FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT713E Church Order and Law: Principles of Church Government and Law

Lecture 6-1: The Purpose and Limits of Church Discipline

Contents 31
PT713E Church Order and Law: Principles of Church Government and Law
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Order in Service of the Body
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Order in Service of the Body
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Why Churches Need Order
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why a Church Needs Order
  2. Lecture 1-2: Offices and Meetings in the New Testament
  3. Lecture 1-3: Authority as Service, and Its Misuse
  4. Lecture 1-4: Checks and Balances in a Fallen World
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, A Decision Map of Your Church
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Structures of Church Government
  1. Lecture 2-1: Oversight From Above: Episcopal Structures
  2. Lecture 2-2: Governing Together: Presbyterian and Connexional Structures
  3. Lecture 2-3: Self-Governing Congregations: Congregational and Independent Structures
  4. Lecture 2-4: Comparing Structures: Strengths, Weaknesses and Common Minimums
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Three Churches
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Meetings and Documents
  1. Lecture 3-1: Principles of Meetings
  2. Lecture 3-2: Constitutions, By-laws and Resolutions
  3. Lecture 3-3: Elections, Terms and Conflicts of Interest
  4. Lecture 3-4: Records and Minutes
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Mock Meeting
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Church and the Law
  1. Lecture 4-1: Church and State: Two Spheres
  2. Lecture 4-2: Legal Status, Property and Contracts
  3. Lecture 4-3: People Who Work and People Who Serve
  4. Lecture 4-4: Insurance, Records and Knowing When to Ask
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check-Locally List
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Protecting People and Keeping Faith With Money
  1. Lecture 5-1: Protecting Children and Vulnerable People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Personal Data, Photographs and Confidentiality
  3. Lecture 5-3: Openness, Conflicts of Interest and Raising Concerns
  4. Lecture 5-4: Responding When a Concern Is Raised
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Safeguarding and Openness Check
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Discipline and Disputes
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Purpose and Limits of Church Discipline
  2. Lecture 6-2: Fair Procedure: Notice, Answer, Evidence, Appeal
  3. Lecture 6-3: Courts, Mediation and Church Splits
  4. Lecture 6-4: Calling, Resignation and Leaving Well
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Walking a Case Through the Steps

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

Few words in church life carry as much fear as "discipline." Some people hear it and think of a pastor who ruled by threat. Others think of a church that saw serious harm and did nothing. Both memories are real, and both are failures of the same thing: a church that did not know what its discipline was for.

This lecture asks the question first. Before we ask what steps a church takes, we ask what the steps are meant to achieve, and where they must stop. Our central claim for the whole course is that church order and law exist to protect the weak, to keep every matter open and fair, and to serve the body of Christ. Discipline is the sharpest test of that claim, because here a church can hurt someone most easily while saying that it is helping.

A note before we begin. This course explains general principles. It is not legal advice and it is not a church's rule book. Law differs by country, region and year. Churches differ in what they allow, whom they let decide, and what words they use. Wherever this lecture touches a duty or a right, it says "check locally." A real case needs the church's own written rules and, where the matter is serious, a qualified person. Nothing here should be used to judge any real person or church.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • State the aims of church discipline, and say what it is not for.
  • Describe the range of steps that traditions use, from a private word to removal from a role or from membership, without making one tradition the standard.
  • Explain from Scripture how discipline is meant to end in restoration, not in permanent punishment.
  • Recognise at least four ways in which discipline is misused, and state why crimes and abuse are outside what a church panel may handle alone.
  • State fairly the disagreement over how wide discipline reaches and how it is carried out.

If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother. But if he doesn’t listen, take one or two more with you, that at the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the assembly. If he refuses to hear the assembly also, let him be to you as a Gentile or a tax collector." — Matthew 18:15-17

World English Bible

For what have I to do with also judging those who are outside? Don’t you judge those who are within? But those who are outside, God judges. “Put away the wicked man from among yourselves.”" — 1 Corinthians 5:12-13

WEB

Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted. Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:1-2

WEB

Sufficient to such a one is this punishment which was inflicted by the many; so that on the contrary you should rather forgive him and comfort him, lest by any means such a one should be swallowed up with his excessive sorrow. Therefore I beg you to confirm your love toward him." — 2 Corinthians 2:6-8

WEB

Avoid a factious man after a first and second warning; knowing that such a one is perverted, and sins, being self-condemned." — Titus 3:10-11

