FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT713E Church Order and Law: Principles of Church Government and Law

Lecture 3-4: Records and Minutes

Contents 31
PT713E Church Order and Law: Principles of Church Government and Law
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Order in Service of the Body
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Order in Service of the Body
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Why Churches Need Order
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why a Church Needs Order
  2. Lecture 1-2: Offices and Meetings in the New Testament
  3. Lecture 1-3: Authority as Service, and Its Misuse
  4. Lecture 1-4: Checks and Balances in a Fallen World
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, A Decision Map of Your Church
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Structures of Church Government
  1. Lecture 2-1: Oversight From Above: Episcopal Structures
  2. Lecture 2-2: Governing Together: Presbyterian and Connexional Structures
  3. Lecture 2-3: Self-Governing Congregations: Congregational and Independent Structures
  4. Lecture 2-4: Comparing Structures: Strengths, Weaknesses and Common Minimums
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Three Churches
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Meetings and Documents
  1. Lecture 3-1: Principles of Meetings
  2. Lecture 3-2: Constitutions, By-laws and Resolutions
  3. Lecture 3-3: Elections, Terms and Conflicts of Interest
  4. Lecture 3-4: Records and Minutes
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Mock Meeting
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Church and the Law
  1. Lecture 4-1: Church and State: Two Spheres
  2. Lecture 4-2: Legal Status, Property and Contracts
  3. Lecture 4-3: People Who Work and People Who Serve
  4. Lecture 4-4: Insurance, Records and Knowing When to Ask
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check-Locally List
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Protecting People and Keeping Faith With Money
  1. Lecture 5-1: Protecting Children and Vulnerable People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Personal Data, Photographs and Confidentiality
  3. Lecture 5-3: Openness, Conflicts of Interest and Raising Concerns
  4. Lecture 5-4: Responding When a Concern Is Raised
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Safeguarding and Openness Check
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Discipline and Disputes
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Purpose and Limits of Church Discipline
  2. Lecture 6-2: Fair Procedure: Notice, Answer, Evidence, Appeal
  3. Lecture 6-3: Courts, Mediation and Church Splits
  4. Lecture 6-4: Calling, Resignation and Leaving Well
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Walking a Case Through the Steps

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

A decision that is not written down is a decision that each person will remember in the way that suits them best. This is not a charge of dishonesty. It is how memory works. Two honest people, a year later, will recall the same meeting differently, and neither can prove the other wrong.

Records settle that. They are the church's memory, kept by someone other than the person who made the decision, in a form that can be read by those who have the right. In lecture 2-4 we named records as one of the six minimums that every structure needs. This lecture asks what a church should record, who should keep the record, how long and where, who may see it, what to do when it is wrong, and why a good record protects the leaders as much as the members.

This is not legal advice. How long certain records must be kept, who may demand to see them and how personal information must be handled differ by country, region and year, and some places set firm rules. This lecture names none of them. Where a point may be one of those it says "check locally". The day-to-day filing systems of a church office belong to the church administration course, and the care of personal information is taken up in lecture 5-2.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Say what the minutes of a meeting should contain and what they should leave out.
  • Distinguish good minutes from poor ones in a short example and say why the difference matters.
  • Explain who should keep the records, where, and for how long, and what to do when the rules are silent.
  • Describe how a church should handle access to records, corrections and closed or sensitive matters.
  • Explain why a good record protects both the leaders and the members.

it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus;" — Luke 1:3

World English Bible

that you might know the certainty concerning the things in which you were instructed." — Luke 1:4

WEB

Thus says Yahweh of Armies, the God of Israel: Take these deeds, this deed of the purchase which is sealed, and this deed which is open, and put them in an earthen vessel; that they may continue many days." — Jeremiah 32:14

WEB

We are avoiding this, that any man should blame us concerning this abundance which is administered by us." — 2 Corinthians 8:20

WEB

Having regard for honorable things, not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men." — 2 Corinthians 8:21

WEB

Luke writes so that the reader may know the certainty of what he was taught: a record is for certainty. Jeremiah is told to keep two copies of a deed, one sealed and one open, in a vessel that will last: a record is made to outlive the moment, and it is kept safe. Paul, handling money for the poor with a team, wants to be above blame in the sight of people as well as of the Lord. We do not say these passages tell a church how to keep minutes. They show the people of God valuing the written, safe, open record as an ordinary part of honest dealing.

