Lecture 3-1: Signs and Discourses in John
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Map of the New Testament
- Lecture 1-2: One Passage, One Thrust
- Lecture 1-3: Letting the Passage Set the Form
- Lecture 1-4: How Preaching Traditions Differ
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Naming the Kind of Writing
- Lecture 2-1: What Kind of Writing a Gospel Is
- Lecture 2-2: Telling a Gospel Scene
- Lecture 2-3: Miracles and the Hearer Who Is Not Healed
- Lecture 2-4: Preaching a Parable
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Scene or a Parable
- Lecture 3-1: Signs and Discourses in John
- Lecture 3-2: Preaching the Passion
- Lecture 3-3: The Resurrection Accounts
- Lecture 3-4: Preaching in the Church's Year and the Short Homily
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Sign or a Resurrection Scene
- Lecture 4-1: Between Description and Rule
- Lecture 4-2: The Speeches in Acts
- Lecture 4-3: The Community and the Hard Passages
- Lecture 4-4: Preaching Acts as a Series
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, One Scene from Acts
- Lecture 5-1: A Letter Is a Letter
- Lecture 5-2: Following an Argument
- Lecture 5-3: Doctrinal Passages and the Traditions
- Lecture 5-4: Household Codes, Authority and Hard Commands
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Mapping One Letter Passage
Most preachers who preach John discover the same thing within a month. The Gospel is easy to read and hard to preach. The words are short. The sentences are plain. And yet a passage that sounds simple on the page can sit in the pulpit like a stone, because John does not work the way the story Gospels work.
In Mark you follow a scene. In John you are often invited to stand still and look at one thing, a loaf, a light, a door, a shepherd, a grave, until it becomes clear what it is pointing to. John calls these acts signs (a sign is a deed that points beyond itself to who Jesus is). He also gives long speeches, called discourses (a discourse is a long, connected speech, not a short saying), which are hard to preach in one sitting.
This lecture asks what changes in the sermon when the passage is a sign, an "I am" saying or a discourse in John. It also deals with one phrase that every preacher of John must handle with great care: "the Jews." Preaching has sometimes turned that phrase into hatred. This lecture shows how to read it, and how never to say it.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Explain, from John 20:30-31, why John chose the signs he did, and what that means for how a sign is preached.
- Preach an "I am" saying by asking what it points to, who first heard it and what it asks of the hearer now.
- Divide a long discourse into parts that can be preached one at a time, each with its own thrust.
- Explain why John must be preached in John's own voice and not mixed with the other Gospels.
- State fairly three ways of reading "the Jews" in John, and handle the phrase aloud without it becoming a verdict on Jewish people today.
Therefore Jesus did many other signs in the presence of his disciples, which are not written in this book; but these are written, that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in his name." — John 20:30-31
World English Bible
Jesus said to them, “I am the bread of life. He who comes to me will not be hungry, and he who believes in me will never be thirsty." — John 6:35
WEB
I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep." — John 10:11
WEB
John tells us why his book exists. The two sayings from John 6 and John 10 are examples of what he means: a picture from daily life, and a person at the centre of it.
1. John tells you what the book is for
Most books do not say why they were written. John does. After many pages of stories, he stops and speaks to the reader.
John 20:30 admits that Jesus did many other signs that are not written in the book. John 20:31 gives the reason for the ones he did choose: "that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in his name."
For a preacher this is a gift. It is rare for a writer to hand you the purpose of the whole work. Here is how it changes the sermon.
First, the signs are chosen, not complete. John did not write a record of everything Jesus did. He chose, and he arranged. If you preach a sign as one more miracle among many, you lose what John did with it.
Second, the aim is faith and life, not information. A sermon on a sign in John that ends with "so Jesus had power over wine" has described a fact and missed the purpose. John wants the hearer to come to the point of trusting Jesus and to find life in him.
Third, the hearer is invited to believe, not pushed. John 20:31 says "that you may believe." The Gospel is written as an offer. A sermon that turns it into a threat has left John's voice.