WEB

but whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to stumble, it would be better for him that a huge millstone should be hung around his neck, and that he should be sunk in the depths of the sea." — Matthew 18:6

WEB

First Corinthians 5:12-13 shows that Paul is speaking of a community judging its own members, not the world outside. Five of these passages are about correction, and each carries a limit inside it. Matthew 18 begins with one person, then widens only if the first step fails. Galatians asks for gentleness and for self-examination. Second Corinthians shows a correction that has worked and must now stop. Titus speaks of a person who divides a community and has already been warned more than once. The last passage, Matthew 18:6, is a reminder of whom the church is most bound to protect.

1. What the word means

The English word "discipline" is related to "disciple." In its older sense it means training, the shaping of a learner. , rightly understood, is part of : the ways a community helps its members to live as they have promised, and helps them back when they fall.

That is the hopeful meaning. It is also the one most easily lost. Many people use "discipline" for punishment alone. A church that does so will tend to ask, "What should we do to this person?" A church that remembers the older meaning asks, "What does this person need, what does the community need, and who must be protected?"

2. The aims

Across the traditions that practise discipline, three aims appear again and again. They are stated in different words, but they are close to one another.

First, restoration of the person. Galatians 6:1 says that someone who is "caught in some fault" is to be restored in a spirit of gentleness. James 5:19-20 speaks of turning a wanderer back. The aim is a person returned, not a person removed.

Second, protection of others, especially the weak. A community has duties to the people in it who can be harmed: children, the elderly, the poor, the newly arrived, the person who depends on a leader. Matthew 18:6 is stern about those who cause "little ones" to stumble. Ezekiel 34 condemns shepherds who ruled "with force and with rigor" and did not strengthen the weak. Sometimes protection must come before anything else, and it may require that a person stop serving in a role at once, whatever the state of their repentance.

Third, the integrity of the community and its witness. In 1 Corinthians 5, Paul is troubled that the Corinthians were proud and had not even mourned over a serious matter among them. A community that shrugs at serious wrongdoing teaches its members that nothing matters. It also teaches onlookers that its words are cheap.

These aims can pull against each other. Restoring a person quickly may leave someone else unprotected. Protecting others may mean stepping aside from the person who needs patient care. A fair process is how a church keeps the aims in order. We come to it in lecture 6-2.

3. What discipline is not

Four things are often confused with discipline and must be kept apart from it.

  • Revenge. If the real aim is to make someone suffer for what they did, or for what they said about us, it is no longer discipline.
  • Control. Using the threat of discipline to keep members quiet, obedient to one leader, or afraid to ask questions is a misuse of the word.
  • Silencing. A person who raises a concern about money, about a leader's conduct or about safety is not thereby a person needing correction. We return to this below.
  • A substitute for the authorities. A church panel is not a court, a police service or a protection agency. We return to this too.

4. The steps, and how they differ

Scripture gives a pattern, and the traditions have built different ladders from it. Here is the pattern at its plainest, from Matthew 18:15-17.

  1. A private word, to one person who has wronged you.
  2. If that fails, a second conversation with one or two others, so that the matter can be established fairly.
  3. If that fails, the matter goes to the assembly.
  4. If the person will not listen even then, they are to be treated as an outsider.

Notice what this passage says and what it does not. It speaks of a wrong done to you. It does not say that every serious matter must begin with a private visit to the person involved. Where the wrong is of a kind that puts someone in danger, or is a crime, the first duty is not a private conversation with the one who did it. We come to that in a moment.

The traditions then build their own steps. A few examples, drawn with equal weight:

  • In churches governed by bishops, discipline often runs through the bishop or a church court connected to the diocese. Steps may include a pastoral warning, a limit on ministry, a removal from office, and, in the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches, a range of penances, restrictions on receiving Communion, and in grave cases excommunication, each handled by the church's own processes.
  • In Presbyterian and similar churches, the board of elders (the session or consistory) hears a matter first. A person may appeal to a wider body, such as a regional assembly. Steps run from a rebuke through suspension from the Lord's Supper or from office to removal from membership.
  • In Methodist and other connexional churches, a matter may move through a minister, a district or conference process and, where the church has them, a bishop or superintendent, with written steps for clergy and for lay members.
  • In Baptist, Congregational and many independent churches, the congregation, or its elected board, is usually the body that decides. The final step is often a vote of the church meeting. Sometimes there is no wider body at all.

