Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
Contents 25
- Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
- Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
- Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
- Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
- Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
- Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
- Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
- Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
- Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
- Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
- Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
- Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
- Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
- Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
- Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
A finance committee member is reading the monthly report and notices that the gifts for November are lower than for any month that year. She remembers that two big events were held in November. She asks the treasurer, who says, kindly, that some gifts are still to be banked. Two months later, the report for January shows nothing about them. (An invented example.) What should she do now?
There are three bad answers. She could say nothing, because she does not want to offend a faithful worker. She could tell other members that "something is wrong with the money". Or she could look through the treasurer's papers when no one is there. There is a better answer, and most of this lecture describes it. She can ask for a plain explanation, look at the documents that should answer it, ask a second person to look with her, and, if the matter is still open, take it to the chair or the governing body. At every point she treats the treasurer as an honest person who has a question to answer, and she treats the question as one that deserves an answer.
This lecture is about checking: the ordinary and outside ways a congregation looks at its own money, and the signs that call for a closer look. Its main teaching is that the purpose of a check is confirmation and protection, and that a warning sign is a sign and not a proof. The right response to a sign is to verify, and never to accuse.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Distinguish the monthly check, an internal review and an outside examination, and say what each is for.
- State what makes a checker independent enough to be useful.
- List common warning signs, and give an innocent explanation for each.
- Describe the steps to take on seeing a sign: ask, look, ask a second person, record, report.
- State fairly the two views on internal and outside audit, and say what this course requires.
He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17
World English Bible
Therefore select from among you, brothers, seven men of good report, full of the Holy Spirit and of wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business." — Acts 6:3
WEB
The proverb is about legal and everyday disputes. It says that the first account of a matter sounds complete until a second voice asks a question. That is no reason to doubt the first voice. It is a reason to want the second question asked. The verse from Acts comes from the choosing of seven people to oversee a daily distribution. We use it for a limited point: the congregation chose people of known character, in the open, for a task that touched the community's shared care, and the community stayed involved in the choosing. Checking is the later half of the same care: those who were chosen are also looked at.
1. What a check is for
Many people dislike the word "audit". It sounds like a hunt. In a congregation the word is often heard by the treasurer as "they think I did something". This is a pity, because the true purposes of checking are quite different.
A check has two purposes.
Confirmation. A check lets the congregation say, with reason, "the money was received, used and recorded as we said it would be." That sentence is a gift to the people who gave. Without a check it is only an opinion.
Protection. A check protects the honest worker. When a doubt is raised, as sooner or later it will be, a record that someone independent has read is the best answer. It also protects the congregation from the slow growth of small errors and from the temptation that comes when nobody looks.
Notice what the purpose is not. It is not to find a villain. A good check, in most years, finds untidy filing, a missing receipt, a rule not followed, and a few small errors. It says so plainly and helps put them right. The value of a check is not in what it catches. It is in the fact that it is done, is known to be done, and is done in the same way for everyone.
2. Three levels of checking
A congregation can check its money at three levels. They fit together; none replaces the others.
1. The routine check, every month. Each month, someone who did not keep the books compares the ledger with the bank statement and looks at the month's report (lecture 3-3). Someone who did not hold a card reads its statement against the receipts (lecture 4-2). Someone who did not count looks at the count sheets and the deposits (lecture 3-1). These are small tasks, taking an hour or two, done by a committee member or a second officer. They are the most useful checks of all, because they happen soon enough to put right what they find.
2. The internal review, once a year or so. A member of the finance committee or the governing body who is not involved in the daily work reads the year's records more widely. Questions an internal reviewer asks include: Do the count sheets match the deposits? Do payments have approvals and receipts? Do the signatories on the bank's list match the congregation's resolution? Were funds given for a purpose used for that purpose? Does the annual report agree with the books? Is each rule in the congregation's own procedure actually followed?
3. The outside examination, at a rhythm the congregation chooses or the law requires. A person from outside the congregation's daily life, who is competent in accounts, looks at the books and reports what they found. The names for this differ: an audit, an independent examination, a review, an inspection by the diocese or denominational office. Some are defined by law and have a precise meaning; others are informal. Which one your congregation needs, if any is required, and how often, depends on its country, its legal form, its denomination and the size of its income. The course does not give a rule. Ask your denominational office, an accountant or the local authority what applies, and write the answer down. If nothing is required, a congregation may still choose to be examined, and many do.