A term to keep. Many Christians read "believe" in John as a word for trust that keeps going, not for a single moment of agreement. Communities describe the moment of faith differently, and this course does not decide that. What matters here is that the preacher keeps John's own word at the centre: the sermon is for believing and for life.
2. A sign points
Here is the first sign John reports. In John 2:11 he writes that Jesus "did in Cana of Galilee, and revealed his glory; and his disciples believed in him."
"This beginning of his signs Jesus did in Cana of Galilee, and revealed his glory; and his disciples believed in him." — John 2:11 (WEB)
Notice the words John uses about it. It is the "beginning of his signs." It "revealed his glory." And the result is that the disciples "believed in him." John does not give the wine a long explanation. He tells you what the deed did: it showed who Jesus is, and it led people to trust him.
So when you prepare a sign, ask three questions, in this order.
- What happened? Tell the scene plainly, as you would any scene.
- What did it show about Jesus? Look at how John himself frames it, at the verse just before and just after the deed.
- What does it ask of the hearer? Not "what should we do this week?" but "what is the hearer being invited to see and trust?"
Here is a small example. (An invented example.) A preacher is working on a sign in which Jesus gives sight to a man born blind. A first draft says: "Today, Jesus can heal the blind places in your life. Bring them to him." This takes a sign and turns it into a promise for every sorrow. It is a warm sentence. But the passage does not say it, and a hearer who is not healed will hear it as a door closing.
A second draft follows the sign: "A man who had never seen anything meets the one who says, 'I am the light of the world.' By the end of the chapter, the man who was blind sees who Jesus is, and some of the people who could see do not. The question for us is who is in the light." This is closer to what John is doing. It does not promise a cure. It points, as the sign points, to who Jesus is. (Lecture 2-3 spoke about the sick person in the room. That care carries over to John.)
3. The "I am" sayings
John gives a group of sayings in which Jesus says "I am" and then names a picture. Here are some of them. Each is a short verse; read them slowly.
"Again, therefore, Jesus spoke to them, saying, “I am the light of the world. He who follows me will not walk in the darkness, but will have the light of life.”" — John 8:12 (WEB)
"Jesus said to her, “I am the resurrection and the life. He who believes in me will still live, even if he dies." — John 11:25 (WEB)
"Jesus said to him, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father, except through me." — John 14:6 (WEB)
Together with John 6:35 (bread), John 10:7 (the door) and John 10:11 (the shepherd), and the vine of John 15:1, they form a set. Notice what they have in common.
- They are pictures from ordinary life. Bread, light, a door, a shepherd, a vine. A hearer anywhere in the world knows what these are for.
- They name a need and an answer. The bread answers hunger. The light answers darkness. The shepherd answers the danger the sheep are in.
- Each is said to someone. They are not slogans for a poster. Each is spoken in a scene, often to someone who has just been fed, or who has just been challenged.
(Some readers also notice places where Jesus says "I am" with nothing after it, and they hear an echo of the name of God. Readers differ on how strong that echo is. This lecture does not build on it, and a preacher should not either unless they have studied it for themselves.)
Here is how to preach one saying. Take John 10:11: "I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep."
Step 1. Hear the picture as the first hearers heard it. A shepherd was a worker whose life was tied to the flock. The picture is about care that costs something. It is not a picture of a pretty field.
Step 2. Hear what the saying is set against. In the surrounding passage the shepherd is placed beside others who do not care for the flock. The saying is not only comfort; it is also a standard against which leaders are measured. That is a point for the preacher too.
Step 3. Hear the cost. "Lays down his life" is the centre. The shepherd is good because he gives himself, not only because he is gentle.
Step 4. Ask what it asks of the hearer. It asks the hearer to know whose voice to follow and to trust the one who gave himself.
(An invented extract.) "We like the picture of the shepherd. We put him on windows. But a shepherd who is only a picture can't help a sheep in the dark. Jesus says, 'The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep.' The sentence is not about how the shepherd looks. It is about what he does when the wolf comes."
Notice what this extract does not do. It does not make every detail of the picture mean something (the staff, the gate, the pasture). It stays with the thrust the passage itself gives. Lecture 2-4 gave the same care for parables.
