Lecture 3-3: Reaching Agreement in Different Structures
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Planning an Act of Faith?
- Lecture 1-2: Mission, Vision and Values: Telling Them Apart
- Lecture 1-3: Discernment in Scripture: Praying, Planning, Being Blocked
- Lecture 1-4: Discerning Together: Who Is in the Room
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Draft Calling Statement
- Lecture 2-1: Starting From What You Have
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to Your Neighbours
- Lecture 2-3: Your Story, Your Wounds, Your Limits
- Lecture 2-4: People, Time, Money and Health: Counting Your Capacity
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Picture
- Lecture 3-1: Writing a Vision People Can Say
- Lecture 3-2: Priorities, and What to Stop
- Lecture 3-3: Reaching Agreement in Different Structures
- Lecture 3-4: Counting the Cost and Taking a Risk
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Three Priorities and One Thing to Stop
- Lecture 4-1: Goals You Can Obey
- Lecture 4-2: Calendar and Rhythm
- Lecture 4-3: Roles, Volunteers and Resources
- Lecture 4-4: Plan and Budget Together
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Year Plan
- Lecture 5-1: What to Count and What Not to Count
- Lecture 5-2: Reviews That Teach
- Lecture 5-3: Honest Reporting
- Lecture 5-4: Evaluating Work Without Judging Persons
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Year-End Review
A direction that only one person believes is not yet the community's direction. But "agreeing together" means different things in different places. In one church the congregation votes. In another, the bishop decides after listening. In a third, a board of trustees holds the legal power, and in a mission agency a council meets twice a year.
This lecture does not say which structure is right. It does something more useful. It asks, for whatever structure you have: where does the final decision sit, who has a real way to speak before it is made, and what stops any one person from making the community's discernment their own?
The word "participation" has a bad side. It can mean a real hearing, and it can mean a ceremony that stamps a decision already taken. A community that has been through the second kind will not easily believe in the first. So we will spend time on how to tell the difference.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe where the final decision sits in your own structure and in at least two others.
- List five ways in which people can take part in a decision and say what each is good for.
- Recognise five signs of participation that is only a ceremony.
- Explain how to protect the minority and the quiet in a decision.
- State fairly the three views on open debate and private settlement, and what this course requires of all three.
Then it seemed good to the apostles and the elders, with the whole assembly, to choose men out of their company, and send them to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas: Judas called Barsabbas, and Silas, chief men among the brothers." — Acts 15:22
World English Bible
it seemed good to us, having come to one accord, to choose out men and send them to you with our beloved Barnabas and Paul," — Acts 15:25
WEB
For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us, to lay no greater burden on you than these necessary things:" — Acts 15:28
WEB
Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22
WEB
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
WEB
He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17
WEB
but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15
WEB
The council in Acts 15 is the best-known scene of a church deciding together. It is also a passage on which traditions disagree about what is being modelled. We will read it for what it plainly shows, and no more.
1. Where does the final decision sit?
The first task is to be honest about where the power is. Churches and agencies describe themselves in friendly language, but a decision always sits somewhere, and people deserve to know where.
Here are the main patterns. Real communities mix them, and your own may not match any of them exactly. Nothing is implied about which is best.
| Structure | Where the final decision usually sits | Typical ways others take part |
|---|---|---|
| Episcopal (led by a bishop) | The bishop, often with a council or synod, for the matters assigned to each | Parish councils, synods, consultations, and the bishop's duty to listen |
| Presbyterian (led by elders) | A body of elders (session, presbytery) and larger assemblies | Elected elders, congregational meetings for certain matters |
| Connexional (linked churches under a conference) | A conference or assembly for the whole body; the local church for local matters | Delegates, circuit or district meetings |
| Congregational | The congregation, in a meeting of members | Members' meetings, votes, committees |
| Independent (an independent church under a pastor and board) | The board or the pastor and board, according to the constitution | Elders, deacons, members' meetings if the constitution gives them |
| Mission agency or non-profit | The board, within the law and the founding documents | Staff consultation, donor or member meetings, partner churches |
If you do not know where the final decision sits in your own community, find out. Read the constitution, the rule or the founding documents. If it is unclear, that is a finding, not an embarrassment, and the fix belongs to the church order and law course. A community whose members cannot say who decides is a community that will be tempted to let the loudest voice decide.
