Lecture 6-3: Law and Tax: Ask Locally
Contents 25
- Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
- Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
- Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
- Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
- Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
- Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
- Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
- Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
- Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
- Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
- Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
- Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
- Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
- Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
- Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
A treasurer in a small assembly is asked by a new member who works in an office: "Do we give receipts for gifts? Does the congregation have to file something each year? Are the people who clean the hall employees?" The treasurer knows the answer to none of the three. She says she will find out. Then she realises that she does not know whom to ask. (an invented example)
This lecture is about that moment, and it is deliberately short on answers.
This course is not legal, tax or accounting advice. It cannot be, for a plain reason. Law, tax rules, accounting standards and the legal standing of congregations differ between countries, between regions inside a country, between denominations and between years. A rule that is true in one place is false in the next, and a rule that was true last year may have changed. A lecture that tried to say what the law is would be wrong for most readers, and it would be wrong in a way that could cost them. So this lecture does something different. It names the questions every congregation should be able to answer, it says whom to ask, and it describes how to keep the answers. It names no statute, no rate and no threshold, and it should not be used in place of a local professional.
The central claim of the course says that money is given to God and entrusted to a few. Part of keeping what was entrusted is knowing what the surrounding society legitimately asks of the congregation and doing it, neither avoiding what is due nor imagining duties that do not exist.
What these 25 minutes give you
- State plainly that the course is not legal or tax advice, and explain why it cannot be.
- Name six questions every congregation should be able to answer about its legal and financial duties.
- Say who can answer such questions in different settings, and how to ask well.
- Explain how to record the answers and review them from time to time.
- Describe how Romans 13:1-7 and Matthew 22:21 bear on the treasurer's work, and where readers differ about their reach.
Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God. Therefore he who resists the authority, withstands the ordinance of God; and those who withstand will receive to themselves judgment. For rulers are not a terror to the good work, but to the evil. Do you desire to have no fear of the authority? Do that which is good, and you will have praise from the same, for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn’t bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil. Therefore you need to be in subjection, not only because of the wrath, but also for conscience’ sake. For this reason you also pay taxes, for they are servants of God’s service, attending continually on this very thing. Give therefore to everyone what you owe: taxes to whom taxes are due; customs to whom customs; respect to whom respect; honor to whom honor." — Romans 13:1-7
World English Bible
They said to him, “Caesar’s.” Then he said to them, “Give therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”" — Matthew 22:21
WEB
The first passage is long and has been read in many ways across the centuries. Nearly every reader agrees on a modest point: the Christian is asked to give what is owed, with respect, and for conscience' sake. The second is the answer Jesus gives to a question about taxes. Both are used here for that modest point, and not as a full account of how Christians should relate to the state.
1. Why this lecture gives no answers
It is natural to want a list: "Congregations must do these five things." The wish is understandable, and a lecture could pretend to satisfy it. That would be a kind of dishonesty. A treasurer who relies on a general statement may fail to do what her own place requires, or may do something her own place does not ask. Each mistake has a cost, and each is avoidable by asking the right person.
Two opposite errors are common, and both come from assuming. The first is assuming that a congregation is outside the rules: "We are a church; the law does not touch us." In many places a congregation has duties, perhaps few and perhaps many, and some are strict. The second is assuming that a congregation is bound by rules that do not apply to it: "Our friend's company must do this, so we must too." Sometimes a congregation is treated differently from a business, and sometimes it is not. Neither assumption should be made. The honest position is: I do not know; I will ask.
Also notice what the lecture does not say. It does not say that the law is always right. It does not say what a Christian should do if the law and conscience conflict; that is a large question and belongs to other courses. It says only that a treasurer's ordinary work includes learning what is asked and doing it faithfully.
2. Two Scripture passages, read modestly
Romans 13:1-7 appears in a letter to Christians living in the capital of an empire. Paul tells them to be in subjection to the higher authorities and gives reasons, and in verses 6 and 7 he speaks of paying taxes and of giving to everyone what is owed: taxes to those to whom taxes are due, respect to whom respect, honour to whom honour. Matthew 22:21 records Jesus' reply to a question about paying tax to the emperor: give to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's.
Readers differ about how far these passages reach. Some read Romans 13 as a general call to obey the state, and others read it more narrowly or in the light of Acts 5:29, where the apostles say they must obey God rather than men. Some read Matthew 22:21 as a sharp separation between two spheres; others read it as a question that Jesus turns back on his questioners. This lecture needs only what all of these readers can say. A person who handles the money of a congregation should know what is due and should give it, openly, without evasion. What is due to God, the entrusted money of lecture 1-1, is not lessened by it. Respect for what is owed to others is part of the faithfulness the course describes.
