FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT712E Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards

Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure

Contents 25
PT712E Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Money That Was Entrusted
  1. Introduction: Money That Was Entrusted
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Entrusted Money
  1. Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
  2. Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
  3. Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
  4. Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Budget
  1. Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
  2. Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
  3. Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
  4. Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Receiving, Spending, Recording
  1. Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
  2. Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
  4. Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Safeguards and Checks
  1. Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
  2. Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
  3. Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
  4. Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Reporting and Special Funds
  1. Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
  2. Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
  3. Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
  4. Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Hard Times and Responsibility
  1. Lecture 6-1: Shortfalls and Debt
  2. Lecture 6-2: When You Find a Problem
  3. Lecture 6-3: Law and Tax: Ask Locally
  4. Lecture 6-4: Practice Lab: A Review of Our Financial Practice

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

This is the fourth Practice Lab of the course. Like the others, it asks you to do something and not only to agree with something.

Today's task is small. Take one procedure by which money moves in a congregation, write it in plain steps, and mark where it has a gap. A gap here means a step where one person does two jobs, where no second person can see, where nothing is written down, or where the step fails if the person is away. The procedure may be your own congregation's. It may be one you watch as a quiet observer. Or it may be an invented one that this lecture supplies. All three are real ways into the lab, and none is a lesser one.

The first three lectures of this week gave you ideas: never leave it to one person (4-1), know what you hold and who may act (4-2), and check in order to confirm and to protect (4-3). This lab asks you to hold those ideas against one procedure with its steps laid out. Reading about a gap is easy. Finding one in a plain list of steps, and finding a small, kind way to close it, is a skill, and it is gained only by doing it.

Notice what the goal is not. It is not to find fault with a person. A gap belongs to a procedure, not to the one who follows it. In nearly every congregation the gaps exist because the people involved were generous and trusting, and nobody ever sat down and asked the questions. The goal is to see clearly, and to choose one small fix.

What these 24 minutes give you

  • Complete the sheet "Finding the Gaps" for your own procedure, for one you observe, or for the invented one in this lecture.
  • State the four promises of privacy that govern this lab.
  • Name a gap by the test it fails, without blaming the person who follows the procedure.
  • Choose one small fix that a congregation could make within a month.
  • Explain how to run the lab in a small group so that nobody is exposed.

Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their labor." — Ecclesiastes 4:9

World English Bible

Keep this verse in front of you while you work. It does not say that one person is bad. It says that two are better. As you fill in the sheet, look for the steps where a good worker is working alone, and ask what a second person would add.

1. Why a procedure, and why steps

A congregation's money does not move by a principle. It moves by a procedure: a series of things that people actually do, in an order, on certain days. Most of these procedures were never planned. They grew. Someone began to count the offering because they were there. Someone began to pay the bills because they had a computer. After a few years, "the way we do it" had become a habit that nobody could describe.

A habit that nobody can describe cannot be checked. The first value of this lab is therefore plain: to write the steps down, in order, in the words of an ordinary person. Many people find, when they do this, that they did not know what happened between two steps. That discovery is already part of the exercise.

2. The four promises of privacy

Say these before you begin. If you are leading a group, say them out loud.

  1. Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours.
  2. Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer to write.
  3. You may pass on any part. Leave a box empty if you wish; that is a complete answer.
  4. The leader fills in a sheet too. The person at the front is not an examiner.

Two more rules go with these. Do not write a real amount, a bank detail, a card number or any member's giving on the sheet. The lab is about steps and who does them. It never needs a figure. And do not write the name of a real person. Write "the person who counts" or "the officer", not a name. A name turns a procedure into an accusation.

3. How to do it

The steps, whichever way you choose

Step 1. Choose your way from the three below. You may change your mind part way through.

Step 2. Copy the sheet in section 4 onto a page by hand, or reproduce its headings on a blank page. Do not skip the headings; they are the exercise.

Step 3. Write the procedure in up to eight steps in rows 1 to 8, in a few words each. Use plain verbs: "counts", "carries", "pays", "files".

Step 4. For each step, tick what is true. Four tests are in the columns: Two jobs (one person does two of approving, holding, recording and checking), Unseen (no second person can see this step), Unwritten (it is not written down anywhere), Fails if away (the step would stop or go wrong if the person were away for a month). Leave a box empty if you do not know. An empty box is a complete answer.

Step 5. Write one sentence in each of C, D and E. One sentence is enough. If you cannot think of a sentence, leave it blank.

Step 6. Read the sheet once to yourself, and underline one word that surprises you.

4. The three ways into this lab

Way 1: In your own congregation. Use this way if you handle or oversee money there. Choose one procedure, such as "from the offering plate to the bank" or "from a request to a payment". Write it as it really happens, not as the rules say. Do not use any real amounts. If you find a gap, do not act on it this week. Only see it. In the week after, think about who should be asked and how. Do not ask a colleague to fill in the sheet with you unless you are certain they will feel free to refuse.

