Lecture 2-3: Self-Governing Congregations: Congregational and Independent Structures
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why a Church Needs Order
- Lecture 1-2: Offices and Meetings in the New Testament
- Lecture 1-3: Authority as Service, and Its Misuse
- Lecture 1-4: Checks and Balances in a Fallen World
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, A Decision Map of Your Church
- Lecture 2-1: Oversight From Above: Episcopal Structures
- Lecture 2-2: Governing Together: Presbyterian and Connexional Structures
- Lecture 2-3: Self-Governing Congregations: Congregational and Independent Structures
- Lecture 2-4: Comparing Structures: Strengths, Weaknesses and Common Minimums
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Three Churches
- Lecture 3-1: Principles of Meetings
- Lecture 3-2: Constitutions, By-laws and Resolutions
- Lecture 3-3: Elections, Terms and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 3-4: Records and Minutes
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Mock Meeting
- Lecture 4-1: Church and State: Two Spheres
- Lecture 4-2: Legal Status, Property and Contracts
- Lecture 4-3: People Who Work and People Who Serve
- Lecture 4-4: Insurance, Records and Knowing When to Ask
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check-Locally List
- Lecture 5-1: Protecting Children and Vulnerable People
- Lecture 5-2: Personal Data, Photographs and Confidentiality
- Lecture 5-3: Openness, Conflicts of Interest and Raising Concerns
- Lecture 5-4: Responding When a Concern Is Raised
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Safeguarding and Openness Check
The third family answers the question of lecture 2-1 in the nearest possible way. When something needs to be decided, who can act? The answer is: the people who are here.
In congregational and independent churches, the local church is the complete unit of government. It chooses its own leaders, calls its own pastor, keeps its own property and makes its own decisions. Many Baptist churches, Congregational churches, many Pentecostal and charismatic churches, many Bible churches and many house churches and new churches are ordered this way, although they differ greatly among themselves. Some are led chiefly by the whole membership voting together. Some are led by a board of elders or deacons. Some are led strongly by one pastor or founder. These are not the same, and the differences matter a great deal.
This lecture gives the structure in its strongest form, and then the questions we have asked of every structure.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Describe what self-governing means and name the three common ways such a church decides: by the whole congregation, by an elected board, and by a strong pastor or founder.
- Explain how associations and networks link self-governing churches without ruling them.
- State the strengths and the weaknesses of self-governing congregations, with equal care.
- Explain what a self-governing church can do to supply the checks that a bishop or a wider council would otherwise give.
The eye can’t tell the hand, “I have no need for you,” or again the head to the feet, “I have no need for you.”" — 1 Corinthians 12:21
World English Bible
that there should be no division in the body, but that the members should have the same care for one another." — 1 Corinthians 12:25
WEB
As they served the Lord and fasted, the Holy Spirit said, “Separate Barnabas and Saul for me, for the work to which I have called them.”" — Acts 13:2
WEB
The two verses from 1 Corinthians are about the body of Christ, and they are quoted by churches of every structure. Self-governing churches often read them as a picture of a congregation in which every member has a place and a voice. Acts 13:2 shows a local assembly at Antioch hearing the Spirit and sending out two of its own people. Churches of this family see in it the kind of authority a local church can hold. Churches of other families see in the same passage a church acting in fellowship with others. Both readings are honest. The passage is here to show where the idea comes from.
1. The picture, in plain words
Start with a single congregation. It meets, it worships, it gathers money, it may own a building. When it must decide something, it uses a rule it has written for itself, or a habit it has formed.
The word congregational is sometimes used for one particular shape: the congregation, meeting as a body, is the highest authority, and important decisions are made by the vote of members. The word independent is used more widely for churches that have no authority over them and answer to no wider body. Many churches in this family are, in practice, both: the members have a vote on certain matters, and the church has no outside body to answer to.
The shape is not as simple as "everyone votes." There are three common ways of running such a church, and a student should be able to tell them apart.