A treasurer who is careless about what is owed does harm in two ways. She may bring a penalty on the congregation. She may also give a poor witness: people look at how a church deals with its public obligations. Equally, a treasurer who is anxious about every possible rule may give up useful work out of fear. Asking is the answer to both.
3. Six questions every congregation should be able to answer
Here are six questions. For each, the lecture says what it is about and whom to ask. It does not say what the answer is.
1. What is our legal status, and are we registered? Is the congregation a legal body in its own right, or part of a larger one such as a diocese or a denomination? Does it need to be registered anywhere, and has it been? In some places a congregation has no separate legal existence, and then the question becomes: who holds the bank account and the property, and who is responsible if something goes wrong? Ask the denominational office first, if there is one, and a lawyer who knows how local congregations are organised.
2. What may we say, and what must we say, when we receive gifts? Some places have rules about acknowledging gifts, giving receipts, or the form in which a giver may claim any benefit the law allows. Some have no such rules. A giver may ask for a statement, and the treasurer should know whether one is allowed, required or neither, and what it must contain. Ask an accountant who works with congregations, or the denominational office.
3. What must we file, and when? Is there a yearly return, an annual report to a regulator, a registration to renew, a statement to the denomination? Who is responsible for each, and by what date? Ask the same accountant or the office, and ask the neighbouring congregations of your own tradition, who often know the practical details.
4. What are our duties toward the people who work for us? Does the congregation employ anyone? Who counts as an employee, and who counts as a volunteer or a contractor? A person called a volunteer who is, in fact, working set hours for regular payment may be treated by the law as an employee, in some places. The same question was raised in lecture 1-4 about volunteers. There may be duties about pay, contributions, leave and safety. Ask a lawyer or an accountant who knows employment rules in your place. Ask early, before the arrangement is made, and not afterwards.
5. How long must we keep records, and in what form? Lecture 3-3 described the ledger and the monthly close. How long should the ledger, the bank statements, the count sheets and the receipts be kept? Is there a rule, and does it differ for different documents? What happens to the records when a treasurer leaves or the congregation closes? Ask an accountant, and ask the denominational office, which often has its own rule that is stricter than the law.
6. How must we protect personal information? A congregation holds the names, addresses and sometimes the giving of its members. In many places there are rules about how personal information may be collected, stored, used and shared. Lecture 3-1 argued that an individual's giving is private. Here the question is whether the law also says so, and what it requires: who may see the records, how they are stored, how long they are kept, and what happens if they are lost. Ask the same advisers, and ask someone who understands data protection locally.
These six are a start, not a complete list. The best advisers will tell you of others. A congregation that owns property may need to ask about insurance and building rules; one that runs a school or a food bank may face special rules; one that works across borders may face more. The list can always grow. What matters is that the habit is set: when a question about law or tax arises, nobody guesses.
4. Whom to ask
No single person is the right one in every place. Here are the usual sources, with a note on each.
- The denominational office, diocese or regional body. Often the first stop, and often free to the congregation. It knows the particular rules for congregations in your tradition and place, and often has a handbook, a helpline or a standing adviser. If your congregation belongs to a body like this, ask there before paying anyone else.
- An accountant who works with congregations or similar non-profit bodies. For tax, filing, records and receipts. Ask what experience the person has with congregations in your place. A general accountant who has never seen one may give correct answers to the wrong questions.
- A lawyer. For legal status, property, employment and contracts. Some lawyers help religious bodies at reduced cost or free; ask.
- The local authority or the regulator of charities or religious bodies, where one exists. Some publish plain-language guidance and answer questions from small bodies. They can say what the rule is, but they will not decide what is best for you.
- Neighbouring congregations. Useful for practical knowledge: how they register, what they file, which accountant they use. They are not an authority, and they may be wrong or may be in a different situation. Treat their answers as leads, to be checked.
- Your bank. For how accounts are opened and who may sign. The bank does not give legal advice.
In a cathedral parish where the diocese holds the accounts and handles most such matters, the treasurer's work is often to know what the diocese does, what it expects the parish to do, and whom to ask in the office. In a small independent assembly, the treasurer may have no office to call, and the question of whom to ask becomes the first question. In a house church that has no legal form, the people may still need to ask what, if anything, applies to them, and which person should be the one to hold the account.
