FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT713E Church Order and Law: Principles of Church Government and Law

Lecture 2-4: Comparing Structures: Strengths, Weaknesses and Common Minimums

Contents 31
PT713E Church Order and Law: Principles of Church Government and Law
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Order in Service of the Body
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Order in Service of the Body
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Why Churches Need Order
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why a Church Needs Order
  2. Lecture 1-2: Offices and Meetings in the New Testament
  3. Lecture 1-3: Authority as Service, and Its Misuse
  4. Lecture 1-4: Checks and Balances in a Fallen World
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, A Decision Map of Your Church
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Structures of Church Government
  1. Lecture 2-1: Oversight From Above: Episcopal Structures
  2. Lecture 2-2: Governing Together: Presbyterian and Connexional Structures
  3. Lecture 2-3: Self-Governing Congregations: Congregational and Independent Structures
  4. Lecture 2-4: Comparing Structures: Strengths, Weaknesses and Common Minimums
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Three Churches
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Meetings and Documents
  1. Lecture 3-1: Principles of Meetings
  2. Lecture 3-2: Constitutions, By-laws and Resolutions
  3. Lecture 3-3: Elections, Terms and Conflicts of Interest
  4. Lecture 3-4: Records and Minutes
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Mock Meeting
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Church and the Law
  1. Lecture 4-1: Church and State: Two Spheres
  2. Lecture 4-2: Legal Status, Property and Contracts
  3. Lecture 4-3: People Who Work and People Who Serve
  4. Lecture 4-4: Insurance, Records and Knowing When to Ask
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check-Locally List
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Protecting People and Keeping Faith With Money
  1. Lecture 5-1: Protecting Children and Vulnerable People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Personal Data, Photographs and Confidentiality
  3. Lecture 5-3: Openness, Conflicts of Interest and Raising Concerns
  4. Lecture 5-4: Responding When a Concern Is Raised
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Safeguarding and Openness Check
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Discipline and Disputes
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Purpose and Limits of Church Discipline
  2. Lecture 6-2: Fair Procedure: Notice, Answer, Evidence, Appeal
  3. Lecture 6-3: Courts, Mediation and Church Splits
  4. Lecture 6-4: Calling, Resignation and Leaving Well
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Walking a Case Through the Steps

Jump to the key points ↓

19 min

We have now met three families of structure: oversight from above, governing together, and self-governing congregations. Each was described in the form its own members would accept. This lecture puts them side by side.

The purpose is not to produce a winner. A table that ends with a prize would be false to the evidence, because every structure on the list has led to good lives and to harm, in every century. The purpose is to learn two things. First, what each structure is good at and where it is likely to fail, so that a leader in any structure knows what to watch. Second, what is common to all of them when they work: a set of minimums that a church cannot do without, whatever its shape.

Then comes the last of the disputed questions in this week: who has the final word? The lecture states the positions fairly and says what this course requires.

What these 19 minutes give you

  • Compare the three families on the same questions: who decides, who checks, how a concern is heard, and where each is likely to fail.
  • State the six common minimums that every structure needs.
  • Explain why a mixed or hybrid church is common and how to analyse one.
  • State fairly the three positions on who has the final word, and say what this course requires of all of them.

Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they watch on behalf of your souls, as those who will give account, that they may do this with joy, and not with groaning, for that would be unprofitable for you." — Hebrews 13:17

World English Bible

I wrote to the assembly, but Diotrephes, who loves to be first among them, doesn’t accept what we say." — 3 John 1:9

WEB

for the perfecting of the saints, to the work of serving, to the building up of the body of Christ;" — Ephesians 4:12

WEB

Three short passages hold the three halves of the matter. Leaders are to be respected, and they are leaders who will give account. A leader who loves to be first is a danger in the early church as much as in any later one. And the purpose of every office is service that builds the body. A structure is good to the degree that it makes the first and third true and the second less likely.

1. Comparing on the same questions

Here is one table. It does not rank. It asks every structure the same questions, and the answers are tendencies, not laws. Many real churches mix the types and differ from the pattern.