2. What Acts 15 shows, and what it leaves open
In Acts 15, a dispute about what Gentile believers must do has reached Antioch. Paul and Barnabas travel to Jerusalem. There is discussion, testimony and a reading of Scripture. Then a decision is reached and a letter is written. The passage says that it seemed good to the apostles and the elders, with the whole assembly, to send chosen men, and that the letter says it seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to them.
Several things are plain. People who disagreed were heard before anything was decided. Several kinds of people were present: the apostles, the elders, the whole assembly. The decision was sent in writing, with named messengers who could answer questions, and not as a rumour. And the decision was not described as a victory for one side; it speaks of a burden that was lightened.
What is not plain is the structure. Episcopal readers see the apostles and elders taking the lead. Presbyterian readers see a gathering of elders in an assembly. Congregational readers stress "the whole assembly." And some readers say that the passage tells us about this one situation and is not a pattern at all. This course does not settle the argument. What every reading can take is the habit: hear the people who disagree, bring several kinds of people in, decide, write it down, and send it with people who can explain.
3. Five ways to take part
A community seldom decides in one step. It usually uses several ways of taking part, each good for a different purpose.
Listening meetings. People gather to be heard, with no decision at the end. They are good for finding out what people really think, especially when a topic is tender. Their weakness is that they can become a show: people speak, and nothing happens. Say in advance what will be done with what is heard.
Prayer and fasting together. In Acts 13, a group prayed and fasted before a major step. Prayer is not a substitute for discussion, and discussion is not a substitute for prayer. Prayer together is good for slowing a community that is rushing. Its weakness is that a leader can say "I prayed and God told me" to end all discussion.
Small groups and written responses. Small groups let quiet people speak. Written comments, including anonymous ones where safe, help those who will not speak in front of leaders or elders. The weakness is that someone must read and answer them honestly.
Votes. A vote makes the result clear and gives each member a share. It is good for a decision that must be made on a date. Its weakness is that it can produce winners and losers, and a vote taken too early locks people into positions before they have heard each other.
Approval by a board or council. In many structures, the legal responsibility lies with a small body. Its approval is necessary and also limited: a board can approve something that the community cannot live with.
A sound process usually joins several of these: listen first, pray, hear in small groups, then decide by the path the community has already agreed. The order matters. A vote taken before listening is not the same as a vote taken after.
4. Signs of participation that is only a ceremony
This is the hard part. Many communities have a meeting where a decision is "approved." Not every such meeting is a decision. Watch for these signs.
- The decision was announced before the meeting. If the leader says in the corridor, "we are all going this way," the meeting is a signing.
- No time or paper beforehand. People are given a thick document at the door and asked for a vote in an hour.
- Questions are answered with the vision. "That would not fit our vision" is used to close a question that deserves an answer.
- There is no real alternative. The choice is between the leader's proposal and nothing.
- Dissent is named as disloyalty or lack of faith. People who ask are told they are resisting the Spirit.
Add a sixth that is subtler: office is used to press a discernment. A pastor, bishop, director or chair is listened to more, and so has a heavy responsibility. Using the weight of the office to push a view is different from offering one. It helps if the person with the office speaks last, not first, and if they say plainly what they think and also what would change their mind.
None of these signs proves bad faith. Busy leaders fall into several of them out of tiredness. But a community should be able to ask, kindly, "did we really give people a chance to speak?"
5. The minority and the quiet
In almost every community there are people who do not speak in meetings: the young, the old, women in a tradition where men lead the discussion, recent arrivals, people with little schooling, people whose language is not the main language, and the people the community serves. Their voices are most likely to be lost, and often they are the ones who will live with the decision longest.
Ways to hear them:
- Ask for views in small groups or one to one before the main meeting.
- Allow written comments, with a way to give them privately.
- Offer interpretation where there is more than one language.
- Ask, deliberately, "who is not in this room, and how will we hear them?"
- Ask the people served, with their consent, and ask them in a place where they are not afraid.
- Make sure a person with a minority view can state it in their own words, and that it is recorded fairly even if the decision goes the other way.
