about legal cases. It says that a matter should not rest on a single witness. The second comes from a reflection on work and company. Neither is about money, and neither should be stretched into a rule for accounts. Together they show a habit of mind that this lecture borrows: where much depends on one person, a second person is a protection, and often a kindness.
1. The question behind the controls
Ask a treasurer what she is afraid of, and she will seldom say "theft". She is more likely to say "a mistake", "an angry member", "being blamed for something I did not do", or "being ill and leaving a mess". These are better guides to why controls matter than any list of dishonest acts. A control is a habit that lets a mistake be found early, lets an honest person show that she is honest, and makes a wrong, if one is ever done, harder to hide and easier to stop.
This lecture teaches safeguards, and it does not teach how people go wrong. A treasurer is not a detective. Her work is to keep the money carefully, to show how it was kept, to check with someone else, and, if something looks wrong, to pass it on (lecture 6-2 explains how). The controls below serve those four verbs.
2. Four jobs, four pairs of hands
Every flow of money has four jobs in it. The names vary, but the jobs are the same.
- Approving is the decision that money may be received in a certain way, or spent for a certain purpose. It is the decision that "yes, this payment is in the plan and is allowed."
- Holding is the care of the actual money: cash in a safe, a payment card, access to a bank account.
- Recording is writing it down: the count sheet, the ledger, the receipts file (lectures 3-1 and 3-3).
- Checking is looking at the record and the bank, and asking whether they agree, and whether what was done was what was approved.
The principle is simple to say: no one person should do all four for the same money, and in particular the person who holds the money should not be the only one who records it, and the person who records it should not be the only one who checks it. If these jobs sit with four people, a wrong needs four people to agree on it. If they sit with one, a mistake or a wrong needs no one's help to stay hidden.
Notice that this is not an accusation. It is a description of where a mistake or a wrong would have to pass, and a decision to put people in the way. Think of a bridge with two guardrails. No one puts up the second rail because they think the first is a liar.
3. Dual approval: a second signature that means something
Many congregations ask that a payment above a certain size have two approvals, and that a bank account need two people to release money. This is called dual approval (or "two-person approval"). Lecture 3-2 set out approval limits by size of payment. This lecture asks a harder question: is the second approval real?
A second approval is real when:
- The second person is independent. They do not report to the first person, they are not in the same household, and they do not depend on the first person for a favour or for pay. If the treasurer's husband is the second signer, there are two signatures but only one decision.
- The second person sees what is being approved. They look at the request, the plan and the invoice or reason, not only at a form with a space for a name. A signature on a form the signer has not read is a decoration.
- The second person is allowed to say no, and is not punished for it. If the second signer has never refused anything in five years, ask whether the second approval is a check or a ritual.
- The second person can be reached. If the second signer is always abroad, the first person will find ways round the second approval, and the rule will slowly be forgotten.
Say it plainly in the congregation's own rules: who may approve, what they must see, and what happens when the second person is away. A rule that does not say what happens in an absence will be broken on the first Sunday it is needed.
4. Rotation and time away
Two habits help more than most people expect: changing who does what from time to time, and making sure every job can be done by someone else.
Rotation means that jobs are not held by one person for ever. The persons who count the offering change between weeks. The person who reconciles the ledger to the bank statement (lecture 3-3) is not always the same one. Officers have a term, after which they may serve again only after a pause or with a fresh decision by the congregation. The reason is not suspicion. It is that a long-held job becomes invisible: no one remembers how it is done, no one asks, and the holder cannot be replaced if they fall ill. A fresh pair of eyes sees what an old pair no longer sees.
Time away means that each person who holds a financial job takes time off from it, and that someone else does the work while they are away. This protects the work: it shows that the job can be done without that one person, and that the written procedure is real and not carried in one head. It protects the worker too: a treasurer who has never been away has no way to show, in a hard season, that things are in order without her. It also protects her from weariness. A faithful worker who cannot ever be spared will be tired for the wrong reasons.
5. When the congregation is very small
The advice so far assumes that a congregation has enough people to share the jobs. Many do not. A house church may have a dozen members, one bank account and one volunteer who does everything. It is not a failure of faith to be small. It does call for a few honest substitutes for separation:
- Use two people where you cannot have four. One person counts and records, and another, who is not of the same household, verifies the count and signs the sheet. Another person receives the bank statement directly, and looks at it first.
- Give the statement to someone who is not the treasurer. Let the bank send the statement (paper or electronic) to a second person, or let a second person log in to view it, using their own access. If it is a joint account, check the bank's own rules about how access is given; the course does not advise any sharing of secret details (lecture 4-2).
- Ask someone from outside. A retired bookkeeper from another church, a trusted member of a neighbouring assembly, a person from the denominational office, or a local accountant can look through the ledger and the bank statement once or twice a year. This is the "outside eye" of lecture 4-3.
- Write the rules down on one page. A small congregation needs a short, clear page more than a large one needs a thick manual: who counts, who holds, who approves, who checks, and who is the back-up for each.
- Accept that not all risks go away. A congregation of eight cannot reach the controls of a congregation of eight hundred. It can still reach a second person looking at it, which is the main thing.
Note what these have in common. None of them requires more people than the congregation has. Each puts a second set of eyes on the same money. That is the lesson to carry from the large parish to the house church: the number of people is not the point; the point is that no important step is seen by only one person.