3. Who is independent enough?
A check is worth only as much as the independence of the person making it. The question to ask is: could this person be tempted to see only what is comfortable?
A good checker is:
- Not involved in the daily handling of the money being checked. The person who counted is not the person who checks the count.
- Not closely related to the people being checked. A husband checking his wife's books is not a second pair of eyes. Rules on what counts as "close" vary; follow local law and the congregation's own policy.
- Not dependent on them. A staff member who is paid by the treasurer's decision, or a volunteer who needs the pastor's favour, will find it hard to ask a question.
- Sufficiently able for the task. For a routine check, careful reading and a calculator are enough. For an outside examination, ability with accounts is needed; for some kinds, a professional qualification may be required by law.
- Free to say what they find, and to say it to the governing body and not only to the person checked. The report goes to the people who are responsible for the congregation's money.
In a very small congregation the choice is narrow. A retired bank worker from another church, an accountant who attends a neighbouring assembly, or a trusted person from the denominational office may be the right one. The cost is often small. The value is large: for the first time in years someone who is not part of the daily routine has looked, and the treasurer has been told, in writing, that it is in order.
4. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: internal checking versus outside audit. One view holds that a congregation should check itself. Its members know the work, understand the ministry and the unusual circumstances, and can look at the books with sympathy and common sense. An outside auditor costs money that could go to ministry, does not know the congregation, and may apply the standards of a business to a place where the books serve a different purpose. A trusted committee, on this view, does the job at least as well, in a spirit of mutual care that an outsider cannot bring; to hand the matter to a stranger may even suggest that members cannot be trusted to look at their own affairs. The other view holds that an internal check, however good, is a check by the same people who work, worship and make decisions together. Friendship, shared history and the wish to avoid a hard conversation make it difficult for even an honest member to ask the awkward question. An outside examiner is not bound by those ties, brings experience of how books go wrong, and gives the congregation a statement it can show to givers, to a bank, to a denomination or to a doubter. On this view, an outside check is a form of care, and the fee is small compared to the trust it protects. Each view contains something true. Insiders know the ministry; outsiders are free of the ties.
This course requires less than either side asks for. It requires only that the check match the size and the risk of the congregation's finances, and that someone who is not involved in the daily work must look. A small congregation with little money may meet the requirement with a trusted outsider reading the books once a year. A large congregation with property, staff and many funds will probably need a proper outside examination. If the law or the denomination requires a particular kind, follow it. What the course does not accept is a congregation where the only people who ever look at the money are those who handle it.
5. Warning signs are signs, not proof
Experienced treasurers and examiners often speak about warning signs: patterns that suggest a closer look is needed. Here are some of the most common, with the plain reasons why each might also be innocent. The point of the second column is as important as the first.
| Sign | What it may mean | Innocent explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Receipts or approvals missing | A step was skipped | A busy volunteer forgot; a receipt was lost; the rule was never explained |
| Reports late or often postponed | Something is not ready | Illness; a new officer; a change of software; too much work for one person |
| One person holds every job | No one else can see | A small congregation with few willing helpers; no one has ever offered |
| A person will not take time away from a job, or will not hand a job on | Others cannot see the work | Real devotion; fear of losing a role they love; no one has shown how to hand over |
| Reluctance to explain, or irritation at a question | A question may be uncomfortable | Tiredness; feeling accused; a poor way of asking |
| Records that do not agree with the bank | An error or something else | A timing difference; a fee not entered; a keying mistake |
| Pressure to skip the second signature "just this once" | A control is being avoided | A real emergency; the second person is away; the rule has no allowance for absence |
Look at the third column before the second. In each case there is a plain, common, innocent reason, and in a real congregation the innocent reason is by far the most frequent. We make no claim about how often. A sign is a reason to look, not a reason to conclude.
This is why the rule of the lecture is verify, do not accuse. If a sign is wrongly treated as proof, a faithful worker may be shamed in front of the community, may leave, and may never return; the congregation then loses both a worker and its trust in one another. If a sign is ignored, a small problem may grow. The path between is quiet, plain and fair.
6. What to do on seeing a sign
Suppose you notice something that does not look right. Here is a sequence.