A minority that has been heard and then overruled can still be part of the community. A minority that has not been heard rarely can.
Finally, every structure needs a check on any single person. In an episcopal church that may be a council. In a congregational church, the members. In an independent church, an board that has real standing, and an outside adviser. In an agency, an independent board member or auditor. The form is for each community to choose. The rule is not negotiable: a community that depends entirely on one person's goodness is one weak year away from harm.
6. Open debate or private settlement
This is a point where readers will not agree on how disagreements about direction should be settled. Some hold that disagreements should be aired in open congregational discussion. They argue that the whole body bears the decision and that hidden conversations breed suspicion; Scripture's picture of a body in which every part matters seems to them to demand it. Others hold that delicate questions are better settled first in small, trusted groups: elders, a council, a pastoral team. They argue that open argument can wound people, can be dominated by the confident, and can harden positions before anyone has had time to pray. Still others hold that leaders should decide after listening, because leaders are the ones who answer for the community before God and the law, and because endless debate can paralyse. Each view has a good form and a bad form, and each is held by thoughtful people in many traditions.
This course requires less than any of them, and the same from all of them: everyone affected has a real way to speak and to be heard, and the decision path is written down and fair. Open debate with no way for the shy to speak fails the test. A small group with no way for the rest to be heard fails it. A leader who listens to no one fails it. A leader who listens carefully and is accountable for the decision may pass it.
7. Pointers
Details of meetings, quorums, voting rules and constitutions belong to the church order and law course; read the constitution you actually have and, where law applies, check locally. If the decision carries conflict, or deep change that grieves people, the course on change and conflict is the right next step.
8. The same work in a different shape
A house church of fifteen may decide by sitting in a circle and listening until the group is at peace. That is a form of consensus, and it works if everyone speaks, including the quiet. It needs one person who watches for the person who has not spoken.
A large congregation cannot hear everyone in one room. It may use a small group of listeners who gather views from each section, and a members' meeting for the final step, with documents sent in advance.
A parish inside a diocese will have the parish council, the priest and the bishop each with defined parts. The task is to know the parts and to see that the parish council is a real listening body and not a rubber stamp.
A mission agency board decides for an agency whose workers and partners are far away. Without deliberate effort, the people who live with the decision are the people least likely to be heard. A mature agency builds a way to listen to field staff and partner churches before the board votes.
Diagram 1. Four questions to ask about any decision path
Diagram 2. Real hearing or ceremony
| A real hearing | A ceremony |
|---|---|
| Papers sent in advance | Papers given at the door |
| More than one real option | One proposal or nothing |
| Questions answered | Questions closed with "the vision" |
| Dissent is recorded fairly | Dissent is called disloyalty |
| The leader speaks last | The leader speaks first and longest |
In short
- Find out where the final decision sits in your structure. If members cannot say, that is a finding to fix.
- Acts 15 shows disagreement heard, several kinds of people present, and a decision written and sent. Traditions differ on what structure it models.
- Five ways to take part: listening meetings, prayer, small groups and written replies, votes, and board approval. They work best in order.
- Signs of a ceremony: decision announced earlier, no time to read, questions closed by the vision, no real alternative, dissent called disloyalty.
- Every structure needs a check on any single person, and a way to hear the minority and the quiet.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| First question about any decision | Where does the final decision sit, and who knows? |
| Five ways of taking part | Listening, prayer, small groups and writing, votes, board approval. |
| A sign of manipulated participation | The decision was announced before the meeting. |
| What this course requires on open or private settlement | Everyone affected can speak and be heard, and the path is written and fair. |
One sentence to remember Agreeing together means a real chance to speak, a fair and written path to decide, and a check on any one person.
This week's action Write down, in one paragraph, how your community decides a matter of direction, and ask one member who does not hold office whether it matches what they have seen.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Where does the final decision sit in your community? Could a new member find out?
- Which of the five ways of taking part does your community use most? Which is missing?
- Have you been in a meeting that was only a ceremony? What was the first sign?
- Who is usually not in the room when decisions are made? How could they be heard?
- State the three views on open debate and private settlement fairly. Which would your community find hardest to accept?