1. The members decide. The members gather and vote on major matters: a pastor, electing deacons or elders, adopting a budget, buying or selling property. The leaders carry out what the members decide. This is the older and strictest sense of the word congregational.
2. A board decides. The members elect a board of elders, deacons or trustees, who make most decisions between members' meetings. The members keep a vote on the largest matters. In many churches this is the real working shape.
3. A leader decides, with advice. In some churches, a pastor, an apostle or a founder holds most of the authority, and a board advises or approves. Some of these churches are healthy and some of the leaders are humble and accountable. Others have a structure that gives one person every key. We said in lecture 1-3 that concentrated power is a risk in any structure. It is most easily reached here, because there is no bishop or council above to say no.
Most churches are a mix. A student who reads a church's constitution should look for which of the three is in fact in charge.
2. Associations and networks
A self-governing church is not necessarily alone. Many join an association, a convention, a fellowship or a network. These are groups of churches that choose to work together for training, missions, relief, publishing, the support of pastors, and the sharing of advice.
The key point is that such a body usually works by agreement, not by command. The churches send representatives to its meetings. The association may set a statement of faith that a church must accept to join, and it may remove a church from its list if the church departs from it. But it does not usually appoint the local pastor or hold the local property, and it cannot overrule the local vote.
Some networks are stronger than this. In some, an apostle or overseer is recognised over a group of churches, and the churches treat that person's word as weighty. The line between a loose network and a form of oversight from above is sometimes thin. A fair student asks, in each case, whether the person has an office with a written limit, or only a personal influence.
3. What this family holds to be true
Members of self-governing churches tend to give these reasons for their form.
- The local church is a full church. Where Christ's people gather in his name, they are the church, and no further body is needed to make them so.
- Every believer has a voice. The Spirit is given to all, and the whole body should take part in the decisions that affect it.
- Those who know the people should decide. A decision made close to the situation is more likely to fit it.
- Freedom to follow conscience under Scripture. A church should not be forced by a distant authority to do what it believes is wrong.
- A church that is free to act is free to reform. A church should not wait for a wider body to move before it repents.
4. The strengths
Nearness. The people who decide know the people affected. A member in need can be known by name, and a decision can be made the same week.
Clear responsibility. There is no one else to whom the matter can be passed. The local church knows that the problem is its own.
Broad ownership. Where the members truly vote, the church belongs to them. They are more likely to give, to work and to stay.
Speed and flexibility. A small church can start a new work, or change course, without waiting for a regional meeting.
Resistance to distant error. If a wider body falls into a mistake, the local church is not carried along with it.
5. The weaknesses
These are the questions that members of the family themselves raise most.
Little outside check. Nobody stands outside the circle. If the pastor, the board and the treasurer are friends or relatives, a concern may have nowhere to go. In the other two structures there is, at least on paper, a body that did not make the first decision. Here there may be none.
Dependence on one leader. The church's life can depend on one person's gifts and character. When that person is wise and humble the church flourishes. When that person fails, falls ill, or abuses the office, the church may have no way to deal with it.
Isolation. A church with no wider links may not hear a voice that corrects it. It may repeat its own mistakes for a generation. Pastors may be lonely, without anyone to ask.
Weak help in a crisis. A small church that faces a serious allegation, a financial problem or a split may lack the people, skills or money to deal with it. A wider body would have supplied them.
Majority pressure. Where the congregation votes, a loud majority can override the quiet, and a popular leader can sway a vote. The members' vote does not by itself protect the weak.
Uncertain authority. If the rules are not written, nobody may be sure who has the right to decide. This leads to quarrels that last for years.
6. An invented example
(An invented example.) Harbour Fellowship is an independent church founded by Pastor Tobias Wren. It has about two hundred members. Its constitution says the board of three directors governs the church. The directors are Pastor Wren, his brother and his brother's wife. The members are invited to hear the annual report, but do not vote.