6. In a parish and in a free church
In a parish that belongs to a diocese or similar body, much of the structure is already there: a parish council or committee, a diocesan office that receives reports or holds the accounts, a visiting auditor or an annual inspection. The risk is the opposite one: that a parish thinks "the diocese checks us", and stops checking itself. The diocesan office usually sees summaries; it does not watch the offering plate. A parish still needs its own two counters, its own approval rules and its own records. The outside body is a second layer, and it is not a replacement for the first.
In a free church or independent assembly, no outside body may exist at all. The governing board or elders are then the only check, and they may be the same people who do the work. In that case the board should make sure that at least one member of it is not involved in the daily handling and looks at the bank statement and the monthly report. Where the board is the treasurer's own friends, that makes it harder, not easier, and the outside eye of an accountant or a sister congregation becomes more important.
Both settings need the same thing, in different clothes: someone who did not do the work looks at the work.
7. Controls apply to everyone, including the clergy
A congregation that has careful rules for its volunteers and none for its pastor or priest has only half of a safeguard. Controls protect people, and they protect them equally. If a payment above a set size needs two approvals, it needs them when the minister wishes to spend, as much as when a volunteer does. If expense claims are checked by someone else, the minister's are checked too. If the bank statement goes to a second person, it does so whoever the treasurer is.
This is not because clergy are more likely to go wrong; there is no reason to think so, and this course makes no such claim. It is because a rule that has an exception for a person of rank teaches everyone that the rule is about rank and not about care. It also puts the person at the top in a lonely position: with no one asking, there is no one who can say, afterwards, "it was all looked at." Many ministers, in fact, welcome clear rules, because they take from them the weight of having to be trusted without a check.
The same goes for the treasurer's own family, the chair of the board and the founder of the congregation. If an exception is needed, let the governing body make it openly, in writing, for stated reasons, and review it.
8. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: whether careful systems show trust or distrust. One view holds that a congregation is a family, not a bank. Members who have known each other for decades choose a treasurer because they trust her. To ask for two counters, a second signature and an outside review tells her, in front of everyone, "we do not think you are safe." On this view, the controls can wound a faithful worker and may make a close community feel like an office; some who hold this view add that love is slow to think evil, and that a church should be able to afford a measure of confidence. The other view holds that controls are what love does when it takes human weakness seriously. People are tired, distracted and sometimes tempted. A system that depends on one person's perfect conduct is a system that will, one day, hurt that person. On this view, controls protect the honest person from suspicion, protect the weak from temptation, and protect the congregation's witness before a watching world; they are no insult, any more than a lock on a door is an insult to the neighbours. Both views begin from care for people. They differ on what care requires, and on how it feels to the person being watched.
This course requires less than either side asks for. It requires only that controls protect people, and are applied to everyone, including the clergy. It does not require that anyone is distrusted, nor that anyone is trusted without a check. A treasurer who says "please have someone look at this with me" is not confessing a weakness. She is doing her work well. The way a congregation introduces its controls matters as much as the controls: say plainly that they are for everyone, that they are about the money and not about the person, and that the first person to be checked will be the most senior.
9. What the Scripture scene shows
Deuteronomy 19:15 sits in a passage about legal cases. Its point is that a charge against a person should not be settled on one voice. It protects the accused from a single mistaken or hostile witness, and it protects the community from acting on a single report. Read for our subject, it is a reminder that a second witness helps the accused first. A treasurer who has two counters and two signatures has two people who can say, if someone doubts, "I saw it, and it was right."
Ecclesiastes 4:9-12 speaks about work and company. A person who has no one to lift them when they fall is in danger. A "threefold cord" is not quickly broken. We do not read the passage as a financial rule. But it shows a way of thinking: it is not good to be alone with a heavy thing. Money entrusted by others is a heavy thing. The treasurer who is alone with it is carrying a weight that was not meant to be carried alone.
Diagram 1. Four jobs, and who should hold them
In short
- No one person should approve, hold, record and check the same money; a wrong or a mistake then has to pass through several people to stay hidden.
- A second approval is real only if the second person is independent, sees what is approved, may refuse and can be reached.
- Rotation and time away keep jobs from becoming invisible, show that the procedure is written down, and protect the faithful worker from weariness.
- A very small congregation can use two unrelated counters, a statement sent to a second person, an outside reader once or twice a year, and a one-page written rule.
- Readers disagree on whether controls show trust or distrust; this course requires that controls protect people and apply to everyone, clergy included.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four jobs | Approving, holding, recording and checking; no one person should do all four for the same money. |
| A real second approval | The second person is independent, sees what is approved, may refuse without penalty, and can be reached. |
| Why rotate and take time away? | A long-held job becomes invisible; rotation and absence show the work can be done by others, and rest the worker. |
| What does this course require of controls? | They protect people and apply to everyone, including the clergy. |
One sentence to remember Where much is entrusted to one person, a second person looking is a protection and a kindness, not an insult.
This week's action Write down, on one page and without names, which of the four jobs each step of your offering-to-bank route is done by, and mark any step where one person does two jobs.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Who in your congregation does more than one of the four jobs (approving, holding, recording, checking) for the same money? Is that by design, or has it happened over the years?
- Think of a second approval in your congregation. Is the second person independent, do they see what is being approved, may they refuse, and can they be reached? Which of the four is weakest?
- Has anyone in a financial job taken a real break from it? What would happen this month if that person were suddenly unable to work?
- How would a faithful treasurer feel if her congregation introduced two counters tomorrow? What would help her feel that the change is for her protection and not against her?
- Are the same rules applied to the minister or priest as to a volunteer? If not, who decided, and was it written down?
- Which of the two views in the disagreement paragraph is closer to your own congregation's instinct? What would the other view say to you?