4. Preaching a long discourse in parts
John gives long speeches. The longest, in John 6, begins with a feeding, moves to a long conversation about bread, and ends with a division among the followers. No one can preach all of that in twenty minutes. Trying to do so produces a sermon that skims the surface of everything.
The answer is to preach it in parts, each part with its own thrust. Here is one way to cut John 6 into four parts. Other cuts are possible, and your community's reading may decide for you.
| Part | What happens | The thrust, in one sentence |
|---|---|---|
| The sign | A crowd is fed | Jesus provides for the hungry, and the crowd wants more of the bread. |
| The saying | "I am the bread of life" (John 6:35) | What they are really hungry for is Jesus himself. |
| The hard words | Jesus speaks of the bread as his flesh, given "for the life of the world" (John 6:51) | The gift is costly, and it is for the world. |
| The division | Many leave; Peter speaks (John 6:66-69) | Some turn away and some stay, and the reason to stay is Jesus' words. |
"At this, many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him." — John 6:66 (WEB)
"Simon Peter answered him, “Lord, to whom would we go? You have the words of eternal life." — John 6:68 (WEB)
A few cautions follow from this.
- Do not preach the whole discourse as an outline of a doctrine. Communities will hear John 6 in light of the Lord's Supper. Some will hear it in that light because their tradition does, and others will hear it as a picture of trust. Say which you are doing. This course does not decide the matter, and a sermon that settles it by force has taken a side the passage does not require. (The church year and the sacraments are the subject of a later course, PT731E.)
- Keep the response in the sermon. John 6 ends with people leaving. A sermon that ends with the bread and leaves out the leaving has cut off the ending of the passage. Peter's answer, "to whom would we go?", is a better place to rest than a cheerful ending the passage does not give.
- Give the hearer a way back in. Each part, preached alone, must stand without the others. State in a sentence where you are: "Last week the crowd was fed; today Jesus speaks about what the bread means."
5. John in John's own voice
The Gospels do not all tell the story the same way, and lecture 2-1 explained why a preacher does not hide the differences. John is the Gospel that differs most. It has different material, a different order of some events, and a different way of speaking. Many readers notice that John tells far fewer short stories with a punch line, and gives more space to long speeches and to the questions people ask Jesus. Scholars and communities differ about how to explain each difference, and this lecture does not settle them.
What the preacher needs is a simple rule: preach John in John's voice. A few habits help.
- Listen for John's repeated words. Believe, life, light, world, sent, abide. When a word comes back many times, the passage is leaning on it.
- Do not fill in a scene from another Gospel. If you mix the details of the supper in John with the supper in Mark, the hearer hears neither.
- Notice the misunderstanding. In John, people often take Jesus' words on too low a level. They hear "water" and think of a well. They hear "bread" and think of a lunch. The misunderstanding is part of how John teaches, and a sermon can use it: the hearer is allowed to make the same mistake and then be led out of it.
6. The phrase "the Jews"
Now to the hardest care in this lecture. John uses the phrase "the Jews" many times. Read carelessly or aloud, it can sound as if John, and Jesus, stand outside a people called "the Jews" and speak against them. That is not so. Jesus was Jewish. His mother, his disciples and the first believers were Jewish. John's book is full of Jewish feasts, Jewish scripture and Jewish hope.
Read the way John uses the phrase in three places.
