Lecture 2-3: Your Story, Your Wounds, Your Limits
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Planning an Act of Faith?
- Lecture 1-2: Mission, Vision and Values: Telling Them Apart
- Lecture 1-3: Discernment in Scripture: Praying, Planning, Being Blocked
- Lecture 1-4: Discerning Together: Who Is in the Room
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Draft Calling Statement
- Lecture 2-1: Starting From What You Have
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to Your Neighbours
- Lecture 2-3: Your Story, Your Wounds, Your Limits
- Lecture 2-4: People, Time, Money and Health: Counting Your Capacity
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Picture
- Lecture 3-1: Writing a Vision People Can Say
- Lecture 3-2: Priorities, and What to Stop
- Lecture 3-3: Reaching Agreement in Different Structures
- Lecture 3-4: Counting the Cost and Taking a Risk
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Three Priorities and One Thing to Stop
- Lecture 4-1: Goals You Can Obey
- Lecture 4-2: Calendar and Rhythm
- Lecture 4-3: Roles, Volunteers and Resources
- Lecture 4-4: Plan and Budget Together
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Year Plan
- Lecture 5-1: What to Count and What Not to Count
- Lecture 5-2: Reviews That Teach
- Lecture 5-3: Honest Reporting
- Lecture 5-4: Evaluating Work Without Judging Persons
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Year-End Review
Every community arrives at the planning table carrying its past. Some of that past is a source of gratitude. Some of it is a source of pain. Most of it is a mixture, and most of it is never spoken aloud. A new plan made over an unspoken past is like a house built on a floor nobody has swept: it may stand, but something will keep moving under it.
This lecture asks a community to look honestly at its own story: the founding, the high points, the proud moments, the failed plans, the losses, the quarrels and the griefs. It also asks the community to name its limits without shame. None of this is meant to dig up old wounds for their own sake. It is meant to let the community plan as the community it really is, and not as the community it wishes it were or fears it is.
Week 2 so far has looked at gifts and at neighbours. This lecture turns the eyes inward and backward. The next lecture turns them to capacity.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Explain why a community's history shapes its planning whether or not anyone mentions it.
- Describe a way of telling a community's story that includes pride, wounds and failed plans.
- Name the signs that a past plan or loss is still affecting a community's willingness to plan.
- Explain how grief can affect planning, and where to go for help with deeper conflict.
- Distinguish honest naming from blame, and a limit from a failure of faith.
We will not hide them from their children, telling to the generation to come the praises of Yahweh, his strength, and his wondrous works that he has done." — Psalm 78:4
World English Bible
that they might set their hope in God, and not forget the works of God, but keep his commandments," — Psalm 78:7
WEB
This I recall to my mind; therefore have I hope." — Lamentations 3:21
WEB
It is because of Yahweh’s loving kindnesses that we are not consumed, because his compassion doesn’t fail." — Lamentations 3:22
WEB
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
WEB
Psalm 78 is a long telling of Israel's story, and it does not leave out Israel's failures. It is told so that the next generation will "not forget" and will set its hope in God. The writer of Lamentations is sitting among ruins, and says: "This I recall to my mind; therefore have I hope." Memory is not the enemy of hope. Memory told honestly, before God, is where hope is found. Romans 12:15 is the rule for how to sit with one another while the story is told.
1. Why the past is already at the table
(An invented example.) The elders of a congregation called Harvest Road decided to write a three-year plan. They had a clear sense of , a good asset list and a willing group. In the first meeting, a proposal to hire a part-time children's worker brought a strange silence. One said, flatly, "We tried that." Another changed the subject.
Nobody present could say clearly what had happened. Some years before, a children's worker had been appointed, the post had been paid from a special gift, and the gift had stopped. The worker had left in distress. A quarrel followed about who had made the promise. The quarrel ended without anyone saying sorry. The congregation never spoke of it again, and the memory sat in the room like a stone that everyone walked around.
This is how the past works. It does not announce itself. It appears as a silence, a shrug, an angry remark about an unrelated thing, a "we tried that" with no explanation, a leader who becomes tense at a certain word. A community that wants to plan well must be willing to find these places and speak of them, gently, before it plans over them.
2. Telling the story: a simple way
Tell the story of the community in a single meeting, or a series of short ones. A house church of twelve can do this in an evening. A larger community may do it in groups. A mission agency can do it with long-serving staff, board members and partners.