1. What a record is for

A church record has four jobs.

It remembers. What was decided, when, by whom, and on what basis. This helps the church that has to carry out the decision, and the church ten years later which has to understand it.

It informs. Members who could not attend can see what was done in their name. People who join later can understand why things are as they are.

It protects. A leader who has acted with the authority of the meeting can show that the meeting gave it. A member who raised a concern can show that it was raised. A person who disagrees can show that the disagreement was heard. This is the use that is least understood, and we return to it below.

It holds to account. A record lets a wider body, an outside examiner, a successor, or in some situations an official body see what was done. A church that is willing for its record to be seen has little to fear from being asked.

Notice that none of these jobs is about suspicion. A record is not a sign that the church has stopped trusting the pastor. It is the ordinary habit of a church that takes its own decisions seriously.

2. What minutes should record

Minutes are the record of a meeting. Their style differs widely. Some churches keep long accounts, some a single line per decision. For most meetings a short style is enough. The core is the same.

A good set of minutes records:

  • The meeting: the date, the time, the place (or the means, if it was held by call), and the type of meeting.
  • Who was present and who sent apologies, and who chaired and who kept the record. This shows whether there was a quorum.
  • Whether the notice and the agenda were given, in a sentence. This answers the later question whether the meeting was proper.
  • Each matter dealt with, in the order taken, with a short note of the main points of the discussion, enough to show that the question was considered and not so much that every remark is reported.
  • Each decision, in the exact words of the motion, with the result of the vote: for, against, abstaining. Where a person has declared an interest and left the room, that is stated.
  • Any matter that is passed to someone, with the name of the person and the date by which it is to be done.
  • Any dissent that the member asked to have recorded, where the church's rules allow it.
  • The time of closing and the date of the next meeting.

A good set of minutes leaves out:

  • who said what, in a way that turns a discussion into an exchange of accusations. The record normally attaches a decision to the meeting, and not each remark to a person;
  • gossip, jokes and personal remarks about members;
  • the detail of any matter that was properly discussed in a closed session, beyond the fact of the session, its reason and its outcome;
  • personal information of members that is not needed (we return to this in lecture 5-2).

3. Good minutes and poor minutes

Here is a short, invented example. The same meeting is recorded twice.

(An invented example.)

Poor minutes

Council met. Usual people there. Talked about the roof, then the youth group. Everyone agreed we should do the roof soon. Pastor will look into it. Treasurer said money is fine. Brother Samuel was upset about the hall booking, discussed. Meeting closed late.

Better minutes

Council of the Elm Street church, Tuesday 12th, at the church hall, 7.30 p.m. Notice and agenda were sent on the 2nd. Present: the chair (Mr. Okafor), the secretary (Ms. Lindqvist), the treasurer (Mr. Banda), and four other members. Quorum of five confirmed. Apology: Mrs. Reyes.

  1. Roof. Two quotes were presented. Mr. Banda declared that the first firm is owned by his cousin and left the room for the discussion and the vote. Resolved: to accept the second quote, subject to a written contract being read by the council before signing. For: 5. Against: 0. Abstaining: 1 (the chair). Action: Ms. Lindqvist to obtain the contract by the 26th.
  2. Youth group. Report received. No decision.
  3. Hall booking. A member's complaint about a double booking was heard. Resolved: that the secretary keep a single booking book, to be kept in the office. Action: Ms. Lindqvist, from the 1st.

The meeting closed at 9.10 p.m. Next meeting: Tuesday 9th. Minutes read and approved at the next meeting. Signed: ______ (chair), ______ (secretary).

The difference is not in length, since the second is only a little longer. The first leaves a hundred questions. Which roof quote? Which people? Who agreed, and who did not? What did "look into it" mean, and by when? Was the treasurer's cousin involved? Did anyone object? Who is Brother Samuel and what was decided? Six months later, if the roof contract is in question, the first set of minutes protects no one. The second protects the treasurer who declared his interest, the chair who abstained, the secretary who was given a task, and the member whose complaint was heard.