"His parents said these things because they feared the Jews; for the Jews had already agreed that if any man would confess him as Christ, he would be put out of the synagogue." — John 9:22 (WEB)
"Therefore many of the Jews, who came to Mary and saw what Jesus did, believed in him." — John 11:45 (WEB)
"When therefore it was evening, on that day, the first day of the week, and when the doors were locked where the disciples were assembled, for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood in the midst, and said to them, “Peace be to you.”" — John 20:19 (WEB)
In John 9:22 the parents of the man who was healed are afraid of "the Jews." But the parents are Jews. In John 11:45 "many of the Jews" saw what Jesus did and "believed in him." In John 20:19 the disciples, who are Jewish, lock the door "for fear of the Jews." The phrase cannot mean all Jewish people, because the people in these verses are Jewish. In each place it points to a particular group in a particular situation: authorities, or a crowd in Judea, or the people who had power to put someone out of the synagogue.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some scholars read the phrase mainly in the light of a conflict inside the Jewish community at the time John's Gospel took shape, a family argument between those who believed in Jesus and those who did not, painful because both sides were Jewish. Others stress that it often means the Judean authorities, the leaders in and around Jerusalem, and not the people as a whole. Others stress that John uses the phrase, along with "the world," for the wider refusal to receive Jesus, a refusal John says the whole human world shares (see John 1:11-12). Each reading has strong support, and many preachers combine them. Some scholars also doubt how much the exact details of the conflict can be known. What this course requires is less than any of these readings. It requires that you never let the phrase become a verdict on Jewish people today, and that you say only what you are sure of.
Here is what that means in practice.
- Do not say "the Jews" in your own sentences as if it meant one people who rejected Jesus. Say what the text says: "the authorities," "some of the leaders in Jerusalem," "those who had power to put a person out of the synagogue." If the reading you are using says "the Jews," say a sentence before it: "John uses this phrase for a particular group in a particular situation, and he and Jesus and his friends were themselves Jewish."
- Remember who is listening. Jewish people may hear you, or the friend of a Jewish person, or someone who has been hurt by a sermon that said something worse. The preacher assumes that someone in the room remembers what this phrase has been used to do.
- Tell the truth about history. Passages like these have been used in preaching to build contempt and worse. That is a fact the church has to look at honestly. Judaism is a living faith with its own present, not a stage the church has left behind.
- Do not make the leaders in John a stock villain. They are afraid, curious, divided and sometimes believing. John 12:42 notes that many even of the rulers believed but did not say so for fear of being put out of the synagogue. The text allows more than a villain.
Diagram 1. John 6 in four parts
Diagram 2. Sign, saying and discourse compared
| Sign | "I am" saying | Discourse | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A deed that points beyond itself | A short statement with a picture | A long, connected speech |
| What to ask | What does it show about Jesus? | What need does it meet, and for whom was it said? | What are the parts, and what is each part's thrust? |
| Main risk | Making it a promise for every sorrow | Giving every detail a meaning | Preaching all of it at once |
In short
- John says why the book exists: that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and have life in his name (John 20:31).
- A sign points beyond itself. Ask what happened, what it shows about Jesus, and what the hearer is invited to see and trust.
- An "I am" saying is a picture from ordinary life, spoken in a scene. Preach its thrust, not a meaning for every detail.
- A long discourse is preached in parts, each with its own thrust, each able to stand alone, and with the response in the passage kept.
- Preach John in John's voice. Do not fill in the scene with details from another Gospel.
- In John, "the Jews" does not mean all Jewish people. Say who is meant, and never turn the phrase into a verdict on a people today.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What is a sign in John? | A deed that points beyond itself to who Jesus is, chosen so that the reader may believe (John 20:30-31). |
| How is an "I am" saying preached? | By asking what need it meets, who first heard it, and what it asks, not by giving each detail a meaning. |
| How is a long discourse preached? | In parts, each with its own thrust, stating where you are each time, and keeping the response at the end. |
| How is "the Jews" handled? | Say who is meant, remember Jesus and his friends were Jewish, and never make it a verdict on a people today. |
One sentence to remember Let the sign point, let the saying be heard where it was said, and let the phrase "the Jews" never become a verdict on a people.
This week's action Choose one "I am" saying and write, in two sentences, what need it answers and who first heard it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- John 20:31 says why the book was written. How would you change a sermon on a sign if you had John's stated purpose in front of you?
- Choose one "I am" saying. What need does it answer, and who first heard it?
- How would you divide a long discourse into parts? What would you say at the start of each part so it stands on its own?
- If a reading in your community includes the phrase "the Jews," what sentence would you say before or after it? Write the sentence.
- Why is it better to say "the authorities" or "some of the leaders" than to repeat the phrase as it stands?
- Which tradition in your community decides how John 6 is heard, and how would you say so honestly in a sermon?