Question Oversight from above Governing together Self-governing
Who decides ordinary matters? Parish clergy and local officers, within the bishop's direction Local council of elected elders or officers The members, a board, or the leader, as the church's rules say
Who decides a disputed matter? The bishop, with or without a council A wider council, after local discussion The members or the board; usually no body outside
Who checks the local leader? The bishop and diocesan bodies The local council and the regional body The board and the members, and any association the church joins
Who checks the top person? A council of bishops or a court; varies widely The assemblies in which the person is one voice Often nobody unless the church builds a check
How is a concern heard? A letter or visit to the bishop's office The council, then the regional body The board or the pastor, unless a route is written
What is the great strength? Continuity, wider care, a clear line Shared judgement, appeal Nearness, speed, responsibility
What is the likely failure? Distance, concentration, slow answers Slowness, committee habits, a small circle No outside check, dependence on one leader
What does a small church gain? Help, training, a person outside the quarrel Support, a pool of ministers, advice Freedom and ownership
What does it risk? Being overruled by those who do not know it Waiting for a body that meets twice a year Being alone

Read the last two rows twice. The same feature is both a gain and a risk in every column. Nearness is a strength and a hazard. A ladder is a protection and a delay. A clear line is a service and a concentration of power. This is why neither "bishops are dangerous" nor "committees are safe" nor "independent churches are free" is a fair sentence.

2. Mixed churches

A student soon discovers that few churches fit one column. Here are some common mixtures.

  • A church with bishops that also has a synod in which clergy and lay members vote, and a council that the bishop cannot overrule.
  • A church with elected local elders and a regional officer who has a veto on certain matters.
  • A congregational church that belongs to a convention which requires it to accept a statement of faith and gives it a ministers' pension fund.
  • A newer network of independent churches led by an overseer who is accountable to a board of other pastors.
  • A church whose written rules are of one type and whose actual practice is of another, for example a written constitution that gives the members the power to vote, and a custom that no member ever has.

To analyse a mixed church, ask the questions of the table about the actual practice, and then compare it with the written rules. If they differ, the first thing to repair is the gap.

3. Failure can happen in any column

It is easy to read the failures in the table as belonging to others. A fair student reads each of them as a possibility in their own structure.

The distant bishop's office can be captured by a small circle who protect each other. A body of elders can be dominated by one strong voice and a regional body can be filled by the same few people. A self-governing church can be run by a board of one family. The reverse is also true: any of the three can have a wise leader, an outside friend and a record of fair dealing. In each case the structure creates some conditions; the habits fill them. A church of any shape can use its structure to serve, or use it to hold power.

4. The common minimums

If the three structures answer the question of authority so differently, is there anything they must share? We believe there is, and that it is the substance of this course's central claim. Here are six minimums. We call them minimums because a church with fewer is in danger, whatever its shape. They are not a ranking of structures, and no tradition's rules are being quoted. They are what you find when you ask what a structure must do in order to be a service.

1. Serving authority. Anyone who holds an office holds it to serve, and the church says so in words and in practice. Authority has limits, and those limits are written. Ephesians 4:12 states the purpose: the building up of the body.

2. Shared deliberation. Important decisions are not made by one person alone. A bishop consults a council, a council of elders weighs, a congregation votes, a board discusses. The form varies. The principle is that more than one mind and more than one voice are present, and that those affected by the decision can be heard.

3. Records. Decisions, finances, appointments and complaints are written down by someone other than the person who made them, kept safely and open to those who have a right to see them. Lecture 3-4 comes to this in detail.

4. A check on any single person. There is someone, or some body, that can question the bishop, the chair, the pastor, the treasurer or the founder. Which body this is depends on the structure. That there is one does not.

5. A way to hear complaints. Every member, and every person who works or serves, knows to whom a concern can be taken, and knows the person who raises one will not be punished for it. The route does not run only through the person complained of.

6. Protection. The church protects children and vulnerable people and sees that concerns about abuse, violence or crime are reported to the proper authorities, and not buried in a church process. We devote Week 5 to this.

These six can be put into any structure. A bishop's diocese can have all six, and so can a congregational church. A structure with only some is weaker than it looks.

Notice that three of them (records, a check, a way to hear complaints) are what the structures supply in different ways. The episcopal church supplies the check from above. The presbyterian church supplies it by the council. The self-governing church must supply it by its own decision. The minimum does not change. The way the minimum is met does.

5. A point where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree: who has the final word in the church, the local body, a wider body, or an office-holder?