- Ask a plain question, without a charge in it. "I could not find the receipt for this payment. Where is it?" is better than "Why is this missing?" Choose a time and place that is not public. Allow an answer to take a day or two.
- Look at the document that should answer it. Often the answer is on a sheet you have not seen. The bank statement, the count sheet, the minutes and the approval form can often settle the matter in minutes.
- Ask a second person to look with you. Not to gossip, but to be a second pair of eyes. Choose someone discreet, from the finance committee or the governing body. Proverbs 18:17 reminds us that one side of a matter often sounds complete until another question is asked, and that applies to your own first impression as well as to the other person's explanation.
- Write down what you saw and what you were told. Short, dated, factual notes, with no guesses. Keep them where only the people who must see them can.
- If the question is still open, report it to the chair or the governing body, not to the whole congregation. They decide what to do next. Lecture 6-2 explains how to handle a problem that may be a mistake or a wrong, how to protect the person who raised it, and when professionals or authorities must be asked.
A few things to avoid. Do not investigate alone beyond what your role allows. Do not search through a person's belongings or private accounts. Do not discuss your concern with people who have no need to know. Do not assume the worst, and do not assume the best either; your job is only to find out whether the records agree. A treasurer is not a detective, a lawyer or a police officer. The ethic is to keep, to show, to check and to pass on.
7. Receiving a check well
The treasurer or officer being checked has a part in this too. A check goes better when she:
- welcomes it as a service, and says so at the start;
- has her records ready, with the folder in order and a short list of anything she knows is incomplete;
- answers plainly, and says "I do not know, let me find out" when that is true;
- does not take a question as an attack, and asks for the question to be put in writing if she feels pressed;
- thanks the checker, and says so to the congregation when the report is shared.
A congregation can help by deciding in advance that checks are normal: they happen every year, for every officer, and the report goes to the governing body. When checks are routine, no individual feels singled out. When they happen only after a doubt, they feel like a trial.
8. In a parish and in a free church
In a parish, the diocese or denominational body may carry out inspections, or may require an annual report that is read by someone there. This is helpful, but the parish should not mistake it for its own monthly check; the diocese sees summaries, and a summary can look tidy while the local work is not. In a free church, the board may be the only body, and the board may be the same people who do the work; an outside reader is then especially valuable. In a house church with one bank account, the whole procedure may be: the statement goes to a second person every month, and a trusted outsider reads it once a year. That is a real check.
Diagram 1. Three levels of checking, and what to do on seeing a sign
In short
- The purpose of a check is confirmation, so the congregation can say the money was used as stated, and protection of honest workers; it is not a hunt for a villain.
- Three levels fit together: a monthly routine check by a second person, a yearly internal review, and an outside examination of a kind and rhythm that local law or custom sets.
- A checker must be independent: not in the daily work, not closely related or dependent on those checked, able enough for the task, and free to report to the governing body.
- Readers disagree on internal versus outside audit; this course requires that the check match size and risk and that someone not in the daily work must look.
- A warning sign is a reason to look, not proof; ask plainly, look at the document, ask a second person, write notes, and pass the matter on.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Purpose of a check | Confirmation that money was used as stated, and protection for honest workers and the congregation. |
| Three levels | A monthly routine check, a yearly internal review, and an outside examination chosen or required locally. |
| A warning sign is... | A reason to look, not a conclusion; each sign has a plain innocent explanation that is usually the true one. |
| On seeing a sign | Ask plainly, look at the document, ask a second person, write dated notes, and pass it to the chair or governing body. |
One sentence to remember Check in order to confirm and to protect, and when something looks wrong, verify before you speak and never accuse before you know.
This week's action Ask a person who does not keep your books to compare this month's ledger with the bank statement, and ask the keeper to thank them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- When you hear the word "audit", what do you feel? What would help you, or your treasurer, hear it as confirmation and protection?
- Who checks the ledger against the bank in your congregation each month? Is that person independent of the person who keeps the ledger?
- When did someone not involved in the daily work last read your congregation's books? What was said afterwards?
- Think of one warning sign in the table. Can you name two innocent explanations for it from your own setting? How would you ask about it without a charge in the question?
- How would your congregation respond if a member raised a question about the records? Is there a path that protects both the member and the worker?
- Which of the two views on internal and outside checking is closer to your congregation's instinct? What would the other side say?