Notice also what the second does not do. It does not report that Brother Samuel was upset, and it does not name the member who complained. A record should be accurate, and it should also be kind.

4. Who keeps the record

Three principles hold across structures.

The record is kept by someone other than the person it concerns. The one who makes a decision is not the best person to write it down, because he will remember what he intended. A secretary, a clerk, a registrar or a notary (the title varies) is appointed by the church or by the body it belongs to. In a small church where the pastor does everything, a trusted member can take the minutes, and the pastor reads them.

The record is read and approved. Minutes are usually read at the next meeting, corrected if wrong, and then approved by the meeting, and signed. That is the moment at which the record becomes the church's own, not one person's account. Churches that do this seldom have disputes about what was said.

There is a back-up. A record kept only in a notebook in a drawer, or only on one person's telephone, is at risk. A church that has digital records should have a second copy kept apart from the first and kept safe. A church that has paper records should think about fire, damp, insects and the departure of the person who holds the key.

The structure may add its own layers. In an episcopal setting, a diocese may require that certain registers (of baptisms, marriages, appointments, property) be kept in a set form and sent on, or kept in a central place. In a presbyterian setting, a council's minutes may be inspected by the regional body. In a congregational or independent church there may be no outside inspection at all. That is exactly why such a church needs to be diligent for itself and let its members read the record.

5. Keeping, and for how long

How long should records be kept? There is no single answer, and this lecture does not give a number. Three considerations help.

Some records belong to the life of the church for as long as it lasts. The constitution and its amendments, the minutes of the governing body, the registers of members, baptisms, marriages and similar acts, the deeds and papers about property: churches commonly keep these permanently. Many traditions treat parts of them as sacred records of the community.

Some records have a shorter life. Routine papers such as receipts, notices, ordinary correspondence and booking forms are kept for a limited time and then discarded.

Some records are subject to rules from outside. In some places the law sets minimum periods for certain financial, employment or other records, and sometimes a maximum period for certain personal information. These differ by place and change. Check locally, and ask a qualified person. The church finance course deals with financial records.

Whatever the length, a church does well to write a short retention note: what is kept, where, by whom, for how long, and how it is destroyed when the time is up. Records should not be thrown away in a clear-out by someone who does not know what they are. And records should never be destroyed to hide something, nor when a dispute or an enquiry is in prospect. If a matter is in dispute or under investigation, the wise rule is to keep everything that might be relevant until a qualified person says otherwise.

6. Who may see the record

A record has no use if nobody can see it. And it can do harm if the wrong people can. The balance is the church's own to set, in writing, and it should be set before a quarrel.

A sensible pattern separates three layers.

Open to all members. The constitution, the by-laws, the minutes of ordinary meetings, the yearly report and accounts in the form the church adopts. Members have a stake in the church's life. A church that treats these as secret has an unhealthy relation with its members.

Open to the leaders who need it. Personnel matters, the details of individual giving, pastoral matters, information about named people. These are available to those who must act on them, and no one else.

Held in closed form. The notes of a closed session, reports of concerns, matters involving children or vulnerable persons, counselling records. These are kept apart, with a note of who may see them and why, and are shared with the proper authorities where the law or a safeguarding duty requires. The ethics of counselling confidentiality belong to the pastoral-counselling ethics course, and the protection of personal data is taken up in lecture 5-2.

Whether a member has a legal right to see certain records differs by place. Check locally. But the church should not wait for a legal demand. A church that says plainly what members may see, and shows them, will find that fewer ask.

7. Correcting the record

Records have errors. A date is wrong. A name is spelled badly. A decision is recorded in words different from the ones the meeting used. Sometimes a member says: "That is not what I said," or "That is not what we decided."

There is a fair and simple way. An error is corrected by a note, in the open, at the next meeting, and the correction is itself minuted. The original is not erased or torn out. If the original were rubbed out, the record would stop being a record. The corrected version is added, the date of the correction is shown, and the person who made it is named.

A different thing happens when someone proposes to change a decision under the cover of correcting the minutes. Correcting the minutes says: "this does not say what we did." Changing a decision says: "we should do something else." The second needs a new motion, with notice, as lecture 3-1 describes. A church that keeps this line clear will not be tricked, and will not be tempted.