5. How to ask well
A good question gets a good answer. A few habits help.
Bring the facts. Say what the congregation is, what it does, whether it employs anyone, how it receives gifts and what property it holds. Advisers can only answer what they understand.
Ask the question in one sentence. For example: "Are we required to give written receipts for gifts, and what must they say?" A vague question gets a vague answer.
Ask for the answer in writing, or write it down yourself immediately and send it back for confirmation: "I understood you to say this. Is that right?"
Ask what is not covered. "Is there anything else we should be asking?" is often the most useful question of all.
Ask how current the answer is. Rules change. Ask whether this is what applies now, and when it should be checked again.
Do not ask for approval of a plan already made. A question asked before the decision can change the decision. A question asked after is often a request to bless what was done.
6. Keep the answers
An answer that lives in one person's head is lost when that person leaves. A simple file solves this. Keep a single document or folder, which the congregation owns and a successor can find, with four things in it.
- The questions and the answers, each with the date, the name and office of the person who gave it, and how to reach them again.
- A list of what is due and when: the filings, renewals and reports, with dates and the name of the person responsible for each.
- The records that the answers say to keep, and for how long.
- A note of when to ask again. Once a year is a reasonable habit, and again whenever the congregation changes what it does: hires someone, takes on a building, starts a programme with children or begins to handle money across a border.
This file is not secret from the governing body. It should be shown to the finance committee, and the report to the congregation (lecture 5-1) can say that it exists. It belongs with the other materials a new treasurer receives.
7. What faithfulness asks, and what it does not
Faithfulness here is not fear and it is not cleverness. It does not mean arranging the congregation's affairs to pay as little as can be got away with, and it does not mean acting as though every cautious reading must be adopted. It means finding out what is asked and doing it. Where the answer is unclear, ask again, and say so to the governing body if no one can tell you. A congregation that has asked and kept the answer has done what can be asked of it.
And it means never pretending. A treasurer who is asked, "Is this all right?" and does not know should say, "I do not know; I will find out." That is an honourable answer. Saying "Yes, of course" to avoid embarrassment is not.
8. In a parish and in a free church
The parish that is part of a larger body and the free church that stands on its own both need the same six answers. The difference is where the answers come from. For the parish, many are already held by the diocese, and the task is to learn them and to ask the office what is not clear. For the free church, the answers must be gathered: from the denominational network if there is one, from the accountant, from neighbouring congregations and from the lawyer. In both places, the discipline is the same: ask, write it down, and review it.
Diagram 1. Six questions, and where to take them
In short
- This course is not legal, tax or accounting advice; law and tax differ by country, tradition and year, so the lecture names questions and not answers.
- Do not assume either that a congregation is outside the rules or that it is bound by rules that do not apply to it.
- Six questions: legal status and registration, receipts for gifts, filing duties, employment duties, how long to keep records, and the protection of personal information.
- Ask the denominational office, an accountant or lawyer who knows congregations, or the local authority; treat neighbours' answers as leads only.
- Ask in one sentence, bring the facts, get the answer in writing, and ask before a decision is made.
- Keep a file of questions, answers, due dates and records, and ask again each year and whenever the congregation changes what it does.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Is this course legal or tax advice? | No. Rules differ by country, tradition and year, so it names questions and says whom to ask. |
| The six questions | Legal status, receipts for gifts, filing duties, employment duties, records, personal information. |
| Two errors of assuming | That the congregation is outside the rules, or that it is bound by rules that do not apply to it. |
| After the answer | Write it down with the date and the name, keep it where a successor can find it, and ask again. |
One sentence to remember Faithfulness about law and tax means finding out what is asked, in your own place, from someone who knows, and writing the answer down.
This week's action Write down the six questions on one page and put beside each the name of the person or office you would ask.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the six questions can your congregation answer today, and which could it not? Who would you ask for the others?
- Which of the two errors, assuming the congregation is outside the rules or assuming it is bound by rules that do not apply, is more common where you live? Why?
- Romans 13:1-7 and Matthew 22:21 are read in different ways. What can people who read them differently still agree on about a treasurer's work?
- Where would the answers to legal and tax questions be kept in your congregation, so that a new treasurer could find them?
- Think of the sentence "I do not know; I will find out." When is it hard to say in your culture or congregation? What would make it easier?
- Which adviser in your place would be the first you would ask, and what would it cost to ask?