Some hold that the final word belongs to the local body, the congregation of believers gathered under Christ. They point to passages where the whole assembly is addressed and takes part, and they hold that the church loses its character when a distant body or one person can overrule those who live the life of the congregation. Others hold that the final word belongs to a wider body, a council of elders or of bishops, because no congregation is complete in itself and because a wider body can see what a local group cannot. They point to the assembly in Jerusalem, where a matter that troubled several churches was settled by a meeting from more than one place. Still others hold that the final word belongs to an office-holder, a bishop or an overseer, because someone must be answerable when the group cannot agree, and because they believe the office was given to the church by Christ through the apostles. Each of these positions is held by thoughtful people, who hold it because they believe it protects the church.

This course does not decide between them. It requires something less than any of them requires, and something all three can accept: whoever has the final word, there must be a check on any single person, and the final word must be exercised in the open, according to written rules, with records, and with a way for the weak to be heard. A final word that no one can question, in any of the three structures, is the danger the New Testament names when it speaks of one who loves to be first.

6. An invented case, told three ways

(An invented example.) In three different invented churches, the same event occurs. A volunteer, Mr. Daniel Okoro-Reyes, says that the person who manages the church's money has been using it for personal ends. He has seen documents. He is frightened of speaking.

In the Orrin diocese (episcopal), he writes to the diocesan office. Within a fortnight an outside person has been sent to look at the accounts, and the priest has been asked to step back from money matters. It works quickly because there is a person with the power to act. It might have worked slowly if the letter had been lost.

In the Brook Valley church (elders), he speaks to an he trusts. The council discusses it. Since one elder is a relative of the manager, he is asked to leave the discussion. The council asks for an outside accountant. If they cannot agree, the matter would go to the regional body. It works because shared judgement and a conflict rule were present.

In Harbour Fellowship (self-governing), the board is the pastor and two relatives. Mr. Okoro-Reyes does not know where to go. The church, however, has two directors who are not relatives and a written route for concerns. The route names an outside friend of the church. It works because, in this church, they built the check.

Notice that the three churches differ in shape and share the six minimums. The shape did not decide the outcome. The minimums did. In each church, if one of the minimums had been missing, the report would have been buried, and Mr. Okoro-Reyes would have been left alone with it. And in each case, if the concern had been about a crime, or about a child, the next step would have been to the proper authorities, not only to the church.


Diagram 1. Three structures, six minimums

Different Shapes, the Same Six Minimums The structure decides how a minimum is met. It does not remove the minimum. Oversight from above a bishop and wider council supply the check Governing together councils and appeal supply the check Self-governing the church must build its own check Six minimums in every structure 1. Serving authority, with written limits 2. Shared deliberation: more than one voice 3. Records kept by someone other than the decider 4. A check on any single person 5. A way to hear complaints, without punishment 6. Protection, and reporting crime to authorities A structure with only some of these is weaker than it looks. Which of the six does your church meet in writing, not only in habit? The final word, whoever holds it, must be open to a check and held in the open.

In short

  • Compare the three families on the same questions: who decides, who checks, how a concern is heard, where it fails. The comparison does not produce a winner.
  • Each feature is both a gain and a risk: nearness, a ladder, a clear line. Failure can happen in any structure.
  • Six minimums belong in every structure: serving authority, shared deliberation, records, a check on any single person, a way to hear complaints, and protection.
  • Churches that hold the final word to be with the local body, a wider body or an office-holder are all serious. This course requires an open, checked, recorded exercise of whichever.
  • Many churches are mixed. Compare written rules with actual practice, and repair the gap.
Front Back
Same questions Who decides, who checks, how a concern is heard, and where each structure is likely to fail.
Six minimums Serving authority; shared deliberation; records; a check on any single person; a way to hear complaints; protection.
Who has the final word? Local body, wider body or office-holder, each held seriously. The course requires an open, recorded, checked exercise.
Mixed churches Compare written rules with practice; the gap is the first thing to repair.

One sentence to remember The structure decides how the minimums are met, and does not remove them.

This week's action Write the six minimums on a page and mark each one met in writing, met in habit only, or missing in your church.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • In the comparison table, choose one feature that is both a strength and a risk. Explain in your own words why both are true.
  • Why does this course say that failure can happen in any column? What would be lost if a student believed that failure belongs only to the structures of others?
  • Which of the six minimums is hardest for your own church to meet in writing? Why?
  • State fairly, as a member of that position would accept, the case that the final word belongs to the local body, then the case for a wider body, then the case for an office-holder. Which was hardest to state fairly?
  • A church says: "We do not need a way to hear complaints; our pastor is a good man." What would you say, without questioning the pastor's character?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.