Occasionally a member believes that a record is false in a serious way, for example that a decision was recorded that was never made, or that a vote was miscounted. This is a concern like any other, and the church must have a route for hearing it that does not depend on the person complained of (lecture 2-4, the fifth minimum). Where there may be a crime, such as forgery of a record or theft, the matter goes beyond the church to the proper authorities.

8. Why records protect the leaders

Leaders sometimes feel that records are for the benefit of the members, who can then check on the leaders. That is partly true, and it is good. But the other half is that records are the leaders' best shield.

A treasurer who has recorded every payment and every approval is not easily accused of having taken one. A pastor whose actions are supported by a resolution of the proper body is not easily said to have acted alone. An who declared his interest and whose declaration is minuted cannot be accused later of hiding it. A secretary who recorded a dissent has protected the dissenter's right to be heard, and also protected herself from the claim that she suppressed it.

In churches where there is trust but no record, there is a quiet danger. When a person under strain, a person who is angry, or a person with something to gain, says "the pastor decided this alone", there is nothing to answer with. In churches where the record exists, the answer is in the folder. The record serves the truth, and truth is, in the end, the friend of the honest leader.

It also protects the weak. When a complaint has been heard and a note made, the person who raised it is not told later that it never happened. When a promise has been recorded, it cannot be said to have been imagined. A record is a form of memory for people who have less power to insist on their own account.

9. One more thought: records and Scripture

Records are not merely a modern business habit. The Bible is itself, in a sense, a record: law, genealogies, letters and histories written, copied and kept. Luke's reason for writing is to give certainty. Jeremiah's deeds are made in two copies and stored to last. The Jerusalem church sent its decision as a letter, so that the churches in Antioch could read it and not rely on hearsay. A church that keeps its records well is in good company.


Diagram 1. Good minutes at a glance

What Good Minutes Hold Short is fine. Vague is not. Put in Date, place, type of meeting Who was present, who chaired, who wrote That notice and agenda were given Each decision in the words of the motion The vote: for, against, abstaining Declared interests and who left the room Who is to do what, and by when Leave out Who said what in an argument Gossip, jokes and remarks on people The detail of a closed session Personal information not needed Anything that could not be shown to a member with a right to see it Read, corrected, approved, signed, copied, stored safely A mistake is corrected by a note in the open. The original is never rubbed out. How long to keep and who may see differ by place: check your own rules and check locally. Not legal advice.

In short

  • A record remembers, informs, protects and holds to account. It is a sign that a church takes its decisions seriously, and not a sign of distrust.
  • Good minutes give the meeting, the people present, the notice, each matter, each decision in the words of the motion with the vote, declared interests, actions and dates.
  • Good minutes leave out gossip, accusations, the detail of closed sessions and personal information not needed.
  • The record is kept by someone other than the decider, read and approved at the next meeting, and copied and stored safely.
  • A church should write a short retention note. How long records are kept, and who may demand to see them, differs by place: check locally.
  • Errors are corrected by an open note, never by erasing. Correcting a minute is not the same as changing a decision.
  • A good record protects the honest leader, the dissenter and the weak.
Front Back
Four jobs of a record It remembers, informs, protects and holds to account.
Good minutes hold Date, people, notice, each matter, decision in the words of the motion, the vote, interests, actions and dates.
Correcting a record An open note at the next meeting, itself minuted. Never erase. Not the same as changing a decision.
Three layers of access Open to all members; open to leaders who need it; held in closed form with a note of who may see it.

One sentence to remember A good record is a kindness to the person who is not in the room, and a shield for the person who is.

This week's action Take the minutes of one recent meeting of your church (do not copy names onto this page) and check them against the "put in" list. Write which items are missing.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why does a record protect the leader as well as the member? Give one example of each kind of protection.
  • Read the "poor minutes" in the example again. List five questions they leave unanswered. How does the second set answer them?
  • Who in your church keeps the records of the governing body? Is the person someone other than the one who made the decisions? If not, what small change would help?
  • A member says: "That is not what we decided." What is the fair way to deal with it? What is the difference between correcting a minute and changing a decision?
  • Where would your church place each of these: the constitution, the minutes of an ordinary meeting, the notes of a closed session, a report of a concern about a child? Who should be able to see each?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.