A simple method is to draw a long line on a wall or a large sheet, from the founding to today. Divide it into periods. Ask people to add events and short notes. Use two colours, or two sides of the line.
- Above the line: what we give thanks for. The founding. A leader who served for many years. A time the community cared for others. A building that was finished. A new family that stayed. A year of unexpected help.
- Below the line: what hurt. A death. A leader who left under a cloud. A quarrel. A split. A failed building or project. A loss of money. A time when the community was ashamed. A time when it was mistreated by those outside.
Then ask four questions, one at a time, with time for silence:
- What do we see when we look at the whole line?
- What do we take pride in, and is the pride honest?
- What do we avoid speaking about, and why?
- What did we learn from the hard parts?
Two rules for the meeting. First, everyone's memory counts, including the memory that disagrees with the official story. Newer and older members will remember different things. Second, do not argue about who was to blame. The aim is to see what happened and how it feels now, not to pass a verdict. If the story requires a fuller process of listening and reconciliation, the meeting should say so and arrange it separately, with someone suited to help.
Where the community is mixed in language, generation or origin, let each speak in the language they find easiest, and arrange a way for others to understand. A migrant congregation will often hold two histories at once: the history of the congregation in this place and the history of the home they left. Both belong on the line.
3. Pride: honest and dishonest
Pride in a community's past can be healthy gratitude. It can also be a wall. "We have always done it this way" is sometimes a statement of thanks and sometimes a refusal to look. Test the pride with questions: Does this memory make us more generous towards newcomers or less? Does it help us to see what we were given, or does it keep us from seeing what has changed? Would a stranger recognise this story as true?
A community can also be proud of a wound. "We were the faithful ones when others compromised" is a story some communities tell for generations, and it can be true in part. It can also protect the group from admitting its own part in a division. Honest naming means saying both what was done to us and what we did.
4. Failed plans
Many communities have a drawer of plans that were never carried out. A vision statement from twenty years ago. A building scheme. An outreach programme that ran for two seasons. These plans matter for two reasons.
First, they teach what went wrong. Perhaps the plan was too large for the people. Perhaps it depended on one person who left. Perhaps no one was given the task. Perhaps money ran out. Perhaps the plan was imposed from above and the people never owned it. These are lessons a new plan needs.
Second, they may have left a quiet cynicism. People who have seen three plans fail may not say that they doubt the fourth, but they will be slow to give time and effort. A leader who meets this reluctance and calls it a lack of faith has misread it. It may be that people have been disappointed, and the disappointment is something that needs to be heard.
A simple exercise is to put the old plans on the table and ask for each: What did we hope? What happened? What do we think now? What would we do differently? The review frame of week 5 is built from the same questions. Doing it now, with an old plan, is good practice.
5. Grief and planning
Some communities come to the planning table in grief. They have lost a leader, through death or departure. They have lost a building to fire or flood or the sale of land. Many members have left. A beloved ministry has ended. A crisis has struck the wider area. A person has been hurt by someone in the community, and the community has not yet faced it.
Grief affects planning in several ways.
- It can make people unable to look ahead. Planning feels like betrayal of what has been lost, or it feels too heavy to try.
- It can make people want to rebuild exactly what was lost, as though the past could be restored by a plan.
- It can make people hurry, to get away from the pain by activity.
- It can make people sharp with one another. Anger, blame and silence are common companions of grief.
- It can be hidden. A community may carry a loss for years without having mourned it.
Romans 12:15 asks believers to weep with those who weep. A community in grief is not ready for a plan until it has had time to weep together, to give thanks for what is gone and to sit with what is unresolved. This does not need a long delay. A prayer service, a shared meal, a visit to a grave or a site, a time of simple remembering may be enough. What matters is that the grief is named and honoured before the planning begins, not instead of it.
A plan made in grief should usually be modest and flexible. It should say plainly that it is made in a hard season, and that it will be looked at again when the community is steadier. This is the honesty of Lamentations: to remember, to lament and to hope in the same breath.