Way 2: The observer's way. Use this way if you do not handle money. Spend one hour, once, as a quiet observer of one process: the counting after a service, the way a request for a payment is approved, or the way a petty-cash tin is kept. You are not there to judge anyone. Look for a few things only: Who does each step? Is there anyone else in the room? Is anything written as it happens? What would happen if that person were away? You will not know what is in anyone's heart, and you do not need to. Do not look at any ledger, bank paper or private record. If you cannot watch, recall a process that you have seen, and fill in the sheet from memory. In section A, tick "something I observed", and leave out all names.

Way 3: The partner's way. Use this way if you have a trusted partner and no other way suits you. You will work on a procedure that is entirely invented, so that no personal story is needed.

The procedure (invented). The Maple Street Fellowship is a small assembly that meets in a rented hall. It has about sixty members. Pat is the long-serving treasurer. Lee is a member of the board. Pastor Ruth is the minister. This is how things are done there, as a visitor would see them:

  1. After the service, the plates are carried to the office by whoever is nearest. Pat is usually there.
  2. Pat counts the cash alone and writes the total in the count book. On the first Sunday of each month Lee joins.
  3. Pat keeps the cash at home until Tuesday and then takes it to the bank.
  4. Pat writes the totals in the ledger.
  5. Pat pays the bills online and is the only person who can do so. The board approves the budget in January.
  6. Pastor Ruth holds the congregation's payment card. The statement is sent to her home. Receipts go into a drawer in the office.
  7. A petty-cash tin sits in the office, unlocked, and no one counts it. The youth leader keeps the money for a trip in a personal account until the trip takes place.
  8. The bank statement comes to Pat, who files it. Pat also writes the year-end report alone and reads it to the congregation. Pat has done this for nine years and has never missed a month. The only written instructions are in Pat's head.
  • The person leading reads the procedure aloud, and then asks the plain questions of lecture 4-3, one step at a time: Who does this? Who else could see it? Is it written down? What if that person were away? The leader fills in the sheet as the two talk.
  • The partner plays Pat. Pat is honest, hard-working and a little tired, and wants to hear the questions kindly. Pat answers truthfully but is not pleased to be asked. Then swap: the partner now asks the questions, and the leader plays Pat.
  • Each round lasts about eight minutes. Then talk for five minutes: how did the questions feel from each chair? What wording helped? What made Pat feel accused?

Afterwards, each partner fills in a sheet for the Fellowship's procedure, as if the Fellowship were real, and writes the one small fix that they would suggest.

Notice, in the invented procedure, that some things are done well. The board approves the budget. A second person counts on the first Sunday of the month. The statement does arrive, and someone files it. The lab is not an exercise in finding only faults. It is an exercise in seeing the whole.

5. What usually goes wrong

Four reactions come up often. None means you have done it wrong.

"There are too many gaps." Many procedures, set out plainly for the first time, show a long list. That is normal, and it does not mean that anything is wrong with anyone. Do not try to fix them all. Choose the one that matters most (box D), and the one small fix (box E).

"I don't know what happens at that step." This is an honest and a useful answer. Write "do not know", and leave the boxes empty. A step that no one can describe is itself a finding.

"I feel I am accusing someone." Remember that a gap belongs to the procedure. Write the sheet as if the person who follows it did their best with what they were given. Often they did.

"I feel the person will take offence if I raise it." Possibly. Do not raise it yet. A sheet is for seeing, not for acting. When the time comes, the way to raise a gap is the way of lecture 4-3: a plain question with no charge in it, in private, with a suggestion that a second pair of eyes would help everyone.

A fifth reaction is less common and matters more. Sometimes the lab brings back a hurt: a time when you were wrongly doubted, or when a trusted person was found to have fallen short. If that happens, put the pen down. Speak this week to a pastor, priest, mentor or trusted friend. That is not a failure of the exercise. It is the exercise finding something real.

6. What the sheet gives you

When you have finished, look at the sheet as a whole. You are likely to see two or three things.

You will probably see the same few gaps repeated: one person doing two jobs, a step that no second person sees, and a step that exists only in someone's memory. That is normal, and it is the point of lecture 4-1.

You will probably see a gap that is easy to close and a gap that is not. Giving the bank statement to a second person is easy. Finding a second signatory may take a season. Writing down what is in Pat's head takes an evening. Choose the easy one first, and let it show the congregation what care can look like.

And you will see one small fix (box E). Keep that sentence. It is the one you can act on. A good small fix is one that costs no money, can be done in a month, and makes the congregation safer and the faithful worker's life easier.

7. Leader's note, for running this in a group

Running the lab so that nobody is exposed

Say the four promises of privacy first, out loud. Before anyone picks up a pen, say: nobody will read what you write; nothing is marked; you may pass on any part; I am filling in a sheet too. Say it even if you said it last week.