(An invented example.) The Elm Valley Parish has a bishop. Lakeview Fellowship has a board of five and a members' meeting. When a worship leader at each church was found to have misused a small sum from a youth fund, the parish placed him on a pastoral leave from ministry while a diocesan officer looked into the matter, and Lakeview's board suspended him from leading and told the members' meeting what steps it had taken. The paths differ. In both, the steps were written down, the worship leader was told what was said and given a chance to answer, and the money was reported to whoever the church's rules and local law required. That is the sameness beneath the difference.

5. Discipline is meant to end

Second Corinthians 2:6-8 matters more than it is usually given credit for. A correction was carried out by "the many," and Paul says it was enough. Now the community is to forgive and comfort, "lest by any means such a one should be swallowed up with his excessive sorrow." He asks them to confirm their love.

This is the pattern a church should expect of itself. Discipline is not a life sentence. When the person has turned, the community's task is to receive them, not to keep reminding them. Where a person has not turned, the community may still be bound to protect others, but it should do so with sorrow, not satisfaction.

Two cautions. First, forgiveness is not the same as restoring to a role. A person who forgave a debt may still not be a good person to manage the money. A person who has been forgiven for harming a child is not thereby fit to work with children. Forgiveness and trust are different things, and a church must not let one slide into the other. Second, no one may press a person who has been harmed to forgive, to meet the person who harmed them, or to be silent. Forgiveness that is demanded by a community is a second injury. What the church may do is stay beside the harmed person, protect them, and let them decide what they can bear.

6. Titus 3:10, read carefully

Titus 3:10 says to "avoid a factious man after a first and second warning." The WEB says "factious." Some older translations use a word for a heretic. Translators and traditions have read the word in different ways. The plain reading in the passage is about a person who divides a community, who has been warned more than once. It is about conduct and a repeated refusal, not about a person's opinions. This course gives no verdict on anyone's doctrine, and it does not use this verse to say who is or is not a heretic. Churches that hold a confession will have their own way of handling teaching disputes, and those processes need the same fairness as any other. Nothing in this lecture decides a doctrinal question.

7. How discipline is misused

Because discipline is powerful, it is easy to abuse. A church that reads this list should be able to ask, honestly, whether any of it is true of its own life.

  • Retaliation. A member criticises a leader, asks to see the accounts or raises a concern; soon afterwards a "discipline" matter appears against that member.
  • Selective use. A powerful person's wrongdoing is explained away, and a quiet person's is made public. Fairness means the same steps for everyone, including the pastor and the founder.
  • Public shaming as the first step. Announcing a matter to everyone before anyone has heard the person's side.
  • Judging in one's own cause. The accuser, or the accused person's close friend, sits as the judge.
  • No record, no notice. A person is told after the fact that they have been removed.
  • Confusing disagreement with sin. A member who thinks differently about a programme, a building, or a leader's decision is treated as rebellious.
  • Turning a crime into a church matter. A serious harm is dealt with by a private "restoration process," and the authorities are never told.
  • Putting pressure on the harmed person. The person who was hurt is asked to meet, to forgive quickly, to avoid "causing a scandal."

8. The firm limit: crimes and abuse

Here the course is plain, and it is plainer than any one tradition's rules. A church panel is not the place to handle a crime, abuse, violence or a serious danger to a person. Where there is a crime, or a legal duty to report, the matter goes to the proper authorities under local law. Where the church has a wider body or a named safeguarding person, the matter goes to them too. The church's own steps may follow, run alongside, or wait, but they never replace the authorities, and the church's own panel must not investigate in a way that could interfere with the authorities' work. What the duty to report is, who must make a report, and to whom, differs by country and year: check locally. Lecture 5-4 gave the first hours; lecture 6-2 shows how the church's own process fits beside it.

The reason is simple. A church can be sincere and still be unable to protect a child, to gather evidence or to hold someone who is a danger. The people it is trying to protect deserve more than good intentions.

9. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree: how wide discipline should reach, and how it should be carried out. Some Christians hold that discipline should be a private matter between a pastor or and the person, and that public steps, however well meant, so often become shaming that they do more harm than good. Others hold that Matthew 18:17 and 1 Corinthians 5 plainly involve the whole community, that a community has a stake in its own purity and the safety of its members, and that public steps are sometimes the only honest way to protect the vulnerable. Others stress removal from membership as the necessary last step, since a church that never removes anyone cannot protect anyone. Still others stress suspension from an office or a role, while leaving the person's membership in place, as a lesser and more proportionate step, particularly for leaders, since 1 Timothy 5:19-20 speaks of an elder who sins. Each of these holds a real reading of Scripture, and each has seen a harm that it fears. Traditions with an established ladder tend to trust the ladder; independent churches with no wider body often must build their own. This course does not settle the question. It requires less than any side requires, but what it requires is firm: the purpose must be restoration and protection; the procedure must be fair (lecture 6-2); and discipline must never be used in retaliation.

10. Seeing the same thing in other structures

If your church has a bishop, ask who hears a matter about the bishop himself. If it has an assembly above the local church, ask whether a member can reach it. If your church is independent, ask who outside the circle can hear a complaint about the pastor. In every structure, a person who holds the keys of discipline needs someone who can check them. That was the claim of lecture 2-4, and it applies here without exception.


Diagram 1. The aims, the ladder and the limit

Church Discipline: Aims, Steps and Limit Use the lowest step that serves the aim, and no step outside the church's own sphere What discipline is for 1. Restoration of the person (Galatians 6:1) 2. Protection of others, the weak first (Matthew 18:6) 3. Honesty of the community and its witness When the aims pull apart, protection of the weak comes first. What it is not Revenge Control of members Silencing a concern A substitute for the authorities A ladder (names and order differ by tradition) A private word counsel, warning With others one or two, or a small group Limits on a role supervision, leave, suspension Sacraments withheld for a time, where practised Membership removal, the last step at every step: forgiveness and a way back when the person has turned (2 Corinthians 2:6-8) The firm limit Crime, abuse, violence or a duty to report goes to the proper authorities under local law. The church's own process may run beside it, but never in its place. Never press a harmed person to forgive, to meet, or to keep silent.

Diagram 2. Misuse and what a fair church does instead

A pattern of misuse What a church committed to restoration does
Discipline follows a member's criticism of a leader Treats the concern on its own merits, apart from the person who raised it
The powerful are spared, the quiet are exposed Uses the same steps for everyone, the pastor and the founder included
The matter is announced before the person has been heard Hears the person first and shares only what the aim requires
Accuser or close friend sits as judge Asks anyone with a conflict to step aside
A crime is dealt with by a private process Refers it to the authorities and keeps the church's own step beside it
The harmed person is urged to forgive quickly Protects them, offers support and lets them decide

In short

  • Church discipline is part of discipleship. Its aims are restoration of the person, protection of others, and the honesty of the community.
  • When the aims pull apart, protection of the weak comes first.
  • Matthew 18 gives a pattern for a wrong done to you; it is not a procedure for crimes or for danger.
  • Traditions build different ladders: bishops, elders and assemblies, conferences, congregations; no ladder is the standard.
  • Discipline is meant to end: 2 Corinthians 2:6-8 calls for forgiveness and comfort once a person has turned.
  • Forgiveness and trust differ, and no one may press a harmed person to forgive or keep silent.
  • Misuse includes retaliation, selective use, shaming, judging in one's own cause, and turning a crime into a church matter.
  • Crimes and abuse go to the authorities under local law; this is not legal advice, so check locally.
Front Back
Aims of discipline Restoration of the person; protection of others, the weak first; honesty of the community.
What it is not Revenge, control, silencing a concern, or a substitute for the authorities.
2 Corinthians 2:6-8 A correction that has worked must end in forgiveness and comfort.
The firm limit Crime, abuse and duties to report go to the proper authorities; check locally.

One sentence to remember Discipline exists to restore a person and to protect the weak, and it ends in forgiveness, never in revenge or silence.

This week's action Look at your church's written rules, if it has any, and note who can check the people who hold the power of discipline.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • In your own words, what are the aims of church discipline? Which could be forgotten most easily in a church you know about?
  • Why does the passage from 2 Corinthians 2 matter for the way a church ends a process?
  • Forgiveness and trust are different. Give an invented example in which a person is forgiven but should not return to a certain role.
  • Choose one of the four positions in the paragraph on which readers will not agree. State it in the way its holders would be glad to hear it.
  • Why must a crime or abuse be referred out, even if the church is sincere and wants to deal with it itself?
  • In your own structure, who can check a person who holds the keys of discipline?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.