The church has many strengths. It is close, generous and quick to help a family in need. When a member loses a job, the church acts within days. Pastor Wren is humble, honest and well loved.
Then a member, Ms. Lena Carrow, notices that a large gift to the church has been spent on a purpose the donor did not intend. She asks the board. The board is three people who are family. They answer kindly that all is in order. She has nowhere further to go. There is no bishop, no regional body, and no vote of the members.
Notice what has gone wrong. The pastor is not, as far as we know, a bad man. The structure has no place for the question. There is no one who is not part of the circle. This is the point lecture 1-4 made: checks are not an insult to a good leader. They protect a good leader from suspicion and protect the church from a bad one.
Harbour Fellowship can supply these checks by its own decision, without giving up its independence. It can add two directors who are not relatives of the pastor. It can have its accounts looked at once a year by a person outside the board. It can allow the members a vote on the annual budget. It can write down who receives a concern about the board, and give that person the right to take it further. It can join an association, and ask the association to name a trusted outsider whom the church agrees to consult. None of these steps takes the church out of its tradition. All of them put a second pair of eyes in the room.
7. The same problem in other structures
In an episcopal church, Ms. Carrow would write to the bishop's office, which might act, or might be slow (lecture 2-1). In a church governed by elders (lecture 2-2), she would take her concern to the elders and, if unanswered, to the regional body. In each, the structure gives her a second door. In a self-governing church, the church itself must build the second door, because the structure does not supply one.
This is not a reason to call self-governing churches weaker. It is a reason to ask them to be careful. A congregational church that is truly governed by its members, with a wise board, written rules and an association it listens to, may be better placed than a ladder that nobody climbs. The structure does not decide the outcome. The habits do.
8. What every church of this shape needs
- Written rules stating who decides what, and how the rules can be changed.
- Directors or elders who are not all related to the pastor or to each other, and who can say no.
- Terms and rotation for board members and, where the church allows it, for the pastor's authority over money.
- An outside look: an annual review of the accounts and, where possible, an outside friend or association to whom the church will listen.
- A route for concerns that does not run only through the person being questioned, and that protects the one who raises a concern.
- A rule that crimes and safeguarding are reported to the proper authorities, whatever the church's size or independence. We return to this in Week 5.
Diagram 1. Self-governing: where the second door can be built
In short
- In a self-governing church the local congregation is the whole unit of government. It may decide by the members, by a board, or by a strong leader, and most churches mix these.
- Associations and networks link such churches by agreement, usually without command, though some networks give an overseer real weight.
- Strengths: nearness, clear responsibility, ownership by members, speed, and freedom to reform.
- Weaknesses: little outside check, dependence on one leader, isolation, weak help in a crisis, and majority pressure on the quiet.
- Such a church must build in the checks that other structures give: unrelated directors, written rules, an outside review and a route for concerns.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Self-governing | The local congregation holds the whole authority: it chooses leaders, keeps property and decides. |
| Three ways of deciding | The members vote; a board decides; a leader decides with advice. Most churches mix them. |
| Association or network | Churches that join by choice to share training, work and advice, usually without command. |
| Main risk | No one outside the circle to check, so the church must build its own second door. |
One sentence to remember A self-governing church is close and quick, and it must build for itself the outside check that other structures supply.
This week's action Ask who, outside the people who make decisions in your church, could receive a concern about those people, and whether that is written down.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The lecture names three ways of deciding in a self-governing church: the members, a board, a leader. Which does your church most resemble? What does it gain and what does it risk?
- In the Harbour Fellowship example, nobody did a wicked thing that we know of. Why was Ms. Carrow still left with nowhere to go?
- List three checks that a self-governing church could add without giving up its independence. Which of them is the hardest for a loved pastor to accept, and why?
- Why can the vote of members fail to protect the weak? Give a reason and an example from your own experience that does not name any person.
- If you belong to a church with a bishop or a regional body, what does it do for you that a self-governing church must do for itself? What might you learn from a self-governing church?