Fill in your own sheet. Sit down and write alongside the group. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination.

Let each person choose their way. In one group there may be a treasurer using Way 1, a member who has watched a counting using Way 2, and a pair working on the Maple Street Fellowship using Way 3. All are equal. Do not ask anyone to say which way they chose.

Give fifteen quiet minutes for writing, then ten minutes in pairs for anyone who chose Way 3. Do not fill the silence with commentary or music.

Ask about feelings, never about contents. Do not ask "What did you write?" Ask: "What was it like to write that?" Or, for those who worked the invented procedure: "What was it like in the chair you sat in?" Then allow anyone to pass. Say: "If you would rather not say anything, just pass," and move on without a pause that makes passing costly.

Do not ask anyone to describe their own congregation's real figures, accounts or people. If someone begins to name a person or an amount, say gently, "You do not need a name or a number. Tell us the pattern."

For the Maple Street procedure, you may share these gaps after the pairs have finished, if the group wishes to hear them. Step 2: one person counts alone most weeks. Step 3: cash stays overnight in a private home. Step 4: the person who counts also records. Step 5: one person can pay, and the budget is approved but the individual payments are not seen by anyone else. Step 6: the card holder is the only one who sees the statement, and receipts are not matched. Step 7: the tin is neither locked nor counted, and the trip money is in a personal account. Step 8: the person who keeps the books also checks and reports them; the work has not been shared or written down. Also invite the group to name what is done well. Say that the list is not complete, and that a group may find more.

Do not turn the lab into a plan. The sheet is for seeing, not for deciding. Plans come later in the course.

Do not answer a hurt with a defence. If someone describes being wrongly doubted, or a trust that was broken, do not move on quickly. Stay with it for a moment. Follow it up privately after the meeting, and if what you hear is beyond you, say so and help the person find someone who can carry it.


Diagram 1. The form: Finding the Gaps

FINDING THE GAPS -- PRIVATE Practice Lab 4 -- copy onto a page by hand -- no names, no amounts -- date: ____ / ____ A. This sheet is about (tick one) my own congregation's procedure a process I observed or remember the invented one B. The procedure in up to eight steps, and four tests (tick what is true) Step, in a few words Two jobs Unseen Unwritten Fails if away one person, two no second not written stops for a month of the four jobs person can see down anywhere if they are away 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 C. What already works well in this procedure (one sentence) D. The gap that matters most, named by the test it fails (one sentence) E. One small fix that costs no money and could be done in a month (one sentence) Nobody reads this sheet. Nothing is marked. You may pass on any part. The leader fills one in too.

Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab

Item Done
Said the four promises of privacy out loud before anyone wrote [ ]
Said that no amounts, bank details or names belong on the sheet [ ]
Filled in my own sheet alongside the group [ ]
Let each person choose their way and did not ask which [ ]
Gave fifteen quiet minutes, and ten for pairs [ ]
Asked "What was it like to write that?" and not "What did you write?" [ ]
Offered a real option to pass, and moved on cleanly [ ]
Invited the group to name what is done well, as well as the gaps [ ]
Stayed with anyone who described a hurt, and followed up privately [ ]

In short

  • The lab asks you to write one procedure in plain steps and test each step for four gaps: two jobs, unseen, unwritten, and fails if the person is away.
  • There are three equal ways in: your own congregation, the observer's way, and the partner's way with the invented Maple Street procedure.
  • Four promises of privacy: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills one in too.
  • Never write a real amount, a bank detail, a member's giving or a person's name; a gap belongs to the procedure, not to the person who follows it.
  • Write down what already works, choose the one gap that matters most, and choose one small fix that costs nothing and can be done within a month.
  • Running it in a group: promises first, the leader writes too, ask "What was it like to write that?", and never ask about contents.
Front Back
Four tests for a gap Two jobs, unseen, unwritten, and fails if the person is away.
Three ways in Your own congregation; the observer's way; the partner's way with the invented procedure.
Four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills one in too.
Whose gap is it? The procedure's, not the person's; also note what works, then choose one small fix.

One sentence to remember A gap belongs to the procedure and not to the person, so look at the steps kindly and close the easiest gap first.

This week's action Fill in the sheet on an actual page, keep it where only you will find it, and underline the one small fix you wrote in box E.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What was it like to write that? Answer with a feeling, not with the contents.
  • Which of the four tests (two jobs, unseen, unwritten, fails if away) turned up most often on your sheet? What might that tell you?
  • Which step was hardest to describe plainly? What does that suggest about how well the procedure is known?
  • If you worked on the invented procedure, how did it feel to ask the questions, and how did it feel to be asked as Pat? What wording made it easier?
  • What did you find that is done well? Why is it important to write that down as well as the gaps?
  • If you wish to say what small fix you would choose (box E), do so. If you would rather not, pass.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.