Where grief is tied to a conflict, a division, a harm done by a leader or a deep distrust, a planning meeting is not the place to resolve it. It needs a patient process, often with help from someone outside. The change-and-conflict course takes up how to lead a community through such seasons. If the wound involves abuse, harm to a child or a vulnerable adult, or any danger, it is not a matter for a planning group at all: it belongs to the community's safeguarding procedures, the proper authorities under local law and a qualified person. Do not let a planning meeting become a place where such matters are handled informally.
6. Naming limits without shame
A community's story also shows its limits. Perhaps the community has never had more than twenty members. Perhaps it has lost its young people to the city. Perhaps its leaders are elderly and tired. Perhaps its income has never covered what it hoped. Perhaps it has a building it cannot keep up.
Some leaders treat naming a limit as a kind of unbelief: "If we say we cannot, we deny God's power." That is a mistake, and it is not what Scripture teaches. Paul asks the Corinthians to give "according to what you have, not according to what you don’t have" (2 Corinthians 8:12, which the next lecture reads in full). Honest limits are part of faithfulness. A community that pretends to have strength it lacks will plan beyond its means, and will wear out its people.
At the same time, a limit is not always final. Some limits can change with time, help or a different approach. Some are not limits but fears. The task of honest naming is to tell the difference as far as the community can: to say "we cannot do this now" or "we cannot do this alone" or "we are afraid to do this", and to say it truthfully. A community that can say these three sentences correctly is already more prepared than most.
(An invented example.) A small congregation in a mountain town named three limits in an evening. "We cannot afford a full-time pastor. That is a fact." "We cannot reach the outlying farms alone. We would need help from the neighbouring parish." "We are afraid to speak of what happened with the old building. That is not a fact; that is a fear." Each statement had a different consequence. The first changed the plan. The second led to a conversation with the neighbouring parish. The third led to an evening of prayer and listening, led by a visiting elder from another community, before any plan was made about the building.
7. Honest naming and blame
All of this has a danger: honest naming can turn into blame. The past contains people, and some of them did wrong. Some are still in the room. Some have died. Some have left.
A few guides:
- Name events and effects before names of persons. "A quarrel about the money ended with two families leaving" is honest. A list of who caused it may be necessary in some process, but it is not the task of a planning meeting.
- Speak for yourself. "I felt abandoned when the vicar left" is a statement of the speaker's experience. "He abandoned us" is a verdict.
- Include the community's part. Even a community that was wronged usually has some part, and honesty names it.
- Do not demand forgiveness on a timetable. Forgiveness is a gift of God and a work of time. A planning meeting can create a space for it. It cannot command it.
- Protect the vulnerable. A person who was hurt should not be asked to tell their story in front of the person who hurt them, or in a large group, if they do not wish to. People may pass.
8. Rest in the story
Finally, the story should end in rest. After a meeting on wounds, close with thanksgiving and a simple prayer, perhaps a psalm of lament and trust. Do not move at once to the next agenda item. Give people time. If the meeting has opened a door that cannot be closed in an evening, say plainly that it is open, and arrange a time and a person to return to it.
Diagram 1. A community's line
In short
- The past is at the planning table whether or not it is named; it shows as silence, shrugs and "we tried that".
- Tell the story on one line: thanks above, hurts below, with everyone's memory counted.
- Test pride: does it open the community to newcomers or close it?
- A failed plan teaches what went wrong and may have left a cynicism that needs hearing, not rebuking.
- Grief affects planning; weep together first, plan modestly, and send deep conflict to the change-and-conflict course.
- A limit is not unbelief. Say honestly: not now, not alone, or afraid.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The community's line | Thanks above the line, hurts below; everyone's memory counts. |
| Failed plans | They teach what went wrong and may have left quiet cynicism. |
| Grief and planning | Weep together first (Romans 12:15); plan modestly and revisit. |
| Three sentences about limits | Not now. Not alone. Afraid. |
One sentence to remember A community plans as the community it really is, so it must first tell its own story honestly.
This week's action Write one thing your community is thankful for and one thing it avoids speaking about, and keep both to share only if you choose.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What does your community avoid talking about? How does that silence show itself at meetings?
- Think of a plan your community began and did not finish. What do people say about it now, and what do they not say?
- Where in your story is the pride honest, and where might it be a wall?
- If your community were in grief, what would a short, honest time of weeping together look like in your tradition?
- Which of the three sentences about a limit is hardest for your community to say aloud: "now", "alone" or "afraid"?